Dismissed

The Cement Corporation of India v. The Union of India

Telangana HC19 Jun 2023WP/72/2013

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court dismissed a writ petition filed by Adilabad Cement Factory employees seeking declaration regarding the applicability of IDA Pay Scales. The petition was dismissed for non-prosecution due to the absence of the petitioners during the hearing on the scheduled date.

What the court decided

AI extract

The Cement Corporation of India Vs The Union of India — Service and Employment | Telangana HC (2023)

¶1

HIGH COURT FOR^{THE STATEOF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD} (SPecial Original Jurisdiction)

¶2

¶3

MONDAY, THE^{NINETEENTHDAY OF JUNE} TWO THOUSAND^{AND TWENTYTHREE} ".

¶4

PRESENT

¶5

THE HONOURABLE^{SRI JUSTICENAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO}

¶6

WRIT PETITION NO:^{72 OF 2013}

¶7

Between:

¶8

[: r.,	1 'ff,"CementCorPoration^ofIndia EmploVees^{Union AdilabadCement} F";Lty,^{Adilabad, AdilabadDistrictrep} bythe^{GeneralSecretarY}
	S.VilasS/o^{DhajiShanker,} EMPNo.^{4326,agedabout56Years'} occ:Assistant, B:Nadldev^{S/o Narraji,EMPNo'37I4} 'a[eddtiout57Years,occ:Cashier' B.Rarni:'Reddy^{S/o Vithal,EMPNo'4322} ,g.JAiJu"t^{qdyears,occ:TCCLSupervisor'} .,, 2 --3 4
ic E I I Ilit I I I : al .;. !j	Ma-herUl Qudir,^EMPNo'4682 5l&rrnS:'Oqaair'^{agedabout55vcars'} Sffffi*+St,^''' q S P. O,t1^{edabout 48Years,} S/o NaPa, EMPNo.⁴⁷⁵⁴ v-{,#i',.:", ^Fitter, MPNo.⁴⁷⁶⁹ Mazdoor, EMPNo.⁴⁷⁷⁸ occ:PumP^OPerator, ,st:. 7 : 8 9 K.Shankar,^EMPNo4781 - S/o Dhondiram,^{agedabout48 Years'} occ:Clerkll, 10DSat5ralaraYana,^EMPNo4998 S/oNarsaiah,^{agedabout54 Years'} occ:Welder, 11.Bada-l^{Debnath,trMPNo4999} S/oS.Debnath,^{agedabout55Years'} occ:H.E.O., 12.M.^{Kishan,EMPNo'5056} S/oVenkanna, agedabout⁵²Years'^{occ:H E'O''} .6. r :.r,',1 o D,

[:
r.,

1
'ff,"CementCorPoration^ofIndia
EmploVees^{Union AdilabadCement}
F";Lty,^{Adilabad, AdilabadDistrictrep}
bythe^{GeneralSecretarY}

S.VilasS/o^{DhajiShanker,}
EMPNo.^{4326,agedabout56Years'}
occ:Assistant,
B:Nadldev^{S/o Narraji,EMPNo'37I4}
'a[eddtiout57Years,occ:Cashier'
B.Rarni:'Reddy^{S/o Vithal,EMPNo'4322}
,g.JAiJu"t^{qdyears,occ:TCCLSupervisor'}
.,,
2
--3
4

ic
E
I
I
Ilit
I
I
I
:
al
.;.
!j

Ma-herUl Qudir,^EMPNo'4682
5l&rrnS:'Oqaair'^{agedabout55vcars'}
Sffffi*+St,^'''
q
S
P.
O,t1^{edabout 48Years,}
S/o NaPa,
EMPNo.⁴⁷⁵⁴
v-{,#i',.:", ^Fitter,
MPNo.⁴⁷⁶⁹
Mazdoor,
EMPNo.⁴⁷⁷⁸
occ:PumP^OPerator,
,st:.
7
:
8
9
K.Shankar,^EMPNo4781
-
S/o Dhondiram,^{agedabout48 Years'}
occ:Clerkll,
10DSat5ralaraYana,^EMPNo4998
S/oNarsaiah,^{agedabout54 Years'}
occ:Welder,
11.Bada-l^{Debnath,trMPNo4999}
S/oS.Debnath,^{agedabout55Years'}
occ:H.E.O.,
12.M.^{Kishan,EMPNo'5056}
S/oVenkanna,
agedabout⁵²Years'^{occ:H E'O''}
.6.
r
:.r,',1
o
D,

