Kishore Chelani v. Uco Bank

DRT6 Jul 2023SA/580/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

. CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No.......

CASE No.......

DATE DESCRIPTTON OFTHE ORDER	REMARK
vfr.g^580,/2023
06.07. 4023 oTr'fq-6^qeTdftq*fu{qffi 3Tfuq-ffirI
strt-qrfrto,dfr\frEfdgi 3rfu{ffiil 1.Vrrrr^q8rdtft-f,qefir3Trilfi^qd.q. 2ass/2023d^qreToiilRq sarrrdrdffg wEqrTqrtt
2.^g-S-{uIOT3iS-dt6-qfu-qr^rrqrt
3.rlslrto:f+aqefiror-ilfiflftgrwq fo-qr^qr{6rtI 4.sTril{f,^qeTHRrft{;q'zz.oo.2o23oi T6e?DwTErnr17(1)S-i+ffiVreZoOzd crqqriidsiird-dfr'rq+,sTrfuq-sr1ffir o)erqrwfrrn^qfid^qrprfreTcro--+€T q{dgt6nrcIRf,sTrtcrfti'.r{,1a.08.2022 o)erqrwfrrn^{qd qi}sfl?rf,rdffieT 3r{srFr6rrErrrdrfurtgdfuqI^rrqrtt 5.e-6-rqseIITEwrerofuerBf,ttEfl tgffdqsrcr^Gfint{qqrl..zass/zozs+ qrtqqtffirqrqdo.-t^qggfuo<ot ffiTfrrt^qriororTtEfoqr^rrqrtt 6.srril{fi^qeTENI{fl3il-iqq^qrild rqteqfisor^EqHw^sTBmwrgrtr t+grqdw.g.1sl202sfrcrR'f,,ttttcoi-" 08.q6.2023(qi-Ey^q/3)gsottotoi-" 26.0s.2o2s^{(si-@i q,/6)qreTIotrf,}o{^ild {€rT^rnntofsTrtfficsHr-{$^ttrEo frdTntrm-{urvfl.q.1s/2023t fr{c sTrilfi e-qf,fl^eTcrfuf,rfrz sq-dgi gMcrRdsTrtcrfrirofi.0s.2022o,IsTcrK ffi^qddlsfl-rrf,r^{e-trrfuf,ofT{fr,}

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

PAGE No..

¶7

Kishore Chelani versus Uco Bank — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶8

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
ffiS. 1s,/2023sTrtcr frirooe.oo.2o23dsi-Em-r^qrEonurd GFTrs^qftEworfrqt^rTqTIEHor{q rEf,foi^.rnfivnq-c arrd-fi,rer"FsTr+fi qdfrmqflcroTr-il{qoisTffiildtgtEg Eem'^{BDYUIsqflo{tofErirrdrfr.r$f} sSEtiTdrd^oiild-dq5ltn{urrqdfuqr qro-rfuoqafiroTrt{qrq(fuqrrrqrtI 7.vffiqrfrsTE{ffir^grqrGil-ilfirnrat$ fufudwErsrqdl-€tfrrqr^.rwt,foE dfuo,wtenqfuTdo-rffi^.r$ta6 rqde-s-{urt^q-qfreftdriqiqqoTr}-qq rEofuvt^rrqrwgq:rE(^y-or-rfrrfi qibatrerqmGl-qfuqrkdt,ftrg-dc-6Tvrt sil-nffiTeTer,l-q?DrEfi-Ef{^q-€ttr 8.{6ErQTIfuf,14frtoffuf,q$Trn"T arFrTcr-qofsrffiorofwm-oo-rort, .rdfrfr+ftqsrErgrcft-qrEdqrtgqt GTrcfuqdco-{-fr rrgdIrsH-<g{ rrFftqvqerqamflcrq?DI qEiilstrtr otstrqtfuu.rf+nHIHr+Afrfres ffrq O.ffi^(zors)o \fl.fi.fr.+rzsr-{d}o;ftq tI vgro-tqd^qmfiqB@RrritrEt'.rrDI srftqdtfuqnrgrqkrsrDfr{qd Hsqrfl-gtTrfumqtrqd^qnE,or0-d, sTr'ffiftrwoqfuqrqfi.nlqqfrfrftft rTHERrCfufl-Sqfu-qr.rqrd.q.RuIHrrrr ficreTs$rerfl^;q[qof^qifrqrqrilq ot ffior tn1^y,Trfuf,orarBt
9.eielffl^gerrf,:qltfficcTrh)q-6ckIFIT firofemro-+€ruEEWERrcrR-d sTrelrRt[fi18.08.2022ofeTcrwffiqd
tsffi q-mYorfrsrqSqrdGi{r

