Allowed

Balkrishna Agrawal v. State of Chhattisgarh

Chhattisgarh HC9 Feb 2007WP/3781/2006

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This single bench disposed of a writ petition challenging an order by the Joint Registrar cancelling permission for a society to re-sell land. The court held that since the Registrar lacked initial authority to grant such permission for educational purposes, his perjury order was ultra vires and automatically redundant, leading to cancellation of the impugned cancellation order as well.

What did the court decide?

The order recording permission was quashed and the consequential order of cancelling was also cancelled.

Balkrishna Agrawal Vs State of… — Contract and Commercial Disputes | Chhattisgarh HC (2007)

¶1

'ii'-in ^rf<x?wr^il |DT i nc^V /'MMATT!CnAB!-l»/nn?ii it<^^r^i-%nir^AT*_ Rl!h?ij^rSS?*—^£^&CD{ 10

¶2

Singl^ Bsiich ; HonTbi& Shu Vijsy Ky?liar Shnvsstsvs, -J.

¶3

WriS PetiSor. No. 3781 OF 2005

¶4

PETmONER:

¶5

Baikrishna Agra'A'ai, S/o. Late Shri R.D. Aarawal, Agsd about 49 ys-ars, R/o- 24, Doongagi Coiony, Raipur (CG).

¶6

vsreus

¶7

RESPONDE?\TS

¶8

Ths State of Chhattisgarh, Through the Secretary, uooperative Q^QSir^Fi^Q^t mantraiaya, D.K.S. Bnawan, Ra'pur, CG. The isgi'str; Co-oc-opsrativs*1< Societies, Raipur, CG. -•a Ths Depufrj Registrar, Cooperative iaocieties, Kaipur (U<3).

¶9

The Joint Regtetrar, Co-operative Societies, Raipur.CG. f'irih Agroha \5> ii i Nirman Sahkari Samiti Maryadif ( a registered CoQnQratiyQ ^/vJQh;^ UlfOUQh Ite Manager, snn Knsnna Kumar Gehre, Agressn Nagar, R'ng Road Chowk, Mahadeo Ghat Koaa, Kaspur (UU). Ct Hari Ram 'li-iaiHtiii/is?\n%wsMf^ T^r**ei>i iM&i., througn rts President Shri Rsii&nrfrciJ «»rtt•A Goya! MOIA/ Tiryihor Market, Fafadeeh, Raipur (CG)-

¶10

Pracopit ••

¶11

Shri Rajsev Shrivastsva, counss! for the pstitioner. Shri N.K. Agrawai, Deputy Advocate Generai for respondente No. 1 to 4/State.

¶12

Shri V.S. Agra'A'ai, counss! for rsspondent No.5. Shri Ravish Agrawai, sr. Advocate with Shri Manindra Shrivasfava, Sr. Adyocats snd Shri Ssnjsy S. Agrsws', counssl for rsspop.dsnt NO-B. Shri Gautam Bhaduri. counss! for Intcr'/ener —Santosh Aorawa!

¶13

\6 O R D E R (Passedon 08/02/2007)

¶14

T^fri<£ Tsfi*if*^!^ i*r>r!iKi1'1 &4?ll& ^OC/'?'?? nf+h^ ^nr^o+^t i^An ^>^ tr»rts* ^sso i ) ii^? j»'^?uuvu ui\fj?» f~\it.i'^if ^s-^s^i^i Va uw /'hifiii?tii,«iUvii i/i tiiui^i ii<<*>

¶15

i^A^i** fftf^,^ <!>/v^I^ir>^t ^s(l/»i<tirt<"i rii'^li/s'fie • wswi iif^^ ^ffcTvjij^ ii/livWJJiw iWtiVii^. "Ts !ssu9 wnt of cerSoran ter yuashfng ff?© onrfer dated 19wy2006 passed by ihe Joini lwry'"'»"J^{•l^-w'} hiry/iu-* ul **»»»•l/»<r»/^»^*^»<-l»^< %WtfJWfMf .

¶16

'•;h

¶17

Respondenf No.5 prepared a p!an to consfrucf a coiony af Agrasen Nagsr st vHisge Raipura. !n the said coiony iand measuring 6.54 UI>T?Q;^>s-rso ^/^fiiiiiyha-srinn rMicl5»i«iK'h-xera i~iiV^,Mne ^?"r^/,"^.dR <fi^ii^^t't7n ^^V^'fQ /-t-t^tAA ^^vf£.^tt.P./') ^-h//A.1ACn ciii^iar.ri ^-futAn hs2 Has>f ^'on+ •'^<^sr>./^'4 fftr iS'^'ir'ai'S'M^-'s! »!!m^^i& ^i it^<.n/<titi&r»^h» 1^^ tsff^ titttf s^Wii n<?jufi, i t;t3<?j Vs?'u it^i ^?v<viv<tUvj icii l/yfji/ti/^t.?. *i./U>i/^<?viys?itiiyj yj^? i>cliv» isnd was soid fo rsspondsnt No.6 for sducationai purpose v-ids registered sate desd dated 29/09/2CX3';. Ho'A'ever, rospondsnt No.6 did not f'^fvrw^vtf^i^ t»^*^<'^r*i/t^»^i>"i /tn ('t^A tf»-^i^4 i-^«^/4 Vt'^f\v^\ff\vf^ » r/%o/\tirM/Mn +^^ <k/^/^! ^vi i i i idi iv^? i^Vi i5»Hy^iiivi i Si'ii iiiii.? dufw iuiiU, Uid <?ii/jc?, ci i^^ib/iUUii/ti i.v/ S»i t>^.^»v»«?^!!/M^frf\iiv* +hA O^tritio'tr^af /^/s /^K^»'•»+»/\ C.i^.ft^+i.n^ +/^ /»si^/<'<^I +t</\ &• ^vSiiiil^^Y'^ii iiVjii ui'vS Mk'^yi^ii ui, wV~Vj^«i?jEii,iv%7 OVi/i%?uw& iV i/tfiiiiLrisi iir uisfeFv*'^s&^ Wt'oWdS yt'9^'>&/4^t35^fc;w v»if^f^{'4£k/ri'?/'?Q^S} i^ivA.f&.wV h/y^? ii?5^/yiiy<51iirQi^y^^ff&^ ^if^f'KV.i?^ (.ifiyft^t^ <5ii^ioA^r vfc/li<iiftif^i^'froSr*?*^^! ywic^/M'n^iOGi/'y*S i ii&SiVj t tl^^'&i jC "li^/^t//^tfifc/wV^? itfiit^(in»4 iU iflanff¥y«i> fj^i <s?-:5>viwa»/^l/^ Ii^ii i ft'at^/\tiCivwiiii>» ^i^^f f^f\H i<? ^^^+W/sn/Mt/i^iiUyi ici. '^^y&^t'^&v1 i wi w.i Wi i !tf^f^vtvi^ f\ff^^.yViU^i ff.^'^.'^wtfeiwu '?i^ff/Vt£./'/\f Q/r^cS/?^V^-^ iw^^viiu'Viii.(•'!»««ni^in^^rf i-<iV.vMi?\ '^ rl^'!'^?'^/^U^v*cii^FW *('<-&iii's? ssie deed executed in favour of the psSitener as iiteflai and void, hsnce the instant petition.

