St. Thomas (Spg) Tamil Church Society, v. The Church of South India Trust Association (Csita)

Telangana HC20 Apr 2023SA/64/2019

Download

Case brief

from the order text

What is this about?

COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA…

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

St. Thomas (Spg) Tamil Church Society, Vs The Church of South India Trust Association (Csita) — Telangana HC (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶11

I J i	st. (Rl Th twe Th ..ii. I""g . , 1	en: omasISPG)^{Tamil ChurchSocicty'} N..z..r^{I,stationRoad' Secu.dtrabad} tti,t^{t,egatSecretaryEinsteinSamuel} ...Appettant/^{Appellant/Defendar^:} inOSNo'^14511997 AND TheChurch^{of SottthIndiaTrust Association(CSITA)} Acompanyincorporated^{underthe Indian} 3"*pi.i.i"e.,"ird havingits^{registered ()fficeatNo5'} WhitesRoad,RoyaPettah,Madras' ^{Rep.by its GeneratPov/ero[AtLorneys'} I a
	' ,	il Dr.B.vimal Sukumar, -' S/oRt.^{e",.B p Suganrlcr'agedaboi'rt4lycars'}. Treasurer^{churchoG''oti'india'DioccsiofMedaklnrl} Cplrlrrotaer^{ofC'St T-lt'prcmisesno-10-3--165'Diocesart} 5il;r,'-Oil^LancerLines, -Himmatllagar's(:sundcrabad- ^' 5OOO25'
I I i ! I ( I -t I I I t. I	. 2 3. 4. / '	iil Dr.K-Dayanand,^{S/oDr"K'BushalatmDavid'} "t' IntJ"Uo.lt sS^{years, l'aySecretaryCS[Medak Diocese'} 6"sioi""."^"^{"oflice,oldLancerLines'uirnrnatNagar'} Secunderabad-so0025' ' ..'."Respondent/^{PlaintilfinO-SNo'7451t'997} D. Pakiadas,^{S/o.S.N' Pakia':ias,} agedaboui⁷⁺Years,^Pensioner, Residcnt^{of PlotNo.32,} Railway^{Colonysituated atPicket'} Secunderabad^(died). Vincent^{Samuel,S/o-Salnuet,} Asedabout62Years,^Pcnsioncr-, ii]rl. zr-2,^{St. Thomas(Seti)churchcompound'} Station^{Road, Secunderabad'} SPSounder^{Rajan,S/o.S N Pakiadas'} Aeedabout69Years,^Busint";s, ii:ff;;:;;i it^{s,sit -,.t"4: t t Bholakpu r,secundcrabud(diccl) .} I I

¶12

	-.1) 1--,
	I⁽:,r(',.Ieagircr,li/o.P.Mr:ar1her, Ill ,:rlr:rt[^(rOyr:ars,Advo(jitlc, I Nr i)-.j 490/aI, situatc(l.rLThukar.rftr (;a(( A,)rri)!^..lirgLd.i,Sccundcrabrrd.(drcd)
	fu/:j.A(tncBuildt.rs, Repr,'sertr:dbyitspartncrA.M.L)ntanucl, Llusirrr:s;,li.NO.92-61/ I,
	SIu;lt(:(a_SD. I?oad. SecunCcrabad
r'- '	,..AipfuII)t(land GencralStores, Prr:rrr.st:No.Zl-{>/2to4atStationttoad, S..oLrnd(.a5a(1,relt by itslirol'essorGulamHusl .rin tfitrz.arulra Mukkadarn(dicd).	)
	HindrrsrrnPetroleum Limited 13O/l,SD.Road,Secundcrabad, wlrichispar{ir6(lp,r,, ol,.). StThorr as(SEG)Churchcorrpouncl, Oppo..,itc tof*rilwayStation, tjccund erabad.	I
	MaLhatanEmltorium, O-,ppositr:SzLnthoshHotel, StationRc,ad, Wtrichisrartand parcelo[S.:,.Thomas (SpG;CIrur,;tr Coupour d,OPpositetoRailuay Station,secund,:rabix.
lo,	S-k.^{(irll(.:trons,} O-pPosrtcianuroshHotel, St.rtionR.,ad, Whiclris)a:-tand parcelotSt.Thomas(SpG) Chrrt:hCr,rrrJ-,orrnc.l, OpJ,ositcoRaitwayStatiotr,i.,ccunclerabad-
11,/	Classtc Iir)t-r/earCentre, O..plrosiLciiatltioshHotel,Sta-.ion Road, WhrchsIartand parcelotSt.Thomas (SpG)Chrrrclrcr rn)()urd, Opl,osrret)lla.itwayStation, Sec.rnrl,.ri bld-
12/'	Sonv["(,oF,,eitrCentre, O..ppositcSrrr:thoshLodge,Sh.ionRoad, w'hi':hr;,rrr.ardparcer o[sLt'homasispc)churc]rco
	,orrrLa, Oppcsitrr-rFailway Station,SccunCcrabad.	I
i13	Ashok lioow(:ar, ()jp,,sir,:S rnLhtrshLodge,Sta,ionIioacl, \hr(lrr:.l,rrtand parcelo[St-.thornasispclChu:chCor,l,]rrd, ()pp,)sit,trRril,vayStarion,S..cunderabad.	I
t4	Kiddr'stiarrn,:nls, Opp,,.i,, li,nthosh Holl-I, prcnrisesNo?-l6/12, Stati,nl]oil,SecunderaLad Whiclr.ripirtandparcelofSt..Thomas(SpC)Chur.hC,,rrl,rrrrl, OPp',,i,t,rR,rilrnryStatron,Sr:cuncierabacl-
l5	Bhoj,,v,rrriEnterprises,
'	911{)o-^{SinrhoihLodge,Sro;;,-.n Road,}
[	,,,, wntc rr,1r.rtrnrlparcei olSl.thumas(SlrC) Churrh()onrl,,,n(1, ()pp,,.i,,.r' I?.iluiyStclion.S,currrlor.rbarl. .

