Allowed

G.Madhusudhan Rao v. The State of Telangana

Telangana HC4 Mar 2022WA/48/2022

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court of Telangana in a common judgment disposed of multiple writ appeals challenging non-selection of teachers to the post of Principal. The court applied rules specific to Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions, ordered reconsideration keeping those rules in mind for all applicants, and directed passing a positive order within 15 days.

What did the court decide?

The High Court directed the respondents to keep the case of the appellants under reconsideration keeping in mind the rules regarding Telangana Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Socie

G.Madhusudhan Rao Vs The State of Telangana — Pension and Retirement Benefits | Telangana HC (2022)

¶1

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

¶2

FRIDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF I/ARCH

¶3

TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO

¶4

PRESENT

¶5

THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA AND

¶6

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUIVIAR SHAVILI

¶7

WRIT APPEAL NOS: 487. 621. 624. 655 & 656 OF 2021 AND 48 0F 2022

¶8

wA NO.487 0F 2021

¶9

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Preferred Against the Order Dated 07-04-2021 in WP. No. 19434 of 2019 on the fite of the High court.

¶10

Between:

¶11

S.Kavitha, D/o.S.Bhupathi Reddy, -^{Aged abl,t 39 years,Unemployee.} R/o. H. No.2-9-37613, Sneha Nagar, N GOs Colony Road, Hanamkonda, Warahgal District ( Hall Ticket No.1729000137)

¶12

2 Panuganti Rajesh Kumar, S/o.P.Bak kanna, Aged about 43 years, Unemployee, R/o. H. No.13-3-586/E/2/2, Shanti Nagar, Jiyaguda, Hyderabad (Hall Ticket No.1729001 575)

¶13

...APPELLANTS/WRIT PETITIONERS

¶14

ANO

¶15

1 The Telangana State.Public Service Commission, Rep. by its Secretary, Nampally, Hyderabad.

¶16

2 The.Telang_qna Residentral Educational lnstitutions Societies, Rep. by its Charrman, Masabtank, Hvderabad.

¶17

3 The Stale of Telangana. Rep. by its Pflncipal Secretary. Social Welfare Deoanment Secretariat, Hyderabad.

¶18

1. Telangana Tribal Wel[a re-Residential Educational Institutions Society, Rep. through rts Secretary. DSS Bhavan, Masabtank, Hvderabad - 500 oig.

¶19

1. Jelgngina^{ResrdentialEducationat tnstitutronsSoiiety. Rep. by its Secretary.} DSS Bhavan. N,4asabtank. Hyderabad - 500 028.

¶20

1. c Radhika, D/o c Bhaskar Reddy,, Ased ,o;;i+t3??I[lEjll'r"'i""#r15]J:,'-^*t Rl o.H.No. 42-242120, New Town Cotony, Wana parthy. N,4a habubnagar D-istrict (Hall Ticket No. 1 729001 246)

¶21

Note. Respondent No.6^ivrit Petitioner No.3 in Wp is not a necessary party in the present Writ Appeal.

¶22

..,RESPONDENT/WRIT PETITIONER NO. 3 IN WP

¶23

lA NO: 2 OF 2021

¶24

Petition under Section 151 CPC prayinq that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit {iled in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to keep 2 posts vacant to the post of Principal pursuant to the Notification No. 29/2017 dated. 02.06.2017

¶25

lA NO: 3 OF 2021

¶26

Petition under Section 15'l CPC praying that in the crrcLrmstances stared rn the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the proceedings in pursuance to l\lemo No. S0O/Principat REIS/2016, daled. 22.07.2019

¶27

Counsel for the Appellants: SMT. K. UDAYA SRI

¶28

Counsel for Respondent No.^'l: SRI D. BALAKTSHAN RAO (SC FOR TSPSC)

¶29

Counsel for Respondent Nos. 2,4 & 5: SRI N. BHOOPAL REODY

¶30

Counsel for Respondent No. 3: GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE

¶31

WA NO: 621 OF 2021

¶32

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order dated 0710412021 in WP No.19'127 of 2019 on the file of the High Court.

