Union of India challenged an Armed Forces Tribunal, Goa Circuit Bench order. On a territorial jurisdiction objection, the Bombay High Court transferred the petition to its Goa Bench, extended an interim stay till 2 August 2024 without expressing any view on the merits.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
16-wp-924-24.doc
Digitally signed by URMILA URMILAPRAMOD PRAMODINGALEDate: INGALE 2024.07.10 14:54:11 +0530
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 924 OF 2024
Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Defence (Army) .. Petitioner
Versus
Maj. Piyush Shandillya (Retd.) .. Respondent
Mr. Kedar B. Dighe, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr.Pranav Dessai a/w Mr.Tushar Agrawal i/b Mulani & Co., Advocates for Respondent.
CORAM :B. P. COLABAWALLA & FIRDOSH P. POONIWALLA, JJ. DATE : JULY 05, 2024
P. C.
1. The above Writ Petition is filed by the Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Defence (Army) challenging the order dated 22nd December 2022 (for short, “the impugned order”).
Page 1 of 4 JULY 05, 2024
Urmila Ingale
16-wp-924-24.doc
since the impugned order was not being implemented, the Respondent herein filed Writ Petition No. 1380 of 2023 (F) before the Goa Bench of this Court. This Writ Petition was disposed of by order dated 12th September 2023 when the Goa Bench of this Court interalia ordered implementation of the impugned order. Since the impugned order was still not being implemented, the Respondent herein has also filed Contempt Petition No. 16 of 2024 before the Goa Bench. In the Contempt Petition, the Court has also issued notice to the alleged contemnors. The learned Advocate for the Respondent, therefore, submitted that this Writ Petition should also be filed before the Goa Bench of this Court otherwise there is every possibility of there being conflicting decisions.
3. Faced with this situation, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the Petitioner [Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Defence (Army)] sought a direction that the above Writ Petition be transferred to the Bench at Goa.
4. Considering the circumstance narrated above, we direct the Registry to transfer the papers and proceedings in the above Writ Petition to the Goa Bench of this Court and have it tagged along with
Page 2 of 4 JULY 05, 2024
Urmila Ingale
16-wp-924-24.doc
Contempt Petition No. 16 of 2024 filed by the Respondent herein before Goa Bench of this Court.
5. We have noted that in the above matter an interim order was passed on 04th October 2023 granting a stay of the impugned order dated 22nd December 2022 (Exhibit ‘A’ to the Petition). According to the Respondent, this stay has been obtained by suppressing material facts, namely, the order passed by Goa Bench in the Writ Petition No. 1380 of 2023 (F) dated 12th September 2023. He submitted that though this order is annexed to the Writ Petition, the same was not specifically brought to the notice of this Court when the Petitioner obtained the order of stay on 04th October 2023. He submitted that this is because had the order dated 12th September 2023 was brought to the notice of this Court, no stay would have been granted. This, of course, is refuted by learned Advocate appearing for the Petitioner.
6. Since we have transferred the above matter to the Goa Bench of this Court, we do not want to get into this controversy at this stage. Suffice to state that the stay granted by the order dated 04th October 2023, is extended, without prejudice to the rights and contentions of all the parties, till 02nd August 2024. The Goa Bench will
Page 3 of 4 JULY 05, 2024
Urmila Ingale
16-wp-924-24.doc
then decide whether the aforesaid stay should continue or whether the same should be vacated.
7. We must clarify that we have not opined on the merits of the matter which shall be decided by the Goa Bench of this Court uninfluenced by any observations made in this order.
8. This order will be digitally signed by the Private Secretary/ Personal Assistant of this Court. All concerned will act on production by fax or email of a digitally signed copy of this order.
[FIRDOSH P. POONIWALLA, J.] [B. P. COLABAWALLA, J.]
Page 4 of 4 JULY 05, 2024
Urmila Ingale
Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Defence (Army)
Maj. Piyush Shandillya (Retd.)
B. P. Colabawalla
Firdosh P. Pooniwalla
As recorded by the court registry
3 orders share this CNR
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
