Partly allowed

The Special Deputy Collector v. Islavath Surya and 19 Others

Telangana HC19 Sept 2022LAAS/125/2014

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court partially allowed a land acquisition appeal filed by the Special Deputy Collector. The court reduced the market value of land in Malyala Village from Rs. 80,000 to Rs. 45,000 per acre, while confirming the existing value for land in Korivi Village, aligning with a prior related judgment.

What did the court decide?

The market value for land in Malyala Village reduced to Rs. 45,000 per acre. Market value for Korivi Village confirmed at Rs. 80,000 per acre. Claimants entitled to statutory benefits.

The Special Deputy Collector Vs Islavath Surya and 19… — Land Acquisition | Telangana HC (2022)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT FoR THE STATE oF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

¶2

N]ONDAY THE NINEIEENIH DAY CF SEPTEfulBER TWO THOUSAND AND rWENry T\ryO

¶3

PRESENT

¶4

THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE G. SRI OEVI AND THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE M.G.PRIYADARSINI

¶5

L.A.A,S Ot 125 F 0'14

¶6

Appeat Under Section 54 oF L.A. Act 1984 against lhe Judgment and Decree dated Mahabubabad.22.04.2022 made in O.p.No.g of 1999 on the file of the Court of lhe Senior Civil Judge,

Between:

The Special Deputy Collecror,
Land Acquisition Officer.
L.A. SRSP, Sragc - I & il. Unit-I, Warangrt
.... petirioner/ Appellart
I. Istavartr Surya S/o. Doodya R/o. #tl,l, viti"g" Uarabubabad Mandal
Wuargal Distr:ict.
2. Nuravathi Rangi Wo. Flemla R/o. Malyaia Village Mahabubabad Mandal
S Badavath Bodya s/o. Bareeya R/o. Malyura vilage Ma]rabubabad Mandal
4. Badavatb parsu S/o. Lingiya R/o. forivi ry) * tfU) Warangal Dist.
5. Isalavarh Ranrcihan S/o. Surya R/o. Korivi (V) & ilvi) Warangal Disl
6. Banorh Lingya S/o. Bodya IVo. Korivi (V) & (M) Waral8al Dist.
7. larpula LaJu S/o. Devuja R/o. Korivi (rf) ft (M) Warangal Disl.
8. -latpula Koldeeya s/o. serya R"/o. I(orivi (V) & (M),i/ar.angal Dist,
9. Jarpuia Nurya S/o. Dcvuja R/o. Kor.ivi (V) & (M) Wqrangal Dist.
10. Banothu Haruji S/o. Arnar.silgh R/o. Korivi (V) & (M) Warangal Dist.
Il. Badvath Ha(ti S/o. Lingya R/o. Korivi C\t & (M) Walangal Dist.
12. Badvath Balaji S/o. Chandru iVo. Korivi (V) & (M) Warargal Dist.
13. Banothu Dasru S/o. Ramdas Rlo. Korivi (V)& (M) Warangal Dist.
14. Banothu BiclE S/o. Bameeya R/o. Korivi fl) & (M) Warangal Dist-
15. Badavath Vasram S/o. Lingya R/o. Korivi (V) & (M).Warangal Dist,
16. Badavath Balu S/o. Hatri R/o. Korivi (V)& (M) Waranga Disi.
17. Banoth Kesu S/o. Lokya R./o. Korivi (q & (M) Warangal Dist.
18. Banoth Harichardru S,/o. Bludru singh lVo. Korivi (V) & (M) Waraagal Dist.
19. Banoth Sakru 5/6- Baflchya Rzo. Korivi (V) & (M) Warangal Dist.
20 Banoth Setharalr S,/o. Venkati R/o. Korivi (V) & (M) Warangat Disr
Respondents /Claimanr

¶11

l.A. NO: 3 OF 2014(LAASMP. NO: 403 OF 20 141

¶12

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumslances stated in the affidavit filed herein, the High Court may be pleased stay all further proceedings including the execution of EP No.43l2O07 of the decree in OP No.9 of 1999 daled 22.04.2002 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Mahabubabad, pending disposal of LAAS.No.125 of 2O14 on the file of the High Court.