¶20

:.j (
<br>.L
0
I i Royal Bool(H,)Ltsc, sl'c^cl.rur.ll.c()nrlnrrnd,sr.r,,,r,Ir,,r, l, wnrchtspitrtanctn.l1..lutS,r.r,.,.,.,",:D,.,^,- opposireroRairwrr*,",,,,,,,,,,,'ll;l::i:i::",^Churchcompour,rr.
71 I SundaramFootwe.rr. SPGChurchCompound. :lP?i't.^{toRailwayslariont(o3d,} wnrcnISpartandnrrc(-lofSLTlromas(SpC)ChurchCompound, OpposltetoRailwaySlrtion,:,e(.unctcrihu(l '
Dosani Enterprises. StationRoad, Secun.ter^h..t Which,is partandp-..i "ii-,thomas(SpC) ;lXT:'..J[H"nd,^{opposire roRailway,sra-Jon,} 9 I
'12../AnandHosiery, $tation^{Road, Secundcra}bad
i I, , Which ispart andparc churchcompou"d'.o":l^:l^{s'Tlromas(sPGl} S."underabai.^{.._,_pposrte toRailway Slation,}
29,,-R.K..GoldenWatch and I(adiUCornl)any, ' L9,:.-"^{Road,Secunderabart,} WhichispartandDarc church compou.,o'o..tl^?l ^{ttrhomas(SPC)} S."urO.=UJl-..*,^{_pposr er.RailwayStation,}
2)-R.C-N.TravelinsGoods StationRoad,Secunderabad, .Whichis partandDarce .church compour,,i.ooo'^"1."'. 'lhomas(sPG) Secundembad.^{..osrte tol<ailwayStation,}
.2/ Narayarla parr Shop, Near-RailwayStationRoad,Secunderabad. which isparana"".".r,is,.1:ir"_"1"t1?q ChurchCompound', oo Secunderaba.l^{.posltetoRailwayStation,}
23-Durga TeaStall, '' gppositebAlphaHotetsr^i;^-D^^r^ q/hicr,.ii#;ffi;:.iilifi,[.i:!?$3;0"o,o, , 3i:Tlf".#fund,opposite^{toRairway'6taiion,}
24.A.S.^panShop, 2,'-Opposite to Alphal{otel,Near RaitwaySration, Secunderabad,Which is part and.parcelofii.ifromas1SeC1 Church Compound, oppositetot.tailway Staf ion, .- Secundeiabad
Sai Baba Opposite Laundry, to Alpha Hotel Near RailvrayStation, 25 ,"
l
I <br>" ** *
.;r#i{li-- - .::. ..<ia;