r.,

rl t

,,/

^{L3S. r-\n:rnrlr Rao, ENIPNo.5O68} S/o ;isl-rrr rlnath Rao j aged about 58 years, occ: A.ssis; a::t.

¶16

L. Sreerar: r, EMP No. 5077 S/o,\nthz.ah, aged about 56 years, occ: Sccrrr i.t'/ Superin.tendent,

¶17

a:: i>

¶18

B. Posh,:t1^,r. EMP No. 5084 S/o Bakrr irna. aged about 53 years,

¶19

occ:^'IC-ct rr- LS

¶20

16, B. Ganga te,ddy, EMPNo. 5086 S/o Ash ar na, aged about 53 years, occ: Pern

¶21

:3. Garlac hrr, EMP No. 5089, r $/ o: Raja,ra rra, aged about 56 years, occ: Adsis a.:rt,^.

¶22

T. Raja.nn r. li/o Ashanna, aged abou l-¹⁵⁶ Years, occ: CLerk III, , EMP No. 5090

¶23

K. Karun,; kzr S/o Ramakishtu aged hborj t- 1i4 years, occ: Pump Operator, EMP Np. I 0')8.

¶24

A. Ki stu ii i c Poshetty, aged abor-^{1- 157} Years, occ: Assis a;:it, EMP No. 5103

¶25

2l A. Bhoorn :Lrna S/,o Somanna, aged abor- :^,51 years, occ: TC-cum-LS, EMP Nc. I 1,14

¶26

22 R. MohzuL S/o Lachanna, aged abo- t 51 years, occ: TC-cum-LS, EMP Nc. I 111

¶27

1. Pradeep, S ingh S/o Suraj Singh aged abo.-^'i 55 years, occ: Driller EMP Nc. I 113

¶28

1. S. Chinna ah S/o Bakanna, aged abo. i 56 years, occ: Driller, EMP Nc. I 117

¶29

1. Fathrucld: n S/o Moinuddin Shah aged abo.- [ 54 years, occ; Shift Incharge, EMP Nc.. I 810

¶30

;?r.ts.;r:

