Allowed¶12

Diwakar Tripathi Alias Chhotu v. State of U.P.

Allahabad HC3 Apr 2023BAIL/7868/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Allahabad High Court bail grant; Crl. Misc. Bail Application No. 7868 of 2023; Sections 366 and 376 IPC; Case Crime No. 763 of 2022; consent of major prosecutrix; Section 161 CrPC and Section 164 CrPC statements; temple marriage at Allahabad; allegation of threat and forcible taking; bail conditions including no witness tampering and cancellation clause; Umesh Chandra Sharma, J.; decided 3.4.2023.

What did the court decide?

Bail granted to the applicant Diwakar Tripathi alias Chhotu on furnishing a personal bond and two sureties of like amount to the satisfaction of the court concerned, subject to the enumerated conditions; breach of any condition to be a ground for cancellation of bail. ¶12

Diwakar Tripathi Alias Chhotu Vs State of U.P. — Allahabad HC (2023) — LawSathi Research

What the court decided

AI extract

Outcome

¶12

Issue for consideration

Whether the applicant Diwakar Tripathi alias Chhotu, accused in Case Crime No. 763 of 2022 under Sections 366 and 376 IPC, is entitled to bail.

¶5

Court's answer

After considering the arguments of both sides, the Court held that the bail application deserved to be allowed.

¶12

Ratio / Principle

The applicant Diwakar Tripathi alias Chhotu is to be released on bail on furnishing a personal bond and two sureties of like amount to the satisfaction of the court concerned, subject to enumerated conditions: no inducement, demand or threat to case witnesses; no tampering with evidence; no misuse of liberty; an undertaking against seeking unnecessary adjournments; and personal presence on each date fixed for framing of charge, recording of evidence and examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C.

¶13

Key takeaways

Breach of any of the bail conditions shall be a ground for cancellation of the bail.ratio¶19

Detailed headnote1 paragraphs

Bail allowed — High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Hon'ble Umesh Chandra Sharma, J.), order dated 3.4.2023 in Criminal Misc. Bail Application No. 7868 of 2023: applicant Diwakar Tripathi alias Chhotu, accused in Case Crime No. 763 of 2022 under Sections 366 and 376 IPC, directed to be released on a personal bond and two sureties of like amount, subject to conditions. The prosecutrix (date of birth 16.02.2002; aged 20 when her Section 161 CrPC statement was recorded on 18.12.2022) stated that she knew the applicant for 5-6 years, left home with him on 17.12.2018 (as printed) and was taken to Allahabad where a marriage was performed at a temple, and that on 19.12.2022 she told the Magistrate she wished to leave him; counsel for the complainant argued the acts were consensual and neither kidnapping/abduction nor rape was made out. Opposite-party counsel relied on her Section 164 CrPC statement alleging threats to make her video viral, forcible removal from her house to Allahabad and detention, and argued her later statements were under parental/family pressure. The Court, on the basis of the above discussion, allowed the bail application subject to conditions (no inducement/threat to witnesses, no tampering with evidence, no misuse of liberty, undertaking against adjournments, personal appearance on all dates including Section 313 Cr.P.C. examination); breach of any condition to be a ground for cancellation of bail.

¶1

Court No. - 53

¶2

Case :- CRIMINAL MISC. BAIL APPLICATION No. - 7868 of 2023

¶3

Applicant :- Diwakar Tripathi Alias Chhotu Opposite Party :- State of U.P. Counsel for Applicant :- Bipin Kumar Tripathi,Aditya Pandey Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.

¶4

Hon'ble Umesh Chandra Sharma,J.

