Disposed

Bandi Naresh and 9 Others v. Aggidi Srinivas and 7 Others

Telangana HC2 Jun 2021LPA/3/2020

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court disposed of Letters Patent Appeals and Interlocutory Applications as not pressed. The court observed that while the appeals were technically maintainable, the appellants, Junior Panchayat Secretaries, could not challenge an order regarding their own office, and the State had already initiated corrective action.

What did the court decide?

Leave granted to withdraw the appeals; L.P.A. No. 3 of 2020 and I.A. No. 1 of 2021 disposed of as not pressed.

Bandi Naresh and 9 Others Vs Aggidi Srinivas and 7… — Service and Employment | Telangana HC (2021)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR rr nvnrffiaiHE^{oF TELANGANA}

¶2

'i#5',',fl',r JiS"'^. iB Hpi #S J y,

¶3

rHE H.N,BLE ,ru [[iuT],]rrcE H,MA KoHLr

¶4

rHE HoN,BLE r*,rr3),?, B.vrJAysEN REDD'

¶5

t.A. NOS. 1 &2 OF 2020tN/ ND L.P,A. N :3OF 2020 AND Nos 1to3 IN/AN D L.P.A. N o. 1 OF 2021

¶6

L.P.A .No.3 of2020:

¶7

Appeal Under Clause 15 of Letters patent Act aggrieved by the order dated 27-12-2019 in c c. No. 714 0f 2019 in W.p. No. 46869 0f 2018 0n the fire of the High Court. Between:

¶8

1' Bandi Naresh S/o Kistaiah Aged about 2g years occ . Junior panchavat Secretary o/o panchayat Bir-ino"niir.i 6li"roprunt Governmenr-of Tetansana (Nizamabad),Telangana-State Gidda Vi,ase, R;'r;^' H;i;; -sg, Ml"n'iar,^i'rv' 'v Kama Reddy Districr

¶9

Chukkabofla Bharath, S]9 Rgvi Aged about 22 yearc Occ Junior Panchayat secretary olo eancrrzyit i5i-rno Rurar Deveroomenr Government of rerangana -cangliam inrnJ".'i"irr#"""ifiiililil Nizamabad District Telarigana State "-^-

¶10

Ullengula Nikil, S/o Ullenguta Mallikarjun Aged. about 28 years Occ ll::^P:Tnlyat^{Secreta-ryoro eanchiyatHJjand Rurat rje*6p.""t} bovernment or Ieranoana Dongergaoon Gp. Narnoor lVandar, Ad'irabad District Telangana Stale

¶11

Darra. Anjiah, S/o Bho_omaiah Aged about 28 years Occ Junior Panchayat .^{Sg"j"lury O/o} .^{panchiyatRaj and 'nurat-Oevef} opmeni

¶12

uovernment of Telangana Jayavaram Gp, Vemulawada (Rural) Mandal, Rajanna Sircilla District Telanjana State

¶13

Ashok Varikuppala, S/o Shankaraiah Aged . about 30 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary 0/o Panchayaf Ral and Rural Development G.overnment of Telangana Pottigubbadi Thanda Gp, Raghunaihpally Ir/andal, Janagaon District, Telangana State

¶14

Jadhav Shivanath, S/o Jadhav Rameshwar Aged about 25 years Occ Junior Panchayat Secretary O/o Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Government of Telangana Potpally-B Lokeshwaram Mandal,Nirmal District Telangana State

¶15

Balusani Ramu, S/o Munidhar Aged about 23 years Occ Junior Panchayat Secretary O/o Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Government of Telangana Paidipalli GP, Velgatoor^[Vlandal, Jagtial District Telangana State

¶16

Arragattu Ashok, S/o Yadagiri Aged about 28^{years Occ} '^Junior PanChayat Secretary O/o Panchayat Raj and^{RuralDeve-lopment} Government of Telangana Mamidala GP,^{Tirumalagiri Mandal'Suryapet} District Telangana State

