Basmati Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. and 4 Others — Allahabad HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

Basmati Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. and 4 Others — Allahabad HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

Neutral Citation No. - 2025:AHC-LKO:4278

Court No. - 16

Case :- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 257 of 2025 Appellant :- Basmati Respondent :- State Of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. And 4 Others Counsel for Appellant :- Ankit Pandey,Navneet Singh Counsel for Respondent :- G.A.

Hon'ble Karunesh Singh Pawar,J.

Heard learned counsel for the appellant and learned AGA for the State.

Notices to respondent no. 2 to 4 are dispensed with in view of the proposed order.

This application has been filed against the rejection order dated 23.09.2024 whereby the application filed by the appellant under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. has been rejected.

Perused the record.

The operative part of the impugned order is extracted below:-

ववधधवयवसथथगयथशशददनबनथमसट आफयय०पद०ए०सद०सद० 2013 (80), वदपदलकशमथरवमशथबनथम सट आफयय०पद०ए०सद०सद० 2013 (80) पटज 870 एववववधधवयवसथथकरनधसवहबनथमसट आफ एम०पद० 1992 सद०आर०एल०पटज 3054 ममपवतपथवदतधसदथनततकथभदअवललकनवकयथगयथ।

ववधधवयवसथथगयथसशददनबनथमसट आफयय०पद०उपरलकममयहअवधथररतवकयथगयथहहवकयवद नयथयथलयककरथयममपथथरनथपतदशरथशयसटएववकथनयनकटदशरपयलगकरनटकटआशयसटपसतशतवकयथगयथहह , तबयदवपवकपथथरनथपतममवकयटगयटकथनतसटसवजटयअपरथधकथगठनहलतथहल , तबभदनयथयथलय पथथरनथपतवनरसतकरसकतदहह।इसदधसदथनतकलउपरलकववररतववधधवयवसथथओवममभदपवतपथवदत वकयथगयथहह।

मथननदयउचचतमनयथयथलयदथरथववधधवयवसथथ वबरलथकथरपलरटशनधलवमटटडबनथमएडवटनटजइनवटसटममट 2019 (2) सद०सद०एस०सद०पटज 1640 ममभदयहदधसदथनतपशननपवतपथवदतवकयथनयथहहऔर अवधथररतवकयथगयथहहवकदथणणडककथयरवथहदककउतपदडनकथमथधयमनहहबनथयथजथसकतथ। वपयवकथशदवथसतववअनयबनथमउ०प०सरकथरवअनयए०आई०आर० 2015 ( ए . सद .) पटज 1758 मम यहअवधथररतवकयथगयथहहवकनयथयथलयदव०प०सव०ककधथरथ 156 (3) दव०प०सव०कटअधदनवदयटगयट अधधकथरकलपररचथधलतवकयटजथनटकटधलएनयथवयकमणसतषकककअपटकथकरतथहह।धथरथ 156 (3) दव०प०सव०कटअधदनशवकपयशककरतटसमयनयथयथलयकलसजगरहनटककआवशयकतथहहऔर आवटदनपतकटअवभकथनतककजथवचकरनटकटधलएसवतवतहहतथथपशधलसररपलटरकथभदअववलमबधलयथजथ सकतथहह।

पथथरनथपतपरपथथरवउसकटववदथनअधधवकथकलसशननटऔरपतथवलदममशथवमलपपततकटअवललकनसट सपषहहवकपथधथरनददथरथयहकथनवकयथगयथहहवक , पथधथरनदबथसनतददटवदवदनथवक 08.06.2024 कलरथत लगदथग 09:30 बजटजबअपनटदरवथजटपरबहठदथदवकपडलसकटअवभयशकगरववनयवमथर , मवगटषथवमथर , ललद वमथरवमथलतदवमथरआबथददककजमदनककपशरथनदरवधजशकललटकरदरवथजटपरआकरभदददभदददगथधलयथव दटतटहहयटमथरथपदटथगयथजबआवटवदकथकटजथनबचथनटकटधलयटघरकटअनदरभथगदतलअवभयशकगरदथरथ उसकटदरवथजटकटसथमनटपडदलकडद , सरपर , आवदकलजलथकररथखकरवदयथगयथतथथउसटजथनसट मथरनटककधमककदटतटहहयटजथवतसयचकशबदतसटअपमथवनतवकयथगयथ।

