Dismissed

Smt.Taramani Devi v. State of Jharkhand And Ors.

Jharkhand HC10 Oct 2023WPC/4414/2011

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

In this writ petition, the petitioner challenged orders passed by authorities regarding removal of encroachment. The Court observed that the petitioner's Title Suit had been dismissed by the civil court, negating her claim. Finding no reason to entertain the petition, it was dismissed.

What did the court decide?

The writ petition was dismissed with no orders passed in the matter.

Smt.Taramani Devi Vs State of Jharkhand And Ors. — Writ and Judicial Review | Jharkhand HC (2023)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI

¶2

(Civil Writ Jurisdiction) W.P.(C) No.4414 of 2011

Smt. Taramani Devi

…. …. Petitioner

Versus

1. The State of Jharkhand

¶8

2. The Deputy Commissioner, Dumka.

¶9

3. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Dumka

¶10

4. The Circle Officer, Dumka Anchal, Dumka

¶11

…. …. Respondents

¶12

¶13

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR

¶14

¶15

For the Petitioner : Mr. Rahul Kumar, Adv. For the Respondents : G.P.-II

¶16

¶17

09/Dated: 10^th October, 2023

¶18

1. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

¶19

2. The present writ petition has been filed for challenging the order

¶20

passed by the authorities for removal of the encroachment.

¶21

3. The impugned orders are as follows:-

¶22

“ 11.08.01 vfHkys[k miLFkkfir@ Jh vuq#) vkpk;kZ ¼„½ gjsUæ ;kno ¼…½ fojSaph ek¡>h ¼†½ eukst dqekj us vapy vehu }kjk fd;k x;k isekbl ij vkifRr fd;s gSa] vapy vehu ds isekbZl ij ;s yksx lUrq"V ugha gSA QyLo:i ojh; ifjekid fujh{kd rFkk losZ/kj çfrfu;qDr gsrq cUnksoLr dk;kZy;] nqedk ls bl dk;kZy; ds i=kad 517] fn- 4-8-01 ls vuqjks/k fd;k x;k A vuqjks/k ij Jh T;ksfr"k çlkn jke ifjekid fujh{kd tk¡p ç'kk[kk ftyk cUnksoLr dk;kZy;] nqedk dks ekStk [kqVkck¡/k ds nkx ua- 136 ljdkjh tehu vfrØe.k ds ekih gsrq çfrfu;qDr fd;k x;kA Jh T;ksfr"k çlkn jke ifjekid fujh{kd vfHkyEHc ekih dj ekih çfrosnu lefiZr djsaA

¶23

vfHkys[k miLFkkfir@ Jh T;ksfr"k çlkn jke] ifjeki fujh{kd] cUnksoLr dk;kZy; nqedk }kjk ekStk [kqVkck¡/k Fkkuk ua- 8 vapy nqedk ds [ksljk ua- 136 ds vfrØe.k ds laca/k esa ekih dj ukfi çfrosnu fnukad 18&8&2001 dks çLrqr fd;k gS ftls ns[kkA tk¡p çfrosnu esa çfrosfnr fd;k gS fd vfrØe.kdkjh ¼1½ vfu#) vkpk;kZ ¼2½ gjsUæ ;kno ¼3½ eukst ;kno dh mifLFkfr esa fd;k x;k iwoZ çfrosfnr vfrØe.kdkjh ¼1½ vfu#) vkpk;kZ ¼2½ fojaph ek¡>h ¼3½ eukst ;kno dk vfrØe.k ugha gS flQZ gjsUæ ;kno dk [ksljk la- 136 esa vfrØe.k gSA ,- if'pe rjQ ftldk {ks=Qy 3990 oxZ QhV dM+h ¼2 d- 8 /kwj½ gS] ftlesa budk bZV dk pkgjfnokjh 9 vaf'kd [kiM+Sy] ik¡[k

