Dismissed

Khaja Moinuddin v. The Govt. of Telangana

Telangana HC14 Sept 2023CC(TR)/371/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

In a contempt case regarding non-implementation of Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal orders, the Court noted that services of some petitioners were regularized while others exceeded the age limit. Consequently, no further adjudication was deemed necessary, and the contempt case was closed.

What did the court decide?

Contempt case closed; liberty granted to petitioners not regularized to avail remedies available under law; no costs.

Khaja Moinuddin Vs The Govt. of Telangana — Service and Employment | Telangana HC (2023)

¶1

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD /,,

¶3

THURSDAY ,THE FOURTEENTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE /

¶4

PRESENT

¶5

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO ./

¶6

CONTEMPT CASE TR) NO: 371 OF 20'17

¶7

Contempt Case filed Under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts 1971 Act to for willfully disobeyin! the orders in O.A.No.5201 of 2O15 dated^'14-09.2015. /

¶8

Between:

¶9

KHAJA MOINUDDIN, S/o. Mohammed, 55 years, Sweeper, P.S., Sultanpur (Harijanawada) Yelegede Mandal, Karirmagar District. 7

¶10

P.Jalapathi , S/o. Ramalah, aged 49 years, Sweeper, P.S. Chinnaachampally, Gangadhara Mandal, Karimnagar District. /.

¶11

Syed Aleem , S/o. Slyed Abbas,48 yrs, M.P.P.S., Ramalingapally, Choppadandi Mandai, Karimnagar District, .-

¶12

Jampala Hanumanthu , S/o. Narsaiah, 51 yrs, P.S. SC Manakondur, Manakondur Mandal, Karimnagar District. .

¶13

T,Anjaiah S/o. Ashalu, aged 55 years, M.P.P.S., Ramadugu, Ramadugu Mandal, KarimnagarDistrict.'-

¶14

K.Rajaiah, , S/o Narsaiah, aged 50 years, P.S. Audarpally, Ramadugu Mandal, Karimnagar District. ,-

¶15

Pittala Komraiah S/o Rajaiah, aged 50 years, UPS Vannaram, Ramadugu Mandal, KarimnagarDistrict.,,

¶16

Md. Hussain , S/o. Ra; Mohammed, 54 yrs, P.S. Julapalli (Girls), Karimnagar Mandal and District.

¶17

¶18

Md. Afzal , S/o late Lal Ammad, 49 yrs, P.S. Nagulapally, Julapally Mandal, Karimnagar District.-

¶19

'10. K-Rajaiah, S/o Balaiah, aged 52 years, P.S. Dosallagudem, Gambhiraopet Mandal, . Karimnagar District. .-

¶20

11 . K.Ra;aiah, , S/o. Balaiah, aged 51 years, P.S- SC Harijanawada, Gambhiraopet Mandal, Karimnagar District, -

¶21

12- D.Laxminarayana , S/o. Komraiah, 57 yrs, P.S.Kothapeta, Boinpally Mandal, Karimnagar District. -

¶22

K.lingaiah S/o Butchaiah, aged 53 years, P.S. Mallyala, M- P. Kalvasreemmpur, KarimnagarDistrict.,_

¶23

G.Sarvaiah , S/o. Sammaiah, aged 53 years, P.S. Kalvasrirampur, M. P. Kalvasreerampur, Karimnagar District. -

¶24

K Rajaiah, S/o. Matchaiah, aged 52 years, P.S. GUdem, Odhela Mandal, Karimnagar District ./

¶25

M-D.Shaflullah Baig , S/o. Karim Baig, aged 54 years, U.P.S. Goparapalli, Odhela Mandal, KarimnagarDistrict. /-

¶26

R.Veeraiah , S/o. Mallaiah, aged 52 years, P.S. Molangur,^{ShankarapatnamMandal,}

¶27

' Karimnagar District. ,

¶28

1fi K Lingaiah, S/o. Venkati, aged 58^years, PS. Bommenapally,^{ChigurumamdeMandal,} Karimnagar District. ,

¶29

M.Yella Rajaiah, , S/o. Ramaiah, aged 48^years, P.S. Nagaram, Jammikunta^Mandal, Karimnagar,District.,

¶30

K.Rajaiah, , S/o. Rajabosu, aged 58^years, Sweeper, P.S. Papayyapally,^Jammikunta Mandal, Karimnagar District..