¶33

Between:

¶34

T. Kqluna, (H.T. No.1729000222), D/oSudhakar, Age. 40 Yrs., Occ TGT Science (-TMREIS) Rio Plo! r\or 238, Adarshnagar, Opp. UMCC Hospital, cajutaramaram Qutubullahpur, HYDERABAD- 50055.

¶35

...APPELLANT/PETTTTONER

¶36

AND

¶37

1 Tle_Slate of Telangana, Rep by its Chief Secretary, General Administration (9ERA) Departmenl. Secretariat at Hyderabad

¶38

The Telangana State Public Service Commission, Hyderabad Rep. by its Secretary Nampally, HYDERABAD.

¶39

.., R ES PON D E NTS/RE S PO N DENTS

¶40

Counsel for the Appellant: SRI P. GlRl KRISHNA

¶41

Counsel for Respondent No. 1: GP FOR GENERAL ADMtN|STRAT|ON

¶42

Counsel for Respondent No. 2: SRI D. BALAKISHAN RAO,

¶43

SC FOR TSPSC

¶44

WA NO: 624 OF 2021

¶45

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the hetters Patent preferred against the order dated 0410912019 in W.P No.19289 of 20'19 and pass on the file of the High Court.

¶46

Between:

¶47

Dopathi Srilatha. D/o Tirupathi Reddy, Age 41 years. Occ. Specral Officer KGBV- Karimnagar, Karimnaqar Districi.

¶48

.,.AP PEL LANT/PETITIO N ER

¶49

AND

¶50

¶51

The Telangana^{StatePublicService Commission(TSPSC.)'Pralhibha} ?,11y:ll fvl.J noaO, Numpally,^{Patel Nagar,Ghoshal'4ahalNorth, Nampally' Hyderabad'} felanoana 500 001 ,^{Rep. by its Secretary'}

¶52

z fie SiJte otlilangana.^{Re'o by its Principal Secrelary' School Education} DeDartr.enl, Secretariat.^{Hyderabad, I elangana- z z}

¶53

g 7i5 Si"tJ of ietJnqan, R6p. bv rts Princip,l Secretary'^{SocialWelfare} Deoa'lment, Secretariat,^{Hyderabad'I elangana}

¶54

q ih6 SiJte oi ietangana Rep by its Princip,l secrelary,^{Backward Classes} w"rr" i"'o"pr.tme,ii,^{Secret'ariai,Opposite Lumbini Park, HyderabadTelangana'} 500022.

¶55

s " ii D;;ai;;"1, ""Stat" of Telangana, seCreiariai, Rep opposite^{by its} Lumbrni^{Principal Secretary, l\linorities Welfare} Park Hyderabad, Telangana' 504022.

¶56

" Cro"nrnii ine fetanoana 3id Residentlal Floor, Nampally^{Educational lnstitutions Society, (TREIS)} Hyderabad. Rep by ils Secretary' z iriJielrnq.nu Soiir'^{wutfrre (esrdertialEoucational lnstitutions Socreiy-} irswnrrs'f , Coio^{t to.s, tleai panaoiHanumanTemple,l'4ahendraHills, East} I,4:rrponellv Secunderabao. Reo bv^{ils Secretary'}

¶57

a inl [rr"Jr.li'.r-ivor^{JJ Fnrt-" r" 5ngryra l-a9f.r.1319classe,swelfare Resrdental} " i;;;;x;;;i hiit,rtion., sotietv (vipepecwRls), DSS Btravan, opp chacha f.feii.j^{pir,,I,4asabTanl..l-rydcirabad 500028. Rep. by;tsSecretarv'}

¶58

q " rha Tctanoana N,4inortres R6;d;;l"l Eoliiiion irst:tlt'on Socrety'^(T[lRElS)'8- 2-596,1^ir ,hoad^{No.10. Beside Star Hosp,tal.OpposileKarvyLane Besrdes} 6n"intaair le*uteii,^{ebnjara Hills, Hvde'rabad 50o034 Rep} .by^{its Secretary'}