¶12

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER s-Edo{ rIfleII \rrl tro-rqslEorrurAerril-sfrfu{wfrri^qri c{AGffiiTflrdergqdsqqfind sis,({6rfi-{ursTrt$ftqt6re.oe.2o22d srrrffifrrn^qritge-qdgent,ueror fosqcrnfrri^qrifrrq$1
10.W.q.1sl2023^itcrR-d Gr-tcrfu'ro 08.06.2023^tDT3T.rq,trO-{^q-qq'ftS-OrrOd
srgsR?16^rnqr'Irortfu3Trilcr-6^rrsrErtI Tffi^{]r?Fwrfrffiq-{sTlil{qen{.q.} z2as/202a sil-A{Ift-{ro$.os.2oz2o) Gflrifudfrri^qdtgrydftrqrrqr^QTr\q vs.q.^{'rs/zozsfrclR'f,sTrtslfuiro} 2s.0s.2023(qiffi{^q/6)t se tofsm sil-il<rft{pzo.os.zozgofc-qdfu-qr^rrqr eTr,srQrtdseta1sTrtqrfrqtota.os.zozz dIsTre\fudfrti^qdtgsvi-l-{^sTIilfi ft{pzs.os.zozao\u-go^{fu-urtrqreTI,}d set doTrt{rftqb^ls.es.zozzo)ffi ti tgsdcqqri{hn^qTtfiF{io, 2s.0s.2o23d^qrtqqt^sTFo-qqd^sqe{ q-rtttrft,urrrat,qqfuqrqrrz(r)t-ffi vrrc^{2oo2d crqqn\d ffdq[E6TtuI} vecq6ttt+skqsd^{3iiletrnccrqd} Etcr "TFd I
q 11.crRf,^sTrtcTlfrto^18.08.2022ot oFsf,rstsetoff,'fr^uao\q+<r qeurfifrtqrrqTaTrvs3i-flt{6^qq{3leltd *rftsHslq{o-fr€r^{s{f,g{d HrIcI} sTkf,trrd^qrqqt^sqfurdEcrI,^frt-{ot$
qfltrrqdr€tfuqt dqqrqr(l sTrArT fuiora.os.zozz^{qfuf,fr;qr.rqr,dtqg.fr}
setatcrRd^{sntsls.Tqceno'\ gr-qri} rrr31rt-{Rtol^{qrRdlilqFrqrsTrtcrt,}

¶17

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER 5I=T TTTT a it+ergr6"6* clq frirora.oa.2o22t qrtnt i2.sil-tvrft-ii-o'1s.08.2022o}gctfiti tgftqfRdwrqfrqr+sfu+s03erqq-r 2022dfrsqrcdT+1eft,n;-g* forffrflerqB^tfsfl-il{oce{tTdaikd rfi'{qtricilrrcaTrtrqcu-qf,T€tfuqr^q frsrr-tildtsTrfrfrdfrrn^qfifuwa-a xrwrrqdfu-qr,orQrfdse t^qftTd furqatrfi-wryfl..^{q$/zo2sq qq} ft{;qzs.os.zozso-}ssiu{sTra-fieqd ftqr^rrqr,vtrdo-rht HTqTdfrgqsTrtcr dg+fitttgfqBdoiil,fd^yrqtrfun qrqfrqrwqqe\g+tr 13.w^qkoqqdamVs.g.rslzozsfr crRdsil-t{foqiooe.oo.zozso1ofts-orr+ fr^qatqefu-qr^rrqrtofsTrn{6^qero1 fri+o^qreor<ordfrsqtfrfudtrd e-rqHrrqScro1^qqfqTtrrfrggyrro. F-{ureEoo-{isfr EriTdrri,ftrtsr TStofTdfrrred^qorordqrtqqt silifficeTolGrqEsrfuf,varrrdTtgft yQrsxD{oTu-gnortofEiiTfltfr.ri tr	REMARK
	14.{floTfuo{urdHrreTqqq6 crqrf,-f,ffrs'wrRirozz.oo.zozsolu-qa fuqr^.rqrt,s-sAorqtHTq XdfrsTQrff, oasrqq-{zozzder-EtEercro-n€r qq-dgqgMcIRf,c[rtcrfrqiofi.ol.zoz2 dfrsqtno-qqrgaoriofsqqfrqr sqme)T+t ,fi,irtlvoqnffiq fuS^q-s16urilrto1"eflffio;rw