¶24

W.P.(C). No.4414 of 2011

¶25

¶26

edku gS ¼ch½ iwoZ rjQ gjsUæ ;kno }kjk gha ftldk {ks=Qy 1500 oxZ dM+h ¼0&0&18 /kwj½ gS] esa cxku ds :i esa O;ogkj fd;k tkrk gSA

¶27

ukih çfrosnu ds lkFk ट�ेस esi Hkh lefiZr fd;k x;kA

¶28

vr% Jh T;ksfr"k çlkn jke] ifjeki fujh{kd] cUnksoLr dk;kZy;] nqedk ds tk¡p çfrosnu ds vk/kkj ij vfrØe.kdkjh gjsUæ ;kno dks fd;s x;s vfrØe.k dks gVkus gsrq 24 ?kaVk ds le; nsdj uksfVl fuxZr djsaA

¶29

23.8.01 vfHkys[k miLFkkfirk ekStk [kqVkck¡/k] [ksljk l-a 136 esa fd;s x;s vfrØe.k dks vfrØe.k gVkus gsrq vfrØe.kdkjh dks 24 ?kaVk ds vUnj gVkus ds fy, uksfVl fn;k x;k Fkk vkt fnukad 23-8-01 dks Lo;a LFky tk¡p fd;k tk¡pksijkUr ik;k x;k fd fd;s x;s vfrØe.k ugha gVk;k x;k gSA vfrØe.k gVkus gsrq iqfyl cy ,oa ,d thi dh çfrfu;qfDr djus gsrq vuqeaMy inkf/kdkjh] nqedk dks i= fuxZr djsaA

¶30

15.10.2005 vkns'kA

¶31

;g jktLo fofo/k vihy la[;k 21@06&07 rkjkequh nsoh ekStk nkSyriqj] Fkkuk tjeqaMh] orZeku irk eqgYyk QqVkcka/k] nqedk cuke jkT; ljdkj ds chp vapy vf/kdkjh] nqedk ds vfrØe.k okn la[;k 2@01&02 vkns'k fnukad 11-8-01] 23-8-01 ,oa 7-2-07 ds fo:) nk;j fd;k x;k gSA

¶32

vihydRÙkkZ dk la{ksi esa dguk gS fd xr xsatj lsVsyesaV esa ekStk QqVkcka/k ds nkx ua0 134 dk dqy jdok 3 ch?kk 4 dêk 18 /kwj [kkl ijrh cksydj ntZ FkkA tehunkj xzhxksj gx xzkUV dk eSustj bUnqHkw"k.k cksl }kjk mä tehu dks clkSM+h ntZ dj jftLVMZ MhM la[;k 19@1946 fnukad 15-1-46 dks jk; cgknwj nsosUæ ukFk flUgk ds uke ls cUnksoLr fd;k x;kA ckn esa Jh flUgk vius pkjksa iq=ksa dks mDr tehu pkj Hkkx esa ck¡V fn;kA lcls NksVs iq= lquhfr dqekj flUgk dks 12 dêk 9-5 /kwj fn;k x;kA

¶33

budk vkxs dguk gS fd nkx uaå 136 [kkl cka/k gS tks QqVkcka/k ds uke ls tkuk tkrk gSA nkx ua0 134 ds jdok esa ls lquhfr dqekj flUgk }kjk mä 12 dêk 9-5 /kwj vius fgLls dk tehu dks jftLVªMZ lsy MhM la[;k 2644@1983 }kjk Jh vt; dqekj jktg¡l] nqedk Vkmu dks fcØh fd;k Fkk] ckn esa vihydRÙkkZ }kjk Jh vt; dqekj jktgWl us mä 12 dêk 9-5 /kwj esa ls 02 dêk 03 /kwj tehu jftLVMZ lsy MhM laå 2353@1990 }kjk [kjhn dh xbZ gSA budk vkxs dguk gS fd vihydRÙkkZ mä tehu dk lhekadu ,oa yxku /kk;Z gsrq vuqeaMy inkf/kdkjh ds U;k;ky; esa vkjå,eå okn la[;k 291@2000 nk;j fd;k x;k ftl ij vuqeaMy inkf/kdkjh ds dksVZ vehu ls ekih dj çfrosnu dh ekax dh x;hA vihydRÙkkZ dk dguk gS fd dksVZ vehu }kjk Vªsl uD'kk ,oa ekih dj çfrosnu lefiZr fd;k] ftl ij dksbZ vfrØe.k ugha ik;k gSA vihydRÙkkZ }kjk mä tehu dk eqVs'ku gsrq vapy vf/kdkjh ds U;k;ky; esa eqVs'ku okn la[;k 40@99&00 nk;j fd;k rks deZpkjh ,oa vpy fujh{kd ls