¶22

	i I I U/hrr:hrsJ),rI:rII(l;rarceloISr-'l'lrrrrDr'.;(l I'(]l
i	(lhLrcltCorirpotrt-rd,oppositclo ll.rl$,.r]' lltirti( S';'crrnd(:r:-tt)a⁽I
	l
	I)lc(:an Wal(:hCompa[y, Orp,rsite toAtpha Hotel,NearRailwayStation S<:cunderabad, Whichispartand parcelofSt.Thomar; (SP(i) Cirur-chCompound, opposite toRailway Stati:) St,cunderabzrd- i
)s	Atrdul andAltarFlower Merchaut, ()l)positetoAlphaHotel,NearRailwayStatior,,
	Secunderabad, W'rich ispartand parcelofSt.Thomas(SI,Ci) )lLur-chCompound, oppositetoRailwarStati();r iecunderabad.
')t)	rr,:mSports, )prpositctoAlphaHotel,NcarRailway tltalic,r, :ie:underabad, Vlrichispar1.and parcelofSt.Thomas(SPG) )hurchComPound, oppositetoRailwalStati(,I le,;lurderabad.
()	ititrWatch Company, lelresentedbyitsProprietorMd,Rafiuddin, )pposite toAlphaHotel,NearRailwayl]tation ier:underabad, fiLichispartand parcel otSt.Thomas(SPG) r)hurchCompound, oppositeto RaitwayStation, i;ct:underaba<1.
t1 I I	I^'o(,1WearShop, ()pccsite to Alpha Hotel,NearRailwayStatron, Iecunderabacl, /hichispartand parcel ofSt.Thomas,SpG) (hrrrchCompound,opposite toRailway Statio r, Ir:cunderabad.
\2 l.	!ulrhash HairStyles, (pptisitetoAtpha Hotel,NearRailwaySlation, S:cunderabad, !'hrchispartand parcelofSt.'lhomas(SPG) (hrrrchCompound, oppositetoRaih,layStation -':cunderabad-
1., '/ .-/J	,F.[irmountFancyStores, P^-ernisesNo.7-310,OppositerJoAlphalloiel RailwayStation, Secunderabad,

¶26

{
ffi hichis partandparcelol:lt^'l'lrom:rs(Sl)(l) ChurchCompound, opl)osirc toIlaillval.SL.ition, Sccundcrabad.
3).:OmegaGencralStorcs, ' PremisesNo-73-ll,Opposrte toAlph.r flotel, StationRoad,Sccunderaba(l	,
35. SreeV.L.Stores, FremisesNo-7-3-13,OppositctoAlphal{orel, RailwayStation,Secunderabad, Whichis partandparcelofSt.Thomas(Spc) ChurchCompound, oppositeLoRaitwa)'Sralion, Secunderabad.	t
36 J.Durgaiahand Brothers, PremisesNo.7-3-13,GeneralMerchantStarionRoad, Secunderabad.
y. SriGaneshRarnSweetHousc, PremisesNo.7-3-l3/I,opposirelonlphaHok.l, StauonRoad,Secunderabad.
NobleCollections, FremiiesNo. 7-3-13/1,OppositeroAlph:r Hotel, StationRoad,Secunderabad
99.^{NatiorialPlasticStores,} Premises No.7-3-13/2,situatedatOpposiLetoAlpha Hotel, .StationRoad,Secunderabad.
,o:^{r'AlphaEnterprises,} .PremiSes No.7-3-7312, situated ar OppositetoAlphaHotel, StationRoad,Secunderabad.
Rekha:GeneralStores, l*-iq.: No.7-3-13lD,situare.l ar OppositetoAlphaHorel, StationRoad,Secunderabad. :
Balajibvfee-t, Prcmis;asNo.7-3-13/5,Opposite toAlphaHoLel, 'StatioriRoad, Secunderabad-
'BombayLodge, PremisesNo.7-3-13/H(Second Floor), OppositetoAlphaHotet, -^{StationRoad, Secunderabad.}
HotelSanthoshladgeandResLaurant, 'Premises No.7-3-13(firstFloor), OppositetoAlphaHotet, StationRoad, Secunderabad.
A.lBookCentre, PremisesNo.7-3-13/6(Second Floor), ..OppositetoSPGChurchCompounC, StationRoad, Secunderabad. 5	l t

