Disposed

M/s Maruthi Sai Rice Industries, v. The State of Telangana

Telangana HC3 Sept 2024WP/11577/2016

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Common order disposing multiple writ petitions challenging the collection of market fees on paddy imported from other states. The Court held that respondents must strictly follow respondent No.2's guidelines and refrain from levying fees on such transit imports.

What did the court decide?

Directing respondents to strictly follow respondent No.2's guidelines and not to collect market fees on paddy imported from other states while in transit.

M/s Maruthi Sai Rice Industries, Vs The State of… — Company and Corporate | Telangana HC (2024)

¶1

¶2

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction)

¶3

[³³⁰² ]

¶4

TUESDAY ,TI-IE THIRD DAY OF SEPTEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR

¶5

PRESENT

¶6

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH

¶7

WRIT PETITION Nos: 11502^11577{'t 648^{AND439310F2016}

¶8

W.P. No: 11502OF 2016

¶9

Between:

¶10

Lakshmi Sai Rice lndustries, Yadgarpally^{Village,AmruthnagarPost,} Khammam Road, Miryalguda, Nalgonda^{District, Rep.by its Managing} Partner, Guduguntla Subramanyam.

¶11

Mahalaimi Rfce lndustries,^{- Yadgarpally Village' Amruthnagar Post'} Khammam Road, Miryalguda, Nalgonda^{District,Rep.by its Managing} Partner, Chanduru Venkateswarlu.^.

¶12

3- NagarjJna Dali & Boiled^{lndustries, H.No.31-122,Khammarn- Road,} .^{Raftnigar,Miryalaguda, Nalgonda DiStrict, Rep.byits Managing Partner,} Neela Srinivas.

¶13

Lakshmi Ganapathi Rice lndustries,^{NalgondaRoad' Annap-uteddy Gudem,} Miryalaguda, i"lalgonda District, Rep.by its^{ManagingPartner, Gande} Jaganadham.

¶14

SflVenkateshwara Boiled Rice^{& G.N.Oil Mill, Gandhinagar,Miryalaguda,} Nalgonda District, Rep.by its Managing Managing^{Partner, Gunturu Srinivasaulu.}

¶15

Nalgonda District, Rep.by its Managing Managing^{Partner, Gunturu Srinivasaulu.}

¶16

1. Madeswari Par^{'Boited -} Modern^{Ric-e Hrtitts,Mukundapuram'Nidamanoor} Mandal, Nalgonda District,^{Rep.byits ManagingPartner, Singirikonda Krishna} MUrthy.

¶17

Surya- Rice lndustries, Yadgarpally^{Post and Village, KhammamRoad,} Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,^{Rep.by its Managing Partner, SomaRame-sh.-}

¶18

Sai'Jafa Laxmi-Rice lndustries,^{Yddgarpally Viliage, Amruthanagar Post} Khamniam Road, Miryalaguda,^{Nalgonda District, Rep.byits Managing} Parlner. Malioi Reddv Madqna Reddv.

¶19

M/s Sai Srii'ivasa Rice lndustries,^{Srinivasnagar, Miryalaguda,Nalgonda} District, Rep.by its Managing^{Partner, RepalaAnantha Ramulu.}

¶20

Gavatri Ric'e lndustries. Yaiiqarpallv^{Mlldge' AmruthnagarPost,Kodad Road,} Miry. alaguda, Nalgonda Dislrict,^{Ri:p.by its Managing Partner, MutyalaRama} Krishna Rao.

¶21

1 1 . Satva Food Products;, Yadqarpally^{Village, Amruthnagar Post, KodadRoad,} Miryalaguda, Nalgonda^{Di=strict,Rep.by its Managing Partner,Mutyala} Ramesh..

¶22

Sri Vigneswara Rice lndustries, Satyanarayarapuram^Village, .^{Trip^uraram} Post, Nidamanoor Mandal,^{NalgondaDistrict Rep.byits ManagingPartner,} Mtla Vinaya Kumar.

¶23

13.Sri Vdli Fiice Corporation, D.No.18-176,^{Sagar.Road,Miry-alaguda, Nalgonda} District, Rep.by itd Managing^{Partner,Yechuri Nageswara Rao.}

¶24

t+. Minenbra^'RiCe lndustry] Settipalem,^{Near Miryalaguda,Nalgonda District,} Rep.by its Managing Partner, lnugurthi^{Satyanarayana.}

¶25

¶26

Shiva Rama Krishna Rice lndustries (p) Ltd.. Guntur Road. Gudur tvliryalguda, Nalgonda District, Rep.by it!'Managing Director, fr,taaAineni Srinivasa Rao

¶27

Jagruthi Rice lndustries, Sagar Road, Miryalquda. Naloonda D,strict. Reo.bv its Managing Partner, Chillarn Cherla Venkiteihwjrtu.^"

¶28

'17. Miryalguda Food Products, Plot No.67 and 69, Venkatadrioalem. Mirvalaouda. Nalgonda District, Rep.by its Managing partner, i,rtan6nuiionOZ Venkateswa4u.

