Arigela Narsaiah and Ano. Vs Prl. Secy., Rev. Dept. and 2 Ors.

z. b-rl. liig"l, Liiml,^{wife "of'ArigelaNarsaiah,aged-57 years, occlPation} - fforr"wii", iesiOent bt Bommakai-Village, Karimnagar Mandalam and District'

¶11

...PETITIONERS

¶12

AND

¶13

State of Telangana,^{represented by PrincipalSecretary Revenue (Stamps and} Reon. ) Deoartfrrent, Secretariat,^Hyderabad.

¶14

z. ffrd oistrict Registrar,^{Revenue, Siamps and Registration, Karimnagar} District.

¶15

The Joint Sub-Registrar^{- l, R.O-Karimnagar District}

¶16

...RESPONDENTS

¶17

Petition under Article^{226 of lhe constitutionof lndia prayingthat in the} circumstances stated^{in the affidavit filed therewith,the High court may be} pleased to issue a writ, order^{or Direction, more particularly one in the nature of a} writ of lr/andamus^{declaring the action of the Respondents, more particularlythe} RespondentNo.3,inrefusingtoreceiveandregistertheSaleDeedpresentedby the Petitioners,^{(the same having been receivedas Doct.No.P326l12 and dated} 18-09-2012), in respect^{of their propertycomprising of all that entire extentof land} totally admeasuring^{Ac.2-05 Guntas equivalentto 2.86 Hectares,being agricultural} drylandsituatedinSy.No.l02lA,BommakalRevenueVillage,Karimnagar Mandal, District^{Karimnagar, pursuant to Draft Memo No.Gl/17480196 Dated 08-} 05-2012 issued by^{the Office of the Commissionerand lnspector General of} Registration and^{Stamps,A.P., Hyderabadas illegal, arbitraryand against the} provisions of law and declare the^{saidDraftMemo No.G1/17480/96 Dated 08-05-} 2012issuedbytheofficeoftheCommissionerandlnspectorGeneralof Registration and^{Stamps,A.P.' Hyderabadas illegal, arbitraryand against the}

¶18

provisions of lar,a, a rrl consequently direct the Respondent \o.3 to recelive and register the Sak: I e =d submitted by the Petitioners, (the san re having been received as Doct N; P326/12 and dated 18-09-2012) herein in respect of the property covered rrr^jer the said Sale Deed, the same comprising of all that entire extent of land totrrll , admeasuring Ac.2-05 Guntas equivalent to 0,86 Hectares, being agricultura cl v land situated in Sy.No.102lA, Bommaka Flevenue Village, Karimnagar [Vanrlrr . l)istrict Karimnagar.

¶19

l.A. No: 1 oF 20'lj:l^{yP_lvlE,__N_Ai$Z2E_4E20'!Z)}

¶20

Petition urC e :iection 151 CPC praying that in the circurns:ances stated in the affidavit filecl il r pport of the petition, the High Court malr lre pleased to pass orders, pending rlisp rr;al of the above Writ Petition, to direct^rh,l r3spondent No.3 herein to rece,v€ a 1 register the sale Deed submitted by the :etitioners, (the same having 5 e: r ,r:ceived as Doct. No.P326/12 and date,j 18.09.2012), in respect of their l)r ,:rerty comprising of all that .entire extent of land totally admeasuring Ac. ll. ,; guntas equivalent to 0.86 Hectares, being agricultural dry land situated ir S y'. . o 1021 A Bommakal Revenue Village, i(:rrirrnagar [t4andal, Distrrct Ka rim nra 3 a^-

¶21

Counsel for the l)r-'t tioners: SRI AARIFA IMRAN KHAN Counsel for the R,:s pondents: AGP FOR REVENUE

¶22

The Court made the^rollowing: ORDER

¶23

HONOURABLE^SRI IUSTICE^{N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR} WRIT PETITION^{No.15152 of 2017}

¶24

ORDER:

¶25

Heard learned^{counsel lor the petitioners and learned Assistant} Government Pleader^{for Stamps andRcgistration appearingfor respondent} Nos.1 to 3. With their^{consentthis writ petitionis taken up for disposal'}