¶59

r o ir-rJ iJunorni li,olr^{wejrareResrdent'al Eoucational lnstitutions Sociely'} " irrwnrisi iit riooi, oss Bhavan' l,4asab Tank' Hvderabad 500 028, Rep bv its secretary' ...RESP,NDENTS

¶60

...RESP,NDENTS

¶61

Counsel for the^{Appeltant:SRI P. GlRl KRISHNA}

¶62

Counsel for Respondent^{No 1: SRI D BALAKISHANRAO}

¶63

(sc FoR TSPSC)

¶64

Counsel for^{RespondentNo. 2: GP FOREDUCATION}

¶65

Counsel for^{RespondentNos.3 to 10: GP FORSOCIAL WELFARE}

¶66

NO: 655 OF 2021

¶67

Writ Appeal under^{clause15 of the Letlers Patent Preferred Againstthe Order dated} 07lO4t2O21^{in W.P.No19227oI 2O1Son thefile of theHighCourt'}

¶68

Between:

¶69

Chakravarthula Padma,^{(H.T.No 1729001063),} -Dlo^{Ch sampall^ Klmar} I..i"-rru Aoe a3 Yrs., Oii^TGTEnglish I^{TMRElS), R/o Flat No 309 Block} it]" t6i. brni,inavana ro*nsr,,p^{Ban"dlaguda G s l Post, NagoleHyderabad -} 500068

¶70

APPELLANT/PETI'I.NER

¶71

AND

¶72

The State of^{Telangana, Rep by its Chief Secretary.GeneralAdministration} (SER.A) Deoadment, Secretariat at Hyderabad z i'i-r-" ielrnq5na-St]t"^{protic Service CommissionHyderabad Rep'by its} Secretary Nampally, HYDERABAD

¶73

...RESpoN DENTS/RESpoNDENTs

¶74

Counsel for the Appellant:^{SRI P. GlRl KRISHNA}

¶75

Counsel for^{Respondent No'1: GP FORGENERAL ADMINISTRATION}

¶76

Counsel for^{Respondent No' 2: SRI D" BALAKTSHAN RAo}

¶77

NO: 656 F20

¶78

Writ Appeal^{under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Preferred Againstthe Order Dated} 07 l}4l2)2l^{Passedin W P No 19247of 2019 on the file of the High Court}

¶79

Between:

¶80

I,4adaSu^{Shakunthala.D/o l,4adaSUNaray^ana ,. Re-dd,YAoe 41 vearS' occ,}

¶81

Soeclal officer^{(Princrp;)'il;li;;t;'ib;Canoniaati(a ViovatavdDitchpalli} Nizamabad District.

¶82

?smtl,4BhaovaSheela,D/olvlVenkatasw?Ty'ASe'48years'Occ'Lecturerin' ilNi'R'Gii;;;:'sanearedov saneareddv Ditlli gt -^- -, I Ch. Janaiah, S/o^{SathaiahAge 40 years ucc l(, lx'o Gurr-rkula'JubileeH:lls} " eori-1 , l(urranghat. HYderabad' 4. Bairoiu^{Srinivasu.sro rJE'd'i!nu'n'Age 48 v9,?.'?'- o"tPrincipar' Rahmans} -'F/o" "Vltnuiunii''upur village' Janagoan l'4andal and

¶83

Collecge^{of Educatron} District. ...AppELLANTsi^{PETIT|oNERS1 To 4}

¶84

AND

¶85

1 The Telanqana^{State Public Service Commission (TSPSC.) Prathibha Bhavan'} l,4 .l Road, Nampallv,^{Patel N"gli"G"h;;;Jia'-t'''ui t'lo'tn Nampa!lv' Hvderabad'} i.irnoana 500^{001 'Rep.byrts Sec'etary'} ^

¶86

2 il;isY;i"jl;Lnqrnil^{ne'povG rrfcipatsecreLary School Forcatton} b;;"-ffi;'it^{secreiarratHvherabao' Telangana} i;5liii'i" "i iJrtnqina,^nepo1,iGprinc'pit secretary' social we'lare Department,^{Secreiariat. Hyderabadl elangaca}