¶5

यहजममनतअजरअभभययक/पमररककतरफससमय०अ०सस० 763 वरर 2022 अनतररतधमरम 366, 376 भम०दस०सस०, रमनमभपपरमईच, जजलमरगरखपयरकसवमद ममउससजममनतपरररहमकरनसकसपमररनमकससमरदमजखलभकयमरयमहह।

¶6

पमररकसभवदमनअजधवकमशशभवभपनकयममरभतपमठशएवसरमजयककतरफसस भवदमनअपरशमसककयअजधवकमशशअननतसमररकगसयनमएवसपतमवलशकम अवलगकनभकयम।

¶7

पमररकसभवदमनअजधवकमनसतकरपसतयतभकयमभकपरमससचनमररपगररकस अनयसमरपशभडतमअवयसकहहजबभकउसककमममवमभदनशनसधमरम 161 दस०प०सस० कसबयमनममपशभडतमकमहमईसकसलशहभककपममणपतकसअनयसमरजनमभतजर भदनममक 16.02.2002 हगनमबतमयमजजसकसअनयसमरघरनमककभतजरभदनममक 18.12.2022 कगलरभरपशभडतम 20 वररककवयसकमभहलमरश।वमभदनशनस जजनदगअनयवयभकययकगनमभमतभकयमहहउनहमभववसचकनसदगरशनहहपमयम। पशभडतमनसधमरम 161 दस०प०सस०कसबयमनममयहकरनभकयमभकवहअभभययक कगपममचवररससजमनतशहहतरमबमतकरतशहहतरमभदनममक 17.12.2018 कगरमभत एकबजसअपनशमजरससभदवमकरकससमरपमरभमकसकसलआई, वहममससरगरखपयर सरसशनससदसवररयमरईभफरदसवररयमससइलमहमबमदसमरममहशरए।भदनममक 19.12.2022 कगअपनसचमचमसतयपमलरमयवपयजलसकससमररमनसआईतरम यहकहमभकभदवमकरससशमदशकरनमचमहतशहहम।

¶8

उककसआधमरपरपमररकसभवदमनअजधवकमनसयहतकरपसतयतभकयमभकचसमभक पशभडतमवयसकमभहलमहहतरमउसनसयहबयमनभदयमभकपमरर/अभभययकनसउसस भरमयमनहहहहतरमनहशअपहतअरवमवयपहतभकयमरम, नहशउससइस भनभमतपलयबधअरवमभबलयबधभकयमरम।वहसवयसअपनमघरछगडकरआई, अततअपहरणअरवमवयपहरणकमअपरमधनहहबनतम।

¶9

जहममतकधमरम 376 भम०दस०सस०कमपशहह, इससमबनधममउनहयनसयहतकर पसतयतभकयमभकपशभडतमनसभचभकतसककससमकजजलममभहलमभचभकतसमलयमम यहबयमनभदयमहहभकउसकससमरदयषकमरजहसशकगईघरनमनहहहहईतरमउसनस सवसचछयमअपनमआनतररकपरशकणकरमनसससमनमकरभदयमजजसससयहनहह जमनमजमसकमभकपशभडतमकससमरकगईललभरकअपरमधभकयमरयमहहअरवम नहह।

¶10

भवदमनअपरशमसककयअजधवकमककतरफससपशभडतमकसधमरम 164 दस०प०सस० कसबयमनपरबलभदयम।जजसपरपशभडतमनसयहसमकयभदयमहहभकवहतरम भदवमकरसमर-समरपढतसरसतरमउसककशमदशतयहगनसकसउपरमनतउसनस अभभययककमसमरछगडभदयमतबअभभययकउससभवभडयगवमयरलकरनसकसभय ससडरमनमपमरमभकरभदयम।उससपतमनहहहहभकउसकसपमसउसककककनसश भवभडयगहह।उसनसयहबयमनभदयमभकघरनमकसभदनअभभययकनसउससउसकसघर कसबमहरबयलमयमवहममससजबरदसतशइलमहमबमदलसरयमतरमवहममएककमरम लसकरजबरदसतशरलतसमबनधबनमयम।उपरगककससमबनधममपमररकसभवदमन अजधवकमनसयहतकरपसतयतभकयमभकबमदममममतम-भपतमअरवमपररवमरकस दबमवममआकरपशभडतमनसइसपकमरकमसमकयभदयमतरमवमसतवममउसकस समरकगईबलमतकमरभकयमरयमहगतमतगवहभनभशतहशआनतररकपरशकण करमकरभचभकतसशयसमकयससइसककसमपयभषकरमतश।उनहयनसयहभशतकर पसतयतभकयमभकपशभडतमइलमहमबमदजमनसकसकमममभवभभनसमवरजभनकसरलय ससरयजरतशरहश, यभदउसकमवमसतवममवयपहणअरवमअपरहणभकयमरयमहगतम तगवहकहहभशजनतमअरवमपयजलसकगदसखकरससचनमदससकतशरश।