¶26

2 This Writ petition^{is filed seeking the following} Prayer:-

¶27

"to declare the action of the^{Respondefltstnore particularly tht} Respondtnt N0.3, in^{refusingto receiaeand registerthe Sale Deetl} preiented by the Petitiorcrs,^{(the same haaingbeenreceiaed as Doct'} No.P326fl2 and dated^{18.09.20L2),in respectof tfuit property} compising of all that^{entire extent of land totally admeautringAc'} 2-0; Gu;ta; equioalent^{to 0.86 Hectures, being agiculturaldry} land situated in Sy^{No.102/A,BommakalReztenue Village'} Kaimnagar Mandal,^{bistrict Karimnagtr,} Pursuant^to Memo No.Gf1i4s0/g6 Dated^{08.05.2072 issued by the ofice of} -D-ta[t^the C,ommissioner and^{lnspectorGeneralof RegistrationandStamps'} A.P., Hyderabad^{as illegal, arbitraryand against thcp-r-oaisionsof} law tmi declare^the iairi^{Draft Memo No'G1/17480/95Dated} 08.05.201.2 issued^{by the Ot'fceof the Commissionerandlnspector} General of Registrition^{and Starrps AP, Hyderabad as illegal'} arbitrary ind igainst^{the proaisionsof lau and co-nseque.ntlydirect} the ResiondmlNo.3^{to receiaeand registertfuSaleDeed submittud} by the Petitioners,^{(the same haoingbeen receioed} -as^{Doct No'} iSZefiZ and futted^{L8.09.2072)hereinin respect of tle property} coaered under^{the said Sale Deed the same comprisingof all that} entire extcnt of^{lnnd totallyadmeasuring Ac' 2-05 Guntas} equirsalent to^{0.d6 Hectares, beingagricu,lturaldry land situated in} Sy No.102/A, Bommakal^{ReaeiueVillage, KaimnagarMandal} ' Distict Kuimnagar."

¶28

Brief facts of this^{writ petitionare that the petitioners claims to be the} owners and^{possessorsoi agti.ulturaldry land totally admeasuring Ac'2-05} Guntas equivalent^{to 0.86Hectares,situatedin Sy No 102/4,Bommakal}

¶29

2

¶30

Revenue Viila 1r:, Karimnagar Mandal, District Karimnaga... ,l he petitioners with an irrten i,rn to sell the subject property executed tle ,rale deed and approachec t. s;rondent No.3 for registration. Hor,r.ever, ttre respondent No.3 rel usr c register the same and asssigned the su .lj,:{ri document as P.No.32(i c,f ll() l, the same was communicated to the pet tlon(lr aitle relusal order No.21 of 2r.)14 dated 06.09.20L4, stating the followin5;:_

¶31

" t:;.1t.,t ttcitale of the document, the Schedule of propcrtg c_c.tttrritit :, agriculture property situated at ilomnnkai

¶32

1,, ing,. .\s per Section 6 o7 ifn act, tle pattn-dar p:rcs bock: r.,i r. Title Deed.need"to_be producetl [t" ile tn,r, o1 rcglslt t_t tn. The pafiied didn,t produce the ppB anc, ..D Book_; li rcgistration, which is'eoident in CArc Cirn.,fo, Lt rn f ,'v4,t.N o.G1/'U480/96 dated 08.05.2072..

¶33

Clrallrrrs rg the refusal order dated 06.09.2074, p cti tioners filed before Ap1.rezr. ,io.11 of 20-14 and, respondent No.2 r,lrl: or.cler dated 04.02.2075 cli;rtr . rc,cl the appeal, relevant portion is extractcd Irt rreunder:_

¶34

"Tit,t ('t.t:issioner and Inspector General (R€;S), Ltydet nbnrl throtrqh^{t,kno.No.G1/17480/g6,} aot"a' a.i.iolz iol,iLe l:i,"9,,,!_-^{to tightthe prooisioncontaineduntle)} Satiot. 6 (l) L.tf \1, t.',tghts in lantl and pattedar pass btook Act riir,tcttd the l?e.yi ;t t.ut g nuthorities _to^{insist for pro,du"iion- oi pn utn,} pass b,n)it ,tttd title deeds bet'ore admission of lt)cun erts Regish atit r , ln ll.,e tll .oi^{theaboaecircumstnnces,I and not inclintti} lo isnte ,t,t:1 ' rection to the Resporulent to admit the docur,l,.rtt to R egi:;Lrr. ')1r. Hente th': i ,ce^{al is dismissed.,,}