¶87

4 The State of^{Telanganaxep oilG*i'rinC'p5l Secr.erary'Backward Classes} wir]tIiE'bJpr''i,"e,ii^{sec'eia.iaiijpposrteLumorniPdrkHvoe'abad}

¶88

1. Telanoana,500022.iru SY;i;";f^i"L-ig"nr' [ep^{bvits Principal Secretary'I\4rnorilieswellare} " o""p"",irn!ni iLiieiuriat. oriposite rumoirii Park' Hyderabad'^Telanga,ta' a iiE"f-J"nqrna 50 0022.^{Residential Educational lnstitutions Society (TREIS)} " cri,i"""irrr=i sio rroor' t'lampiiiv Hvderabld^{Rep' bv,its secrelarv'}

¶89

7 The- Telanoana^{Socialwettai6 ii"ti6"ntiilrou"atron-al'lnstitutionsSocietv} iTSWREIS). Road No^{5, i"teai PinaOi HanumanTemple' I'4ahendraHills'East}

¶90

ii#iaoilv,^{SecunderabadRepby its secretary'} ^

¶91

1. The I!'ldhatma^{.lyotiuaenure iiiSdi;;B;"k;;iAcllqses welfare Resrdentral} tr.1, ,..2rional tnstitutrons =o","ti^{l'otssbn'J*n.bpp.ct.,acna Nehru parkl'4asab} irnri. Hvoerauao^{- 500028Repby its secretary'}

¶92

q rhe Telanoana Minorities R;;;5;;ti;iEJ;;aiiJn',lnstitution^{societv (rN'4RElS ) 8-} ,#Jo. Bl"!S B.;^: :"1,,,

¶93

" i Shankarlal Jewelers, l is ai' ii, H;Jo r.r o i^Banjar o e ".i,i;;,; giigj8 i ootSSd'b?f ,l o ii]; tilr!"1-"-"i riiuir w"irnl.'" ni-iio"'niirr Educational^{lnstittrt,ors societv} ' (tui,REfs;:;!in;;;. bss B;;,;;^{r',ruiluiinr'HvderaDad-500028 Repb7} its Secretary' ...RESpoN^{DENTSiREspoNDENTS}

¶94

Counsel for^{the Appellant: SRI P' GlRlKRISHNA}

¶95

counsel for^{Respondents: ADDL ADVOCATE GENERAL}

¶96

WAN :48 F 2022

¶97

¶98

Writ Appeal^{under clause 15 of the LettersPatent Preferred Againstthe orderdated} 07^{-04-2O2lpassed in W P No '18483of 2019 on thefile of the High Court'}

¶99

Between: Kishan Rao, Aqed^{about 45 yearsrOcc private} G.l,4adhusudhan^Rao,s/o. APHB Colony.^{Gajwel. Siddipetulstrlct(earller}

¶100

emploYee,^{R/o.H.No.5-100'} N,4edak District) ...APPELLANT

¶101

AND 1. The State of^{Telanqana, Rep. by itsPrin-cip^al} ^Secretary^{io Govt SocialWelfare} O"pa,im"nt^{Secreiariat. Hyderaoad - 500 029}

¶102

2 -rha Telanoana State PuDllc s"r]JJ corn-ition Rep by^{its Secretary'P"atibha} ei.iua;,^{Nimpatty.Hycierabad- 500001} The Telanoana Social^{Wellare rfeirOJntiat Ed'lcational lnstitutions Sociely'-Rep} ;;ih.-r;h'[;"s;;tr"v.^{b s s e'i.,];uan,H'tasaorankHvderabad - 500 028} ri^^{.r^ri.^o^a} Res.i.rAntial rauJat-io..nal^f nsr'turions^{Soci6tyRep by throughrts}