थथनटककआखयथपतथवलदममसवलगहह . धजसकटपररशदलनसटसपषहलतथहहवकआवटवदकथऔरववपकदगरकट मधयआबथददककजमदनकललटकरवववथवदरहथहह।आवटवदकथदथरथकथनवकयथगयथहहवकववपकदगरदथरथ

उसकटदरवथजटपरपडदलकडद , कलठजलथददगयदथद , परनतशददरथनबहसउसकटदथरथयहभदसवदकथर वकयथगयथहहवकउककलठकटहदबगलववपकदगरककभदकलठणसथतहह।

उलटखनदयहहवकयहसवथभथववकनहहहहवककलईभदवयवकउससथथनपरआगनहहलगथयटगथधजससट उसकथसवयवकथभदनशकसथनहलतथहल।आवटवदकथदथरथधजसजमदनपरकलठआवदणसथतहलनथकहथगयथहह उककटबथबतउसकटदथरथसवयवभदसवदकथरवकयथगयथहहवकववपकदगरदथरथउकजमदनकलअपनथबतथयथ जथतथहह।अतनमथमलथधसववलपककवतकथहह।पथमदषयथयहसपषपतदतहलतथहहवकपसतशतमथमलथ धसववलवववथदसटसमबणनधतहह , धजसकथवनरथकरधसववलनयथयथलयअथवथरथजसवनयथयथलयदथरथहद वकयथजथसकतथहह . धजसकटसवबवधममआवटवदकथउकनयथयथलयममचथरथजलईकरकटकथफकअचछथअनशतलष पथपकरसकतथहह।इससवबवधममपसतशतववधधवयवसथथ इणणडयनऑयलकथरपटरटशनबनथम एन०ई०पद०सद०इणणडयथधलवमटटड 2006 (6) एस०सद०सद० 736 मममथननदयसवरचचनयथयथलयदथरथ यहकथनवकयथगयथहहवकजहथहपरददवथनदपककवतकटमथमलटफदजदथरदवथदबनथकरदबथवबनथनटकटधलए पथथरनथपतवदयथजथतथहलवहथहफदजदथरदवथदवनरसतवकयथजथनथचथवहए।चय व कमथमलथधसववलपककवतकथ

हहवववधधवयवसथथ 2008 (60) ए०सद०सद 1 सशपदमकलटरइनदरमलहनगलसवथमद वअनयबनथमसट

उतरथवचलवअनय ममभदमथननदयसवरचचनयथयथलयदथरथयहकथनवकयथहहवकजहथवपरमथमलथधसववल पककवतकथहल , वहथवपरवकमदनलपवकयथकलशशरकरनथनयथयथलयकटअधधकथरकथदशरपलगहलगथ। पथथरनथपतममववररतकथनतसटयहसपषनहहहलतथहहवकअनशसयवचतजथवतकथवयवकहलनटकटनथतटउसट अपमथवनतकरनटकटआशयसटउसकटववरदअपरथधकथररतवकयथगयथहह।अतनसवजटयअपरथधकथररत वकयथजथनथपतदतनहहहलतथहह।अतनमथननदयसवरचचनयथयथलयदथरथपथररतउपरलकववधधवयवसथथओव एवववदशथवनदरशतकटआललकममपसतशतमथमलटममएस०एस०एस०टद०एकटकटपथववधथनआकवषरतनहहहलतट हह।अतनपथधथरनददथरथपसतशतपथथरनथपतअनतगरतधथरथ 156 (3) दव०प०सव०वनरसतवकयटजथनटयलगयहह।

आदटश

पथधथरनदबथसमतददथरथपसतशतपथथरनथपतअनतगरतधथरथ 156 (3) ८०प०सव०वनरसतवकयथजथतथहह। पतथवलदवनयमथनशसथरदथधखलदफतरहल। "

Perusal of the record shows that it is alleged by the complainant that she was beaten by kicks and fists, however, there is no injury report on the record. Learned court below after going through the record has rightly opined that the dispute appears to be civil in nature. There appears to be no illegality in the impugned order.

The petition is devoid of merits and is accordingly dismissed .

Order Date :- 22.1.2025 R.C.

Digitally signed by :- RAM CHANDER YADAV High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench