Dismissed

Manoj Kumar Saini S/O Ramdhan Saini v. State of Rajasthan

Rajasthan HC29 Aug 2023CW/3099/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court of Rajasthan dismissed multiple writ petitions challenging recruitment advertisements for para-medical posts as infructuous due to the cancellation of the advertisements. The court granted liberty to file fresh petitions regarding eligibility grievances in the future.

What did the court decide?

Petitions dismissed as infructuous; liberty granted to file fresh petitions on grounds of non-registration, qualification equivalence, and bonus marks upon fresh vacancy/notification.

Manoj Kumar Saini S/O Ramdhan Saini Vs State of… — Service and Employment | Rajasthan HC (2023)

¶1

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

¶2

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR

¶3

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1008/2023

¶4

Pritam Mitwa W/o Subhash Chechu, Aged About 30 Years, R/o Village And Post Dugoli, District Sikar.

¶5

----Petitioner

¶6

Versus

¶7

State Of Rajasthan, Through Principal Secretary, Medical And Health Department, Rajasthan, Govt. Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

¶8

Director, State Health And Family Welfare Institution, Rajasthan, Jaipur.

¶9

Chief Medical And Health Officer, Sikar.

¶10

----Respondents

¶11

And other similar matters as per Schedule appended

¶12

For Petitioner(s)	:	Mr. Sumit Kumar Sihag Mr. Jai Prakash Gupta Mr. Mukesh Kumar Goyal
		Mr. Tanveer Ahamad
		Mr. Ram Pratap Saini,
		Mr. Aamir Khan
		Mr. Sunil Kumar Singodiya
		Mr. R.B. Sharma Ganthola Mr. Naveen Dhuwan
		Ms. Shashi Bala Sharma
		Mr. Kuldeep Sharma
		Mr. Pallav Chaudhary,
		Mr. Yogesh Chawla
		Mr. Sandeep Kalwaniya
		Mr. Mukesh Pal Jadun
		Mr. Imran Khan
		Mr. Akshat Chaudhary
		Mr. Praveen Sharma,
		Mr. Saket Gupta
		Mr. Kuldeep Singh Meena
		Mr. Laxmi Kant Malpura
		Mr. Raj Sharma
		Mr. Sukhraj Singh Rathore
		Mr. Vijendra Yadav
		Mr. Hemant Sant
		Mr. Raj Kumar Kasana
		Mr. D.K. Dixit
		Mr. Koushal Bhardwaj
		Mr. S. Gaharana
		Mr. G.L. Sharma

(2 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

Mr. Vivek Joshi, Ms. Preeti Sharma Mr. Abhishek Pareek Mr. Rajveer Gurjar Ms. Aradhana Swami Mr. Kunal Sharma Mr. Rudraksh Sharma Mr. Raghu Nandan Sharma Mr. Surya Prakash Ms. Sudesh Kasana Ms. Madhumita Das Mr. Kailash Choudhary Mr. R.A Verma Mr. Shrawan Gupta, Mr. Nawab Ali Rathore Mr. Karanpal Singh Mr. Sudhir Yadav Mr. Rishi Raj Maheshwari, Mr. Abhishek Bhardwaj Mr. Shivatama Kumr Tank Mr. Mohd. Shakir Khan, Mr. Iliyas Khan Mr. Arvind Kumar Sharma Ms. Swati Tank Mr. Koslesh Kumar Bairwa Mr. Ashwinee Kumar Jaiman Mr. Dheeraj Tripathi Mr. Manish Kumar Sharma Ms. Komal Kumari Giri Mr. Sultan Singh Kuri Mr. Puneet Gupta Mr. Balkishan Saini Dr. Saugath Roy For Respondent(s) : Mr. Bharat Saini Mr. Saransh Saini Mr. Harshad Tholia for Dr. V.B. Sharma, AAG

¶17

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDESH BANSAL Order

¶18

29/08/2023

¶19

Learned counsel for both parties do not dispute that cause of action to file these writ petitions has arisen on account of issuing the advertisement dated 15.12.2022 for the post of Woman Health Worker/Assistant Radiographer/Lab Technician by the State Health and Family Welfare Institution, Rajasthan, Jaipur. Petitioners have

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

(3 of 12)

raised grievance in respect of allowing to submit Offline application form; to issue experience certificate feeling aggrieved by non-registration with the Rajasthan Para Medical Council and to claim the qualification as equivalent for the post in question etc.