¶28

				Ers'	r*e{
			1')^. (	b I
		\|
				;(t	-AI
		tti,	i,)LI 'rrt(ll:(		(c
			; , .. 'r,rr:,r:;No t:.1316.	,	()t
			,)j),)irl(to.^.l1tiraljriLcl, ilt li1	(r0. I	Sr
			r)()rr(),r(,Sct:r-rrrclcri:rbaci	t.	(G
	\|17	l,:rllrrrrr[.'ootu,crrr,	I	0l
			1)r,'rr;,r:r; No.7il13/8,tjcsideSPCemete-yCorrJxunr, lil '	6)	H(
	i		.r11,,111n,.1,Sccrrndeiabad.
	I	,1E	I'r,r Jli{()r('s:rrtrlBakery,		N€
			I'rcr)r^jos.No7313/9,		Sc
			Itr':CrsljI'GCemetery Compound, '	62
			:., Il(,INu;rd,S,:cundcraLlad.		As
					Na
	(	19	l'r,'l:',tut(si,rrrlRakcry.
			I'rr,ri:;r:sNo.7 3-13/9,BesidcSPGCemet,rryCornl:ourd, ..,rrrrtl.'oad,S,.,urrdercbad.	I	As Na
					Sb
		:ro	I.l.Srrrcs(.Iagar), l	I
			Ir,rrr.,sNo./:'il:l/q,BcsidcSPGCemetr'ry Corrp.rrrd. .Il,,rlio;rrl,S,,urrdcralrad.	()*	v1 No
		Ll	(.1-,.rirco[r,Prathiba Apartments,		oI
			lflrrlNo103lstlrloor StationRoad
			, ,, (lpp,s1ctoSt.PatrikHigh School,.Secunderbarl	fr	Si .No
		:;)	\r,rrhSi<ldiqui,Ztepoin	,PremisesNo.9-4-52
			rrrrl)1li2and9-4-53TeaNSnacks DiniogHaIt		.
			, ,, tl,.:i1,.,NavodcyaLodge,	66-	st
			()pt))silctoRzrilwayStation Secunderabad		N;
			,		oi
		53	lirrrrtirBalajr Mit.hai BhandaraidSweets, I'rcris:sNo!l451Bid Ndld	67	d;
			. ,eses avoayaagc, ()l)l)srtcto RailwayStaLion, Secunderabad	,,.	Nr oi
		:.,4	lirrrrt[.Balaji Travels,	'68
			IIlrrrs:sNo 94-51Besides Navodaald	. _
			,. ,,y,oge, ()t)lnsiLc toRailway Station,Secunderabad.		Pi
					O1
		1i.i.	;\1;rn h:rToursan<1Travels,
			llcrrrs(isNo.94-52a];ld9-4-52/ABesides NawodryrLodc	69.-	B(
			, g,		Fi S.
		5t)	Nrrv:laa
			y[,odgc, f^,rcrrrs<,st\o.d-qZD(FirstandSecondFloors)	70	PP
			, (JrIrr;ircro Railu,eLyStation,Secunderabad.	/t	PT C(
		t/	lirillb Oticals		.:
I		:.:	turp, l)rt rrrsts I\o.9 4:l12(GroundFtoor)ofNavodayaLo,:rge,	7r-	Vi
			(,'l,,il(It-'llurlway Siation,Sccunderabad.		Pr SI
I i I			:^.rl,rl,.rt:tI)/ISt)Burrk,		Ol
			(riorrrrflror)of Navodaya Lodge,
			rilrctollarlway Station, Secunderabad () )1,(		Ir
I					PT
			;:

¶30

	a 0l
5?- .	Asian^{'lottrsand l'fa/cllers,} (Ground^{Ftoor),Navodayat.odgcBuildrn;','} '.bppositctqlaitwayStaLion,^{Sccun'ler:1l)arl}
60- '/'	Sri^{KrishnaSweets,} lGround^{Fto6rJNavodayaI.'-rdgrBurldrn''} bpposirc^{to RailrvayStation. S'currdetaUrd}
6I- -'- I	Hotel Gem, V.g.trii-,^{Non-Vegetarian andNorthInclian (CcllarPortion)} Na"vodaya^{LodgeBuitding,Oppositeto llail\r.ayStaLion'} Secunderabad.,
..,ldz -i,rqf-, ''i'' :'i,! ' 63, .11 , { 1 I	.n"irn^{Exple.ss,!e4,} -'Navodava Ilaageeuilding,opposite to[lailwayStaLion ' IS".rttderaPhd:,- ,^,.r., , II AsianTeaStores, ^{:'Nauodayalodge}Buitding,oppositeto^{Railway Station,} Secunderabad. a , <br>\|
I.;- :.'l:.'i :iF. ',--'l'.?' I I	Vaishnavi.'Bihavani^Travels, No.^g-42l2lB/^{l,BehindNavodayaLodg"} iopposite to'nailway Station,^Secunderahad 0I -Sri Jalaram;Triwe.ls, \No.^g-4-2.lilBtt;Behind^{Navodavat'odge,} 'Opposite td'RailwayStation,Secunderabari
9- <br>	SupretheTravels, ni'^g-+-zlztat^{z,BehindNavodavaL'odge'} opposite-to.Railway^{Station,Secunderabad} \ \|
i,.i: i' -.:167^. i.i{ ii+ ,\i.64- .fitr.	.sriSai BabaTours and^Travels, .-.No.^g-4-2li;tB+,BehindNavodaya^Lodge, 'Opposite^{tg;RailwayStation,Secunderabad} :BearrtYElectria^HairDresses .;':,ffi#ft:;.i-rd;;i;r,spc^{cirrsFiighschoorconpound'} .Opposite tolRaiiway^{Station,Secunderabad-}
69. :r' . .ri t_li li I I I	-^{Bombay LaundrY,} Pre-i"g"No.9-.i-138^{to9-l-142,sPGGirts High} ibh;C"*p"ot^{a,oppositetoNlanoharTalkies'Secunderabad} PanShoP, Premises^No.9-^{1'la8and142,SPGCirlst{ighSchool} ...^Qompound,^{OPPoSitetoManoharTalkies, Secunderabad}
i t. 7> i I I	2, - Vijay^{GeneralStores,} Premises^{No.9-1-138alrdi4} SPcci.t"High^{Schoolcompound,'} Opposite^{to Manohar Talkies,Secunderabad-} .t s ijaySTD, PG GirlS Higlir^{schbolCorhPound,} PremiseS.Nti-^{9:l-L38ao:di42,} +l /- +-..!--,.i

¶64

( +i;* -'1 rl,l t. .5 r:.{ :il's.r, ,t! I ttF.:, .t Si So rrr lr:r Rajan, S/cr. S N I,,r!<i;rrlas, Arlr d r lr:. rl^(i!rl,car S, lJusirrls:., ; .s,[. ' II ro r, J61/19, Sirrr:rir:rJ;rr Iilr{)lak r €,rtr. Sc( rr ri. Jt t t[].id ;.fcl' r i: Lc:^j, . \lr ,1,1r.,. i/^ I' l\1r.rglr,.r, . i1nR,,i.,l , I rO y,.-r1s, p.dvo(Jri., t-tI IJ 1.,r. 0 , ,t9O/:, srtuirted at^.l.lru karaiir' Ga Noi l h L:rl. lgrrd:r, Secuncicrab:rcl 6 M/r; r'r rl Ituilders, (' I?eprcl;r.Dl 'd l)] its partncr A.M. Iimanuel, (, Sil-r alr:-l I Si.D Road, Sccur rdcr.:rbad. I 7 Alplra lloL I;rnrl (]encral Storr:s. I I Prerrrist s I ct 7 1-6/2 Lo 4 at Stalion Road, Secunrl^.r; l)ad, rcp lry i: s lrrofr:ssor Gulam Ilussatn Bar;r,rlrllr; Ivf ullkadlrm (clir:d] 8 Hirtri ust ir rr Pr.trolcunr I-intited 130,'1,^j L Iload. Sr:cu r.r d cra [)il(I, which is part a]rd ltarr:r,l of St. l'hrrrrrar (llP(]) Church compound, ()pp,)srl'i l( Railway Station, Scc L.rr rdcrabad. 9 Mah rrarrr l ,n;I)ortum, Oppr)srlr: ll rn Lil(rslr IJote l, Statiort itoad, lVhrt lr r 1,, rl and p.rrceL o[ ti l' Thomas (SpG) Churcb Comportrrrl (. ppositc to Railway Statron, Sccundcr abad. ) 10 S.K^(lollrr r IOIIS, Oppc,silr sl, nr hosh Hotel, Stalion Road, I Whiclr is p; ,1 and parcel ol St. 'flr{,mas (SFG) Chrrrch C,)rot,lrnd, Oppor;itc t,r R: rillvav Slal ion, Sccr rndcrabaci. 11_ Classic I,oo w.:at Cc, t lre, ( Oppositr: Sz rtlrosh Hotcl, Sta trol I l<oad, Whic)r i:; 1>,r ,1^{:lI parccl.oISl.Thomas (SpG)ChLirchcorpcunr.,} Oppositr:^(o l<^j,l lway Sl ation, Secu! rd(-r llc rrl ) t2 Sony lroolvr ar CenLrc, I ,O.-ppo..rit('^{Sa rl 'loshLodge,Station Road,} . Whiclr is pir t .rn(i parcel o[ St. lhomas ispGl Church - com - )o ]n(1, ) Oppo;itr: t(, lail,,ay Station, Secunderabad.^' .- 13 Ashol: [,'rllrtt etrr-, g.ppo.^{ril., Sa} rttro:;h Lodgc, Station Road, .;i. .' Whiclr is l)ir L irn(l ,arcel of S[. Thomas iSpG) ,Church _. -- Corn]o r,.1,-" Oppor;itr to taihray Station, Secundc."U1O.' , L4 Kicldl, r;^(iar r re Il ts,, Oppor,rtr: Sir rtlrosh Hotei, prcmises No T-.1;6/ 12*. I S talion Ii ra< . :lc( undcral,ad r# .i , Whicl ir; lr r : l:^{p:::.1,rf St. Thomas (S3e)ichurcrre,rmlroUrrt} C)ppolir lr ) lo a 1w,y :;latr4n, Scctrrrdcrabdtl::, ii r ' '.!li ir.' 1:f{'t .-r,A). Co ,q,,i* d :i\raltr {