¶17

Booyini Raja Shekar, S/o^{Pedda Bhoomaiah} {ged^{. ab-out 28 years Occ} Juni'or Panthayat Secretary O/o^{Panchayat Raj and Rural Development} Government ofTelangana^{Alia Nayak Thinda, GP Raikal Mandal, Jagtial} District Telangana State

¶18

10.Asoori Ashok, S/o Asoori^{Pedda Babaiah Aged . about27 yearsOcc} Junior Panchayat Secretary^{O/o Panchayat Raj and RuralDevelopmenl} Government of Telangana-Pothugal^{GP,Shabad lr/andal,} [340a.^Reddy .APPIEILLANTS in^All

¶19

District Telangana^-State

¶20

AND

¶21

1 ol Ai"n o. ?til?i^{"-lS,i |S,t:' gii?fif t';fl,3,' il'?Xf; 3'ft} "H^li,"E[l,ii H.T.No.5004838

¶22

2 H,:'?tXI,,'s:T:t,?3#.",".T3i4:i:['.::'il'Ji,i#''::iUnemproved H.T.No,5004906'

¶23

3 Ajmeera,Ja-s31'r :/:-F.'ReilffS 3i,,Y,:ffi-,:i,:^{yi#iBl8'"R/o 3-40'} Kosara, Kosara^{I umPatt}

¶24

Sri Vikas^{Raj. l. A S Principal Secretary PanchayatRai and Rural} Development^{o"p*trn"ni&Ei""oiiir'ig';u'seitt"turi't' Hvderabad}

¶25

Smt. Neetu^{Kumar Prasad IA S} '^{The Commissioner PanchayatRaj and} " Hri.r L.br"vrn"nt u,o,iHuii Lirie' uimavatnagar'^Hvderabad'

¶26

Sri Raieevgandhi^{Hanumanthul A'S' The District CollectorKumaram} Bheerh Dislrict,^Asifabad

¶27

sri Krishna^{Bhaskar, l.A.s,The District collector siddipetDistrict, Siddipet}

¶28

Sri D. Amoy^{Kumar lAS, rheDistrict collector}

¶29

3iJtsPr?+3',tlt:"il ot"'tfl.30"1

¶30

IAN O: 1 OF²⁰²⁰

¶31

Petition under^{Section151 CPC prayingthatin the circumstancesstated} in the affidavit^{filedin support of the petition,the High court maybe pleased to} trant^{permission to the petitioners/appellantsherein to file the present appeal.}

¶32

IA NO: 2 OF 2020

¶33

Petition under Section 5 of^{Limitation Act prayingthat in the} circumstances stated in the affidavit^{filed in supportof the petition,the High} Court may be^pleased to condone^{the delay of 24 days in filing the aboveLPA.}

¶34

lA NO: 3 OF 2020

¶35

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the judgement daled 2711212019 passed by the Learned Single Judge in CC 71412019 in Writ petition 46869i2018.

¶36

lA NO: 1 OF 2021

¶37

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to expedite the matter by fixing an early date for hearing of LPA.No.3 of 2020 in CC.No.714 o'f 2019 in WP.No.46869 of 20'18 preponing from 27.09.2021 .

¶38

lA NO: 2 OF 2021

¶39

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend G.O.Ms.No.10 Panchayat Raj and Rural Development (Mpp and Zpp Admn) Department dated 27.02.2021 and consequential show cause notice in Rc.No.142Ol2O1BlC, dated 15.03.2021 issued by the respondent department pending disposal of the LPA.No.3 of 2020.

¶40

/ /

¶41

C_ounsel for the Appellant in LpA No. 3 of 2020 and Petitioners in t.A. Nos. I A Z ot iO-Zi' ----: SRI J. SUDHEER counset for the Respondents in ,lr F"tiiion", sni A"SiliEJ, [r,ro*,

¶42

I.A, N os. 1 to tN/ ND L.P.A. NO.1 0F 21

¶43

L P.A. NO. 1 oF 2021

¶44

Appeal Under Clause 15. of Letters patent Act aggrieved by the order dared 27-12-20'19 in c.c. No. 714 0f 2019 rn w.p. r.rJ. +oaos of 20180n the fire of the High Court .