¶18

v/^\ TI^.O1 uo ^'^Mii^i?<.s^l'??^>^i i^'<^ t«^ i/odjt^^>^r< /\l^i^^\jei^/<!v/^^/^^^u ii/yl^it r/»tf>»^^>in^<trt»»'lu?x?^pvfjw^iit^ t»iin sS.-^ ff\r^f^fii^iv<?iM; it iijsiiiiWjHTiQnrisr ta tc?yjjysl i QslRS thstui<ai i nii viMS?iorcfsr toii^ ^yijip^i.corrsct thili ^ iiJi&U.i^femi'stsks HI!ri 5dwssto dooc? ^Qted ^..^i^^i&.w i tfl.nT*^•«»•»,tlFtiij r.t^^(<»vii<i?y«aiw•^ ».A*Aiw tfr^iiu^idl^h'o^ra i^'^^ft t^tmml^sr'siiuiiii^^i^, i»v>^/M'e »'.n^^^^fi>.ii<.(^.n+r&<sn^Ln^^n+i ^S(/Vi iU^f ii. i'vV.-^/ M ^s^ iC i^Al«?wwi<7M^\ff/i 1+A^Il< /^rrJ's/lfA?»•&iwri ftf^^ffwGM ^ii/^n A,W/iV/\ifcW^7'?^/'1H/'?rif1£!( iwiii fstf^\trjfiwUi /\fvi ir^en/in^A!^^ ^5|/vi fW^i iti M/^iVv».vff liiiUUyiii-I^r/M i^ifr i*<?ti& Managsr Baikrishna Agra'A'ai, who is petitionor in ths instant pstition, b U{ fKi<?Mti*» i«vi^-?t ^V?</i ^^m^./4^/\r^<^Vi iis?wlivi titii^tl-'"i<* 'w'w'i'l1'^^i^w f'tn»*r^f>e.^/il5>U|./t/i'<=S»^s7*i '»n»<fsiiiU ^*Sui/i>/i<.?t?^HtM ir<»cti«^/<tf'l^^viii'^ »»</»('/\ri'»Iii>ciisii)ic«i 'T'h^r^^r^s faCf,) yvtRni's^rw"^si^n i 1 ti^^fi^i i f^si.^/ ir''^-^'?^ \7~<?siti<-? fh^Ujig? fuiju!'?»il4 ii<i^fra's ;<»<p^iif^'''4^s?» ^^^•I'^s^tii/ft/ieiitj^rU. i jt^it,?!^'*^, *"*h^*><WJi^ii .liVf;S !^^s4^'.&'ItiGit.v.Wi vi^? O)^Mi/l/it**t»^F^<&<i[^^« S755fri i^j t't^^\Uj^ jtirtt^ii^ifivi-n+^rint f^^f^'viu^/H? i»f^s<W««&?u>iViJsjiiitsr/M t/'il'^^ fcniv ^^.Aii i^? rivii^s?n^\ti/i/\ <>/^i^ l^irt+ ^Si'^.t'^'Tf.ir /^ft-'^r^*'^>fi<'^ ^?^?&+s<? H<^ ?^/"H/^/t ^'irH^r e\r^if.f +^^ »/vijiJoin t i Roo s 'ii<?y i O t .iG, »iuifv-v|h/^i<;iiifv^ ii.'Vvf^ii^?^) ii<? i^^uii^u <?<iii^i i/i^^i