¶66

		,:-t I .--:
	15	[3trolirvanrlirtrct^prises, Opposite Santhosh^[-odgc,Station^Road, Whichisparta1ldparcclotSt.^{'lhomas(SPG)Church Conpound,} Oppositeto^{RailrvayStation,Secunderabzrd.}	t ,
(	16 I It(	RoyalBook^House, SPGChurch^compound,Station^Road, Whichispart^andparcelof^{St. Thomas(SPG)ChurchCompound,} Opposrtcto^{Railt!'ayStation, Secundcrabad-} Sundaram^Foots'ear, SPGChurchCompotrnd, Oppositeto^RailwayStation^Road, whiihispartandparcelofSt. Thomas^{(SPG)ChurchCompound,} OppositcloRaitwayStation,^{Sccunderabad.}
	1FI	Dosani Enterprises, Station Rbad,Secunderabad, Whichispartand^{parcelo[St-Thomas(SPG)} -church^{compound,OppositetoRailwayStation,} Secunderabad.
	9I	AnandHosiery, Station Road,Secunderabad, Whichispartand^{parcelofSt. Thomas(SPG)} ChurchCompound,^{oppositetoRailwayStation,} Secunderabad.
	Io	R.K.Gotden^Watchand^{RadioCompany,} Station Road,^{Secunderabad,} Whichispaitand^{parcelofSt.Thomas(SI!)} ehurchComporthd,^{oppositctoRailwayStation,} Secunderabad.
	12r	K.G-N.Traveling^Goods, Station Road^Sccunderabad
	)	,^, Whichispartand^{pa-rcet ofSt. Thomas(SPG)} ChurchCompound,^{oppositetoRaili'ayStation,} Secundcrabad-
	22t	Narayana PanShop, NearRdilway Station^{Road, Secunderabad,'} Whichis^{partajtdparcelofSt. Thomas(SPG)} Church'^{Compound, oppositetoRailwayStalion,} Secunderabad.	't
\|	DurgaTcaStall, Oppositeto^{Alpha Hotel,StationRoad,Secunderabad,} Whichis^{partandparcelo[St. Thomas(SPG)} Church Compound,^{oppositetoRailwayStaticn,} Secunderabad.	I
V	24	A.S.PanShoP, Oppositeto^{AlphaHotel'Near RailwayStation,} SJcunderabad,Which^{ispartandparcelofStThomas(SPG)} Church Compound,^{oppositetoRailway Station,Sgg:lrndcrabad} i'<br>?6 P	( ( ,

