Ms Shraddheya Kuwar Maharaj Shiksha Prasar Samiti v. Encore Asset Reconstruction Company Private Limited

DRT14 Oct 2024SA/967/2022

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

PAGE No

CONTD. ORDER-SHEET

CASE No

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER M ftfu$r{6Rrsrfrnn^y-snqfrfr\rq3r-q cQ-c oq-fr fttu-s gq3i-q w..^e67/2022	REMARK
't4.10.2024	3nieo^qq{dfu *rroeqx W erkq-trrt sm-.4rfrtndfrqfrEf-+frffi srks-ffirI
	ffi ddrdffrq+frsrpftqfrkd erBq-mrt
	1. gtrqs&To\vs.q.u-cgoznrtdgv fa_d-q6terq-rftri^qritgtr{gdfrrn^rr} fuqefiTorrnfi^emr5TqfileftF=qqerr$q 241s/2022ftqrm'OS.1Z.2O22W1J-rT^.rqTt, qf,{ur 613r{dff,{fu-qrqqt
	2. getrrrfl:q6 i fuolricl qBrnrk{ifrzs.ol.2o24dwXvnguu-o<vrd sqqseTo)rrsilq-{3nne{3Td.. 5s72/2024 q.iqrds-$IRdfrtnqdsFddft{yrfrll-6 s63o/2024^q{ETr^qmlqcnrqGrrerT& g{Ba.fu-qr^qqrt,fl6-{3ilAvr^qBfiTfrirn ts.os.2o24dergrrn^qsqdEqfuTo.\vrq cr-qBsrfltrdtWfdcr-qaqrfr;dq.dtg 3itrftq3nk{an$.q.z+rel20226rft{rf,-{uT e)sBIsmomq'cra-q.n6\dfuarudgv sqrr^qeTo)g{{fuqer-qr3nn{r^qrgcr^rl-ql ttdilTsReerftr:^gs'.q.o1vMqor1's fuf,qds-€;r^.F-rfurf{ur fr-qr^qrrdrBI

Ms Shraddheya Kuwar Maharaj Shiksha Prasar Samiti versus Encore Asset Reconstruction Company Private Limited — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶8

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER 3. 3iliqfieH gr{rffiors.r 1.2024d srBf,qqdrrqa{6vs.y.erm17(1)E{+ffi y.rd2oo2dqrdqTr)doHrgs.q.ofdfu-+r zd^qrta.qt^{q'ifu-dq-drimr}ftrfld3trdgq wr\t-aeefa-+rr22ol:ozzfisc-rqrfr ffiqlrcenflttscerrqrfr?F-qr65dqafr frqrRdofr$tgqr1q4fr_6-qorffio) 3rqrrf,frrdq.dsfrtrdrtdTdqTal3rar crjstFrfrrrarcrdTfuu-*gdo1.r$ d,dq.rr gEqrITRTrz(r)w<S,frv+d2oo2d.qrqqdi dcnf,.fdr+gooritgfrtrdvrrqrcrB45 fuqqlt^qtE)idorqurH-oos.rz.2o22d onlef,^qerifu-qerqrfr;dqd tgGird-{r qrl.y.zqfi/2022rrqdfuqTt6amrTq GilqTqtfuGnnffiqero\qm+q qtqq-iaT sa^qlztrf,qrgusq-d-dttrdq-idvtqe{ s-c-rflAilfid3{fus-fiTrgmrfrTgqTr-fiT-fr dellqs^qsfuil-604.11.2022o)qaf,?-qgrfl Eon^{fuE-Eqfufuirozo.oa.zozzq\fuo-qo-r} fr^.riB^q-qfusorqrfr+-f,d6RTfrfuo.
qfu-ffifio-t"srdqfrrnR--flfrdrfrft-6-q offio1^.r{Br
4. 3niffiserorq6fio?-rctfu gn elin-+otsn+rcsqqfiq1dor-dr-itr Tqfrt-avrtrRrd=dd^q-frq-{ft-flzn26.08. zozzr+ofrqrr3f,qB^qiBdBf6Efr-f,q {ffiqrftB,erqrrh.qt,{s{oilqNwfrcreerqr o-{^q-m-{qE.{qr$tg ftdqrioi3r-jq)qfuqT .rqrtt

