Allowed¶51

Subramaniyam (Died) 1. Sekar v. Kanniappan (Died) 1. Venkatachalam

Madras HC19 Feb 2025CMP/3054/2025

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Madras High Court, common order dated 19-02-2025 by Justice S. S. Sundar in CMP Nos. 3054, 3059 and 3061 of 2025 connected with SA No. 1240 of 1999 (Villupuram parties: Subramaniyam/Sekar side v. Kanniappan/Venkatachalam side): 421-day delay condoned, abatement caused by death of first appellant set aside, legal representatives (proposed petitioners 8-10) impleaded as appellants 8-10; no statute or precedent engaged.

What did the court decide?

Condonation of the 421 days' delay; setting aside of the abatement caused by the death of the first appellant; bringing on record the proposed petitioners 8 to 10 as appellants 8 to 10 in SA No. 1240 of 1999. ¶51

Subramaniyam (Died) 1. Sekar Vs Kanniappan (Died) 1. Venkatachalam — Madras HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

¶1

CMP NO. 3054 of 2025

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

¶3

DATED: 19-02-2025

¶4

CORAM

¶5

THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE S. S. SUNDAR

¶6

CMP NO. 3054 of 2025

¶7

AND

¶8

SA NO. 1240 OF 1999,CMP NO. 3061 OF 2025,CMP NO. 3059 OF 2025

¶9

Subramaniyam (died) 1. Sekar S/o. Chinnathambi Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Taluk. and 9 Others

¶10

Appellant(s)

¶11

¶12

Kanniappan (died) 1. Venkatachalam S/o.Lakshmana Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Taluk. and 11 Others

¶13

Respondent(s)

¶14

SA NO. 1240 of 1999

¶15

SUBRAMANIAM

¶16

S/o. Chinnathambi Udayar, Se-budur Vill, Villupuram Tk. and 7 Others Appellant(s) Vs

¶17

Kanniappan(died)

¶18

And 2 Others and 13 Others

¶19

Respondent(s)

¶20

CMP NO. 3061 of 2025

¶21

Subramaniyam (died) 1. Sekar S/o. Chinnathambi Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur

¶22

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶23

Village, Villupuram Taluk. and 9 Others

¶24

Appellant(s)

¶25

¶26

Kanniappan (died) 1. Venkatachalam S/o.Lakshmana Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Taluk. and 11 Others

¶27

Respondent(s)

¶28

CMP NO. 3059 of 2025

¶29

Subramaniyam (died) 1. Sekar S/o. Chinnathambi Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Taluk. and 9 Others

¶30

Appellant(s)

¶31

¶32

Kanniappan (died) 1. Venkatachalam S/o.Lakshmana Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Taluk. and 11 Others

¶33

Respondent(s)

¶34

CMP NO. 3054 of 2025

¶35

For Appellant(s): N.Suresh M. Gnanamoorthy D. Vasanth For Respondent(s): Mr.Mohd Dharwish for RR 4 to 10

¶36

SA NO. 1240 of 1999

¶37

For Appellant(s): M/s N.Suresh G.Baby A1 - Died, Vide Order Dt 24.09.2019 (steps Taken)) A8 - Died, Vide Order Dt 12.11.2019 (steps Due) M/s.R.BalakrishnanD.Rajasekar For R2M/s.D.RajasekarR.Rajarajan For Rr4 To 10R-3 ShankarRr 1, 11- Died ( Steps Taken)R13 - Minor Rep By R12R-12 Mahalakshmi, W/o K.Balu, Residing At Mariamman Koil Street, Muttathur Post, K.Pudur, Villupuram Taluk.Vide Court Order Dt 28/07/2021M/s.D. RajasekarPvt. NoticeAos Filed Reg R12 - ServedRr13 -

¶38

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶39

Minor Rep By R12Rr1 & 11 - Died, Vide In Eb For Respondent(s): R.RAJARAJAN for rr14 R14 - MAJOR & DISCHARGE HER mother from gaurdianship vide order dt 22/07/2022

¶40

CMP NO. 3061 of 2025

¶41

For Appellant(s): M/s N.Suresh N.Suresh G.Baby A1 - Died, Vide Order Dt 24.09.2019 (steps Taken)) A8 - Died, Vide Order Dt 12.11.2019 (steps Due) M. Gnanamoorthy D. Vasanth For Respondent(s):