¶29

lS.Sridevi Parbo,led Modern Rice-& G.N Oil Mill, Gandhi Nagar Miryalguda, Nalgonda District, o Rep.by its Managino partner, Jaini Sriniva"sa Rao] "

¶30

1. M/s Anjanela Ricq .. lndustries, yadgarpalli Village, Arnruthnagar post, Khammam. Road, Miryalguda, Nalgondi Diskict,- Rep.by its^{"tr,tinaginsj} Partner, Polishetty Gopihath.

¶31

Maruthi _Rice Corporation, Guntur Road, Gudur, Mirvalquda. Naloonda urstnct, Rep.by' its Managing Partner, Vanaparthy SatyanaiayZna.

¶32

...PET|TIONERS

¶33

AND

¶34

The State of Telanga.na, AgricuLtural Marketing Department, Secretariat Buildings, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Rep. bv its prindioal Secreti-

¶35

The Commiss,oner and- Director of Agri'cultural, Marketing, bi,vernment of Telangana, B.R.K. Buildinos, Hyderabad.

¶36

3 I!-q lgrsylural...Market iomniittee, Aditabad (Bhorai Check post), Aditabad LJlstnct, Rep. by its Secretary.

¶37

1. The Agricultural The Agricultural Agricultural Uarket '.Committee, Bhodan (Saloom. Check post), Nizamabad District, Rep. by its Secretarv.

¶38

The Agricultural The Agricultural Agricultural

¶39

5 The Agricultural . Markeit Committee, Nirimat (Bhainsa Check post), Adilabad Dishict, Rep. by its Secretary

¶40

Th.e Agricultural _Market Committee, lvlancherial (Wankidi Check post), Adilabad District, Reo. Reo. bv its Secretarv.its Secretarv.

¶41

Adilabad District, Reo. Reo. bv its Secretarv.its Secretarv.

¶42

T The Agricultural Maikgt^-committee, sangareddy (chiragpafly and Zahirabad Check Post), Medak District, Reo. bv its Slcretafu.

¶43

The Agricultural Market Comrhitteie, Kodad, illedak District, Rep. by its Secretary.

¶44

The Agricultural Market. committee, Miryaraguda (Vishnupuram oheck post), . -^{Nalgonda District, Rep. by its Special Gride-Secretary.} l0.The.Agricultural Market'Committee. Miryalaguda (Nagarjun Sagar Check Post) Nalgonda District, Reo. bv its Secretarv.^"

¶45

1 1 . The Agricultu"al Market Committee, Gadwal, Mahabubnagar Dist.ict, Rep. by its Secretarv.

¶46

The Agriculiural Market committee, Kothagudem (pawanchana oheck post), Khammam District, Rep. by its Secretarv.^-

¶47

The Agricurturar Maiket' committee,' Khammam (Kafluru check post), Khammam Dist.ict, Rep. by its Secretarv..

¶48

14.The Agriculturar Markbt. committee, (hammam (Aswaraopet check post), Khammam Dist.ict, Rep. by its Secreiary

¶49

...RESPONDENTS

¶50

Petition under Articre 226 of the constitution of rndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or Direction more particurarry one in the nature of Wtit of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondent Nos.:l to 14 in collecting market fee on paddy whire in transit which is importing from other states by the petitioners as iIegar, arbitrary and in vioration of Articres 14 and 19

¶51

¶52

(ixg) of the constitution of lndia and contrary to the^{circular instructionsissued} by the 2nd respondent in^{Memo No.S111(2)9513} ,^{daled 7.2.2013 and in Memo} s111(3)P-1 1 17012014,^{dated',l9.6.2014 respectively and consequently direct the} respondent Nos. 3 to 14^not to^{collectthe market fee on paddy while in transit} which is importing; from other states^{by the petitioners}

¶53

l.A NO: 1 OF 2016(WPMP.^{NO:14488 0F 2016)}

¶54

Petition under Section 15'l CPC^{prayingthat in the circumstancesstated} in the affidavit filed in support^{of the petition, the High Court may be pleasedto} direct the respondent Nos. 3 to^{14 not to collect the marketfee on paddywhile in} transit which is importing^{from other states by the petitioners pendingdisposal of} the above writ^petition.

¶55

lA NO: 1 OF 2021

¶56

Between

¶57

1 . The Aqricultural Market Committee,^{Miryalaguda (Vishnupuram CheckPost),} Naloori'da District. Rep. bv^{its Special Grade Secretary.}

¶58

z. ftre" Aqrlcuttural Maiket' Cominittee,^{Miryalaguda (NagarjunSagar Check} Post) Nalgonda District,^{Rep. by its Secretary.}

¶59

....PETITIONERS/RESPONDENT^No.9&10

¶60

AND

¶61

Lakshmi Sai Rice^{lndustries, YadgarpallyVillage' AmruthnagarPost,} Xnam.r. Road, Miryalguda,^{Nalgonda District'Rep.by its Managing}

¶62

z. ilaiiitiimi- Partner, Guduguntla nlie^{lndustries, SubramanYam.' YadgarpallvVillage,Amruthnag-a-rPost,} Khammam Road, Miryalguda,^{NalgondaDistrict' Rep.by its Managrng} Partner, Chanduru Venkateswarlu.^.