¶31

¶32

26 D. Yogeshwar Rao S/o Raghava Rao, aged about 52 years, occ: Assistant, 1 EMP No. 6853

¶33

27 A. Kistu S/o Rarnulu, aged about 54 years, occ: Cierk-lll, EMP No. 6885

¶34

1. T. Nagendrudu S/o T.P. Subanna aged about 58 years, occ: Assistant (TO), EMPNo.7177

¶35

1. D. Prakash S/o D. Shanker, aged about 52 yea$, occ: Security Guard, EMP No. 7583

¶36

1. D. Satyanarayana S/o Kankaiah, aged about 56 years, occ: HD Welder, EMP No. 7607

¶37

1. S Pramanic S/o Pankaj Pramaric aged about 56 years, occ: H.E.O., EMP No. 7612

¶38

1. MD:'fih€jA Moinuddtin S/o Md. Jeelani, aged about 56 years, occ: M.V.D. EMP No. 7680

¶39

1. A. Sudhakar S/o Mallaiah ag6d,about 54 years, occ: S.P.O. EMP No. 7698

¶40

1. R.K.:Ghosh S/o A.K. Ghosh, aged about 54^years, occ: Diesel Mechanic, EMP No. 7958

¶41

1. S.K. Biswas S/o Bansidhar Biswas, aged about 54 years, occ: Diesei Mechanic, EMP No. 7960.

¶42

1. R.K. Handar S/o LN. Haldar aged about 54 years, occ: H.E.O., EMP No. 7962

¶43

1. JX. Sharma S/o J.L. Sharma, . aged about 53 years, occ: H.E.O., EMP No. 7963

¶44

1. A. Niranjan Rao S/o A. Kishan Rao, aged about 54 years, occ: Electrician, EMPNo.7970

¶45

1. K. Bapu S/o Bhuchaiah, aged about 55 years, occ: Electriciarr, EMP No. 7973

¶46

¶47

4L b 1.,:rsl. , I:d.1., S7,., Arrjanc.yulu, lo agc,t irt), r rt JI reiu-s. r.,cc: Fiticr, EN4I) No^(t92

¶48

4t B. Prabhr krrr S/o Satharah. 1g:: ",,rr^{1 56..ears.occ: Firrer,} EMF'Nr, lt96

¶49

42 I(. S'.r :rrn', S,ro Bhumanna agerl alre. . 13 ).ears, occ. Shift In-charge, EMP Nc.^' 917

¶50

43 Sr rtr ifI S/o Mira Saheb, ,O.. ^. agcd eb tr.: ;iS vears. or c: Shift In_charge. EMP \o. i,)()8

¶51

44 P. Gopa tj^/c Mondaiah. aged abrrLr 5,5 years. occ: Welder, EMP No 8 )( r'l

¶52

45 S. Kalidas^,J, o Venkat Narsaiah, iq:! 3,b"r^{55 years, occ: Fitter,} EMP No. 8 rC6

¶53

46 N. N.arsirrg R.ro S/o Rajarna, aged rlboul 52 vears, <rcc: pump Operator, EMP No. f r,Ol

¶54

47 B. Ralri Re kty S/o Vithal, aged abouL 5:2 1.ears, occ: TC.cum_LS, EMP No. 8( t:2

¶55

48 N. Na-r'srntlt r iu.amy S/o Krishna Murthv a.ged aboJr 5:r ).ears, occ: Inst. MechaniJ, EMP No, Sri rio

¶56

49 I(. l\lurali I-l u:rana S/,r Ram Mohan RaoE aged atrorir i:. years, occ: M.V.D. efr,ii-NJ. SfrSl

¶57

K. Ranrtrl:r ,/'o Ramchandram,

¶58

aged aborrt ,:: ]'ears, occ: Miller, EMp No. g(156

¶59

5 1 K.V., V. Rzga n S/o Rarnachandraiah, i4 years, o<:c: DG set oJerator,

¶60

;ff$ ft:"li

¶61

A. Madharr : /o Poshett r,

¶62

agecl about I 6 yc.ars, occ: T.C.-cum_LS EMP Nrr. trOl 2

¶63

53,	7 K. Sudarshan^S/oLaxman' agedabout⁵²Yea:rs,^{occ:ST-Issuer,} EMP No.8O73 II
54.	V.Venkateshwarlu^{S/o Venkatratnam,} agedabout57^years,occ:^Asst.A/C EMP No.8074
55.	V.Nagabhushnam^{S/oPidmishetty,} agedabout58^years,occ:^Asst.A/C EMP No.8132
56	G.NageshwarRaoS/oSuryanarayana, aSedaboutS8'Years,^occ:Asst.A/C EMP No.8134
57.	P.^{Anjaiah'S/oRajalingam,} agedabouti54Years,^occ:M.T.O. EMP No.8177
58.	K.^{LaxmaiahSy'oVenkataiah,} agedabout-56^{years,occ:Fitter,} EMPNo.8178
59.	K.^{N'arsingRaoSlor.Ramulu,} agedabout'54^{years,occ:Fitter,} EMP No.8179
60.	N. Laxman^{S/o,Ramautru,} agedabout58^years,occ:^Fitter, EMPNo.818O
61.	K.Sreedhar.^{S/oRarnasubbaRao,} agedabout51^years,occ:^{Computer Operator,} EMP No.8212
62.	Khaja^{Hasanuddin S/oShaik Hussain,} agedabout55^years,occ:^H.E'O. EMPNo.8526
63	.P.B. DeyS/o J.C.^DeY agedabout55^years,occ:Fitter, EMPNo.8536
64	P.K.^NairS/o^{PadmanabanPillai,} agedabout54years,occ:Inst.^Mecharric, EMPNo. 8544
65	.B,JanardhanS/o^Venkatesham, agedabout54years,occ: Steno, EMP^No.8545

