The High Court of Telangana disposed of PIL No. 214 of 2012 filed by Save lvictit Society against various medical colleges. The Court held that the petition had become infructuous as nothing remained for adjudication.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAO
TUESDAY ,THE SIXTH DAY OF APRIL TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI ANI) THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDDY
P.l.L. NO:214 OF 2012
Between:
M/s. Save lvictit Society, Rep. by its President, Prasad V.A.R.K., S/o. V.S. Janaki Raman, Aged about: 51 Years, Occ: Educational Consultant, Office: A- 104, Sri Sai Sai Datta Apartments, Srinir.as Colon,v (East), Anlcerpet, I-11'derabad.
PETITIONE,R AND 1. State. rf Ar-rdhra Pradesl-r, Rep. b1, thr' Secretan', Health, Mt dical, Famil1' Welfare(E1) Department, Government of Anclhra Pradesh, Secretariat, Hvdererbad. Dr'. NTLl Urriversity of Health Sciences, l'Vlo1,rt'.'o.1,.,,Andhra Pradesh -520 008. 3 Mairarajalr's Institute of Medical Sciences. 31-15, Near MDO Office, Nellimarlr-r, Vizianagaram District, Andhra Pradesh, India. 1 Koonaseerna lnstitute of MedicalSciences, NH 214-, Chaitanya Nagar,Amalapuram, East Goclavari District, A.P. 5 Great Eastern Medical School, Ragoiu, Sril<etkulam, SrikakulamDistrict.A.P. 6r G.S.L. Medical College,Rajahmundry NFI - 5, Lakshmipuram,Near Rajanagaram, East Godavilri , Rajahmr-rndn', Anclhrzi Pradesh, Indin- 533294 Alluri Seet-harnma Raju instituteof medical sciences, Eluru - 534 005, WestGodavari District, Andl'rra Praclesh. India.
1_1, Deccan Coliege of Medical Sciences P.O. I{anchanbagh, DMRL'X'ROAD , Santh<rslr Nagar, Hyderabad -500058
17 Chalernreda Anancla Rao Instituteol Medical Sciences, College o1' Nr-rrsing,, Bornmal<al,Kartmnagar Dist - 505 001, Bomn-iaka1, Karimnagar,AndhraPradesh.
13 Sharlern Institute of MeclicalSciences, 'l'eaching Hospital ancl Research Centre, Himal atsagar Roacl, RarrgaRecld-r'Dist, Ar.rdhra Pradesh, lncliar- 500074.
1.9 Mamata MedicalCollege, I(hammam, AndhraPradesh, India -5O7OO2.
20 Bhaskar N{edical College, Moinabad, Ranga ReddY,Moinabad, Andhra Pradesl-r , India, 500075
3
,..,1
,..RtrSPONDENTS,
(R24 is Suo Artotu impleaded as per Court Order daled 22/1112012.)
...RESPONDENTS
.,,.rr!;,lt::: T:,";o,r.j,.,:226.ofthe constirution.of tndia prayins rhar jn the I l.?"# h,i^;,iffi r, * i];:xy,,,:x. llft l[n,# i{i : proressions courses throu-sh .;rr;;t;i;;;; i:T,i"^j:['. ?,3rBT::f.,.ii,,T: ffril|lit:Lir?Tj:J:fl"T: iff,3,iji:t;, rso dated3'o i-io-J,"to," i"il'Ji,?,::"" i" fjli:,: J" s ". s (j i ;iA1i r;;':";';?:; t ;ff il: [] T :;1,? ::X co n s e q_u e n t r y, "t,.r o " ir., u"u ilg" : ::i fl I :" i,"J ": : I l; :% "iiil.* : iii i" t : above Public lnlerest Litigation prL r.'ro zli oir'o"r,i'u the interest of justice.
(Prayer is amended as per C.O dt. 30-1 1-2012 in ptl [/ps 524 & S2S of 2012.)