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
3.
3iliqfieH gr{rffiors.r 1.2024d
srBf,qqdrrqa{6vs.y.erm17(1)E{+ffi
y.rd2oo2dqrdqTr)doHrgs.q.ofdfu-+r
zd^qrta.qt^{q'ifu-dq-drimr}ftrfld3trdgq
wr\t-aeefa-+rr22ol:ozzfisc-rqrfr
ffiqlrcenflttscerrqrfr?F-qr65dqafr
frqrRdofr$tgqr1q4fr_6-qorffio)
3rqrrf,frrdq.dsfrtrdrtdTdqTal3rar
crjstFrfrrrarcrdTfuu-*gdo1.r$ d,dq.rr
gEqrITRTrz(r)w<S,frv+d2oo2d.qrqqdi
dcnf,.fdr+gooritgfrtrdvrrqrcrB45
fuqqlt^qtE)idorqurH-oos.rz.2o22d
onlef,^qerifu-qerqrfr;dqd tgGird-{r
qrl.y.zqfi/2022rrqdfuqTt6amrTq
GilqTqtfuGnnffiqero\qm+q qtqq-iaT
sa^qlztrf,qrgusq-d-dttrdq-idvtqe{
s-c-rflAilfid3{fus-fiTrgmrfrTgqTr-fiT-fr
dellqs^qsfuil-604.11.2022o)qaf,?-qgrfl
Eon^{fuE-Eqfufuirozo.oa.zozzq\fuo-qo-r}
fr^.riB^q-qfusorqrfr+-f,d6RTfrfuo.

qfu-ffifio-t"srdqfrrnR--flfrdrfrft-6-q
offio1^.r{Br

4.
3niffiserorq6fio?-rctfu gn
elin-+otsn+rcsqqfiq1dor-dr-itr
Tqfrt-avrtrRrd=dd^q-frq-{ft-flzn26.08.
zozzr+ofrqrr3f,qB^qiBdBf6Efr-f,q
{ffiqrftB,erqrrh.qt,{s{oilqNwfrcreerqr
o-{^q-m-{qE.{qr$tg ftdqrioi3r-jq)qfuqT
.rqrtt

¶13

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER s. B-d{qffio-qrq1ffiq^qnelanr
	ftqroz+.os.zozqdr+goft;i^.rdqqrsd
	qtaqtfuqerqrerd-fiorffiu6GEq GrrqfuA.dBfu^rIF+qffq^q-*srs@ -{t tqtd^q qn-sfrd,-qrfuridr{qeTqrFdor @qlznaB22/2022dgqq{Sdrtq+d
	cTFCfrrd-cftqiEzo.oa.zozzdfrqqtnT{d
	*}r+r€q-{^Fr6xr'rfrrerrflRrrfrfrd
	eTk{ffir^gwrq6dsq{gI^rrqTelTsEtcn}fi
	woddd{rc sorqrfr6qroI dorB{ffir
	a-{rfrdor^eqFq-rq-fi-q qq q-dqr ga
	-{rfdq-{ dRT fr{rqn -ql{flaiq 6t
	srfr-mla-qrq aazz/zozzI^EilE-dtrqF+o
	04.11.2022ffi qfronil{f,qerieRo
	gqqrg3r-nfifuroro.oe.zozqdtrterq-+fl{
	rdwtrqoo1r$*,otoR-sTsGtr
	weq-s3nfttrd6r^qd3ilqfufrT$Bfu
	qrfumTfrerqFnooid w isqRel-oqer
	im-qiftdq+rtsx{6r{rufrrenw{Rnfrfrd
	3rk{trr+frS.d.eu-dr-f,6nrzFB6r 11^it
	fu-qrwTndu-*gofu-qT^rrqrergs{6ild
	rtcr^rrzrlsnfu^q.Grr.{fr.ftmqidfuBd{ot
	tRrq-drSr-qfrfu-{fi^qrfuoT-nafoffi1
	ftrffig$dr€^qdo)fr-o-q^qrfrqrozo.
	ol.2o22dff{qtFdo"-qfuqrt,3nAYrat
	dB6re^gs1ri^qrB-ordenqfro-o-ot^qeT
	trrdfideq-qoN^r
	ork{frT+ftS.derqqrdgms-{gdfrrn.ri
	ilddosdioT^q"f{tftmdrqqGEqlq
	F-+TaT^qrrr.fif,TBfu enqM M

