Disposed

Hillal Uddin Barrbhuiya v. Musstt. Latiful Bibi and 10 Ors.

Gauhati HC4 May 2019I.A.(Civil)/175/2019

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This application sought a temporary injunction to restrain the opposite parties from altering the suit land's nature by digging a well during pendency of an appeal. The High Court ordered maintenance of status quo regarding possession and nature of the land.

What did the court decide?

Direction to maintain status quo regarding possession and nature of the suit land including ownership till disposal of the connected second appeal.

Hillal Uddin Barrbhuiya Vs Musstt. Latiful Bibi and 10 Ors. — Property and Title | Gauhati HC (2019)

¶1

Page No.# 1/10

¶2

GAHC010005942019

¶3

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

¶4

Case No. : I.A.(Civil) 175/2019

¶5

1:HILLAL UDDIN BARRBHUIYA

¶6

S/O- LATE HAJI SONAHAR ALI BARBHUIYA

¶7

R/O- BORHAILAKANDI PART-III, P.O.- BAR HAILAKANDI, P.S. AND DIST.HAILAKANDI

¶8

VERSUS

¶9

1:MUSSTT. LATIFUL BIBI AND 10 ORS. W/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶10

2:MD. ABDULLAH MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶11

3:MD. SADULLAH MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶12

4:MD. ABDUL JALIL MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶13

5:MD. ABDUL KARIM MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶14

6:MD. ABDUL RAHIM MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶15

7:MUSSTT. ZAMILA BEGUM MAZUMDER WDO- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶16

8:MUSSTT. ROYNA BEGUM MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶17

9:MUSSTT. JAHANARA BEGUM MAZUMDER D/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶18

Page No.# 2/10

¶19

10:ABDUL KAYUM MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER

¶20

11:MOINUL HAQUE MAZUMDER S/O- LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDER ALL ARE RESIDENT OF RANGAUTI PART-II P.O.- RANGAUTI P.S. AND DIST.- HAILAKANDI PIN- 788155 ASSA

¶21

Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. A H M R CHOUDHURY Advocate for the Respondent : MR. M H RAJBARBHUIYAN

¶22

Linked Case : RSA 289/2018

¶23

1:MUSSTT LATIFUL BIBI AND 10 ORS W/O LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 2: MD. ABDULLA MAJUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 3: MD. SADULLAH MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 4: MD. ABDUL JALIL MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 5: MD. ABDUL KARIM MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 6: MD. ABDUL RAHIM MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155

¶24

Page No.# 3/10

¶25

7: MUSSTT. JAMILA BEGUM MAZUMDAR(DAUGHTER) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 8: MUSSTT ROYNA BEGUM(DAUGHTER) MINOR IN 2014 TO BE REPRESENTED BY MOTHER R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 9: MUSSTT JAHANARA BEGUM MAZUMDAR(DAUGHTER) MINOR IN 2014 R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 10: ABDUL KAYUM MAZUMDAR(SON) MINOR IN 2014 R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 11: MOINUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR @ AYNUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR(SON) MINOR IN 2014 R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 VERSUS 1:HILLAL UDDIN MAZUMDAR AND 15 ORS S/O LATE HAJI SONAHAR ALI BARBHUIYA R/O BAR HAILAKANDI PART III PO BAR HAILAKANDI PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155 2:JALAL UDDIN BARBHUIYA S/O LATE HAJI SONAHAR ALI BARBHUIYA VILLAGE HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO . 1. PO HAILAKANDI PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI ASSAM 788155 2.1:2(a) MOINA MIA CHOUDHURY

¶26

Page No.# 4/10

¶27

D/O LATE JUNAB ALI CHOUDHURY RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶28

3:(g) RUKIA BEGUM MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶29

3:(a) AHMODUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶30

3:(b) AMINUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶31

3:(c) ISLAMUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶32

3:(d) UBADUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶33

3:(f) WAHIDA BEGUM MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶34

3:(e) HAMIDA BEGUM MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶35

Page No.# 5/10

¶36

3:ON THE DEATH OF JAMAL UDDIN HIS LEGAL HEIRS

¶37

4:(a) MUSSTT. KULSUMA BIBI W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶38

4:(g)NAME STRIKE OUT AS PER HON'BLE COURT'S ORDER DTD.1.3.2019

¶39

4:(f) NAME STRIKE OUT AS PER HON'BLE COURT'S ORDER DTD.1.3.2019

¶40

4:(e)NAME STRIKE OUT AS PER HON'BLE COURT'S ORDER DTD.1.3.2019

¶41

4:(d) NAME STRIKE OUT AS PER HON'BLE COURT'S ORDER DTD.1.3.2019

¶42

4:(c) (NAME STRIKE OUT) AS PER HON'BLE COURT'S ORDER DTD.1.3.2019

¶43

4:ON THE DEATH OF SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR HIS LEGAL HEIRS

¶44

4:(b) KAMAL UDDIN MAZUMDAR S/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶45

Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. M H RAJBARBHUIYAN Advocate for the Respondent : MS. R CHOUDHURY (R1)

¶46

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil) 3701/2018

¶47

1:MUSSTT LATIFUL BIBI AND 10 ORS W/O LATE MOINA MIA MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155

¶48

2: MD. ABDULLA MAJUMDAR(SON)