¶45

Between:

¶46

B.lr/allesh, S/o. B pochaiah Aged about 26 years Occ. Junior panchavat secretary R/o. H. No. 4!_fiil!,-N;;; Zp,i'S"hoor "K;;;;;,;[ih:: Attapur Rajendra Nagar, nanga nbodyti#ci.^'

¶47

2 Shaik Mubeen pasha. S/o. Saleem pasha Aged about 28 years Occ. Junior^panchavat Sebretary-na H.r.t." r_?75it,'lr"* Sangi Viltage I,4amada Mandil, Nirmal Disirict.

¶48

J N.Sai Kumar. S/o. N.papanna Aged about 30 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary ruo. ieObalr vl"norr,lirr* nl[na gar District.

¶49

4 P.Eshwar, S/o. p.Sanieeyq.Fao Aged about 26 years Occ. Junior o. n r.ro i-i-i6+ro,V"!v',i,.N,s;, [lL;,;l;;,

¶50

fiil.J:il:i.r::[,::?r "

¶51

Kodaveni Venkatesham, S/o.K.Ramulu Aged about 29 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secrerarv R/o H.N;. ii _i_iiiai\bb C"1;;y ,ii;;r;ifi, Nizamabad District.^'

¶52

6 Chirumarthi Venkanna. S/o._Dhasharadha Aged about 29 years Occ. Junior Panchavat Secrerary n1o. rf .r.ro. Z_ie,'Ei;'h#Iru Ve,emta Vi,age Narketpalli [r/andal, Nalqonda District.

¶53

7 Jadhav Ganesh, S/o. Jadhav lM^ohan Aged about 2g years Occ. Junior District.Panchayar Secretary R/o. H.No. o_+7 Lairamirrand;"pA;t luandat: Nil;'l

¶54

B Anjya Naik Vadithva. S/o Chandu Naik Aged about 31 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secret'ary nto. n.r.ro^- 1 -ii).^"tv;;;;iatiy vi,age peddemut A,4andal, Vikarabad district.

¶55

I Pirangi Ajay. S/o.tr,4allesh Aged about 23 years Occ. Junror panchayat Secretary R/o. H.No. 4/13, Thanthoti Vrrrig'e Aiira-;; [,4andat, Adltal;; District.

¶56

1 0. Jetty . Sai . S^agar, S/o. Hanmandlu Aged about 26 years Occ. Junior Panchayql Secretary Rl/o. H.No. 1-1-93i, navinOranagdr Cofo"v AoiLnii, Adilabad District.

¶57

ll P.Prashanth, s/o. Ramuru Aged about 34 years occ. Junior panchavat lggrglr.V^{RVo. H.No. 6-4-99.-Kumarpet Astiok noaO,AOlaOaO,} AOii"O'*i District.

¶58

12.Dadi Sathish, S/o.D.Nagaiah Aged about 26 years Occ. Junior panchayat Secretary Ryo. H,No. 6-48, Dongathurthi Dharmaram mandal, peddapllli District.

¶59

D.Narsimha, S/o. Anjaiah Aged about 29 years Occ. Junior Panchavat Secretary R/o. H.No. 6-53 ,^Thimmanagar Village Medak Mandal, IVedak District.

¶60

14.Shaik \agul Meera, S/o. Shaik lmamsaheb Aged about 25 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary Ri/o. H.No. 3-3121241C, Nayanagar Kodad Village and lt4andal, Suryapet District.

¶61

Kotha Ravinder, S/o. Kotha Lingaiah Aged about 45 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary R/ o. H.No. 1-174, Shanagar Ramadugu l,4andal, Karimnagar District.

¶62

¶63

'l6.K.MohanNaik,S/o.RajuAgedabout28yearsOccJuniorPanchayat '- S;;;i;t nlo. uarictrahd T"handa, Thunikl village Kowdipallv lr'4andal' Nrledak District.

¶64

17.G. Vishnu, S/ o, G.Narasimha^{Aged aboul27years Occ Junior Panchayat} S""r"tr.v ruo H.No.^{1321d, Machupally Village Kodairlt'4andal,} Nagarkurnool District.