¶24

Learned counsel for both parties are ad idem that since the advertisement dated 15.12.2022 itself has been cancelled, therefore, the basic cause of action to file instant writ petitions do not survive, accordingly, all writ petitions have become infructuous. However, it has been pointed out that since the grievance raised by petitioners in these writ petitions have not been dealt with on merits, therefore, petitioners be given liberty to raise their grievance in future, as and when either fresh vacancies notified or a fresh cause of action arises.

¶25

Learned counsel for respondents have no objection in that respect.

¶26

Accordingly, all writ petitions arising out of advertisement dated 15.12.2022 are dismissed as having become infructuous. However, as far as grievance of petitioners in respect of nonregistration with the Rajasthan Para Medical Council/treating their educational qualification as eligible for the post in question/entitlement of bonus marks for the experience etc. are concerned, petitioners would be at liberty to file fresh writ petitions, as and when need arises to ventilate their grievances. 5. Stay applications and any other pending application, if any, stand disposed of. 6. A copy of this order be placed in each file.

¶27

(SUDESH BANSAL),J

¶28

TN/290-467 except 313 & 407, 457, 462, 463, 464,465, 366 467

(4 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

SCHEDULE

S.No	Item No.	Writ Petition No.	Party N	ame
1.	291	SBCWP No.19439/2022	Sagar Hardaniya & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
2.	292	SBCWP No.19478/2022	Asharma Nagar & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
3.	293	SBCWP No.217/2023	Laxmi Devi	The State of Raj. & ors.
4.	294	SBCWP No.273/2023	Roshani	The State of Raj. & ors.
5.	295	SBCWP No.287/2023	Chandan Agarwal	The State of Raj. & ors.
6.	296	SBCWP No.425/2023	Babali & Anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
7.	297	SBCWP No.429/2023	Radharaman Sharma & ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
8.	298	SBCWP No.433/2023	Vimala Sahariya & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
9.	299	SBCWP No.456/2023	Sunita	The State of Raj. & ors.
10.	300	SBCWP No.461/2023	Suman Kumari Meena &Anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
11.	301	SBCWP No.643/2023	Rukmani Kumari	The State of Raj. & ors.
12.	302	SBCWP No.812/2023	Denis Jindal & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
13.	303	SBCWP No.829/2023	Hemraj Sharma & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
14.	304	SBCWP No.1010/2023	Geeta Kumari	The State of Raj. & ors.
15.	305	SBCWP No.1011/2023	Sangeeta Kuldeep	The State of Raj. & ors.
16.	306	SBCWP No.1012/2023	Manish Meena	The State of Raj. & Anr
17.	307	SBCWP No.1013/2023	Mohit Kumar Yadav	The State of Raj. & ors.
18.	308	SBCWP No.1017/2023	Hemlata Meena &	The State of
			Ors.	Raj. & ors.
19.	309	SBCWP No.1044/2023	Sonee Sharma	The State of

(5 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

			&Ors. Raj.	& ors.
20.	310	SBCWP No.1053/2023	Ajay Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
21.	311	SBCWP No.1138/2023	Ashish Kumar Jhadoliya & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
22.	312	SBCWP No.1215/2023	Sheeba Bee The Raj.	State of & ors.
23.	314	SBCWP No.1288/2023	Mamta Choudhary The Raj.	State of & ors.
24	315	SBCWP No.1299/2023	Krishna Mehar The Raj.	State of & ors.
25	316	SBCWP No.1309/2023	Manish Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
26	317	SBCWP No.1318/2023	Kapil Sharma The Raj.	State of & ors.
27	318	SBCWP No.1326/2023	Kavita Gochar The Raj.	State of & ors.
28	319	SBCWP No.1327/2023	Manju Gochar The Raj.	State of & ors.
29	320	SBCWP No.1328/2023	Deepika Prajapat The Raj.	State of & ors.
30	321	SBCWP No.1332/2023	Yashoda Kumari Meena The Raj.	State of & ors.
31	322	SBCWP No.1337/2023	Aishwariya Sharma The Raj.	State of & ors.
32	323	SBCWP No.1438/2023	Anita Kumari Bairwa & Anr. The Raj.	State of & ors.
33	324	SBCWP No.1440/2023	Ashwani Ametha & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
34	325	SBCWP No.1441/2023	Sulochana Choudhary The Raj.	State of & ors.
35	326	SBCWP No.1449/2023	Preksha Meena The Raj.	State of & ors.
36	327	SBCWP No.1450/2023	Manta Bai & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
37	328	SBCWP No.1477/2023	Arbaz Khan The Raj.	State of & ors.
38	329	SBCWP No.1518/2023	Riya Goutam The	State of
			Raj.	& ors.
39	330	SBCWP No.1528/2023	Himanshu The	State of