¶19

-<br>

¶20

-a>

¶21

ft-fstMCii.*"t^uinrfiu iL?iii»·^c·r^/^r».yk/>i .»»^ini>».n(k/«iiWi <'k/^U is? <• ^^tta^ciiii? .rt^*/\^^«?<=f^t AU-^^*!SA<>?^UfcS?\*i^.&<^ iiIi^ i f^\rf\ti<»II^ri^frMt'a i ii itft Agrsv.'ai. 4) Undisputsdiy, ths disputed land has been so!d by respondsnt No.5 t^\tv c^tc»ri^k»^^i/\K+it.?^i^vi iU^iii, i-ijv.wM^s C 1/jft^t* r^\,ni<*t/^fy\/4i^af&ii^icw ^'»I^s^cii^ .y4<^..ft/4u'is^ui •f/^fiVi ^*.rt>^*?'i^4.^r'a'^?'M^^vi i5iiu<^i«aiiVii f^^luiiiii esf^uit/s.fss^usSUUy tt\tyftf^t i^y\f'i\r /\rK?M-uppi^icijyuiiJ^?JilKi **i** ni»^Lt^?jy ^'^.^\v*!fi^istt\i^j/^Vjtji/uiijf +hi>/y fhiSui/vuitf^^!!rf f/tfcv ^ fh^UiS? ^./i!^r^l>»'t\/vjt>IVij lA'hi^t**Wifi^ii &tyUiVi*•>• !<^*^r?~'s^!i^^^.i \/vjjifc!^*r»f Gf\f^i-?i !rftff\f*!^\i <•/» <*/'kH ^/\^*i/^+i^^ l'a»^/4 ^M' +/^ .^ilr.n.f't i1t?l>?^'*r'ls'n?>A'viufxiiiw va.ftttsuiriui Is'.a'idW, li/Mt-ht!<" +/^iv vs^ifxuil^vi&<£+'!i^lt&h M<eij^Vjj&tiiVJi?*^>!^'^^|i'ttl/^?l< ^-fvi +h^Ui^ fr^in^wic u<?<?u^l/tjn.^l n^iiw /t<li/k in^^n+ h'^tf I^.AJ^I^ -^.rl<nli ».?A.rI lA^t^^i^ ^.frSl^r f'F'»rt<?A>ir »v»<i/4At»t.»i r^\rvic-tf\v^irf wv/u(ii<. itu^? w^ii aiuUM^^u. ¥Sfj^?ij i^diit^i i.iwiiS?i^i iiiuw^ h/y tf^ ^f^^^f ie »»i^ j^'vi<?<'^«^/-/^ <?* ii^c>i'/<it I/M^+ o/alA /4i^.A^ <>%^.A^»I1+^^/4 »»fray/Mir ^\f ^wiv utSF^vj i^ ji» ^?Ai^ii?Jii/^, ^uii/d<?^u^?j li ^fiiiis? <uf^s?u ^Ais?Mui<;u jij i<2¥vyi Vi i^Af'tfi^n^rti/^ui.ivi id , liif ti,if i^i& f'niv h/s?i^^ ^iii^'iv^s*,ar'?/?'^^'1^ ^h"afiiiictii /kj;tf^<<li /»»»h^Vitiy U^h<s sn^F''^^^!^iilVi^^U iw'y^1' ?4^"!etr''>+AnU<i?MirtiriUvii ^V^s .0 y^^MW»»^^.4'^!n(+?niltr+ /^y .ft,4^^rkan<»^ >»> ^i.^y/ir^ifliit^A latti^t .»v(^^sir |/^»»t)^»a»tiftfty i/y & wfiip^t^Fi ii ^/VUii Vi VUi^iWi^t? iij Uii^L'viMtfiU^t.; Witii vii i^i is?y«i tiiuifiiis?i, T^'f!/^i iiis/ i'''"^riai i vjiiyf^t/ fv(^ "ie/»^+^il^/S/<ifif^^^jiuijiissvd Giii.^i^kfi^ir ^<t^ frA»^tlK-^<^/M^iu^Fi^iijiiiiuiivii ii^vi t»^ri/M*^Vtitiivu^ ^"K^+^i6iiL<in? <ia, ''x*^'^'^**uii^asyw^lQr'^ft W.ft/yKy v/vfy\ii/vMih^h T)^^fh^uj^t "Ar4iA<st^^trfi.negrfcii U^^ _Wi,itJ^it."{^t»jn « w.h<»K.f^yMiiiii? r /^^ ^ i*i!m iir/^ i.^j^ytailie ^ i-t' i i l ^stM.^.i^n^/^^viu<?i^t"^^r><»j^'^ 'sx.rt<(<iiivin'4 <ua^»»tt^fe^+'t^i!iuviUui -n.rlit f/<fi.n^»+i/»»^ t.t^iyvii^dUvi i.

¶22

¶23

6} When Joinf Regsstrar wss not empowsrsd to granf psrmission to respondsrst No.5 to se!! ths !snd, automsticaSiy rscaiiiRS of such permissio", is redundant.

¶24

!n tf h e rssuit, not + only n.t^Kr ^fr»* ths orci®rH-&ri us«t^uf*^&fi >t^!HAHf\n^,i ^tu-rf £.w\f ww^vt-s^^/sr^t'ift?'* Uii iy perrRjssion fo socisty by Shi Rsgistr,cSi w ^uitL'^ii^u, Ktrf ^^^<>*^n^ sequent thersto recaiiing ths ssid ordsr v'.ds smpugnsd order is ateo canceiisd.

¶25

R31U

¶26

Sd/V.K. Shrwastava Judge

Balkrishna Agrawal v. State of Chhattisgarh

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Balkrishna Agrawal v. State of Chhattisgarh

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

M/S Maruti Clean Coal and Power Ltd. Vs South Eastern Coal Field and Others

M/S Maruti Clean Coal and Power Ltd. Vs State of Chhattisgarh and Ors.

Bhaiya Lal and Others Vs Ram Vrichha @ Shiva and Others

Murari Lal Yadav Vs the Cg.State Election Commission andORS

Abdulla Yusuf Vs State of Chhattisgarh and Ors.

Shyam Mohan Agrawal Vs State of Chhattisgarh and Ors.