Ainuddin Vs State of U.P. and 3 Others — Allahabad HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

Ainuddin Vs State of U.P. and 3 Others — Allahabad HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

What the court decided

AI extract

Outcome

Interim directions only (writ petition otherwise pending): show-cause notice to Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate, returnable on 23.01.2025 at 2 pm; service of notice through the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ballia and the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia; matter to be laid fresh on 23.01.2025 at 2 pm; order to be communicated the same day to Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate and the Consolidation Officer through the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ballia by the Registrar (Compliance).

Issue for consideration

Whether appropriate action should be taken against Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate for his consistent dilatory tactics and interference in proceedings of the Court. +1 more

Court's answer

Notice was issued to Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate appearing before the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia, directing him to appear before the Court on 23.01.2025 at 2 pm and show cause why appropriate action be not taken against him for his consistent dilatory tactics and interference in proceedings of the Court.

Ratio / Principle

The notice upon Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate (appearing in Case No. 448 of 2022-23 pending before the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia) is to be served through the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ballia and the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia.

Detailed headnote1 paragraphs

Allahabad High Court (J.J. Munir, J.), interim order dated 17.1.2025 in Writ - B No. 4605 of 2024 (Ainuddin v. State of U.P. and 3 others). Acting on the report dated 16.01.2025 of the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia (submitted in compliance with the Court's order dated 09.01.2025) - which recorded that the 10.01.2025 hearing was lost to a bar strike, that on 13.01.2025 counsel for Mainuddin sought replacement of the presiding officer Shahnawaz Khatun alleging bias, and that a further application of 15.01.2025 seeking substitution of deceased parties was rejected after hearing - the Court issued notice to Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate to appear on 23.01.2025 at 2 pm and show cause why action not be taken against him for his consistent dilatory tactics and interference in proceedings of the Court. Notice to be served through the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ballia and the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia (Case No. 448 of 2022-23); matter laid fresh on 23.01.2025 at 2 pm; order communicated the same day by the Registrar (Compliance).

Court No. - 49

Case :- WRIT - B No. - 4605 of 2024

Petitioner :- Ainuddin Respondent :- State Of U.P. And 3 Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Ramesh Kumar Chaurasia Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.

Hon'ble J.J. Munir,J.

In compliance with the order dated 09.01.2025, the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia has submitted a report dated 16.01.2025, the material part whereof reads:

"ववाद ककी कवाररववाहही कके ददौरवान ददनवानांक 10.01.2025 कको ममैननुदहीन, ऐननुदहीन कके अधधिवकवा हवाधजिर आरके। ममैननुदहीन कके अधधिवकवा दवारवा बतवारवा गरवा दक आजि हमलकोग न्रवादरक कवारर सके दवरत हमै। धजिसमम न्रवादरक कवारर सके दवरत रहनके कके कवारण पतवावलही मम ददनवानांक 13.01.2025 ककी दतदण दनरत ककी गरही। ददनवानांक 13.01.2025 कको महमनुदनुररहमवान कके अधधिवकवा दवारवा एक प्रदतस्थवापन प्रवाथरनवा पर प्रस्तनुत कर ममॉग दकरवा गरवा दक पक्षकवार शहनवाजि खवाततून ककी ममृत्रनु हको चनुदक हमै। धजिसकवा दनस्तवारण दकरवा जिवार। धजिसमम ऐननुदहीन कके अधधिवकवा दवारवा आपधत्ति दवाधखल करनके हकेतनु अवसर ककी मवामाँग ककी। पतवावलही मम तवारहीख पकेपेःशही ददनवानांक 15.01. 2025 दनरत ककी गरही।

ददनवानांक 15.01.2025 कको पतवलही मम सभही पक्ष कके अधधिवकवा हवाधजिर आरके, महमनुदनुररहमवान दवारवा प्रस्त प्रदतस्थवापन प्रवाथरनवा पत स्वहीकवार दकरवा गरवा। ममैननुदहीन कके अधधिवकवा दवारवा एक प्रवाथरनवा पत प्रस्तनुत कर मनांग दकरवा हमै दक पतवावलही मम ममृतकको कवा प्रदतस्थवापन नहही हको पवारवा हमै, इसधलए सभही ममृतककों कको प्रदतस्थवादपत करनके कके उपरवान्त ववाद ककी कवाररववाहही आगके बढवाई जिवार। तथवा सभही प्रदतस्थवादपतकों कको नकोदटिस जिवारही दकरवा जिवार , धजिसपर ऐननुदहीन कके अधधिवकवा दवारवा दवरकोधि दकरवा गरवा। प्रवाथरनवा पत पर बहस स न ुवा गरवा धजिसमम सभही अधधिवकवाओनां ककी बहस स न ुनके कके बवाद ममैननुदहीन कके अधधिवकवा दवारवा प्रस्तनुत प्रवाथरनवा पत दनरस्त कर ददरवा गरवा।

पतवावलही मम स न ुववाई ककी जिवा रहही हमै। पतवावलही कवाफकी दवववाददत हमै। धजिसमम तहीन पक्षकवार हमै। पतवावलही बहहस हकेतनु ददनवानांक 20.01.2025 दनरत हमै। । सभही पक्षकों कको स न ुनके कके उपरवान्त दनरमवाननुसवार ववाद कवा दनस्तवारण शहीघ्र हही कर ददरवा जिवारकेगवा।"

Issue notice to Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate appearing before the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia to appear before this Court on

23.01.2025 at 2 pm and show cause why for his consistent dilatory tactics and interference in proceedings of the Court, appropriate action be not taken against him.Notice shall be served upon Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate appearing in Case No. 448 of 2022-23 pending before the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia through the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ballia and the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia.

Lay as fresh on 23.01.2025 at 2 pm.

Let this order be communicated to Mr. Mainuddin, Advocate and the Consolidation Officer, Sadar, Ballia through the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ballia by the Registrar (Compliance) today .

Order Date :- 17.1.2025 Brijesh Maurya

Digitally signed by :- BRIJESH KUMAR High Court of Judicature at Allahabad