¶103

4 iJir"iirv,"o.s-^{s.e nivan.wasao rankHvderabad - 500 028}

¶104

5 The Telanoana Trlbal^{Weltarex"esijeniiaf'f oucational lnstitutionsSociely Rep'} 6 'nlErlj.iii.'E"E,"i"".v^{o! s e1'"in visaorankHvderabad - 500 028} The Frlrcat,onal l,4ahatma lnstrlLtio'"rs^{JvothrlraPnJ'e} so.,erv "Ligj;i'^{ft'e"pl'iir.ough Bitl;ard il;-Sec-epv itassesWelfare ResidertralRoon No'206' 2nd} Frlor. O.S S.Bhavan^{lvlasab rankHvderabao - 5uu uzb'} I lnsl'tJtions.Soc'etles^Rep'

¶105

7 ii". r.lri"lr'"'" v..^noi tl.t^{q"s oenrial'ro} '"atlona ir],.I""i]rJsir.r,jtra.v.^{a-z-sso i'r. noaotrlo'' o eesioe Star Hosoital} -Oop-^{- .} idYr? L;;"";;fi Js'sia-nra'ra^{Le*eiteisBa njara H'Is Hvdu'no'R;$KBi1irc}

¶106

lA NO:^{1 OF 2022}

¶107

Petition under^{Section 151 CPC prayingthat in thecircumstances statedin} the affidavit^{filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleasedto direct} the respondents^{to keepone postof Principal vacant underthe Notification No'29 of} 2017 dated 02.06.2017^{by suspendingthe orderof this Hon'bleCourtdated} 07 .04.2021 passed in WP^{No 18483of 2019, pendingdisposal of the abovewrit} appeal

¶108

Counsel for^{the Appellant:M/S K' V' RAJASREE}

¶109

Counsel for^{RespondentNo 1: ADDL ADVOCATE GENERAL}

¶110

Counsel for^{RespondentNo 2: SRID'BALAKISHAN RAO' SC FOR TSPSC}

¶111

counsel^{for RespondentNo3 to 6:SRl N BHOOPAL REDDY' SC FORTREIS}

¶112

Counsel for^{RespondentNo7: SRIABU AKRAM}

¶113

The Court made^{the following:COMMON JUDGMENT}

¶114

_-)-

¶115

TIIE HON'BLE T}TE^{CHIEF JUSTICE SATISHCHAN DRA SHARMA} AND

¶116

THE HON^{,BLE SRI JUSTICE ABEINAN D KUMARSHAVILI} W.A.Nos.487 624 655 & 656^{of 2O2l^ a nd. 48 of 2022}

¶117

COMMON JUDGMENT, r;'..^{ilJr n.i'rn'rn'(rir'r} '"^: "^{:n:Lsicirrl irir sr(rrJiri}

¶118

Rcgarcl bcirlg-^{l-r:rc1roLhe colll:'o\rcl'sl illvlrlrccl rtlLlltl} lillfcsiLi(1 calses, illcl^{rr,crr' lrcarcl 1oq(rr'llei- lLl-lciate lleitrgd''ciileti} bv a common^orcler'

¶119

The f.rcts o1^{W.A.No.'187ol2021 arcrcpro(lltcccliis} under':-

¶120

The present "rrit^{appealis arisingout of the orcler dillc(l} A7 .O4.2021^{passed by thc1e'rrncci Single JuclgeI t't} w.P.No. 19.13'l ol^{20 19.}

¶121

The ur-rdisputed^{facts ol lhe casc reveal that th'r \ ril} petition $,as prefcrred^{b-v-.the appcllantsbeingaggrievecl bv the} non-selection to the^{post of PrincipaLl(SchooL)in lhe schools rltt.t} b! thc resiclentiai^socicties

¶122

'l'1rc Notilicatiot.t issned lll thc^{rcsp{)ndci'lt/'l'elarlgrlrL'r} State Public^{Se rvice Commission ('I'SPSC)datc(L02 '06 201 7 is} on rccorcl ancl^{ti're qutLlilicationpresr:r'ibcdrttlclcr thc Notlli''lLioll} is N4aster's^{Dcgrectrltlt.lguitl-r B llcl ll'r3r!:('''llIt''ilppclliLtrlsrrr't'''} pcrmirrccl lo parrticlllilLe^{ill ilresclet'LlLrlI lll} 'ft'ss' Hrlri L'l ''l ' le sr-ilts havc rloL^{l)cc1l c1ccl.'rtci1, ns thcr i1o noi llilvl' 13'Eri'Lrr'}

¶123

c.lrLivalernl Dcgrec^{r'it1.t thcTeachirlg N'lethodologl inther} conccrnccl sultj^ect.

