and Ex.PB, which shows that the respondent is owner-in-possession of the land situated at Mauza Bhoga and Mauza Dugali. PW-2, Bhindro Devi, deposed that petitioner is her sister-in-law. She has stated that in the year 1986, the respondent has beaten the petitioner and thereafter, her sister-in-law Bimla, had brought her back to the house. She has further stated that Birbal, who is brother of the petitioner stated that he will not send the petitioner to the respondent’s house and thereafter, the petitioner stayed at her parent’s house for thirty years. She has stated that during the entire time, the respondent came to the village thrice, but never visited to the house of petitioner. She has stated that the petitioner maintained herself by doing household chores. She has further stated that the respondent has kept another lady at his house from whom he has three children. She stated that she does not know the name of that lady and stated that the respondent has retired as a teacher and has also landed property in his name. RW-2, Piar Singh, stated that the respondent never refused to maintain or gave beatings to the petitioner and also did not force her out of the house. He has stated that three children were born out of their marriage and respondent took care of the upbringing, education and marriages of the children. He has stated that when elder son of the respondent was two years old, the petitioner left his house and went to her parent’s house. RW-3, Harish Kumar, stated that
