High Court of Rajasthan cancelled the bail granted to the petitioner and imposed a fine upon the accused and his co-accused or their sureties.
Cancellation of bail and imposition of fine of 2,00,000 rupees on accused and 1,00,000 rupees each on two sureties.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
-1-
र�जस � �न�उच � �न � ���ल��ज�प�र�प�ठ�ज�प�र
आद�श
एकलप�ठ�द�ण� � क�व�व�ध�जम�नत�प��!न��पत��स$ख � �- 16302/2016
Gurudev Singh Son of Shri Puran Singh by caste Aheer Resident of Village Mudiyar P.S.Shahbad Distt. Baran. (Presently confined At Distt. Jail Baran)
---Accused/Petitioner
Versus
State of Rajasthan through Public Prosecutor
--Respondent
आद�श ददन��क 04 जनवर�, 2017
म�नन�य न य�य�ध�पत� श� बनव�र� ल�ल शम��
श��र'हन�ज)न, अधध�क�-अभ.��क-प��/�क0�ओर�स
श��णजत�न2�श�म�ल3- व�द�न5�ल'क�अभ.�'जक���सत � र�ज�
--
अभ.��क-प��/�न � अपन��जम�नत�ह�त � �ह�जम�नत�प��!न��पत�द�� पक8���स$हहत��क0�ध�र��439 क��अध�न�प�भलस���न� -- श�हब�द जजल� ब�र�� म: प$ज�बद�क0�ग���प�म�स>�न��स$ख��- 21/2016 अपर�ध�अनतग!त�ध�र�-498ए, 304-ब��.�रत���द���स$हहत��क��समबनध�म:�पसत�त�कक���ह)।
इस�पर�अधध�क��अभ.��क-प��/���व�द�न5�ल'क�अभ.�'जक�क'�स�न� ग���त���पत��ल3�पर�उपलबध�कर����ग���स�मग��क��ध��नप>�!क अ�ल'कन�कक���ग��।�
-2-
व�द�न5�अधध�क��अभ.��क-प��/�श��र'हन�ज)न�न � नन��दन�कक���ह)�कक सह-अभ.��कगण�ल3ल��ब�ई� (मHतक��क0�स�स) ��प>रण�भस$ह( मHतक��क� सस�र) क��जम�नत�आ��दन�प>�!�म:�सहप�ठ�द�र��स��क�र�कक���ज����क��ह) और�सहप�ठ�न � अपन � आद�श�हदन�$क� 07 न�मबर, 2016 म:�इस�तथ��पर व���र�कक���ह)�कक�दह�ज�क0�क'ई�म�$ग�नह3$�ह)�त���ध�र�-304-ब��.�रत�� द���स$हहत��क��घटक�स�बबत�नह3$�ह'त � हN।�प��/�ह�ल�$कक��मHतक��क��पनत ह)�ल�ककन�उसक��उसक��म�मल��सह-अभ.��कगण�स � ककस��पक�र�भ.नन�नह3$ ह)�त���प��/�हदन�$क�27.02.2016 स � न��न�क�अभ.रक��म:�ह)�त���पकरण म:�म�ख��ग��ह�पर3ककत�ह'���क��हN, अत: प��/�क��जम�नत�आ��दन�स��क�र कक���ज���।
व�द�न5�ल'क�अभ.�'जक�श��णजत�न2�श�म�ल3�न प��!न��पत�क� व�र'ध�कक��।
उ.��पक�क��तकQ�पर�व���र�कक���ग��।
पकरण�क��समसत�तथ�R�ए�$�पररणस�नत�R�त���पत��ल3�पर�उपलबध कर����ग���स�मग��त���व�श�ष�रप�स � इस�तथ��क'�दवWगत�रखत � ह�ए�कक सह-अभ.��कगण�ल3ल��ब�ई���प>रण�भस$ह�क��जम�नत�आ��दन�प>�!�म:�इस न����ल��क0�सहप�ठ�द�र��आद�श�हदन�$क�07.11.2016 स � स��क�र�कक���ज� ��क��ह), णजसस � प��/�क��क�स�ककस��पक�र�.��भ.नन�नह3$�ह), मN�पकरण�क� इस�प8म�पर�ग�ण��ग�ण�पर�क'ई�अणनतम�र���व�क�कक� � बबन��अभ.��कप��/�क'�ध�र�-439 द���पक8���स$हहत��क��प��ध�नR�क��तहत�जम�नत�क0 स�व�ध��हद���ज�न��न���'ध�त�प�त��ह>$।
अत: अभ.��क-प��/�द�र��पस�त�त��ह�जम�नत�क��प��!न��पत�स � �क�र कक���ज�कर�आद�श�हद���ज�त��ह)�कक��हद�अभ.��क-प��/�ग�रद � �भस$ह�प�त प>रन�भस$ह�नन��स�-णजल��ब�र�$�द�र��रप� � 2,00,000/- (द� ल�ख रपय� म�त ) क��स � �$�क���ब$ध�पत����रप� � � 1,00,000/- -1,00,000/- (एक-एक ल�ख रपय� म�त) क0�द'�पनत.>नत�व���रण�न � ���ल��क0�सन�त�णZ�ट�क0�प�श क0�ज���, त'�उस � प�म�स>�न��ररप'ट!�स$ख � �- 21/2016 प�भलस���न�- श�हब�द णजल��ब�र�$ स � सम�बणन�धत�पकरण�म:�इस�शत!�क��स���जम�नत�पर�ररह��कर हद���ज�� � कक��ह�पकरण�क0�स�न��ई�क��द[र�न�न � ���ल��द�र��ब�ल�� � ज�न� पर�उपणस � त�ह'त��रह�ग�।
-3-
(न य�0 बनव�र� ल�ल शम�� )
अननलशम�/M-19
2 issues framed by the court
Whether bail should be cancelled under Section 439 CrPC in view of the supplementary charge under Section 304 IPC.
Whether the petitioner must pay a fine imposed at the time of bail cancellation.
3 provisions across 3 enactments
गुरदेव सिंह others
State of Rajasthan
नामांकित न्यायमूर्ति
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