¶35

Thereafte,r the petitioners under Section 5(B) of Ap RigJrt,; in Land & Pattadar Pass Ilc:,l<s Act 1977, filed Appeal bearing No.Dr,174.,i/200g and

3

\ \

,t

the Revenue Divisional Officer at Karimnagar zsidt order dated 07.O7.2012,

¶40

passed following order:-

¶41

"In aiew of the fncts, circumstances of the case, the appeal is allowed aru1 the Tahsildar, Kaimnagar is directed to tttke action as follouts:

¶42

(i) The name of the respondent should be deleted in possession column of pahanies from tht year 1979-80 to till date in respect of^theland in

¶43

Sy.No.102/A measuring 2-05 Acres situated at^{Bommakal Village} of Knimnagar MandaL

¶44

(ii) The name of the respondent shauld be deleted in patta column^{of pahanies} from^{theyear 1998-99to till date in respectof Sy.No.102/A measuring} 2-05 Acres situated at Bommakal aillage.

¶45

(iii) Tfu name of the appellnnt should be entered in pahanies in possession column from tlrc year 1979-80 to 2008-2009 i.e.,^{Uptothe date of} fling^this appeal.

¶46

Regarding sanction of Virasath/Mutation^the awellant^{should apply} before the Tahsildar, Karimnagar^afresh t'or^{consideration,on the basisof the} aboae orders and the appeal is allotaed €t disposed accordingly'"

¶47

Today when the matter has been taken up for^{hearing, learned}

¶48

counsel for the petitioners submits that in^{pursuanceto the orderdated} 07 .07 .20t2 passed in Appeal No.D/ 1745 /2008, the^{petitionerswouldtake} appropriate steps to get their names mutated in revenue^{records and obtain} pattedar pass book in respect of the subject proPerty^{and proceed.}

¶49

Learned counsel for the petitioners further pray this Court^{to direct} the respondent authorities to receive,^{registerand release the document} sought to be submitted by the petitioners in respect^{ol the subjectproPerty.}

¶50

Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Stamps^{and Registration}

¶51

submits that if the^petitioners by^{enclosingall the relevantdocuments} stated in the refusa1 order^{dated 06.09.2014, submits the documentbelore}

¶52

4

¶53

the responder I authorities, the same would be consider,:cr ar rd appropriate orders i,r,-or rLl rr:, passed in accordance with law.

¶54

9 Recc,rcl^-.ll the above submissions and without expressing any opuron ,tn n , :ts of the case, this writ petition is dispo:;c.c of, granting liberty t,-r r.:r:rit r:rers for obtaining pattedar pass book and ger; their names mutated ir r., ,^.enuc recorcls in respect of the subject p roperty and thereafter' th: r"'titioners by enclosing all the relevant d,rcunrents and by complying the rr:rjections raised in the refusal order daterl 116.09.2074, may submit thr: sut,t ::t docum.nt to the Registering Authority r^.hr. shall either register/rr:l-r sc, le same as per the provisions of Indian {t,gir.rtr.ation Act, 1908, and [;r1i,r I Stamps Act,7g99, by duly assigning reas( ]ls in terms of Section 7l cf t r : Act, 190g and communicate the said decision to the petitioners

¶55

With tlrc ,rbove rjireciions this writ petition 1i cli,;posed of Miscellane,our; r1 1 lications, if any pending, shall stand clost:cl, I,Io order as to costs.

¶56

- ,a-SD/- A. SRINIVASA REDDY AlStSTAr.tT^REGTSTRAR //TRUE COPY// ) \ ,^{sEcroNoFFrcER} I Ilg ]i"gli,,^{l, ;,)cretaryRevenug}(StampsanO Reln ;^{Dep,rrt.nent,} secretanat. 'l^,lerabad, State of Telanoana_ \f 2 The Distr-ic. l, ,tistrar, Revenue, Stamp-s and Reg-istratior. t(a .imnagar District. J lhe^{J^op! S e b F.legistrar - l, R.O. Karimnaqar} District. 4E Two CCs kr G UNE U(. tO S F^r AARIFA FoR REVENUE, IIVRAN KHAN, High Couri6;inJbLte AdVOCAtE IOPUC of Tetangana, at Hyderabad f t' .tT1 6 TwoCDCcpie. <sup>+r-

To

PSK. GJP

T

HIGH COUR"

DATED:06101 t2025

ORDER