This appeal is filed by the plaintiff insofar as item No.2 of the plaint schedule property, which is house property bearing No.4/37 in Palthur village, Vidapanakal Mandal of Anantapur District. The plaintiff filed the suit for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the plaintiff’s peaceful possession of the plaint schedule properties and to declare the plaintiff’s right to item No.2 of the plaint schedule. Admittedly the defendants are in possession of item No.2. Therefore, the question of the plaintiff seeking permanent injunction against the defendants in respect of this item does not arise at all. Further, PW.4 in cross-examination admitted that family of the defendants are residing in the schedule house for the last 50 years along with Ramakka. The plaintiff as PW.1 himself admitted that the defendants were allowed to live in their house at the request of their grand mother Ramakka to look after her since his grand father died at the early age, by which time his father was minor. PW.1 further stated that with the permission of his mother, his grand father Errappa