¶71

	./..'	lirrIl;rlr;rl,ilrlll(lr. Olrl)oliltc ioAli)h:lIloLcl.Nc^rr S,r1)Lrr)(l(trl)tlrLd, \ilrrclrrsIrarLart(i l)arcelo[:]1 (llrLir(lr(1,)n1l)orrrrti. opp,:tstt' S,:t-rrrrrlr:tirbacl- li,!l.r; ],SrrtrorI 'llrr,rrLrr;(il'(i) lrIlir.,,r\ ililll()lt,
	26	SriRarnS'lD/lSI) C)pl)osrtctoAlpl)aIIotcl,Ncir Sr:crrndr:rabad, Whir:hisparl:rrld [)ilrcelo[.]t ChurchCompound.oPposlll St:cundcrabad. lliril,.ry S;ltroll. 'I'ltrrr.r;(iI'>C) l(I.l.1^{.,a_</sup>ltati()n,}
	27 (	DeccanWatch Company, OppositetoAlphaIlotcl,NcrrR:rilrirySralion, Sccunderabad,
		Whichispartand p:rx:clofStTh(niis(jI'G) CirurchCompround,opposit,-t.(,[.lai ,,ayiLzrtion, S<:r:rrnclcrabad.
	I ²⁸	AbdulandAltar I.lowcrMcrhirn(, OpposrtetoAlptraIIotel,NerrIiail!.ryS(atron, Sccunderabad, Which ispartarrdp:rrcel ofJt.^'lhcrnrs(liPG) ChurchCompound.oppositrtoliailrray itation, Sr:cundcrabad.	tcI
	I	Pre[rSports, OppositctoAlpha l{ote[,Ne,Lrlialllva/Station, Secundcrabad, Whichispart andparcelof St.^'ltrcn.rrrs(liPG) ChurchCompound.opposittto Rallrrayiiration, Sccundcrabad.
	30	Star Watch Company, Ropresented byitsPr.)priet.rMd.!iaiudIn, OppositetoAlphallotel,Ne:rrl.,ailuarStatron, Secunderabad, WhichisparLarldparcelofSt.^'ltLonrrrs(lil)G) ChurchCompound,opposit,)tollaI\ayljtation, Sccundcrabad.	om orl
I	p1- 1	Foot Wear Shop, Opposite toAlphallotel,NeirrRaih/a-/Strtion, Secunderabad
I		, Which ispart andparceloflit.'t'lioorrLs(!iPG) ChurchCompound,opposit,.toRalr,iay:ltation, Secunderabad.
	2 r	SttbhashHairStylcs, OppositetoAlphaHotcl,Ncirrllai[.'ir,,Strtion, Secunderabad, Which is partandparcclo[lit.'ihorLLs(i;pG) ChurchCompound,opposit(,t()Jialu,ay :;tatiorr, Secundcrabad.
I I		ca
f		_

¶81

	A= I	A.Illool(^(lnlr.c, PrcrnscsN:' 3-i3/6iScco[cll"ioor), Oppo:iteioll'GCtrur-<;1rCotnl-,orirrcJ. SLifli(nFlo.rl,Scr:undc:r.rir:-rd		t I
	46	Bookl)ararlse. PrenrisesNr i 3i3/5, OppoijitetoAl:rhaI{otcl, Sl-at1cnIio:rL,lecunderabad
	47	Lakn:ni^t(xtuear, Pre:uisesNr.7-3-1.3/13,ElesideSI'CcmetcryCompourrd, Sta[ionRoal, tiecunderabarl.
	4B	PremSto.esard:fficry, Premises Nc.T3-13/9, Bcsidr:sSP(CemeteryCompound. StationRoa,,liecunderaltad-		, ,
	49	PremStoresarLdBakery, PrcmisesNc7-3-13/9,BcsidcSPGCernetery Compounc[, StationR,la(,Iiccundcrabad.
	50	R.K.StorostJagarJ, PremisesNo7313/9,BesideSPG Cemetery ComJ)ourr(, StationRoar.<iecunderabad.	(
	51	C.S...Lrco):,'rathibaApartmcDts, Fiat Nr;.1Oiil'tFloor, SlationRoad,		I
		Oppositer-ollt.Patrik l{ighSchool,.Secunderbad.	/
	52	AyeshSiddirui7*epoinL,Premises No.9-4-52 and9-4'.52znc9-4-53,TeaNSnacks,DiningI{aJl, BesidesNrvrdryal-odgc,	(
		Opposrte {oI:ailwayStatiorr,Securlderabad.
	l.r.)	Srinath BalaLX4ithaiBhalctarandSweets, Prentst$IrIo.9,4-5 1, Besides Navodr[a..i.odge, OppoaitetoIaitwayStation,Secundffabad.	/
	4 <br>p	SrinathBa.la, i^'Iravels,
		Premisesllo.9-4-51Besides NavodayaI-odge	1
		, , Oppositetc Iai]way Station,Secunderabad_
	8S	AjarrthaTour;andTravels,
		Premis,:sllo.9-7-52 and9.452/A,Besides NavodalrLLodgo,
		Opposircr., Ftilway Station, Secundcrabad.
	I156.	Navodaya-orqe.
t \|<br>i	Prcmis:sllo..)I212{FirstandS"condlrloors), Opposi'er,rti.rilwayStalion.Sc(underabad.	I
		^{i t}
I	[z.t I	^{srBara cp :a s,} 'Prcmis,'slo)'212(GroundFloor)ofNavodaaLdl
	.. \r	.. + yoc, Opp,,sieL('RrilwaVSlation,Secunderabad.		t
-				I
/.\|			I
i ,
				I
I		co	^Fft
		t -^{.,,-.s,;*d4;ii;{:}	fuo ir:.t-.,	L