¶21

DATE DESCRTPTION OFTHE ORDER qlcreIqHrorGlr+rorTsTEI{tg-qf,T6 trtr-{qIuIdswEilqritgTr6qfo-qr^qr s-o-ort"t	REMARK
1s.T6sdqfiqtot^qm+o@krrr qrqld-rldENIqfilqrAfroaIfufr& P4sq^qfufidq,Etrgqr^gferq2oo48)
gc.Evd.q.4osofoftsfi"roztqa frB RTrfudorfr^.r$tAerrr17(1)s{+ffi v€ +ff,.f(u-qodi^qrdenieqoT ssqsrtfrrfi'erffiorwisrd ^qtqtf,g drrqar^ar.c.{.dtrdu-qd*t^qrdeK vadergwEtdIt,dt^qqg'sstfi-oqqd $rTf;r^Errqr17(1)Hqdffi^g€dstr( sifu-d rrgrirflItHdtrf,rfiwr^GIsltxT sTrtfiorFr-sq^qt-Errzdergw+dTt vq^qmrz(r)wffi$E^2oo296^frils sq.itiB,ffi trds-fi-{qlsil-tfirtrd ttr{ttg^qryqfiqrsrEol-{qvsqfrt ft{iot+s fl+qsfrtssct^H-qErR-dB, ffi^qqklsTfufu{q1e63of^qnrsd rrrrn;trsqdtTt,tfrro-sqtar.1c-S fuqr urTtfrDillgg^g.e,fi^qmfiqvqilq RII{IIdq amoqrdtfu ^{gfffrqfrr gst}
crf,frq ffrqfitfrr.rd +d;dstriT{
BqCtrc\ti srqOooa) zvs.fr.fi.^rogt cffi{doTftqd^erqf,qfiqg
' 16.{sdTITgTfr^{qTTftqqqr*IBEI}
an{nrFrds.sfi-denrfr.srnft.(F.ft$.)
o.qt6378stdn ^gfiffirTd^crff,c
tum&f{s€ ^{sTanr{w oTrstsr EFgq-{tf}
q'i-fr'qtq'tisrq qrFror iFqFF3r2sl/zo'tgI

¶27

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	RE]',ARK
Erlttdfiurqfil{i6o5.oe.2o1eqfrffiqiDG	?D<II
GI qfqfcfq dqrsftddENTsrffiT
orqRfrocrg+efuft&ciierq frtqoqqr
T6-dffRtierqzoro \ry.fr.fr.sfrc drf,{
ed6d[1361 qr+ftqdrorvaqrffirqd
Er{T d.fi.qqc6t{r+dErss stEIsII
TFII?EHfrTEEiTT.F.iT Gffi{ffiT
ordtsn ftTfr&2or5\rrT.fr.fi.silq dr{r
*tqrzsnz cffi{d^qq-{Ertiffrfltqq^q
T6frfuEteTrfrd01T$to1umrz(r) q$ffi T€2oo2ddil.fdu-qodtord
erfi!{^qnssqIF{ tflq^qaor+drt,fti-sq qrn5ErqifloTEftqqdqrqETHarrlrfrdit

¶33

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	RE]I,ARK
	Eil';ITSISIqI tr
	19.^rDErFrSg3il-iq-fi^qeTOteirtrqa fuaqsqrsTr'ffiur$.v.zess72o23ffi drrq^qdrittr{Rfu-qr^qrdrBr
	20.AfuoTi+eoERTrqdro{uroi-qfu qrfudt,EHtrnuroTrileo,cerssroqqi srq{o-i{cr^qs-d$ilttcIfuoTrt{rf{ir6, 11.os.zo22dffi ftrqterrn^qriorfi ro-qnc-€t BI 21.sTrt{6cs{o1r te-Ed^rrdSs.. slo/2o23sr-qfu^qrkddqT furi'RdoGgv qrterMlfudftrnqfidrrqqi tfS kRqrft{tro1^qffiBt 22.^qRunq<ddtt 2s.s-6ruroTfuilqFnr^ttwkdrgrffi, slD
	ffi{qffi S.enq.fr^q.c.Tsu-ffwra

Kishore Chelani v. Uco Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Mr Santosh Kumar Sahu versus Uco Bank

Shiv Industries versus Punjab National Bank

Ms Narbada Dairy Foods and Farms Pvt. Ltd. versus Union Bank of India

Pushpendra Raikwar versus Aspire Home Finance Corporation Ltd.

Kishore Chelani v. Uco Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Mr Santosh Kumar Sahu versus Uco Bank

Shiv Industries versus Punjab National Bank

Ms Narbada Dairy Foods and Farms Pvt. Ltd. versus Union Bank of India

Pushpendra Raikwar versus Aspire Home Finance Corporation Ltd.

Ghanshyam Das Rungta Foundation versus Hero Fin Corp Limited

Chand Kumar Sehgal versus Bank of India