¶64

¶65

ir^r:r	N. Rulrrrill,rilS/()Nara-r-ana, aEc(l.,rlr)rLt54vears) occ:DGSetOperatcr, El.lP:.tJ655 it_--
67	A.,la:radhaIrS/oLingajah, aged:11))L.t56_vears,occ:Peon,EMP No.29tl,lL
68	N{Odr:l.rS/oRajaiah, aged:r1))L.t53years,occ: Coal CR.Operator, trlvlP,:.19042
69	J.Potliin^-raS/oGanganna, aged,lbrL.t47years,occ:M.V.D EA{P.\r:119060
70	B. AdellrS/o Rajarna, aged ab)r:t54years,occ:Peon, EI{PNr:!}9063
7t	S. Gopaa Rao.S/o Laxmaiah, aged,ab)u.t.54years, occ:.Inst.Meehanic, EI{Pl\o!19064
72	.M.Satl'rlandam S/oNarsirntra:n,^. agedab)ut56years,occ:SecurityGuarcl, EMPlVt>119075
73	.K.Sh:,r,2iS/oGangaram, agedi1b iut55years,occ:T.C.G ENIPl{r>1,}9078
74.	M.Chalr:rpaniS/oRatnam, agr:drrb:ut54years,occ: CoalCraneOlrerator, EI,IPl{ott9086
75	.P.Venkr.teswarS,/o Ballingam agr:d:rtrrut55years,occ:Inst.Mecharrit:, EI,IP],,kr29O96
76.	L.Deverd:rReddyS/oLingaReddy, agr:dabrut54years,occ:Clerk-W, EIvIPItlo29098
77.	J.lLt)er
78	.Smt.l3rrh:tradasW/oM.L.Das, agedaL,,,ut48Years,occ:Mazdoor, ENIPI.Jo29167

¶66

ii 1l

¶67

¶68

79 H.N. Sharrna S/o M. Sharma aged about 5O years, occ: M.A EMP No. 29168

¶69

l1>

¶70

Smt. M. Lakshmi W/o Ramuiu, aged about 49 years, occ: Mazdoor, EMP No. 29173

¶71

G. Bhushnam S/o Devaiah, aged about 48 years, occ: E.C.W. EMP No. 31399

¶72

AIl are employees of Cement Corporation of India l-:imited lCCILl.^{.fdilabad, an$ all residents CCI Township,} Ad ilabad, Adildbad District.

¶73

Petitioners

¶74

AND

¶75

1 The,Linion of India, Ministry of Heavy Industries & Public Enterprises, New Delhi rep by the Cabinet Secretary

¶76

2 The Cegrent Corporation of India Limited, New Delhi rep by the Chairman & Mariaging Director

¶77

The Chief hbour Commissioner^(Central), I 2O-Shramshakti Bhavan, New Delhi.