¶31

21.M.D. Raja Ankushavali S/o. Rajmohammed, aged 57^years, Sweeper,^P.S. Laxmannapally, Jammikunta Mandal, Karimnagar District. -

¶32

L.Lingaiah , S/o. Veeramallu, aged 58 years, Sweeper, P.S. Papakkapally, Jammikunta Mandal, Karimnaga District.^,

¶33

B.Rajamallu, , S/o. Rajaiah, aged 51 years, Sweeper, P.S. Gopalapuram, Jammikunta Mandal, Karimnagar District. T

¶34

S.Durgamma, , W/o. Komralah, aged 58 years, ZPHS, Jammikunta New, MP Jammikunta, Karimnagar District.,.

¶35

M.Ramaswamy S/o. Narayana, aged 55^years, P.S. Jaghirpally, M.P. Saidapur, Kanmnagar District. ,

¶36

M. Narsaiah , S/o. Rarnaiah, aged 52 years, Sweeper, PS.Jogapur, M.P. Chandurthi, Karimnagar District. -

¶37

27.MD. Dadasaheb, , S/o. Rajmohammed, aged 57^years, Sweeper, P.S Ashireddypally,^M.P. Chandurthi, Karimnagar District. -

¶38

P.Narayana , S/o. Chandraiah, aged 54 years, Sweeper, PS. Kondapur, Konaraopeta Mandal, Karimnagar District. -

¶39

Md. Valimohammed , S/o. Rajmohammed, 54^years, Sweeper, P.S.^Pallimaktha, Konaraopet Mandal, Karimnagar District. _

¶40

30.Md. Ankus , S/o. Khajamiya, aged 52 years, Sweeper, PS. Bottalapally, Huzurabad^Mandal, Karimnagar District. -

¶41

N.Mondaiah , S/o. Odelu, aged 57 years, Sweeper, PS. Gandhinagar, Huzurabad^Mandal, Karimnagar District.,-

¶42

32.K Yellaiah, , S/o. Rajamallu, aged 47 years, Sweeper, PS.Prathapwada, Huzurabad Mandal, Karimnagar District. --

¶43

E Mogulaiah, , S/o. Lingaiah, aged 53 years, Sweeper, PS Rajapally, Huzurabad Mandal, Karimnagar District. -

¶44

B.fujaiah, , S/o. Mallaiah, aged il years, Sweeper, Primary School, Fakeerpeta,^Mandal Karimnagar, District Karimnagar. ,-

¶45

B. Balaram, , S/o. Suchinarsaiah, 53 years, Sweeper, Primary School, Malkapur, Mandal Karimnagar, District Karimnagar. -

¶46

N.Laxmi , W/o. Rajalingam, aged 54 years, Sweeper, Primary School, Elagandal, Mandal Karimnagar, District Karimnagar. _

¶47

G.Narayana, , S/o. Venkatnarsaiah, 53 years, Sweeper, Primary School, Chippakurthi, Raamadugu Mandal, Karimnagar District. .

¶48

K.Narsaiah , S/o. Achaiah, 50 years, Sweeper, Primary School, Tatipalli, Mallial Mandal, KarimnagarDistrict. a.-

¶49

39.M.Gangaram, S/o. Sayulu, 57 years, Sweeper, Primary School, Obulapur, Mallial Mandal, Karimnagar District.-

¶50

V.Ramaswamy S/o. Hanmaiah, 55 years, Sweeper, Primary School, Apparaopeta, Kodimiyal Mandal, Karimnagar District.