¶85

		(
	58	Sr-iB;rbrrSTD,iISllflunl.:. (grounclfloor-)ofNirtr:,rl;r]'ir^Locl!l:. QPnusit.^{to-Raihval, SraLion,S<:i:rlnderabatl}	t
i I	(ss	Asian^{'lbursand'l'rarrellers,} (CroundFloor) Navodiryat^dgeBuiiding, Opposite to^{Railway Station,Secuntlerabad}	I
	Fo	$riKrrshnaSweets, (Ground Ftoor-)Navodaya^{Lodgelluitding,} OppositetoRailway^{Station,Sccunderabad.}
	(at-	HotelGem,. t.g"tu.irtiNon-Vegctartan^{andNorthIndian(Cellar Portion)} iltarodaya todgeBuilrling,^{OpPosrtetoRailway Station,} Secunderabad-
	62	AsianExpress^Tea, irlavodayatodgeBuitcling,^{oppositetoRailway Station,} Secunderabad.	I
	1		I
	63	AsianTeaStores, Navodayatodge Building,^{opposite toRailway Station,} Secunderabad.	,.
	64 (	Vaishnavi Bhavani Travcls, No.9-4-212lB/l,Behind^{Navodaya Lodge,} Opposite to RailwayStation,^Secunderabad
	65. 1	SnJalaramTravels, No.9-a-2L2/ts/l,Behind^{Navodaya l-odge,} Opposite to RailwayStation,^{Secunderabad-}
	/^66.	^{Supreme Travels,} No.^{g-4-2l2l.Bl3,}BehindNavodaya^l,odge, Opposite!oRailwayStation,Secunderabad
	( oz.	s;SAiBabaToi:rsandrravels, ; No.9-4-212l84;BehiDdNavodaya Lodg6, Oppo:sitetoRail*aySlation,Secunderatlad
	68	PreririsebNo.9-l-I38to142,sPGGirlslHighSchoolCompound, Opposite to RailwayStation,Secunderal)ad.
	1u"	BombayLaundry, . PremisesNo-9-1-138to9-L-142,SPGGirlsHigh SchooICompound, Opposite to Manohar Talkies, Secunderabad
	I 70.	PremisesNo. 9-1-138ard142,SPGGirlsHighSchool Compound, Opposite to Manohar Talkies,Secunderabad.
	/zt-	Vijay GcneralStores, PremisesNo9-1-138 and142
		., SPGGirlsHighSchoolCompound,
		Opposite to Manohar Talkies,Secunder4bad
		,
I	J	f?b

St. Thomas (Spg) Tamil Church Society, v. The Church of South India Trust Association (Csita)

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

St. Thomas (Spg) Tamil Church Society, v. The Church of South India Trust Association (Csita)

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Smt. Raj Kumari Vs Dr. K. Sudha

Smt. Raj Kumari Vs Dr. K. Sudha

Mohd. Ahmed, Hyd Vs Mohd. Usman, Hyd

Mrs. Delphine Stracey Vs Smt. Santosh Murlidhar

Bibin Prashad,Narsing Prashad and Another Vs Smt.Anasuya and 17 Others

St. Thomas (Spg) Tamil Church Society Vs the Church of South India Trust Association (Csita)