The Telangana High Court disposed of a PIL regarding management quota seats in medical colleges as infructuous because nothing further survived for adjudication.
Petition disposed of as infructuous along with pending applications.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
.L HIGH COURTFOR THE STATE OF TELANGANAAT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY ,THESIXTH DAY OF APRIL TWOTHOUSANDANDTWENTYONE/'
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLETHE CHIEF JUSTICEHIMA KOHLI '- AND THE HONOURABLESRIJUSTICEB.VIJAYSENREDDY P.t.L. NO:226 0F 2014
Betwee n:
M/S. Tclangana Studcnts JAC lir -rsLL :L il l r-(t( I ll , So, r tr.- rri 15,,1r 'r I rl ]i,,r,r '., O/o: l' ,:. " il, r'. i r r lr i . ,:,,, r', , ,1, ,, r.ll,irs r,,,r, l.ppar \1.rrrrlrr1. l(.1? )tsL. i)()(t lr0, Represented by its Presidcnt & General Secrctary Sri. Iirrltrr-a1l ])i trltmctll. S rt: Sr IJirrrrnr,rIr. ,\qr:: i) I ( lrls.()('('.: SlLt(1( n1. il o: ,, i ,i.l l);rlr':r-r Vill,rg,.. \r,iirc].:,rl \l,rrclrl. \r rqorrrl;r I)rstria l.'l'clanq;tr.trr.. ii r'j.(lh:rritn Kitushik Sinqarn. l)/o: Sri Vccramallur, Aqr:d: 28, C)r:c.: StL-rdt nt, R/o:li 12 l5 80.2, Nlitnikcsh,,r':rri Naqar, Osma nla lJ rr ivc lsitr', IIvdt'rtib;td. .\t) '. 1lt, St, , ,,t 1,l, rr3,r;r. Ilc'p. lrr Ih(' Sc('rcli)r-. I Icaltlr. \lL'rIlt rrl. If:r:rrilv \'cl lrrrL (l'.lJ l)( pr1r't nrcn l .(lr,r r'r'n r rr n l ol- 1'r'lL'nq;rn:r, S('( r'('liiI-iirl I lr rI,'r'IrIIi,rL -2. l)rVf R L rr,.r'r sil., olllr .rltlS( rr r('('s \iilrt,,irrtrrrlir, .\rtrllrt'rr l)r';rrilslr ii)o .1. \llclrL rrl(',rLurL r ol TrrrlL, l)','i,L i >, :,.t -. I )';tlj rkr, I)]-,rrsr I, 'itu I)t llrr l lrr() , ;. lrrrlr,r ,1. \rrrlltrrr l'r;rcli slr \lr rlicrrl ri. l)tntrr' C,,llcgr \ssoci;rtir,n. ()/o: rt 103, Rcliancc llcsiclt--nt'r,. { )pp. N'1'll St:rdirrm, lr rdirii [)arl< ].ioad, Ilvclcr:rbirrl. 5.,\pol o InsliILLlt'rrl \1t-dic;rI Scicr-rt,'s ti, Rcsr'arch. Apollo II( illLh(lir-, OarnpLts, .11rbrlt'c llills. I lvrlr'r.'ib:rcl :r0t) 0lr().'l'clanganir.
PETITIONER
I
s.l...t( i{ r, 15 1,' ,rrll|iilrrl).1. ,..,1il(rr ;ll,:;l:,ll;::, ,,,,,,,, r li,l,l, . L t.) LLir ),\1 .1, ) ", ",'rri,"",;.,; r .);r.)r, ),,,,,..,ii,',,.,,;1.;ir'i,,,,.,i],,1;1,;i ., r,,q ,,Jr,,il r '( ).)l l.)1.)s JlirrJ0,l()l . ":il;;1,'j l;llt ll :l?,i )rrr I(,l ,, ,n:,1f ,i; ,,;,iill,ir",lll,',';i;l ;.1ii,;,1 t:Lit;i;.r:1r.;.{l-,,0 O0cl t.)r" ..,,./l|,) :r.l:'l-'. ) lU,ll.rJi,t].i]li ..r..ru,nA<sup>.i!i,, .l,-'',,1;. .ai n .J(I'LI-),l,zv ':1,, 'l
r:ur;Btrelo-1..aoo /og . u_r r ; LU Lr.r r-" u \r
,.rH:11r_r3 lpJrpJh,,,,,_,I[, ." 1 'i.,/_o ooll ' lllil '],1';,i ,,1,1,i],,,y,,,1,,11 ,.".-.;::;:: ; ,i .r,.,, .,,. ;:,[j; ,J',]:),,11 ,i ,, ,,,,, il , , lr)0 !(),.^ tsr(l
.rr-;'r,rtrLr r.t|'ri .lrjli r: u, ul ( )< l 's, ). ) !.)1.)(. I ,, ,r\ ,,; ; ,,,1::l;,'1 ,"1;:);'1,, ', ,i I ,
|?uuFu11.t.1_, ' l, ,n,. .J,ji.trl.r,.rr..j jr ur:ul{.JJ,,l .trj;r,\ r, ,, .- ,,',,,,,, 'i, i' :.,..-, (,\ ,s, ,p ,.,r,rr,, tr ),,.,, 'l<sup>r(r.)lt ,,,r,1,,,,, ,, ,,; ,l
., .r.,J ,J. .1,,,it,.:.,..'t , . \ ,, I ..,.,,.,r1,; .rr L. rJ I.rr, ,, L ,,i,i ,,,.)lJ. ),r:\ I,,r\ )r 111 It
.r:OO 60!l -rriirrrrrl..qrLlcl,\l,J;rl,n,lr:1,:llJ]1, ,J;-JlloJ ir?Jri)i)n i) a s OI
,,,,, r r,,,,.1;, J ;1:l ]: ;:1,"i,_l )r!,^, r;)ii1"; il,:j j:l ; Jr, (:
' qHr;11 tr cq-rue, t]',,"0 ".,"r',, r.rrrr'rg 1,,r, p!"; i, rlr,;j r, Jl l:l 8
' eu r:.:]- u 11.r.1,, ) s1 6 1,r : p.rrr,i 11;1*v,,i1 1ecJ l.r1: ru 1