PILMP .NO:26 40F2012
Petition under Section^15.,l. CpC . praying that in the circumstances stated may be preasei'stay in the affidavit fired in srnoort of the p"tition,'i'r,l ,,n1 "*rl 3;,'i:T;'i::: #': #: l1%%;i "q"'";; ". ; ;,'; ;;: ", c a te g ;iv',;i' r",. -,, e,s
4
,'/
/
Counsel for the Petitioner:SRl. Y SUDHAKAR
Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: GP FORMEDICAL& HEALTH/
ADVOCATE GENERAL
Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. D.V. NAGARJUNABABU Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 3 & 6: SRl. CHPUSHYAM KIRAN Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: SRl. T.V.S. PRABHAKAR RAO Counsel for the Respondent No. 7: SRl, KAMATHAM GOVARDHAN REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No. 8: SRl. N.V. SRAVAN KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent No. 9: SRl. V. V. ANIL KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent No. 10: SRl. B. SARVOTHAM REDDY Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 11 & 22: SRl. K. G. K. PRASAD Counsel forthe Respondent No. 12: SRl. G. MADHUSUDHAN REDDY Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 13 & 19: SRl. E. AJAY REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No. 14: SRl. M. S. SRINIVASA IYENGAR Counsel for the Respondent No. 15: SRl. SRICHARAN TELAPROLU Counsel for the Respondent No. 16: SRl. J. RAMACHANDRA RAO Counsel for the Respondent No. 17: SRl. V. RAVI KIRAN RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No. 18: SRl. S. SRI RAM
Counsel for the Respondent No. 20: SRI VEMULAPATI PATTABHI Counsel for the Respondent 21: SRl. V. B. SUBRAHMANYAM
Counsel for the Respondent No. 23: SRl. A VEERASWAMY Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 5: NONE APPEARED The Court made the following:
Item No. I 22
THE HON'BL E THE CHIEF J USTIC E HIMA KOHLI AND
THE HO N' BLE SR I JUSTIC EB.VIJAYSEN RE,DDY
P.I.L. No.214 of 2012
ORDER: (per the Hon'ble the ChielJustice Hima Kohli)
I . Learned counsel for the petitioner states that nothing further survives for adjudication in the present petition, which has been rendered infructuous.
along with the pending applications, if any.
assrSP/^rBisffiAYAl'l //TRUE COPYII Go
To,
SECTION OFFICER
,1
PI/
ica r. .Fa m i rv we rfa re ( Er ) Depa rrm en r s ta re of iisltl:'J:i3ll;iEjli:.Y:d l,?;Jurouii,i"'t,;,i31?iilH,'i:3i:irj;.J,:iffi1?;g,,"tritzt 3. One CC fo s.i v c,,, ;. d;; EE ,I Bll.l,r"udhakar.Advocare(opuc) b. one cC rn q.i ,_^ a'agarjunagaou ndvocl;'r 6 ;;: xx l: :ll Yl, I'3fi:[K;;i:^ffJ3:il?58[,tsi) t^"" 1oer] q I R:: ii fi lil.",,?iflifl'3:[:if^X? X3!3; roeuc' i; Eff EE I Sl ]t ffixffi5i']",%[ffir'tJ" r i oij" dd iI dli ? B?"JljII"^lgv. nouopii"lo,eucl 12 lne cc i;5;i 3 i;l^[,i1ii?,'i9y9!qt" (opuc) 13.one cc tn s.; tr ^;:. R;Jd"i;hT#,r" A:JfiF (oPUC) ]l.3f F: }3:iy,,:,Si,n,,,.uryensar, Advoca# .i; X::uu ro sri.srichararrTerapiotu eo"""rj"ibJ3By",.n!"l?,,:tA? ji Elll:X l: ::l l; E1,qgn,ntrn;" lp X^Iv. ru o,l.^V.KaVt ;x x,,,-u,u sr b "" o#i*.t::rflr,xsrliib"J33it' :l ,?yne 3ffuL: :ito iiSri il,I.y:i:Sri Vemrsiml,ar,;*l:.,8;,!?i,", s ta t e o r :: ig:,?;;,%"" i i ;;? Y;T,: :,,i 4' fi 3!i t,i ll; n'S"Lon',y,?l " the Advocate Generat, High court for the state of relansana. 24.Two ",d,fi:]t CD Copies.
HIGH COURT
DATED:06/04/2021
1 HE SIA
<br>').?
o
23 mn 2021 IL
+r ir,'
ORDER
PlL.No.214 of 2012
Disposing of the WP As infructuous.
Vt,u'f''
Save lvictit Society, Rep. by its President, Prasad V.A.R.K.
Government of Andhra Pradesh, Health, Medical, Family Welfare (E1) Department
Dr. NTLl University of Health Sciences, Movlurao, Andhra Pradesh
Mairarajalr's Institute of Medical Sciences
Koonaseerna Institute of Medical Sciences
Other Respondents (Nos. 3-19, 21-23)
Hima Kohli
B.Vijaysen Reddy
As recorded by the court registry
Litigation brought on behalf of the public interest rather than a personal grievance, relaxing the usual rule of locus standi.
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