¶63

s. Nio-Jririni oaii & aoiteo^{lndustries, H.No.31-122,Khammarn-Road,} - ffiffiaga;, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda DiStrict, Rep.by its Managing Partner, Neela Srinivas.

¶64

+. LaGtrmi Ganapathi^{Rice lndustries, Nalgonda Road, AnnaquteddyG1!e1,} Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,^{Rep.byits ManagingPartner'Gande} Jaoanadham.

¶65

S;iv;;k;t";hwara^{Boiled Rice & G.N. oil Mill' Gandhinagar,Ivliryalaguda,} Naloonda District, Rep.bv^{its Managing Partner, GunturuSrinivasaulu'}

¶66

o. irrtitieswiri^{par 'Boil'ed'Modern-Rice tttitts,Mukundap-uram, Nidamanoor}

¶67

Mandal, Nalgonda District, Rep.by its Managing Partner, Singirikonda Krlshna MUrthv.

¶68

z. Su-rv'a'if ice lndustries,^{YadgarpallyPost and Village'KhammamRoad,} trlirvalaouda. Naloonda District,^{Rep.by its ManagingPartner'soma Kame-sn'}

¶69

I 5;il;;-Gimi"niCe industries,^{YddgarpallvVil-lage, Amruthanagar Post} - Khil;6m- R;Ja, viryataguoa, Nalgdnda District, Rep bv its Managing s. -' Partner, Oislriit, nep.by M7i'Sii Maligi Reddy -frin-ivaJi Rice its Managing^Madqna t"ndustries, Partner'^Reddy. Repala Anantha Srinivasnagar, lr{rYalaguda, Ramulu' Nalgonda

¶70

¶71

"[],{,-1,H:S"lii:iJ[fi Gayatri Rice lndustrir :,"dr:p,Tf fl I#f fl S^ffi :1,?!"S3ffiS1,[?,XT[:f,,;

¶72

ll&Hx3p:ft^{x'ii3[?}iaJ'$v&11"1:,#,i:s;tr,il,:#gfl!'Eih[",:"ilnffi} *

¶73

" El,:i,&L1lEl1#'f;,",J!:i"$:tb":,,,,31?131fl33:#11"yi,j;"?,,1J,'"Tft11,1 Vitla Vinaya Kumar

¶74

f'mflmm*,ru9+rryrnffi

¶75

'16. Jagruthi Rice lndustrir

¶76

;;*Htff ;:E$#i,_1',i],;;Efr #i$i,#g3:,,;ffi ,1ffi ,ffi ,i,"ilI,

¶77

::ffiffi'3:;u#:#Iinif*[qfnrffi^$tr'E;Hffi; '"ff €[1H]XilBr,?."lf, Bi,Xl,1[#1;,:1,[X1r;,?i%ii,y:Xi,,,l*Na,sonda

¶78

i]8i,.:s:;:,1;:ilg?l3,,tsrcuturar;['ff^]'-=:f T::l::: i;f^{R,eftdd;'fr,"l;Hfi{,,1}',;H:Tlff} ffi :_

¶79

i;giffirffi Bhodan (saroom check Post)'

¶80

;; +l'f IsfuddEIfi ,H:il!!,3"sIJ1"""?;'

¶81

^^^{urstflct, Rep by its s""r"?rH''t'u"'Niimal (Bhainsa checkl)ost),Adilabad} :: ili,6:'Bilt[i]^{#;:[",i',Ssg[g?:Mancheriar(wankidi check post),}

¶82

;iis{}rs,,.fl:ffi }8,:,":HJ-Bi;titH.dir::I"::1:,,,:#TT:

¶83

The Agri-cultural Market Committee, Gad w al, M a h a but ^ -^{its Secietary} \rdu dr' Iu n oubnagar D strict, Rep. by 30. The Agricullural Market C ud e m ( Pa wa n ch a n a c h eck pos r ),

¶84

; ; +nS,mf ,,o,,5*'," Khammam ( Karru ru (]heck Post)'

¶85

,, rlsqllnfl *l'fiHi.{ifs3g1.[8, ^n"n.!;HS:""%[Uas

¶86

<nam,-i";ibi,i,"lft ;;lb??3Bli?3i,1/,i,,ffi :LH:ff L:;i:

¶87

¶88

Petition under Section^{'151 CPC prayingthat in the circumstancesstated} in the affidavit filed in support^{of the petition,the High court may be pleased to} vacate the interim orders^{made in lA No 1 0f 2016WP. No. 11502 0f 2016 dated} 1110412016 as there are no merits

¶89

Counsel for the Petitioner:^{SRl. V. V. N. NARAYANARAO}

¶90

Counsel for the Respondent^{No.1: GP FORAGRICULTURE}

¶91

Counsel forthe Respondent^{Nos. 2to14: SRI C. HARIPREETH,}

¶92

SC FOR TG AGRLMC

¶93

w.P. NO: 11577 OF 2016

¶94

Between:

¶95

M/s Maruthi Sai Rice lndustries,^{Sy.No.154,163'Vill Chilakamarry.PA'Pally} Mandal, Nalgonda District-508257'Rep.^{by its ManagingPartnerChokkarapu} Ravinder Kumar

¶96

z sri iiiaino Comoanv. Kondamallepallv,^{Devarakonda Mandal'Nalgonda} - Oi"trict - SO-A ZqZ, Repl by its lvlanaging Partner Samudrala Venkateswarlu 3. - Sii N^jtgonOi 5;i Laxmi District Riie - 508^{Indudtries, Guri'm5davally Village, Devarakonda 243 Rep. by its Man'agingParnter veeramalla Mandal,Kiran} Kumar

¶97

...PETlrloNERS

¶98

AND

¶99

1 . The State of Telangana,^{AgriculturalMarketing} .^{D^epartment,Secretariat} Buildino. Secretariat.^{FlvderabadRep'by its PrincipalSecretary}

¶100

1. The C5inmissioner anU^{Director of' Agricultural Marketing'Government ot} Telanqana, B.R.K. Buildings,^Hyderabad.

¶101

g. ihJA-griculturai Market C5nimiitee, Devarakonda , Nalgonda District. Rep'^by its Secretary

¶102

+. ine egriiutiural Market^{Committee, Gadwal, MahabubnagarDistrict-Rep by} its Secretarv

¶103

s. iiJAgriiutiural Market^{Committee, Adilabad, (Bhoraj Check Post), Adilabad}

¶104

u. ?iT''i#,?ori,3lr'l"r??i"Ji""ommirtee,^{Bhodan, (Saroora checkPost),} Nizamabad District.^{Rep. by its Secretary}

¶105

z t6J Aoriculturai uarfejt C6mmittee,^{Niimal(BhainsaCheck Post),Adilabad} District: Rep. by its Secretary

¶106

e. ihe AdriiJliura'r^{n71i*etconimittee, Asifabad'(wankidi checkPost), Adilabad} District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶107

s iht Airiiui-uidt Maiiet Coftmittee,^{Sansareddv (Chiragpallv andZahirabad} CheckPost). Medak^{District. Rep. by its Secretary}

¶108

ro irrJ Aoricuitlili ujt[ei Committee,^{Mirvalguda,-(Vishnupuram CheckPost),} Naloori-da District. Reo. bv^its Secretary

¶109

r r ihd Aoacuii,jrai tvta'iref Committee,^{Miryalguda (NagarjunasagarCheck}

¶110

,,rifr :'h$r#i,.1,x1R':H:tS":l,"i[JE?ff '^",'31'0",(pawanchanacheckpost), Khamfram District. '^{Rep. bv its Secretary}

¶111

r a. ilre" AorlCufturattr,tartet^{'Committee, ' Khammam,(Kalluru CheckPost),} Khammlm District.^{Rep. by its Secretary}

¶112

¶113

¶114

The Agricultural lr4{ket Committee, Kothagudem (Aswaraopet Check Post), Khammam District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶115

The Agricultural Market Committee,^-Saftupalli, (Sattupalli Check post), Khammam District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶116

16.The Agricultural Market Committee, Mulugu (yeturunagaram Check post), Warangal District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶117

...RESPONDENTS

¶118

Petition unde- Article 226 of the Constitution of tndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High C,lurt may be pleased lo issue Writ, Order or Direction especially one in the Nature of Writ of Mandamus declarrng the action of the respondents 3 to 1 6 in insisting and collecting the market fees on paddy while in transit which is importirrg from other states by the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and in violation of Articles 14 and 19 (i) (g) of the Constihttion of lndia and contrary to the Circular instru{ttions issued by the 2nd respondent in Memo No.S1 1 1 1(2)951 3 dated l-2-2O13 .)nd in Memo No.S111(3) P-1117012014 dated 19-6-2014 respectively and consecuen y direct the respondents 3 to 16 not to collect the market fees on paddy while in transit which is importing from other states by the petitioners

¶119

l.A. NO: 1 OF 2016(WPMP. NO: '14573 OF 20161

¶120

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstanr:;es stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may bo pteased to direct the respondenrs 3 to 16 to not to collect the market fees on paddy while in transit which is importing from other states by the petitioners pending disposal of the above writ petition

¶121

Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. CH. RAVINDER

¶122

Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR AGRICULTURE

¶123

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2to16: SRI C. HARIPREETH,

¶124

SC FOR TG AGRLMC

¶125

W.P. No: 11648 OF 20't6

¶126

Between:

¶127

Sri Satya Sai Paraboiled lndustries, Nellikonda Villaqe. Naoarkurnool ^^{MahlboobnagarDistrict - S09 209. Rep. by its Managingpaitnerpo-laRamu} 2. M/s qaShu.Rama lndustries, D.No.1-7-218l19/C, Ko-thj Cheruvu Road, Nelr New Gunj, Mahabubnagar-509001 .