,sJJ!.)r )! rr.rrrl.)r,,,,r,,..,,,,,1rt,,,,J1rr11r\r . ttr u-t t tcl.t.;-r g
'lru l)--Lr.)1.)-1, ,lr)1 lO!l '(s^r\llri .^-,,,"' lstl,l',':,ilirPI</sup> |r'qrI.)I'.trrdrrr:qi1 7_ i,r 'q,r, ,l ,l\ ,,, ,rtl,,,,r \r, i...\ .
3
. Petition under Articre 226-of the constitution of rndia praying that in the crrcumstances stated in the affidavit tr"o tn"i"utn, the High court mav be pleased to issue an appropriate writ,'oiae,. oriir".,io" more particurarrv one in -g, -ilrtii'l rhe nature of writ of lVtandamus "i ,.,v #"i lppropriate writ decraiino the Government order G.o.-y: No rr,r"glq:t...1 ramity WerraiJ 1cr1 Department, Dated 2s.082011.gsjl,gt ;;iil",.il',,c,,.[iManasemcnt seats] is illegar' arbitrarv and viorarion of principres or nrir..lt justice apa,. from vioration of Article 14 guaranteed uno"," conriirti* ii"iroi., consequenry direct the respondents to appoint a committee ano aomit ,L.tro"nt" based on merit in I;i;:r"r manner oy impremeniing l.rir" rirl..rs for academic year, 2014_
PILMP . NO: 325 0 F 2014
petition under Section :51 ,C-pC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit fired in support of the p"titioi, ii" High court may be preased to stay the admissions into management quota seaL under Category ,,C1,, for MBBS Course for academic year, 201 4_2A1 S.
Counsel for the petitioner:SRl. RAJASHEKAR THALLApALLy
Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: Gp FOR MEDICAL & HEALTH
Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. A PRABHAKARA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: SRl. SRINIVAS DAMMALAPATI
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 6 & 10: SRl. G MADHUSUDHAN REDDy
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.7 & 9: SRl. E AJAY REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No. 12: SRI.J. SREENTVASA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No. 14: SRl. S. SRI RAM
Counsel for the Respondent No. 16: SRl. S. NIRANJAN REDDY
the Respondent Nos. 4, s, a, 11,13, 1s & 17 to 1e: NoNE ff;l^il"J
The Court made the following:
I
ltem No.159
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI
/
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B. VIJAYSEN REDDY
P.l.L. No.226 of 2014
ORDER: (Per the Hon'ble the Chicf Jusrice Hinra Kohti)
l. Leamed counsel for the petitioner states that nothing further survives for adjudication in the present petition, which has been rendered infructuous.
2, The present petition is, accordingly, disposed of as infructuous
along with the pending applications, if any.
SD/.I.NAGALAKSHMI
To,
//TRUE COPY//
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
+-
HIGH COURT
DATED:06/04i2021
ORDER
PIL.No.226 of 2014
1t1.- > l"n/€:
6+ QA
Y
.i-
c:)
(.) 2 4 APH 2021 o
,..v {
,,..'t
<br>\ 1-<br>rrcdt
Disposing of the PlL. As infructuous.
{,,t y?L"\ot, e)
1 issue framed by the court
Whether the petition regarding management quota seats in medical colleges requires adjudication.
2 provisions across 2 enactments
Ms. Telangana Student Lawyers
Secretary, Health, Family Welfare (R) Department, Government of Telangana
Dr NTR University of Health Sciences
Hima Kohli
B. Vijaysen Reddy
As recorded by the court registry
Litigation brought on behalf of the public interest rather than a personal grievance, relaxing the usual rule of locus standi.
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