¶124

I-earned counsr:l fol^{the:lppellalnLs has drari'n the} .tLcntiorl ol this^{Collrtto\'ardslhcNotificatiorr(latc'l} A'2.06.2afl and^{her corltcntionis that tl.leRules rclalrrrgrr'} Telangana Tribal Wellare^{ResidentialEducalionaiInstirrrlrLrns} Societ-v (Gurr-rkulat.n)^{are to belollorved in thcmatt eroI} rccrLriLrnellt ancl the^{aloresaid Rulesorlly prcscribcP C Dcgrec} along u'ith B.Ed.^{Dcgree. TheTSPSCand the Slale Cloverntncnt} havc not at all takcn^{inLo accounl Lhe aforesaiidaspect\rl.]ile} r:or.rsiclcring lhe^{case s oI the appellants. h-otonlY this, tht]r(' i5} '1 porvr:r of relaxatioll av:rilal;le^{rvitl.r rhc respor-rdent/ TSPSCancl :t} hls bt:ert irrlorntcC^{l:llal lilrganunlbcTlli} llt)sLs^{ilic llillq r';tc;rlll}

¶125

lLr rhc light oI lltc ;Lhlttlslicl,^{lilcrLlslloll(1cnr,/'1'SI)S(l:s} ciilcctr:cl lo cottsiclct lhc^{cttscsof tllc appcllalnts, kccpillg Lr' ricrr} 1i'rc Rulcs rclatitrg^{toTclarnganaTribal \icllarcResirlcniial} IirluciltloL-ritl lltstitutiolls^{Sor:ietr'(Gurr:krtltrtn) it-t rcspcct oI} ecLucaLional c1u:rlificartot-ts^{ancl topass aspcaking ordcrin} rcspect oI the appellar.its'^{selecLiott posirivelv l'ithina period of} .15 c1:rvs lrom todar-.

¶126

¶127

Wrth lhe nlbresaid, thc ri.rir appcals srand (iispos(..1 ot.. Pending misccllaneous applicaticrls, i1. ari,, sirall slirncl closcd. l'herre shall be no orcler as to cLrsls

¶128

SD/. CH.VE N KATESWARU LU DEPUTY REGISTRA

¶129

//TRUE COPY//

¶130

SECTION OFFICER

¶131

To, '1 . The Secretary, Telangana State public Service Commjssion, Nampally. Hvd era bacl 2. One CC to Srrt. K Udaya Sri Advocate IOPUCI 3. One CC to Sri D Bataki'shan Rao(SC FOR TSFSC) Aclvocate IOPUCI 4. One CC to Sri N. Bhoopat Reddv. Advocate (OPUC ) 5. T-w-o_CCs to GP For Sociat Wetiare. High Corrl for ine State of Telangana tourl 6. One CC to Sri P. Giri Krishna. Advocate (OPUC I 7. One CC to Sri Balakishan Rao. SC for TSpSC (OptJC) 8. One CC to Sri Abu Akram, Advocate (OPUC) 9 One CC to Sri N Bhoopat Reddy, SC ior TRIES (OPUC) '10 Two CCs to GP For General Administration. Hiqh Cour-i for the State of Telangana. [OUT] 1211 J*9 lwo 99. CCs to^{to GP For} the Advocate General, High^{Educalon,High Court} Colrt^{forthe State} for the State^{of Telangana.} of Te"langaha.[OUrltourl IJ One CC to Smt. K. V. Rajasree. Advodare (OpUC) 14 One Spare Copy MB C

¶132

HIGH COURT

¶133

DATED: 0410312022

¶134

lrlE SI4 i{:
)
*<br>Jo,J 25 I-4AB2022

¶135

COMMON JUDGMENT

¶136

WA NOS: 487,621, 624, 655 & 656 OF 2021

¶137

AND 48 0F 2022