¶78

_^Respondents

¶79

Petition under Article 226 ot the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondents in not applying IDA Pay Scales under Memorandum of Settlement dt: 30.01 .2012 entered into during the conciliation proceedings under Sec. 12 (3) of the lndustrial Disputes Acl, 1947, to the petitioners while applying the same to the identically situated employees, though the 1st respondent has directed the 2nd respondent to apply IDA Pay Scales w.e.t. 1.4.2010 to all the employees. of 2nd respondent, as illegal, un-just, arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia and cohtrary to Sec. 12 & 18 of the lndustrial Disputes Act, 1947 and in violation of the orders dL: 20.4.2OO7, which were modified by orders dt:27.2.2008, passed by this Hon'ble Court irt W.P.No.5487 of 2007 and consequently direct the respondents to treat the petitioners on par with identically situated employees of the 2nd respondent by applying IDA Pay Pattern w.e.f. 1.4.2010 with all consequential benefits including arrears of pay

¶80

t.A. NO: 1 0F^2013(WPl f!['.^{No: 77 OF 2013)}

¶81

Petition under^Se r:t on 151 CPC praying that^{in the lircunstancesstated in} the affidavit^{filed in suPl} orl of the^{petition,the HighCourt nray tre plea:;ed to direct} the resPondents^{tc fortl} with pay salaries^{and arrears to ttre pe( tir'rners 2 to 81 in} accordance^{with lDl</sup> :'ay Pattern as per the Memorardum cl Settlement^dt: ,rs;al of the above writ Petition 30.1 .2012, Pending^disg Counsel for^{the Petitio} rers: SRl. K R PRABHAKAR^{(NOT PRES|E:NT)}}

¶82

Counsel for^{the ResPo} rdents: SRI GADI PRAVEEN^KUMAR' DEPUTY SOLICITOR^{GENERAl. OF IIIOIA}

¶83

The Court made^{the fo lowing:ORDER}

¶84

¶85

¶86

TIIE HON'BLE^{SRI JUSTICENAMAVARAPURA*IESIIWARRAO}

¶87

W.P.No.7^{2of 2O13}

¶88

ORDER:

¶89

When the^{matter is taken up for hearing' thereis} no representation^{for the petitioners'}

¶90

On 14.06.2023,^{when the matter was taken up} for hearing,^{there wasno representationfor the} petitioners and^{therefore,the matterwas directedto be} listedunderthecaption'ford'ismissal''Today'though the matter^{is listed under the caption for dismissa-l"} there is no^{representationfor thepetitioners'} Therefore,^{this Court is of the considered view that the} petitioners are^{not interested to pursue the litigation'}

¶91

1S dismissed^{for non-} Hence, the^writ Petition

¶92

prosecution.^{No costs}

¶93

Pending^{miscellaneousapplications'if any' shall}

¶94

¶95

stand closed.

¶96

SDLV.KAVITHA //TRUE COPY// ASSISTANT.RE(fi GISTRAR SECTION OFFICER

¶97

'O,1^{. on" CC to SRI. K.R.PRABHAKARAdVOCAtE^[OPUCI} 2. one cc to^{sri caoi p'rjil5n'iiliri'ri, it.[,{y.gglicitor'Generalof lndia[oPUC]} 3. one cc to^{SRt. RAMA'froeAlriiiNnhchRi,SC toi central Government} toPUCl

¶98

Two CD^CoPies

CHR ^ cJPA/--

HIGH COURT

DATED:19106 2023

ORDER

W.P.No.72 of ilCt13

.rt'-'',{.7e1'(,
y'.a*
i': ,)
l:ii 'l lr ,l[ ?$8
\r"
i
.: ..+:,- ()

¶105

DISMISSING T HE WRIT PETITION FOR NON-PRC ISECUTION WITHOUT COS TS

¶106

,;--
[o,)
M
1\r,

The Cement Corporation of India v. The Union of India

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

The Cement Corporation of India v. The Union of India

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

V.Veeraswamy, Hyderabad., Vs the Govt. of India, Rep Dir of Enforcement, Spl.Pp.

V. Jayasri Vs Jasmeet Singh Jolly

Bujji, Nalgonda Dist and Others Vs the Tsrtc, Hyderabad and Others

Isharath Banu Vs State of A.P. rep. by Secretary

Dr. Dongari Venkat Ram, Vs Sri Venkateswara College (Grant-in-Aid Institution) rep. by

Ch.Sathi Reddy S/o Yella Reddy Vs The Government of Andhra Pradesh