¶65

18.B.Mallesh, Sio.B.Bacchanna Aged^{about 28 years Occ,Junior Panchayat} Secretary R/o. Govindayapalty^{Village Tadoor Mandal, Nagarkurnool} District.

¶66

V.Anjaneyulu, S/o. Sreenu Aged about^{27 years. Occ. JuniorPanchayat} Secr6tary Ri o. H.No. 2-40, Chennampally^{Village Lingaltr,4andal,} Nagarkurnool District.

¶67

20.lr/inqani Harish, S/o.tvl.Shankaraiah^{Aged about27 yeats Occ. Junior} Panthayat Secretary Rl/o. H.No. 16-3-235,^{L.B.NagarGodavarikhani} Vilalge, Ramagundam lvlandal Peddapalli District.

¶68

2l.Anthadupula Prakash, S/o. Narsaiah Aged about^{26 years Occ. Junior} Panchayat Secretary R/o. H.No. 2-70, Thombaraopet^{Village Medipally} Mandal, Jagityal District.

¶69

22.P.Shivudu, S/o.Narayana Aged about^{41 years Occ. JuniorPanchayat} Secretary Fi./o. H.No. 2-44, Eedhamma Temple Nagarkurnool, Nagarkurnool District.

¶70

¶71

23.Vallamdas Uday Kumar, S/o.V.Shivaiah Aged about 27^yearc Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary Fl/o. H.No. 1-234, Rahimkhanpet Village Athmakur Mandal, Yadadri Bhongir District.

¶72

24.fharya Naik, S/o. Pandya Naik Aged about 29^{years Occ.Junior} Panchayat Secretary FYo. H.No. 1-80, bapally Thanda Bomraspet Mandal, Vikarabad District.

¶73

M.Vamshi Krishna, S/o. tr,4.Chandraiah Aged about 28^years Occ.^Junior Panchayat Secretary R/o. H.No. 7-9-1301A, Sreeram Nagar Colony Phanagal Road, Nalgonda, Nalgonda District.

¶74

K. Srinivas, S/o. K.Lakshmaiah Aged about 41^years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary FYo. H.No. 4-2-391 , Shivaram nagar Colony Vikarabad Mandal, Vikarabad District.

¶75

2T.Yadagti Pythara, S/o. Ramulu Aged about 32^years Occ. Junior Panchayal Secretary Rio. H.No. 5-55, Kurthiwada Village Papannapet ltrlandal, Medak District.

¶76

23.Santhosh Kumar, Sio. Venkata Ramulu Aged about 38 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary R/ o. H.No. 2-4111 , Kulakcha rla Village and l,4andal Vikarabad District.

¶77

29.B.Vishnu Vardhan Reddy, S/o. B.Damodar Reddy Aged about 31 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary Ri./o. H.No. C-99, Vemula Village Midgi Mandal, Mahabubnagar District.

¶78

N.Srinu, S/o. N. Ambru Naik Aged about 27 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary Rl/o. H.No. 3-27, Peddabai Thanda Balanagar Mandal, Mahabubnagar District.

¶79

31 .A. Thimmappa, S/o. A.Hanmanthu Aged about 26 years Occ. Junior Panchayat Secretary R/o. H.No. 5-26, Jajapur Village Narayanapet Mandal, Narayanapet District.

¶80

.. Petitioners/APPELLANT in all petitions

¶81

AND

¶82

1 Aggidi Srinivas, S/o. A.Sambhulingam Aged about 31 years, Occ. U.nemployed Fl/o. H.No. 10-731111, Near Police Station Gajwel lr,,4andal, It/edak District. H.T.No. 5004838

¶83

2 tVattapalli Sathish, S/o. lvl.Veerababu Aged about 2T years, Occ. !lemplgyqd^{R/o. H.No 1-55/1 , NandigudemlVlandalPataram, Natgonda} District. H.T. No.5004906