¶42

CMP NO. 3059 of 2025

¶43

For Appellant(s): M/s N.Suresh N.Suresh G.Baby A1 - Died, Vide Order Dt 24.09.2019 (steps Taken)) A8 - Died, Vide Order Dt 12.11.2019 (steps Due) M. Gnanamoorthy D. Vasanth For Respondent(s):

¶44

COMMON ORDER

¶45

The above miscellaneous petitions are filed to condone the delay of 421 days in filing the petition to set aside abatement caused due to the death of the 1^st appellant by name Subramaniyam ; to set aside abatement and to bring on record the proposed petitioners 8 to 10 as appellants 8 to 10 in the

¶46

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶47

above second appeal.

¶48

2.The proposed petitioners are the legal representatives of the deceased 1^st appellant and the relationship is not in dispute.

¶49

3.This Court is convinced with the reason stated in the affidavit filed in support of CMP.No.3054/2025 to condone the delay. Since the delay is

¶50

explained to the satisfaction of this Court and there is no dispute regarding

¶51

relationship between the deceased 1^st appellant and the proposed petitioners, these petitions are ordered.

¶52

19-02-2025

¶53

¶54

CMP NO. 3054 of 2025

¶55

¶56

Kanniappan (died) 1. Venkatachalam S/o.Lakshmana Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Taluk.

¶57

SHANKAR S/o. Chinnathami Udayar, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Tk.

¶58

Annadayee Ammal W/o. Kanniappan, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Tk.

¶59

LALITHA W/o. E. Subramanian, Vinayagar Koil St, East Pondy Road, Villupuram.

¶60

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶61

K. Subramanian

¶62

S/o. Kaniappan, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Tk.

¶63

K. Mohan

¶64

S/o. Kaniappan, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Tk.

¶65

K. Sekar

¶66

S/o. Kaniappan, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Tk.

¶67

K. Arumugam

¶68

S/o. Kaniappan, Res. at Se Buddur Village, Villupuram Tk.

¶69

9. SUMATHI

¶70

W/o. Vivek, Manthoppu St, Villupuram. K. Balu (Died)

¶71

10. MAHALAKSHMI

¶72

W/o. K. Balu, Res. at Mariamman Koil St, Muttathur post, K.Pudur, Villupuram Tk.

¶73

11. Minor Sairaj

¶74

S/o. K. Balu, Res. at Mariamman Koil St, Muttathur post, K.Pudur, Villupuram Tk. Rep. by mother guardian mahalakshmi

¶75

12. Minor Deepika

¶76

D/o. K. Balu, Res. at Mariamman Koil St, Muttathur post, K.Pudur, Villupuram Tk. Rep. by mother guardian mahalakshmi

¶77

SA NO. 1240 of 1999

¶78

Kanniappan(died) And 2 Others

¶79

VENKATACHALAM

¶80

3. SHANKAR

¶81

Anandayee Ammal W/o Kanniappan

¶82

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶83

5. LALITHA

¶84

W/o E.Subramanian Vinayagar St East Pondy Road Villupuram

¶85

K.Subramanian S/o Kaniappan

¶86

K.Mohan S/o Kaniappan

¶87

K.Sekar S/o Kaniappan

¶88

K.Arumugam S/o Kaniappan

¶89

SUMATHI

¶90

W/o Vivek Manthoppu St Villupuram

¶91

K.Balu(died)

¶92

S/o Kaniappan Nos.1to4, 6to9 And 11 Are Reside At Se Buddur Village Villupuram Tk

¶93

Mahalakshmi,

¶94

W/o K.Balu, Residing At Mariamman Koil Street, Muttathur Post, K.Pudur, Villupuram Taluk.

¶95

Minor Sairaj, S/o K.Balu,

¶96

DEEPIKA (Major)

¶97

D/O K.BALU, NO. 13 AND 14 REP BY MOTHER GUARDIAN MAHALAKSHMI, RES AT MARIAMMAN KOIL STREET, MUTTATHUR POST, K.PUDUR, VILLUPURAM TALUK.

¶98

R14 declared as major and discharge her mother from guardianship vide order of court dated 22/07/2022 made in cmp.9100 of 2022 in sa.1240 of 1999(cvkj)

¶99

CMP NO. 3061 of 2025

¶100