¶49

Page No.# 6/10

¶50

R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 3: MD. SADULLAH MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 4: MD. ABDUL JALIL MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 5: MD. ABDUL KARIM MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 6: MD. ABDUL RAHIM MAZUMDAR(SON) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 7: MUSSTT. JAMILA BEGUM MAZUMDAR(DAUGHTER) R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 8: MUSSTT ROYNA BEGUM(DAUGHTER) MINOR IN 2014 TO BE REPRESENTED BY MOTHER R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 9: MUSSTT JAHANARA BEGUM MAZUMDAR(DAUGHTER) MINOR IN 2014 R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 10: ABDUL KAYUM MAZUMDAR(SON) MINOR IN 2014 R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155

¶51

Page No.# 7/10

¶52

11: MOINUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR @ AYNUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR(SON) MINOR IN 2014 R/O RANGAUTI PART II HAILAKANDI 788155 VERSUS

¶53

1:HILLAL UDDIN MAZUMDAR AND 15 ORS S/O LATE HAJI SONAHAR ALI BARBHUIYA R/O BAR HAILAKANDI PART III PO BAR HAILAKANDI PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶54

2:JALAL UDDIN BARBHUIYA S/O LATE HAJI SONAHAR ALI BARBHUIYA VILLAGE HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO . 1. PO HAILAKANDI PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI ASSAM 788155

¶55

2.1:MOINA MIA CHOUDHURY

¶56

D/O LATE JUNAB ALI CHOUDHURY RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶57

3:ON THE DEATH OF JAMAL UDDIN HIS LEGAL HEIRS

¶58

3.1:AHMODUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶59

3.2:AMINUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶60

3.3:ISLAMUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI

¶61

Page No.# 8/10

¶62

788155

¶63

3.4:UBADUL HAQUE MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155 3.5:HAMIDA BEGUM MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶64

3.6:WAHIDA BEGUM MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155 3.7:RUKIA BEGUM MAZUMDAR RESIDENT OF HAILAKANDI TOWN WARD NO. 1. PO HAILAKANDI TOWN PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155 4:ON THE DEATH OF SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR HIS LEGAL HEIRS

¶65

4.1:MUSSTT. KULSUMA BIBI

¶66

W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶67

4.2:KAMAL UDDIN MAZUMDAR S/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶68

4.3:FAKAR UDDIN MAZUMDAR S/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR

¶69

Page No.# 9/10

¶70

W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶71

4.4:NAZIM UDDIN MAZUMDAR

¶72

S/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶73

4.5:SALMA BEGUM MAZUMDAR

¶74

D/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶75

4.6:RABIYA BEGUM MAZUMDAR D/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶76

4.7:KHATUN BIBI MAZUMDAR

¶77

D/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR C/O KULSUM BIBI MAZUMDAR W/O LATE SAKHAT ALI MAZUMDAR R/O RANGAUTI PART II PS AND DIST HAILAKANDI 788155

¶78

Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. M H RAJBARBHUIYAN Advocate for the Respondent :

¶79

:: BEFORE ::

¶80

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASANTA KUMAR DEKA

-O R D E R-

04.05.2019

Page No.# 10/10

Heard Ms. R Choudhury, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. MH Rajbarbhuiyan, learned counsel for the opposite parties.

¶85

The present petitioner as the plaintiff filed a suit seeking amongst others for recovery of the possession of the suit land admittedly under the possession of the defendants/ opposite parties. The trial court dismissed the suit and on the other hand, the first appellate court decreed the suit. Being aggrieved, the opposite parties as the appellants filed the connected second appeal. During the pendency of the connected second appeal, the present petitioner observed contemplation by the opposite parties to change the nature of the schedule land in the petition by digging well thereon. Considering the claim in the suit, the petitioner is constrained to file this application with a prayer for restraining the opposite parties from changing the nature of the suit land by way of a temporary injunction till the disposal of the appeal described in the schedule of this petition. Mr. Barbhuiyan, on the other hand, objects to the contention of Ms. Choudhury in respect of the act of digging well on the schedule land.

¶86

I have given due consideration to the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties. There is no denial of the fact that the present opposite parties are possessing the schedule land if we look back into the reliefs sought for by the present petitioner as plaintiff. Though a decree is in favour of the petitioner as on date, the same cannot be accepted to have attained its finality inasmuch as the said decree is challenged by the opposite parties in the connected second appeal. The intent of Order XXXIX Rule 1 of the CPC is to preserve the suit property so that no inconvenience or irreparable losses caused to any of the parties to the suit. Considering the same, I am of the opinion to direct the parties to this petition to maintain status quo with respect to the possession and nature of the suit land including the ownership till the disposal of the connected second appeal. Accordingly, this petition stands disposed of.

¶87

JUDGE

¶88

Comparing Assistant

Hillal Uddin Barrbhuiya v. Musstt. Latiful Bibi and 10 Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Hillal Uddin Barrbhuiya v. Musstt. Latiful Bibi and 10 Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Md. Safiqul Islam Vs on the Death of Late Lakheswar Deka

Sri Bed Prakash Agarwalla and 4 Ors. Vs Sri Puranmal Agarwalla and 9 Ors.

Nazitora Bori Vs Sambhu Prasad Thakur and 5 Ors.

M/S Gagan Deal Trade Private Limited Vs the Union of India and 5 Ors.

Smti. Maina Das Vs the Union of India and 6 Ors.

On the Death of Bibekananda Roy His Legal Heirs and Anr. Vs Smti. Probhabati Roy and 3 Ors.