¶34

W.P.(C). No.4414 of 2011

¶35

¶36

tkap gsrq çfrosnu dh ekax dh x;hA gYdk deZpkjh ,oa vapy fujh{kd }kjk tkapksijkUr çfrosnu fn;s ftl ij vapy vf/kdkjh ,oa vuqeaMy inkf/kdkjh }kjk eqVs'ku dks Loh—r dj yxku /kk;Z fd;k x;kA bl ij gYdk deZpkjh }kjk yxku jlhn Hkh fuxZr fd;k x;k gSA

¶37

vihydRÙkkZ dk vkxs dguk gS fd vapy vehu }kjk xyr <ax ls QqVkcka/k rykc dh ekih dj vfrØe.k fn[kkdj vapy vf/kdkjh] nqedk us vihydRÙkkZ ds Lokeh ij vfrØe.k okn 2@2001&02 nk;j fd;k gSA vihydRÙkkZ bl ij ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; >kj[kaM] jkaph esa jhV fifV'ku ¼lh½ uaå 3982@2001 okn esa ,yåihå,å 440@2003 nk;j fd;k Fkk ftl ij ekuuh; U;k;ky; }kjk okn dks [kkfjt djrs gq, alternative remedy gsrq vkns'k fn;k x;k gSA vapy vf/kdkjh dk ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 11-8-01] 23-3-01 ,oa 7-2-07 xyr <ax ls fd;k x;k gS rFkk xyr <ax ls vfrØe.k fn[kk dj vihydrkZ dks [kkyh djus dk vkns'k fn;k x;k gS tks U;k;laxr ugha gSA vr% bls foyksfir dj vihy vkosnu dks Loh—r fd;k tk; A

¶38

eSaus vihydRÙkkZ ds foK vf/koDrk ,oa foi{kh uo vkxUrqd fefFkys'k dqekj ds fo}ku vf/koDrk dks lquk rFkk nkf[ky dkxtkrksa dk voyksdu fd;kA vihydRÙkkZ dk eq[; :i ls dguk gS fd nkx uaå 136 ekStk QqVkcka/k rkykc esa fdlh çdkj dk vfrØe.k ugha fd;k gSA bUgksusa vius nkos ds lanHkZ esa A.I.R. 1982S.C at page 1081 to 1085 dh Nk;k çfr] ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky;] >kj[kaM ds WP(C) No. 3982/2001 vkns'k fnukad 8-5-03 WP(C) No. 3982/2001 vkns'k fnukad 28-8-01] ,y0ih0,0 440@03 vkns'k fnukad 24-8-06] vkjå,eå okn la0 294@00&01 esa vehu fjiksVZ] djsDlu Lyhi] yxku jlhn vkfn dh Nk;k çfr nkf[ky fd;k gSA vihydRÙkkZ }kjk nkf[ky vehu fjiksVZ eqVs'ku isij oxSjg dks ns[kus ls Li"V gksrk gS fd vihydRÙkkZ nkx ua0 134 esa rhu ikVZ esa fucaf/kr nLrkost }kjk tehu [kjhnh gSA ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; ds mä vkns'k esa jhV fifV'ku dks [kkfjt dj fn;k x;k gSA ckn esa vihydRÙkkZ ,yåihå,å 440@03 nk;j fd;k Fkk ftl ij okn dks [kkfjt djrs gq, alternative remedy gsrq funs'k fn;k gSA foi{kh dh vksj ls nkf[ky dkxtkr ds voyksdu ls Li"V gksrk gS fd vihydRÙkkZ nkx ua0 136 QqVkoka/k rkykc esa 3 dêk 6 /kwj tehu dks vfrØe.k fd, gSa] ftlesa pkgjfnokjh@[kijsy iksl dk edku ,oa 18 /kwj tehu esa cxku ds :i esa O;ogkj djrs gSA vapy vf/kdkjh us Hkw eki fujh{kd] cUnksoLr dk;kZy;] nqedk }kjk tkapksijkUr mDr jdok esa vfrØe.k ik;k] ftl ij vapy vf/kdkjh us vihydRÙkkZ ij vfrØe.k okn la[;k 2@01&02 nk;j dj vfrØe.k dks gVkus gsrq uksfVl fuxZr fd;k FkkA vihydRÙkkZ rkjkequh nsoh ifr gjsUæukFk ;kno }kjk mDr uksfVl ds fo:) ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky;] jkaph esa MCywåihå,å