¶51

G Vijaya D/0. Rajaiah, , 51 years. Sweeper, Primary School, Ramaraopeta, Kodimeyal Mandal, Karimnagar District.^/'

¶52

,: i2.V.Ralanarsu ,^{S/o. Mallaiah,55 y-e.alq'} .^{Sweeper' Upper PrimarySchool,Kanch€rla,} Yella-reddypeta Mandal, Karimnagar^District.,-

¶53

L. Narsamm a ,^{Dto. Ramaiah, 56 years,Strueeper,PrimarySchool,Gollapally.} YellareddypetaMandal,^{KarimnagarDistrict.,}

¶54

44.T Aniaiah, , s/o. Mallaiah,^{49 years, Sweeper, Primary school,lingampally, Gangadhara} Mandal, Karimnagar District. ,,

¶55

A Laxmi wo.^{Rajaiah, 50 yrs, Sweeper,upper Primary school, Kokkerakunta,} Raamadugu Mandal, Karimnagar^District. /

¶56

46.A Rama Swamy ,^{S/o. Narsaiah, aged 57 years, Occ Sweeper, P'S', Potlgal, Mustabad} Mandal, Karimnagar^District. /,

¶57

47.J.Laxman , S/o. Balnarsu,^{aged52 years, occ sweeper,P.S., Chekodu, Mustabad Mandal,} Karimnagar District:/

¶58

P.Narsaiah , S/o. Ramaiah,^{aged 55 years, OccSweeper, P'S.,Pothugal,Mustabad} Mandal, Karimnagar District.

¶59

B.Parsharamulu^{S/o. Yellaiah, aged52 years,oc.e sweeper, P.S., Morrayapally,} Mustabad Mandal,^{KarimnagarDistrict.,}

¶60

Veloula Raianarsu S/o-^{Mallaiah,55 years, occ sweeper, P.s., Gundaram.} Yeliareddy#ta Mandal,^{KarimnagarDistrict./}

¶61

(The applicants all are working on consolidated^{pay on full time basis sincetheir initial} appointment to till date) /

¶62

...Applicants No.1 to 50 in^O.A

¶63

AND

¶64

1 Smt. Ranjeev R Acharya,^{lAS, Principalsecretary,Education Department, Telangana} Secretariat, Hyderabad. -

¶65

2 Sri B. Ramalirishna^{Rao, lAS., Principal Secretary, FinanceandPlanningDepartment,} Telangana Secretariat,^Hyderabad.

¶66

3 Sri S--p. Singh,^{tAS.. irincipal S5cretary to covernment, , Panchayathrajand Rural} Development'Govt-ofTelangana,TelanganaSecretariat,Hyderabad.

¶67

4 Sri S. Kisnan, lAS.,^{Commisiionerand Directorof SchoolEducation, , Govt. of Telangana,} Saifabad, Hyderabad.,-

¶68

5 Sri J.g"O.ri*rr,^{Commissioner of Panchayathraj& Rural Employment, , Governmentof} Telangana, Urdugalli,^{Himayathnagar,Hyderabad.} -

¶69

6 Sri S.-Suraj Kumir,^{Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Karimnagar., TelanganaState} 7 sri s. srinivasa chary,^{District Educational officer, , Karimnagar, Telanganastate} a1 ...Respondent Nos¹ to^{7 in o.A}

¶70

Counsel for the Petitioners^{: SRI' CH GANESH /}

¶71

Counsel for the Respondent^{Nos.1to 5 & 7: GP FORSERVICES'II /}

¶72

Counsel forthe Respondent^{No.6 : SRI R CHANDRASHEKAR REDDY' SC FOR} ZP's ,MP's & GRAM PANCHAYATS / The Court made^{the following:ORDER}

¶73

HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE J. SREENIVAS RAO

¶74

Contemnt Case(TR ) No.37l of 2Ol7

¶75

ORDER:

¶76

The petitioners filed C.A.No.226 of 2016 before A.P.A.T. for non-implementation of the orders passed by A.P.A.T. in O.A.No.5201 of 2015, dated 14.09.2015. After abolishment of A.P.A.T., the matter was transferred to this Court and re-numbered as C.C.(TR) No.37l of 2017.