¶84

3 A?rgptq^{JqSggiqtlS/o.G_opalAged about 24 yearc,Occ.Unemptoyed} R/o. H.No, 3-40, Kosara Tumpalle Aditabad District. H.T.No.5107400

/t'

/ //

'$y;{,,.,*l#fl o#"';,i"i;i,I,,j"?,s:Ei,r,Ttjgy,:u.*3t;,15: j,,o

¶89

'ffr :ffil:fi;ffi i;x';"1*t;i.tffi fi :rs;::fi il5fl H',ir!!Ru;uno

¶90

, 3[,;HB:J,rrfl?dhiHanumanthu,^{r.A.S, The} District Coilector Kumaram

¶91

' Si}#:T"^{Bhaskar, l.A.S, The District colector} Siddipet District,

¶92

Sri,D.Amoy Kumar, l.A.S buryapet. i, The District Collector Suryapet District,

¶93

I fu1. Dever-opment-D;d;;;;t?!1,?.iXT:.".J:?,:f,i:ilfl Raghunandan Rao, presr ,:i jtffjf *,,

¶94

...RESpONDENTS/ Respondents in all petitions

¶95

lA NO: 1 OF 2021

¶96

Petition under section,15r..cpc praying that in the crrcumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of tf,e peiitio'n, til ;;h Court may be pleased to grant special reave to fire, the ,pplur ,guirrt ,ni oro", dared 27r12t201g

¶97

lA NO: 2 OF 2021

¶98

Petition under Section.l5r cpc praying that in the circumstances stated rn-the affidavit fited- j1 support.glt1e neiitio'n, ir" ilgn Court may be pteased to g'rp."nr.u with the firing of certified copv of tne oroei aatea zttlziioTtp;;;"; by.the learned singre Judge in c.c. r.ro. ir+ oiio19 in w.p. No.46869 0f 2018

¶99

lA NO: 3 OF 2021

¶100

Petition under Section 5 of Limitation Act R/W. Sec. 15.1 CpC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit fired in support or the petition, the High Court may be pleased to condone the delay oi (+S1 aays in filing the.above LPA against the Judgment passed by the rearned sing'te.Juoge in C.C. No. 714 of 2019 in No. 46869 oI 2O1B a&ea ZthZtZOrg ] penOiig disposal of the above LpA.

¶101

lA NO: 4 OF 2021

¶102

Petition under section 1s1 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to suspend the operation of the order da|ed.27.12.2019 passed by the Learned Single Judge in. C.C.No. 714 of 2019 in W.p.No. 46869 of dOt8, pending disposal of the above LPA.

¶103

Counsel for the Appellants in LPA and Petitioners in l.A. Nos. 1 lo 3 ol 2021 : SRt C. DAMODAR REDDY Counsel for the Respondents in all Petitions: SRl. A.SANJEEV KUMAR,

¶104

Spl.GP

¶105

The Court delivered the following: COMMON JUDGMENT:

¶106

¶107

Items No.36-37

¶108

THE HON^{,BLE THECHIEF JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI} AND THE HON'BL^{E SRI JUSTICEB. VIJAYSENREDDY}

¶109

I.A.Nos.l&2OF20^{20 IN/AND L.P.A.No.3 OF 2020} & I.A.Nos.1 TO 3 OF 20^2T IN/^{AND L.P.A.No.1 OF 2021}

¶110

COMMON JUDGMENT:^{(Perthe Hon'bletheChief JusticeHima Kohlil}

¶111

The present appeals are directed against the order^dated 27.12.2019 passed by the learned Single Judge in C.C.No.714 of 2019, filed by the respondents No.l to 3 with a grievance that the otllcial respondents had breached/violated the common order dated 26.12.2018 in W.P.No.46869 of 2018 and a batch of writ petitions.

¶112

At the outset, we have requested tiom Mr. J.Sudheer and Mr. C.Damodar Reddy, learned Senior Advocates to address this courl on the maintainability of the present appeals in the light of the lact that the appellants were not parties either in the writ petitions or in the contempt petition and further, in view of the statement made by the leamed counsel for respondents/State before the leamed Single Judge that they shall take remedial steps by cancelling the selections made to the posts of Junior Panchayat Secretaries to purge themselves of the contempt and re-do the selection process under the sports quota, stlictly in accordance with G.O.Ms.N o.74 dated 09.0g.2012.