¶17

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	qf,RrurRienq-{ffie.ftfrd orfuqftT*orq-srddNTa-ddqn+qdqa dPq{sr^.rqrqnfuq.Gilr.rfl.offipa6 fuBcRr-SBfu-{fifrff{N'$-d oTEwi{q ,r€qrfroit-d+sfr+fi26.08.2022d qqqr)fu-qiwrtorrrld esrtrrrqfut rrqBo+d+s furozo.oa.2o22qrflqEq. q{T.q.don-il{o'o.qr61MSWers TsRr'Ifrreilrrnsrrfrfroiffi oq.tt.zozz dTftrqo,sncfu'ts-d{qrfrt-fid qfrB.fudqrurqtongsnr
	6. uagrvfuofrfuBfuqRse.qer< orsqdfr!-qd^q-qqqtqrderestrf,i"r rqorSE3rTE\oqfuf,qerqrfrdrarior e-+nfr6pu1 trfi-dordgv,r+rrrn+gofo-or qmsTEqVsq'f,{ur u-rqno-Sdrlrprfr t{d-qerqrfr.,iqriorsrgfrqft-qrqrqr qTR,fu-ggss-mlutdor-nq-oqeTi3riilfi o1oBf,r+trlav+trmeffiozo.oe.zozz dsrqdior i.+orcgf, frrd .rdonleqA or5dqfur604.11.2022sdfudfrqT,fu-g fuqerqrfrrd^qdoTerfi{aq-+TUTlrqd o{id^qrsrdft=r-605.12.2022orrtgofu-qr rrcnrllerfru-rgf,frrdd3nifit"iior<"r ediqr^q6frEqrsdr.q r-SBqfo.neatqt dr
	7. 3rrd_<-o^qeTof otte'nrgoftd.rn ewrnq qi-@ig/r+qlfu6-qq-afrqrozo. oa.2oz21eqrfuf,^qfrt,{€-dcnq-o}f,{ rqetfu^qgqfrft-rTo2s.08.2022o)qrw

¶21

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER 01^.T{B+E+rfu^q+@i/4dtrf6yE q{ft{AqFTsq6}sqdqrrtrsrwm-rfror fu{r6^.Fqlr6qFt-dt.aeee-gqpqF-mral qT+,TTfuqvaqfr3il'd<-o'qeTifuTro'2e.oe. zo22drr€qr{sorfr^qrq6rfuqr^QrTilqt 3nlEo^qeTd^gr{fr^q6olqBfus-c-rqrfr 6qr6srrqq^rrfd^qeltisd{qrfroqior ({v.er<.rt;{+tr-$ino<=cqqTc6qftd
	6r-rr{rlfuo-q^q:frsFtflqa3llqfud ftq-qdQEvrruftrdcrilq6{taSs^.FI
	qd=q-{ft4pqzo.oa.zozzq\6{rutqTg_6T B nq3rtEo^qeTdftq^qrso]-{uTtdS-ssfi qqftdqfrqrwd{iftnrm2s.08.2022t
	wqqfrqrfl-qTiil-Srro{eridft-{rf,M.10.2022 (fitro-{qrqodqrcrqTEqur,fu-gfuo
	1s.11.2022droEqnrgafu-+r^rmtg-(
	ona-dr6^qeri^qfrqqR-riot^q-fi-(q,[sgd
	o-{itaofr+qotfrarq*iorsrftozrc
	ordgvoil'fi{rtaofuur^g6qcilt{oveT '
	dftroil?rr{ro'^enfuffi r+.ro.zozzI
	Rirore.rt.zozzd^qurqf,{uTrtnoorid
	gVft-a<olvrqlqnTnf1qef,{nTfuq1^qror otfu^qa3rD6{'r^q-{r5^qqt<TGrBfr'qqd
	qrsiliiofglfrilqior[q-.ro<fueErTfrrd q"d+frqs qft-qx ororr
	B. rrilfqqmfiqqtqrtYrs@ -qtqt(,lq 6mffie-rtg@grey-dfiEil6oIE
	$E{r^{gsern qq.20?12024}t^qEE
	3rdYIffi6 tz.oz.zoz+Ifi ^rr{qqrerd
	or-5{rr{lra$ffigqd2oo2dGtrr!-sgdg!