¶77

The Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal while order notice before admission on I4.O9.2O15 has directed respondent Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 to consider the claim of the petitioners regarding regularisation of their services taking into consideration the letter addressed by respondent No.5 dated 15.09.2013 and pass appropriate orders within a period of 8 weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.

¶78

Respondent No.6 hled counter affidavit wherein it is stated that pursuant to the orders passed by A.P.A.T., the services of 22 petitioners t\rere regularised i,e., petitioner Nos.1, 4, 8, 19,20,21,23, 30, 33, 35, 41,2,7,

¶79

¶80

38, 40, 45, tS, 17,25,26, 43 arrd,42. In so far as other petitioners are concerned, they have crossed 61 years of age and are not entitled for regularisation of the services and in this regard, in the counter aJlidavit, they have enclosed a copy of the memo vide No.9O76t7 /CPR&RE/CilMdt/2O2t, dated rS.O4.2O2L issted by Commissioner panchayat Raj and Rural Employment.

¶81

4 In vie'"v of the above, no further adjudication is

¶82

required.

¶83

Accordingly, Contempt Case (TR) is closed granting liberty to the petitioners whose seryices are not regularised to avail the remedies as available under law.

¶84

Pending miscellareous petitions, if any, shall stand

¶85

closed

¶86

j
SD/- M.RAMANA KK
DEPUTY REGI
..::
.a 'a //TRUE COPY//
:i. J
SECTION OFFICER
.., .ir. Tai. ''i "6n. ,: . :*H1'I CC to SRI CH GANESH, Advocate [OPUC] /
2. One CC to SRl. SRI R CHANDRA SHEKAR REDDY , SC FOR ZP's ,MP's &
GRAM PANCHAYAT.[OPUC] ,.

¶87

SD/- M.RAMANA KK HNA DEPUTY REGI ,*y

¶88

SECTION OFFICER

¶89

Two CCs to the cP^{FbRSERVICES-II, High Court for the State of Telangana} at Hyderabad.[OUT1 '

¶90

t*o CD CoPiesa

¶91

¶92

¶93

-;.'r,i' i :?.': - ';,^., - ). .;. t. ' !i. j's::if;:'.,'+ '[..1i : -d-.:,ri. 2z:'l!,i i," ' .'^.-: :.' iil 'i ,i.,i .l: .' -^,r.-l +t i: ., .;: .,l ,i '-a .; . rl ar g E * .i i*..; ${ E I*a .i :'1i.i,^. t:.,:"'^::1 ,f;i 1{"- . ORD E ,i ::H'+ ..!'a:1 Fq-^: * ., .,1 n '.;,:.' '$:x'. cb(rR) o 371 of 2oi7',:il:i:1;'ii . '^l 2'Eta $ #4 . ; .-: 6lt': f, is# e.f ,.i 7 ,Et; .i,' '-..65 ig : .: ert f+i*:!# {r -'EFS.t$t ?.^.f. F:' i 1.. :i '. CLOSING THE CONTEMPT CASEJGR) WITHOUT COSTS .:: -..-1 . ,:^r. i ,,:, + .. t- l+ .. ^^.,] ,.s,:: .:i l+ "+-it f,., I jt*fr ,t .-,i-+ ",.,H8 ii-'i^;;. s .1ffi8"Fdi+f+ .i, i l-1 f .i-r.;':$ .;-f i. "^{1 : ...} r..^;a $ -J..^, -r 5 .9-^,!._ ,'.t E .I5. : .' $ rt:. i 1r :

Khaja Moinuddin v. The Govt. of Telangana

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Khaja Moinuddin v. The Govt. of Telangana

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Nelluri Nageswara Rao Vs The State of Telangana

R. Sarala Vs The Telangana State Road Transport Corporation

T.Rajender Rao, Vs The State of Telangana, rep. by its Secretary

Kema Venkateshwar Vs The State of Telangana

Sk. Yakub Jani Vs The District Educational Officer

A Shankar Vs Sri Raji Reddy