Writ petition challenging a government recruitment select list was dismissed as devoid of merit because the petitioner could not demonstrate any illegality in the selection process for the specific post applied for.
The writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of merit.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC040010912022
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) (ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C) 318/2022
1:Taba Yal D/o Shri Taba Heli, House No. 293 D Sector, Komla, Near Directorate of Vety, Nirjuli, District Papumpare, Arunachal Pradesh, PIN 791109
VERSUS
1:THE STATE OF AP and 57 Ors.
Represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar. PIN 791111
2:The Secretary Horticulture Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Secretariat Itanagar PIN 791111
3:The Secretary Agriculture Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Secretariat Itanagar PIN 791111
4:The Director Department of Agriculture Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Naharlagun Itanagar PIN 791111
Page No.# 2/12
5:Head/Scientist 3 SHRDI Department of Horticulture Chimpu Itanagar Arunachal Pradesh.
6:Simanta Kalita C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
7:Oyinti Megu C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
8:Nagung Camdir Tok C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
9:Tsedar Wangmu C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
10:Hage Munth C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 3/12
11:Rita Nongthombam C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
12:Wahengbam Purnima Devi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
13:Dani Oyang C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
14:Tage Mina C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
15:Takhe Ampi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
16:Duyi Samyor C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 4/12
17:Debia Yamin C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
18:Nani Punu C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
19:Tadung Taku C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
20:Dani Nampi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
21:Leeza Loya C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
22:Pura Hano C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 5/12
23:Tage Kaku C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
24:Hano Tabyo C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
25:Neelam Sunny C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
26:Chukhu Yamin C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
27:Jopi Siram C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
28:Chowlani Manpoong C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 6/12
29:Mumtak Lego C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
30:Taru Dumi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
31:Mihin Noomphy C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
32:Oying Jamoh C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
33:Sangja Khandu Thungon C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
34:Kaling Padung C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 7/12
35:Habung Ali C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
36:Wejimlu Tayang C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
37:Bai Koyu C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
38:Pema Khandu Goiba C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
39:Debia Taje C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
40:Dorjee Tsering Bapu C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 8/12
41:Narang Ampi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
42:Ojoni Teksing C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
43:Tatung Taka Sikar C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
44:Nani Kani C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
45:Kengam Sora C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
46:Mannu Wangsu C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 9/12
47:Lida Jamoh C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
48:Mero Bagang C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
49:Ajum Bulo C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
50:Hage Sunka C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
51:Cindy Tao C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
52:Ronia Linggi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
Page No.# 10/12
53:Tasso Chama C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
54:Landi Jailyang C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
55:Dani Nampi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
56:Ginbom SIga C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
57:Nangbia Kumi C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 791110
58:Kime Mado C/o Krishi Bhawan Directorate of Agriculture D Sector Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh. PIN 79111
Page No.# 11/12
Advocate for the Petitioner : T T Tara
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP)
BEFORE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE NANI TAGIA
ORDER
Date : 14-09-2022
Heard Mr. G. Bam, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. L. Perme, learned Standing counsel for the Agriculture Department representing respondent nos. 3 & 4.
Page No.# 12/12
(Agriculture), Government of Arunachal Pradesh, vide No. AGRI/KVK(E)34/2018-19.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
2 issues framed by the court
Whether the writ petition challenging the selection list in government recruitment posts deserves a notice or is devoid of merit.
Whether the petitioner has established any illegality in the selection process for the post of SMS Horticulture to which they applied.
Taba Yal D/o Shri Taba Heli
The State of AP and 57 Ors.
Nani Tagia
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