¶13

Counsel for the Appellant: SRI D.KIRAN, AGP FOR APPEALS

¶14

Counsel for the Respondents: SRI B. NARAYANA REDDY

¶15

The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT

¶16

I I

¶17

, t

¶18

THE HON'BLE^{JUSTICE G. SRI DEVI}

¶19

AND

¶20

THE HON'BLE SMT.^{JUSTICE M'G.PRIYADARSINI}

¶21

L.A.A.S.No.12 5^{of 2Ol4}

¶22

JUDGMENT:^{(per JusticeG. Sri Devi)}

¶23

This appeal is filed^{underSection54 of the Land Acquisition Act'} 1894^(for short^{"the Act") by the Land AcquisitionOfficeraggrieved by} the order and decree^{dated 22-04.2002 madein O'P'No'9 of 1999on} the file of the Senior^{Civil Judge,Mahabubabad'By the impugned} award the reference^{Courtfixed the market value at Rs'80'0OO/- per} acre

¶24

Heard Sri D.Kiran,^{learned Assistant GovernmentPieaderfor the} appellant and learned^{counsel for the ciaimants'Perusedthe material} available on record.

¶25

The present acquisition^{was for the purpose of excavation of} calal under DBM^{48 SRSP.variousextentsof land belonging to the} claimants, situated at^{Malyala Village and Korivi Village and Mandal'} Warangai Distrlct,^{were acquired by the Governmentfor the said} purpose by invoking urgency^{clause. It is now broughtto our notice} that this Court, while^{dealing\4'ith similar acquisition proceedingsin} respect of the land^{situated in verysame villages,in L'A'A'S'No'5O4 of} 2dO8, preferred^{by the LandAcquisition officer,by its judgment'dated} 16.09.2022, aliowed^{the appeal in part, conhrmingthe market value}

¶26

¶27

flred by the ret'ercrrce Court in rcspccr oi liorivi \rillagc :rnd rr:ducinq the market valLter L,) Rs.4S,OC)0/- pcr a(.re in re spcct o1.Malr,.ala Viliage.

¶28

Sincc it is agreed on either side that thc reasoning aclopteci by this Court in its judgment daied 16.09.2022 holds good even in this appeal, we alloq, the appeal in part while reducing the market value of the acquired land situatecl at Ma-lyala Village from Rs.SO,OOO/- to Rs.45,OOO/ - per acre and confir;-rring the markct value Iixed by the reference Court at Rs.g0,0O0/- pcr acrc in respect of thc land situatecl at I(orivi Village. 'j'he claimanrs arc cntirlecl lor the statutory benetits like Additional amount, solatium ancl interest as per lavr. There shali be no order as to costs

¶29

Miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stanc closed

//TRUE COPY//

SECTION OFFICER

To,

The Senior Civil Judge, Mahabubabad. (with records)

¶34

Two CCs to the GP for Appeals, High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT]

¶35

One CC to Sri B. Narayana Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]

¶36

Two CD Copies

¶37

One Spare Copy gbr

HIGH COURT

DATED: 1910912022

JUDGMENT

LAAS.No.125 of 2014

1 $E ST4 G:
oJ 11 r:0\J 2['I
t'

¶43

PARTLY ALLOWING THE LAAS WITHOUT COSTS

¶44

I
\o

¶45

[3281 ]

¶46

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

¶47

MONDAY ,THE NINETEENTH DAY OF SEPIEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO

¶48

PRESENT

¶49

THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE G. SRI DEVI AND

¶50

THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE M.G.PRIYADARSINI

¶51

LAND ACOUISITION FIRST APPEAL N o: 125 0F 2014

¶52

Between:

¶53

Thc Special Depury Collec tol

¶54

Land Acquisition Offi cer..