¶39

W.P.(C). No.4414 of 2011

¶40

¶41

3982@2001 nk;j fd;kA mDr okn esa lquokbZ ds i'pkr ekuuh; U;k;ky; us fnukad 8-6-03 dks okn dks [kkfjt dj fn;k x;kA

¶42

ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; >kj[kaM] jkaph ds vkns'k ds fo:) Jherh rkjkequh nsoh us ,yåihå,å okn la[;k 440@2003 nk;j fd;kA bl okn esa lquokbZ ds mijkUr fnukad 24-8-06 dks iqu% okn dks [kkfjt dj fn;k x;kA okn esa muds vf/koDrk }kjk /kkjk 80¼1½ lhåihålhå ds vUrxZr uksfVl fnyk;k x;k] ftldk lwV uaå 129@06 lctt&1] nqedk ds U;k;ky; esa nk;j fd;k x;k gSA okn esa ekuuh; lctt&1] nqedk }kjk fnukad 10-1-07 dks mDr /kkjk 80¼1½ lhåihålhå dks [kkfjt dj fn;k x;kA

¶43

of.kZr rF;ksa ,oa tkap çfrosnuksa ls Li"V gksrk gS fd vihydRÙkkZ QqVkcka/k rkykc ds nkx uaå 136 esa 3 dêk 6 /kwj tehu ij vfrde.k çekf.kr gksrk gSA ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; }kjk Hkh vfrØe.k okn ds fo:) vihydRÙkkZ ds jhV fifV'ku ,oa ,yåihå,å nksuksa oknksa dks [kkfjt fd;k tk pqdk gSA

¶44

vr% vihydRÙkkZ ds vihy vkosnu dks [kkfjt fd;k tkrk gSA vapy vf/kdkjh] nqedk dks vkns'k fn;k tkrk gS fd QqVkoka/k rkykc ljdkjh rkykc gSA mDr rkykc ds nkx uå 136 esa vfrØe.k fgLlk dks 15 fnuksa ds vUnj [kkyh djk fn;k tk;A”

¶45

4. It appears that the impugned orders have been passed on the strength that Title Suit filed by the petitioner, has been dismissed. Thus, the claim of the petitioner over the alleged piece of land has been negated by civil court. 5. Learned counsel for the petitioner although has argued the case in favour of the petitioner but could not dispute the above facts.

¶46

6. In view of above facts, this Court finds no reason to entertain the present writ petition, accordingly, the same is, hereby, dismissed.

¶47

(Rajesh Kumar, J.)

¶48

Amar/-

Smt.Taramani Devi v. State of Jharkhand And Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Smt.Taramani Devi v. State of Jharkhand And Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Chhotelal Mandal Vs the State of Jharkhand

Sheikh Miraj Alias Gulla Vs the State of Jharkhand

Rohit Das Alias Rohit Kumar Das Vs the State of Jharkhand

Krishna Mahato Vs the State of Jharkhand

Reena Das Vs State of Jharkhand

Shadab Ansari Vs the State of Jharkhand