¶113

Mr. A.Sanjeel, Kumar, leamed Special Government pleader intb.,.rs this courl that in compliance with the arbresaicr order, the State has already issued G.O.Ms.No. l0 d,ated,27.02..202[ wher.ein. the

¶114

L.P.A.No.3 OF 2020 & L.p.A.No.t OF 202t

¶115

Page I oJ 2

¶116

selections made has been cance.lled and noticesro show cause fiave been issued to the appellants and other similariy placed appointees under the spods quota to the posts ofJunior panchayatSecretaries, in the month of March, 202 l.

¶117

After addressing arguments for some time, Mr. J.Sudheer and Mr, C.Darnodar Reddy, learned Senior Advocates appear.ing for the appellants lairly state that they may be pemitted to withdraw the present appeals while reserving the right of the appellant to assail G.O.Ms.No. l0 daLed 2i.02.2021 and the notices to the show cause issued by the State pursuant thereto, both on facts and in law.

¶118

Leave, as prayed flor, is granted. The present appeals are

¶119

disposed ofas not pressed, along with the pending applications, ifany.

¶120

-7

¶121

SD/.K.SRINIVASA^RAO JOINT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// G,

¶122

SECTION^OFFICER

¶123

To,

¶124

Sri.Vikas^{Raj, lAS, Principal Secretary' PanchayatRai and Rural} Development^{oupat."#3tft" ;iTi;;s"ta decretdriat'Hvderabad}

¶125

Smt.Neetu^{Kumar Prasad,l A'S'The Commissioner Panchayat Raj and} Rural Development^{oepirtmen-t'UrOut-tatt Lane' HimayathNagar} Hyderabad.

¶126

Sri. Raieevgandhi^{Hanumanthu'I A S' The District CollectorKumaram}

¶127

eh"uni Dis[rict, Asifabad

¶128

Sri.^{KrishnaBhaskar' I A S' The District Collector Siddipet District'} SiddiPet

¶129

Sri,D.Amoy^{Kumar' I A S' The District Collector Suryapet District'}

¶130

Suryapet

¶131

^^{1-*i^'i^n6r Panchavat Rai and Rural}

¶132

'H*3PSfl^{SXiS:&X".r3;?t?l""-TT:"'::!':'":'i':tiriiJg'ii'vo"'uu'o}

¶133

One^{CC to Sri C' Damodar Reddy' AdvocateIOPUC]}

¶134

One^{CC to Sri J Sudheer' Advocate (OPUC)}

¶135

nJy,".?S,i;""3',',t:,T5TXS'"TX?3if"%l:r"lernmentPreader'High

10.Two^{CD CoPies}

gbr

HIGH COURT

DATED: 0210612021

HE S 7,rl
c
,l il j: :l ?nfl
ot) I 'l ri '. :-,. r

¶142

COMMON JUDGMENT

¶143

I.A. Nos.1 &2 ot 2020 inland L.P.A.No.3 OF 2020 AND

¶144

l.A. Nos. 1 to 3 IN/AND L.P.A. NO. 1 OF 2021

¶145

DISPOSING OF THE LpA No.3 OF 2O2o AND l.A.No.1 OF 2021 AS NOT PRESSED

¶146

'b^b,

Bandi Naresh and 9 Others v. Aggidi Srinivas and 7 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Bandi Naresh and 9 Others v. Aggidi Srinivas and 7 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Smt.Yenugonda (Balamuru) Bhavana Vs Yenugonda Sneha Seel Naidu Alias Anugonda Sneha Seel Naidu

Bandi Anand Vardhan Vs Smt. Bandi (Nuthalapati) Sri Lalitha

Maddi Laxmi Vs Maddi Shankariaah

Y. Brahmanandam Vs Y. Padmavathi

B.Mallesh Vs Aggidi Srinivas

Jacob Mudi, Vs Kavitha Karnati