¶11

उनहयनसअभगमतकरयहपसतयतभकयमभकपमररकमकगईपसवरआपरमजधकइभतहमस नहहहह, उसकसपलमभयतअरवमभववसचनमकगपभमभवतकरनसकककगईसमभमवनम नहहहह।

¶12

उपरगकभववसचनमकसआधमरपरयहजममनतपमररनमपतसवशकमरभकयमजमतमहह।

¶13

पमरर, भदवमकरभतपमठशऊफरछगरसकगउकमममलसममससबसजधतनयमयमलयकक ससतयभषकसजलएएकवयभकरतमयचलकमऔरसममनरमभशममदगजममनतदमर पसतयतकरनसपरभनमनजलजखतशतरसकसअधशनजममनतपरररहमभकयमजमए1. जमसचयमभवचमरणकसदकरमनपमररसमभकययकगडरमधमकमकर/दबमवदसकर अभभयगजनसमकयकससमरछसडछमडनहहकरसरम;

¶14

पमररभबनमभकसशसररनककममसरभकएईममनदमरशससपरशकणममसहयगर करसरम;

¶15

जममनतपरररहमहगनसकसबमदपमररभकसशआपरमजधकरभतभवजधयमभकसश अपरमधममशमभमलनहहहगरम;

¶16

पमरर, पतयकयमअपतयकरपसस, मममलसकसतथययससपररभचतभकसशभश वयभककगकगईपलगभन, धमककयमवमदमनहहकरसरम, तमभकउनहमऐससतथययकग नयमयमलययमभकसशपयजलसअजधकमरशकगपकरकरनसससरगकमजमसकस;

¶17

पमररइसआशयकमएकवचनबसधदमजखलकरसरमभकवहसमकयकसजलए भनधम र रततमरशखयपरभकसशसररनककममसरनहहकरसरम, अरररवमहअदमलतमम मकजसदहल

¶18

पमरर (i) मममलमखगलनस, (ii) आरगपतयकरनसऔर (iii) धमरम 313 Cr.P.C कसतहतबयमनदजरकरनसकसजलएभनधम र रततमरशखयपरवयभकरतरपससरटमयल कगररकससमकउपससरतरहसरम।यभदरटमयलकगररककरमयमम, इसशतरकमचसक जमनबसझकरयमपयमरपकमरणकसभबनमहह, तगरटमयलकगररकसजलएयहखयलमहगरम भकवहइसतरहककचसककगअपनशजममनतककसवतसततमकसदयरपयगरकसरप

¶19

ममममनसऔरकमनसनकसअनयसमरउसकसजखलमफकमयरवमहशकरस।उपरगकशतरसमम ससभकसशकसउलसघनकसमममलसमम, यहजममनतरदकरनसकमआधमरहगरम।यह सपषभकयमजमतमहहभकपसवरकमममलसककसयनवमईयहमसऊपरभकएरएभकसश अवलगकनससपभमभवतहहएभबनमससचमजलतककजमएरशजगजममनतकसजलए ततकमलआवसदनकसभनपरमनतकहशसशभमतहह।

¶20

Order Date :- 3.4.2023 Rahul

¶21

Digitally signed by :- RAHUL KUMAR High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

Diwakar Tripathi Alias Chhotu v. State of U.P.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Diwakar Tripathi Alias Chhotu v. State of U.P.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Why is it important?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Jai Prakash Vs State of U.P.

Shailesh Kumar Chaurasiya @ Shailendra Vs State of U.P.

Sonu Vs State of Up

Satish Kumar Soni @ Lala Vs State of U.P.

Prem Narayan Vs State of U.P.

Ravi Kumar Vs State of U.P. and 3 Others