AND

...PET|TTONERS

1 . The State of Telangana,^{Agricultural Marketlng} .^{D^epartment,Secretariat} Building, Secretariat,^{FlyderabadRep by its Principal Secretary^}

¶133

z. ine CSinmissioner anil^{Director of, Agricultural Marketing, Government ot} Telangana, B.R.K. Buildings,^Hyderabad.

¶134

e. ih; nt-ricrittuiai nlirtet^{C"om niittee, M ahabub nagar,tvlahabubnagarD istrict'} Rep. by its Secretary

¶135

+. Th6 Agricuttural Mdrket Committee,^{Nagar Kurnool MahabubnagarDistrict.} Rep. by its Secretary

¶136

s. rh-E Arjri&t[urit Mait<et committee,^{Gadwal, Mahabubnagar District' Rep by} its Secretary

¶137

idAdanliural Market^{Committee, Adilabad (BhorajCheck Post), Adilabad} District. Reo. bv its Secretary

¶138

z. inl District. Reo. bv its Secretary^{-Aqiiclrltuiai} Secretarytttjrt<et^{'Committee, Bhodan (Saloora checkPost),} Nizama6ad District. Rep.^{bv its Secretary}

¶139

g. Th?AgricJftnri utart<tjt Cirmmittee, Niimal (Bhainsa Check Post), Adilabad District. Rep. by its Secretarv

¶140

s. ihl Aqricuiiurit Maitet^{Corfimittee,Asifabad (Wankidi Check Post), Adilabad} District. ReP. bY^its Secretary

¶141

ro.ine Aqricultuidl Market corimittee,^{sangareddy (chiragpailyand Zahirabad} CheckPost). Medak District.^{Rep. by its Secretary}

¶142

r r . inJ nqriiuliliii tutJriei^{committee,Miryatguda'(VishnupuramcheckPost),} Naloonida District. Rep. bv^{its Secretary}

¶143

12.th'; Aqri;iiurii^{t',ta'rt<e[ Committee,Miryalguda (NagarjunasagarCheck}

¶144

Post), Nalgonda District.^{Rep. by its Secretary}

¶145

1. Th;'Ai;iCilturit tt,liitei^{Commi[tee, Kothagudem (Pawanchana CheckPost),} Khammam District.^{Rep. by its SecretaryCommittee,- Khammam (Kalluru}

¶146

r+.fne Khammam District.^{'Agrilulturat-} District. uaifet'^{Rep. by its SecretaryCommittee,- Khammam (KalluruCheck Post),} Khammam District.^{Rep. by its Secretary}

¶147

r s ine Aoricuf turat tUarf 6t^{C'ommittee,Krjthagudem (Aswaraopet CheckPost),} r o. ine Khamriam Aqriculdal District.^{Mar'iea Rep. by its Secretary' Committee,' Sattupalli (SattupalliCheckPost),} Khamm-am District.^{Rep. by its Secretary}

¶148

...RES'ONDENTS

¶149

PetitionunderArticle226oftheConstitutionoflndiaprayingthatinthe circumstances stated^{in the affidavitfiledtherewith, the High court may be} pleased to issue writ, order or direction^{especially one in the Nature of writ of} Mandamus declaring the^{direction of the respondents3 to 16 in insistingand} collecting the market^{fees on paddywhile in transit which is importingfrom other} states by the^{petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and in violation of Articles 14 and 19} (i) (g) of the constitution of lndia^{and contraryto the circularinstructionsissued} bythe2ndrespondentinMemoNo.Sllll(2)9513dated7-2-2ol3andinMemo No.S111(3) P-1117Ot2O14^{dated 19-5-2014 respectivelyand consequently difect} the respondents.3 to^{16 not to collect the market fees on paddywhilein transit} which is importing from other^{states by the petitioner}

¶150

¶151

¶152

l.A. NO: 1 OF 201 PMP. NO: 14658 OF 2016

¶153

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the aFfidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pteased to direct the respondents 3 to 16 to not to collect the market fees on paddy while in transit which is impo'ting from other states by the petitioners pending disposal of the above writ petitioi.

¶154

Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. CH. RAVINDER

¶155

Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR AGRICULTURE

¶156

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2to16: SRI C. HARIPREETH, SC FOR TG AGRLMC

¶157

W.P.No: 43931 OF 2016

¶158

Between:

¶159

Rice Millers Association, Regd.No.218l1977, Ramnagar, l,4iryataguda,

¶160

^^{NalgondaDistrict.Rep. by its Secletary, Gouru Srinivas,}

¶161

Bharani Rice Mills Pvt Ltd., V.T.palem, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District, Rep. by its Managing Director, V.Satyanaravana.^-

¶162

Shiva Shankar Traders, Vivenkanagai, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda tristrict, Rep. by its Proprietor, Ranoa Haranath.^-

¶163

M/s Shiva Rice lnduitries.. Khammam Road, Nalgonda District, Rep. by its Managing Partner, Gouru Chandra Shekhar.^"

¶164

Sai Jaya Lakshmi Rice lndustries, yadgarpally, Village, Amruthnaqar post. Kh_ammarn Road. Miryataguda, Natgoidd O-istrict,^"nbo. Ov iJ"F"rt,i"i, N.Raghava Reddy.

¶165

0 Sgne,nOg Rice lndus]ry, Settipalem, Near Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,

¶166

_ 5-ep.Dy^{lts Partner. t.satyanarayana.}

¶167

Mahateja Rice Mills Pvt [td., Srittipalem, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District, Rep. by its Director, Bandaru Kusalhaiah.Director, Bandaru Kusalhaiah.Bandaru Kusalhaiah.

¶168

t by its Director, Bandaru Kusalhaiah.Director, Bandaru Kusalhaiah.Bandaru Kusalhaiah. ud a' Na rsonda D istrict' Rep

¶169

ff^{i,T''fl?:?Tr"Ei[fl1?]} 3il,.tfs'f*"nTl'' "arag

¶170

Kamadhenu Rice Mills Pvt Ltd., Settipalem, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda Di strict,

¶171

_ - Rep^{by its Managing Director,Sinoiri Fonda Ven'u} Uitf,.

¶172

1O. Jaya Lakshmi Paraboiled Modein Rice Mill, Sagar Road, Miryataguda, Nalgonda District, Rep. by its^partner, Cheedalli Raoiu.

¶173

11 Miryalaq_uda Rice lndustiies lyt LId , Sagar,foadl Miryataguda. Natgonda District, Rep. by its Manaqinq Director. Ranioa Raniith.

¶174

¶175

1. Sri Venkateshwara^{parabbil6d.Modern,} Ric; Mills, Sagar Road, M,ryalaguda, . _^{Nalgonda District, Rep.by its-Managingpartner,} G.Umipati R-a-ri.

¶176

Vijaya Krishna Paraboitbd Moderi Rice Miil, Sagai- FioaE, M,ryataguda,

¶177

_ _^{Nalgonda District, Rep. by its partner,} T.Madhari Moh1n.

¶178

Kanaka Mahalakshmi Rlce_ lndustries, Settipalem, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda

¶179

District, Rep. by 'ts Partner. Buruou Sri(anth.

¶180

15 sri shalivardhana^paraboired_ M-odem Rice MiI, sagar Road, Miryaraguda, Nalgonda District., Rep. by its partner, prasaO VoiugJn'ti.

¶181

, ,l"t

¶182

¶183

'- witoonda Sri Lakshmi Ganapathi District. H.eo. bv its^Trading Paitner, Venna^Company, Venkata Rammohan^{Venkatadrlpalem,Mlryalagude'} Rao'

¶184

r z irrrifri cinapit i nice Corporation'^{Sagar Road,Miryalaguda,Nalgonda} District. Reo. bv its Partner, Vidyala^{Nageshwara Rao.}

¶185

18 s;i-i;intk'idtrni niCe indu6tries,^{6untur Road,Miryalaguda, Nalgonda} District, Rep. by its Partner, Athukoori^Swarny.. -.

¶186

rs Sai iiisnihttihit-e corpor'ation,^{Sagar Road' Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,} Rep. by its Partner, Cheedala^Brahmam.

¶187

zo Sii'veirugopita iice & Oil^Mill, ,^{Gandhi Nagar, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda} District, R-ep. by its^{Partner,Smt. RangaSwarurLa.}

¶188

zr. tr,rineiwari'paiaboiled Rica^{Mill, Settipalem,lriliryalaguda,NalgondaDistrict,} Reo. bv its Partner, Sadhu^{Krishna Murthy.}

¶189

zz. rr,ii{ sairi6ln Rice thoustries,^{settipalem, iViryalaguda'Nalgonda District,Rep'}

¶190

hv its [Ianaoino Partner. Pabbathi^Karunakar.

¶191

za.k'eirtni iiiEerE, Ganotii Nagar,^{Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,Rep by its} Managing Partner, R.Anthaiah.

¶192

z+. rr,i/s Bii^"siinirisa aice lndustries,^{srinivasa Nagar, Miryalaguda,Nalgonda}

¶193

District. Reo. bv its^{Partner,Jaini Shankar'}

¶194

zs Jjqiuiiii ni6e iridustries, Sigar^{Road,Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District, Rep' bv} its Partner, Chillamcherla Venkateshwarlu,

¶195

zo.$ii Gi<itrmitr,tooein nice^{Mill, Settipaleh,Miryalaguda' Nalgonda District,}

¶196

Reo. bv its Partner, Gudipati^{Venkateshwarlu}

¶197

zz. ftiii NZ'ndini iriaeis,^{Salar Road, Miryalaguda, NalgondaDistrict, Repbv its} Partner, G.Harnath.

¶198

dkah;i^prjsanna Rice^{Corporation,l,liryataguda,Nalgonda District, Repby} its Partner, R.Vishwanath.

¶199

zs.Sii VdGiedwaia einny^{Modern Rice Mill,Guduru, Miryalaguda,Nalgonda} District, Rep. by^{its Man'aging Partner, KarnatiLakshmi.Narayana'}

¶200

30.Raohavendra'Rice lndustrries'^{Venkatadripalem, Miryalaguda,Nalgonda} Dis'[rict, Rep. by its Partner,^G.Ramesh.

¶201

31.V;;vi'Ri.;6 rniuilriel,^{Veinulapallv, Mirvalaguda, Nalgonda District, Repbv} its Partner, G.Venu.

¶202

Siir; - R;h; kriitrna Rice lndustries Pvt Ltd., Guntur Road, Gudur, --'rr,ri*Jtaou?i. Naloonda District, Rep. by its Director, [t/.Srinivasa Rao' ao Sli xiuliRice borporation'^{Sagar Road,tvliryalaguda'Nalgonda District'} Reo. bv its Partner. R.Raia Sekhar.

¶203

a+. di-vitii dice Jnbuiiries,^{Yadgarpallv Village, AmruthnagarP-ost' Kodad,Road,} Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,^{Rep. by its ManagingPartner'M'Hama} Krishna Rao.

¶204

$ikar-Ri; and^{Solvent lndustries Pvt Ltd., Guduru, GunturRoad,}

¶205

-- ttti-jtaouOa. Naloonda District, Rep. by its Director' Ranga Srikar' se $ii'BalSii Firabrjited Rice Milis^{Pvt [td.' Yadgarpallyvillage' Amruthnagar} Post. K6dad Road,^{Miryalaguda' NalgondaDistrict' Rep by its Managrng} Director, Gouru Srinivas.

¶206

...'ETITIONERS

¶207

AND

¶208

1 The State of Telangana,^{Agriculture qndCg-qpe1alionDepartment'} S66retaaiieuildingi,^{S6cretbriatiHyderabad,Rep- by.its PrinciP-qlSecretary'}

¶209

2 ih; Cor;iss6nei'&^{Director'of'Agricultural, Maiketing, BRKBuildings'} Hvderabad.

¶210

3 ifrJ-Aiiiiuitrt"t Market Committee,^{Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District,Rep'bv} its Spe;ial Grade Secretary ..RES'.NDENTS

¶211

..RES'.NDENTS

¶212

PetitionunderArticle226oftheConstitutionoflndiaprayingthatinthe circumstances stated^{in the affidavitfiled therewith, the High court may be}

¶213

¶214

¶215

pleased to issue a writ, order or Direction more particularly one ir the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondent Nos.2 and 3 in not refund/ad.iust of market fee paid on rice for the years 2oo4-os and 200s-06 pursuant to the c.().Ms.No.96, dated 19.10.2013 is highly illegal, arbitrary and unjust and consequentry direct the 211d and 31d respondents to refund/adjust market fee paid on rice for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06 pursuant to the G.O.Ms.No 96, dated 19 10.2013

¶216

t.A. NO: 1OF 2016(WPMP. NO: 54198 OF 2016)

¶217

Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct 2nd respondent to dispose of the representation dated 20.7.2016 forthwith made by the petitioner in terms of G.o.Ms.No.96, dated 19.10.2013 pending disposal of the above writ petition

¶218

Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI V. V. N. NARAYANA RAO

¶219

Counsel for the Respondent No.i: Gp FOR AGRICULTURE

¶220

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2&3: SRI C. HARIPREETH, SC

¶221

The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER

¶222

THE HON,BLE SRI JUSTICE^K.SARATH

¶223

WRTT PETITION Nos.11502 LL577¹¹⁶⁴⁸ AND 43931 0F 2016

¶224

coMMON ORDER:

¶225

Heard learned counsel^{for thepetitioners,} Sri C.Haripreeth,^I earnedf Standing Counsel^{for the} the entire material^on respondents and peruTbd record.

¶226

¶227

Learned counsel^{for the petitioners submitsthat} are the issued^{involved inthese writpetitions} squarely covered^{by the ordo passed by this Court in} W.P.No.7998 of^{2016, dated 16'07} '2024^and requested to pass^{similar orcier in these writ petitions} as well.

¶228

¶229

Learned Standing^{Counsel for the respondents} has not disputed^{the submissions made by learyr-ed}

¶230

counsel for the Petitioners.

¶231

¶232

In view of the submissions made by learned counsel lbr the petitioners and for the reasons assigned by this Court in W.P.No.7998 of 2O16, dated 16.07.2024, these writ petitions are disposed of, directing the respondents to strictly follow the guidelines/ instructions issued by the respondent No.2 while levying the market fee rrn the transportation of paddy being imported from outside States. There shall be no order as to costs.

¶233

As sequel to it, Miscellaneous Petitions, if any pending, shall stand closed.