¶55

L.A. SRSP, Stage _ I & Il. Llnit_ 1. Waranga)

¶56

Petitiorle/ Appellanr

¶57

.\ncl

¶58

. lslavarh Sur.ya S/o. Iro,,;1., 1i ,,

¶59

¶60

: Nunavathi lkngi 'rf ,e. llenrla IUo. Mrlyala ViUagc Malabubabad Mandal
j
Iladavath Bodya s/o. Batecva R/o. Malyara virage Mahabubabad Mandal
4 Badavcrlr parsu S/o. Lingive R,o. l(orrvr fV) & (M) Warangal Dist.
.5. Isalavath Ranrdhan S/o. Sur).ir R.,o. Kor ivi (V) .t (M) Warangal Dist.
6 Banoth Lingya S/o- Bodya IUo. l(or.ivi (V) & (M) Waraugal Dist.
7. Jarpula LaJu S/o. Devuja R/o. Korivi 1r,;14 (M) Wararga.l Dist.
8.
Jarpula Kondeeya S,/o. Serya R/o. I(orivi 1V) & (M) Warangal Dist. l
I
I 9. Jarpula Nurya S./o. Denrja R/o. Korivr (V) & (lvf) W4rangal Dist.
I
( 10. Balothu Hamji S/o. Arnarsingh R_/o. Korivi (V) & (M) Warangal Dist.
i
I 1. Badvath Hafti S/o. Lingya R/o. Korivi (v) & (N4) V/arangal Dht.
I 12. Badvarh Balaji S/o. Chandru R/o. Korivi (V) & (M Warangal Dist.
lJ. Banothu Dasru S/o. Ramdas R/o. Korivi CV) & (M) Warangal Dist.
14. Banotlru Bicha S/o. Bameeya R/o_ Korivi (V) & (M) Warangal Dist.
15. Badavatir Vasrarn S/o. Liugya R_/o. Kor.ivi (V) 8a (fr,{) Warangal Dist.
16. Badavath Balu s/o. Haui R/o. I(oLivi (v) & (M) warangal Dist
17. Banoth Kesu S/o. Lokya R/o. Korivi (Vt & (M) Warangal Dist.
18. Banoth Harichandru S/o. Bhartru silgh lllo. Korivi (V) & (M) Warangal Dist.
19. Banoth Sakru S/o. Banchya R.io. Korivi (V) & (M) War.angal Dist.
20. Bauoth Sctharam s/o. Vcnkati R,/o. Korivi (V) & (M) Warangal Dist.

¶61

Respordents /Claimallt

¶62

Appeal^{Under Section 54 of L A Act 1g84against the Judgmentand Decree of the} Court^{of the Senior CivilJudge' Mahabubabadmade in O P No'9 of 1999dated22-04 '2022'} This appeal^{coming on for hearing and uponperusing the grounds of appeal'the} Judgment^{and Decreeof the Lower Court and thematerialpapers in the Suit and upon} hearing^{the argumentsof Sri D Kiran'AGPlor Appeals'for the Appellantand of Sri}

¶63

B. Narayana^{Reddy, Advocate for the Respondents'}

¶64

This Court^{doth Order and Decree as follows:}

¶65

That^{the LAAS be and hereby is allowed in part'}

¶66

That^{the market value at the acquiredLand situated at MalyalaVillagebe and hereby} reduced^{from Rs.80,0001to Rs'45'0001 per acre;}

¶67

That the^{market value fixed by the referencecourtat Rs 80'000/- per acre in respect}

¶68

3 oftheLandSituatedatKoriviVillagebeandherebyisconfirmed;

¶69

4 That the^{claimants be and hereby are entitledthe statutorybenefits like Additional} amount'^{solatium and interest as per law; and}

¶70

That^{there shall be no orderas to costs in this LAAS}

¶71

SD/.K,SRINIVASA JOINT^REGIST R

//TRUE^COPYi/

SECTION^OFFICER

To,

lvlahabubabad.^{(with records)}

¶76

1. The Senior^{Civil Judge'}

¶77

Two^{CD CoPies}

¶78

One SPare CoPY
gbr
},-

HIGH COURT

DATED:^1910912022

DECREE

LAAS.No.125^{of 2014}

¶83

PARTLY^{ALLOWING THE LAAS} WITHOUT^COSTS @xe

The Special Deputy Collector v. Islavath Surya and 19 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

The Special Deputy Collector v. Islavath Surya and 19 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

The Special Deputy Collector Land Acquisition Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation Vs v.Manemma

V. Venkateswara Rao Vs The Special Grade Deputy Collector

Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs M. Guru Latha

The Oriental Insurance Company Limited, Nalgonda Vs Kotagiri Satosh Kumar and 4 Ors, Nalgonda District

Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Tharunoju Eshwaramma and 5 Others

The Special Deputy Collector Vs Banoth Manghya