¶26

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHEORDER trfi-{urfrfuaqerqrfrri^qdtgerc5^qqiqr eTfuR{qdHzrErFr^qrdrcqt,fuE^q6
	grvifuoflEBfufuqerqrftri qdtg snn{6ceTo)^q-d}s-q-r-f,q?ilr+ilfr^qqiw 6r{ur^qcIT;ITdrott.t
	e. {s^q6wrt^eirilcoqeTifuqflqr friS^qritnldernmfuqrfu^qrfreR
	ffiooa.rt.zozzd^qm-+qqwq-lqs@ 'qlqleiq g.sft-d-qrfdwdr+rreTqlfuor qnrqaezz/zozzIn-dd<t<tcsf,{fleqa
	dork{ffirdmqqrtn-oqe-q-q6x6rgFr E3n^{qdosafr'{slT{C'.qTfr dqf6;qdn'ss} qqrFraBfugsufu-q,ro.otqsTdEtqq fr-o.-q{iqq-6nf+o-q^qaof^qqtFrdqfrft-flzo 2s.08.22r)^qIR..FTid^q'ssrdtan d^qrliJ11 qr{ft-qs@;qlqrf,qdlsqer,fr g{{s-flord
	onn<o^qeTderks-fiIifr^q-e'dss{sTerr fu-{.frfu-se{qT3n}fiioea)ol^rrdflE"qFr ordgv3il-iEqrqofuureruiou-tgool-ildt-{ qdrrflilfrtcfrqgBdenrgmBr
	10.^qn-+q\r@ilq -qlqlc{q d^grgr
	st{S{ot-ffiq liM ffi-qe-frur^g1
	Asd^(zors)6Vs.fr.fi.412^qqFrqrkd
	olR-qdd^q-qilrTi^qrsr3TqfqlorBftqqd
	utlqmrT{flrfuqtwgds-o-wrft-{trfuql
	qtqtqGq,r-dfrffiqqaiq-q-qrftqror qftlrcqfu-qTe\t uqfrstrroiuTqmfi qeTgr-{tqqq1ffq1orqRflqfuqrfi.T?Trtt
	11. opa\offra"-qTo-{
	Gikf,{nTg{rFrqS^qr!-g"-dT^g6Grril{ove{ Ou'.'

¶31

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER dxrrrgdfraq^erqTGrra-<-{ut!.y.ztts7zozz ftqrm0s.r2.20223lltrrqfr-{tssrid{+m-rEi drq'r€tBI^qRqrqrs$qfuerseffirorrd-fi ftrrdfuqT^qorBt 12.3rq^q-dsffiq tfuerilroqqd
	gRrq6vrr.g.srfurd3r-fdsdgs.q.ot
	oR-dTzfr^qFf-oB,U&qwr) t-afis fr{is26.os.zozz^yqffi6Tffitsrrq
	qrqznr{qdommwqcfrgrrror+orfu u-goo1^.T{torefiderq frxfr^qrqot-r.rrd 3{ltil{^q{\rsqtrq(TfrBI^qsfr3IF-{q-{ 3t-,qoeq[dfrsqd^,frmTiF+-{"rS T$ {r6r{ardnotclfrfrs-f,{rro1frquft{.fi furfRdo1^qrfrBdt^qeen'd-{fr^qeTdxrt{f, dftq-qd^qrfr.r{rrcrrrdrerqB eTkf,B^yq er-qot{!Tdr-{mEria^qrsorqq^q-ilrr-fr
	o-sftoqGnil{6^qeTaRTtrqd{6vfl.q.3il-t g't<ivwt3t^qt-iztrqrfrw^qrftGreri( g..1.qdtg^qMqrfrBr
	13.^qEft[t.qGnd-{fi^qeTarrrr1dvs.q.
	or-qE.^qrBdfttrfRdordgvgsfrrd{w ftwdo1^qrfrtr
	14.nfu.^qrlE-6qeT6r-rttrqdw.q.g,T dq^qsEirrrie}'qrSttry+rqwGna-{dr qeTofoi-rtrqofu-or.rqrffiqsil-n<-{ dnl.y.szzt/262affi;q22.08.2024"ilew
	o-iqe{fl-{r^qrRd3iltyrffi-o.zt.tz.zozed
	frq-qts-Krfud{SEr-{tlr-qBdtGen$.q.
	s63B/2024cilsfdd fr{prt{mEdB,Ur

¶36

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	trm-{ur^qXurE}s^qqft-qro-<q^qY,qtETfr dritftw_nF,r-qer-s; furffud6{dEq F-{trfrrn^qrddI
	15. VIIiI^geT3ITFITsIrFII^q-qq5qo-tlt qRqrqcddr
	r6ToTerfuA-sFTRt^q-qrfu-qrqri f
	(vrft_apc,qld; ffiq3rffi S. 3rr.d.q.q.\rqE-frg1rTa

Ms Shraddheya Kuwar Maharaj Shiksha Prasar Samiti v. Encore Asset Reconstruction Company Private Limited

A compact analysis

Ms Shraddheya Kuwar Maharaj Shiksha Prasar Samiti v. Encore Asset Reconstruction Company Private Limited

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Union Bank of India versus Mahesh Kumar Bhagchandani

Bank of Baroda versus dhiraj

Bank of Baroda versus Mohanlal

Rajesh Gautam So Shri Tilak Singh Gautam versus State Bank of India

Anil Golait Son of Shri Bhagwat Golait versus Canara Bank

Ms Patel Timber Company versus State Bank of India