¶234

¶235

/ITRUE^COPY'/

¶236

^.",3?SNiHAE?ffh stL,o*^oFFrcER

¶237

To,

¶238

I e,Utslx;ffifu,,iillit",.EH::iilff't"^:'#^{"'l I"',} , +lS:'3,:,.tlllg,.icutturat^{Marketcommittee'Bhodan(saloorncheck} Post), Nizamabad^Distnct

¶239

<br>

¶240

5 lh.g $eqglgry ,Agricultural Market Committee, Nirmat (Bhainsa ChecK^posr), Adilabad District

¶241

e ]ne.peg19tgry ,Agricultural Post), Adilabad District ltztarket Committee, Mancherial (Wankidi Check II

¶242

The Secretary ,Aglicultural Market Committee, Sangareddy (Chiragpally and Zahirabad Check Post), Medak District

¶243

The Secretary ,Agricultural Market Committee, Kodad, Medak District

¶244

The.Special Grade Se{:retary ,Agricultural Market Committee, Miryalaguda

¶245

. -^{(Vishnupuram Check Post),NalgondaDistrict,}

¶246

1. The S:gretary ,Agricultural Mark-et Committee, Miryalaguda (Nagrarjun Sagar Check Post) Nalgbnda District,

¶247

1 1- The Secretary ,Agricultural [Varket Committee, Gadwal, Mahabubnagar District,

¶248

1 2. The Serretary_,Agricultural Market Committee, Kothagudem (pawanchana Check Post), Khammam District

¶249

The 9ecretary ,Agricultural Market Committee, Khammam (Kalluru Check Post), Khammam District

¶250

14-The Selretary_,Agricultural.Market Committee, Khammam (Aswaraopet Check Post), Khammam District

¶251

Ihe .State of Telangana, Agricultural Marketing Department, Secretariat

¶252

. ^^{Buildi!9,Secretariat, Hyderabad Rep, by itsPrincip=alSecretary}

¶253

The Commissioner and Director of, Agricultural Marketing, Government of Telangana, B.R.K. Buildings, Hyderabad.

¶254

17.The Agricultural Market Commiltee, Devarakonda , Nalgonda District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶255

'l8.The Agricultural Market Committee, Gadwal, Mahabubnagar District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶256

19.The Agricultural .Market Committee, Adilabad, (Bhoraj Check post), Aditabad District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶257

The Agricultural Market Committee, Bhodan, (Saloora check post), Nizamabad District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶258

21 . The Agricultural .Market Committee, Niimal (Bhainsa Check post), Adilabad

¶259

District. Rep. by its Secretary

¶260

The Agricultural Market Committee, Asifabad, (Wankidi Check Post), Adilabad Diskict. Rep. by its Secretary

¶261

The AgJicultural Market committee, sangareddy (chiragpafly and Zahirabad Check Post), Medak District. Rep. bv its StirltJir'-

¶262

*,|:[fltJf B]!ffi|,rfi $f ?,T^g i ttee, M i varsuda,' (Vish n upuram check post ),

¶263

The Agriculturar Markef_ committeej Miryarguda (Nagarjunasagar check Post), Naloonda District. Reo. bv its Secreta'rv "--- ''

¶264

The Agricultural Market Coqlmj.ttee, Kothagu'dem (pawanchana Check post), Khammam District. Rep. bv its Secretarv

¶265

27 The Agricultural Market - Committee, ' Khammam, (Kalluru Check post), Khammam District. Reo. bv its Secretarv

¶266

The Agriculturar Market cbmmittee, Kdthagudem (Aswaraopet check post), Khammam District. Reo. bv its Secretarv

¶267

29 The secretary, Agricuiturir Market coinmittee, sattupali, (Saftupa i check Post), Khamniam bistrict

¶268

The Secretarv. Aoricultural .^{Market Committee, Mulugu(yeturunagaram} Check Post), Warai'qal Diskict.

¶269

31 One CC to SRI. V. V. N. NARAYANA RAo. Advocate toPUCI

¶270

Two CCs to Gp FoR AGRTCULTURE , uisin Court torine SIaie of rerangana at Hyderabad [OUTI

¶271

One CC to SRl. CH. RAVINDER. Advocate IOpUCt

¶272

One CC to SRl. C. HAR|PREET, SC [OPUC]

¶273

Two CD Copies

BM LS

,-i:

I \

HIGH COURT

SK,J

DATED:0310912024

lt
( 1t\ E STATA o^ )
30 rti' LI:J I
o
*

¶285

COMMON ORDER

¶286

WP.Nos.1 1502,11577,11648 AND 43931 OF 2016

¶287

¶288

t ,

¶289

DISPOSING OF ALL THE WRIT PETITIONS WITHOUT COSTS lL

¶290

2---2* L 38cap-r),.

M/s Maruthi Sai Rice Industries, v. The State of Telangana

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

M/s Maruthi Sai Rice Industries, v. The State of Telangana

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

A.Anjaneyulu Goud Vs The State of Telangana

Sri Dhanalaxmi Agro Industries rep. by Its Managing Partner Vs State of Telangana rep. by its Principal Secretary to

Sri. K.C. Venugopal, Vs The State of Telangana

Lakshmi Sai Rice Industries, Vs The State of Telangana

Smt. Shobha Sharma, Vs The State of Telangana

M/s Ishaan Traders Vs The State of Telangana