(6 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

			Mandawat	Raj. & ors.
40	331	SBCWP No.1571/2023	Puneet Mishra	The State of Raj. & ors.
41	332	SBCWP No.1633/2023	Yogesh Sharma & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
42	333	SBCWP No.1653/2023	Naresh Saini & Anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
43	334	SBCWP No.1760/2023	Naveen Kumar Bairwa & ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
44	335	SBCWP No.1785/2023	Nishant Dhankhar & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
45	336	SBCWP No.1831/2023	Ajay Kumar & Ors	The State of Raj. & ors.
46	337	SBCWP No.1832/2023	Vinod Kumar Gurjar	The State of Raj. & ors.
47	338	SBCWP No.1833/2023	Deepak Serawat & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
48	339	SBCWP No.1834/2023	Ravi Shankar Verma	The State of Raj. & ors.
49	340	SBCWP No.1844/2023	Yash Sharma	The State of Raj. & ors.
50	341	SBCWP No.1845/2023	Neeraj Kumari	The State of Raj. & ors.
51	342	SBCWP No.1849/2023	Sanjay Kumar Saini	The State of Raj. & ors.
52	343	SBCWP No.1850/2023	Kavita Dhaka	The State of Raj. & ors.
53	344	SBCWP No.1851/2023	Tara Chand Sharma	The State of Raj. & ors.
54	345	SBCWP No.1858/2023	Dheeraj Sharma & Anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
55	346	SBCWP No.1862/2023	Sarvadaman Singh Tanwar & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
56	347	SBCWP No.1864/2023	Sonu Singh & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
57	348	SBCWP No.1865/2023	Jitendra Singh & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
58	349	SBCWP No.1919/2023	Mohit Kumar	The State of
			Sharma & Ors.	Raj. & ors.
59	350	SBCWP No.1930/2023	Aastha Kapila &	The State of

(7 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

			Ors. Raj.	& ors.
60	351	SBCWP No.1937/2023	Akshat Trivedi & ors The Raj.	State of & ors.
61	352	SBCWP No.1943/2023	Prachi Jangid The Raj.	State of & ors.
62	353	SBCWP No.1981/2023	Mohit Kumar Kumawat & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
63	354	SBCWP No.1982/2023	Oma Choudhary & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
64	355	SBCWP No.1996/2023	Manisha Kumari & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
65	356	SBCWP No.1997/2023	Guddi Devi The Raj.	State of & ors.
66	357	SBCWP No.2008/2023	Ravina Gurjar &Anr. The Raj.	State of & ors.
67	358	SBCWP No.2009/2023	Pushpa Prajapati & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
68	359	SBCWP No.2040/2023	Sanjay Kumar Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
69	360	SBCWP No.2043/2023	Neha Pareek & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
70	361	SBCWP No.2053/2023	Bhairu Prakash Verma The Raj.	State of & ors.
71	362	SBCWP No.2056/2023	Garima & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
72	363	SBCWP No.2067/2023	Romana Ansari &Anr. The Raj.	State of & ors.
73	364	SBCWP No.2107/2023	Akansha Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
74	365	SBCWP No.2202/2023	Naveen Sharma The Raj.	State of & ors.
75	366	SBCWP No.2218/2023	Rakesh Kumar The Raj.	State of & ors.
76	367	SBCWP No.2246/2023	Shivam Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
77	368	SBCWP No.2248/2023	Sajan Kumar The Raj.	State of & ors.
78	369	SBCWP No.2260/2023	Vikas Kumar The	State of
			Mishra & Ors. Raj.	& ors.
79	370	SBCWP No.2269/2023	Sachin Dhukiya & The	State of

(8 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

			anr.	Raj. & ors.
80	371	SBCWP No.2285/2023	Shivraj Gurjar & ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
81	372	SBCWP No.2349/2023	Manisha Choudhary& Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
82	373	SBCWP No.2359/2023	Ankush Karsoliya & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
83	374	SBCWP No.2391/2023	Aashish Choudhary	The State of Raj. & ors.
84	375	SBCWP No.2495/2023	Karan Singh Sambhriya	The State of Raj. & ors.
85	376	SBCWP No.2524/2023	Riya Bajaj & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
86	377	SBCWP No.2539/2023	Adnan Ahamed & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
87	378	SBCWP No.2549/2023	Sharmila & ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
88	379	SBCWP No.2582/2023	Poonam Kumawat & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
89	380	SBCWP No.2611/2023	Sumit Kumar Swami & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
90	381	SBCWP No.2628/2023	Gaurav Choudhary	The State of Raj. & ors.
91	382	SBCWP No.2633/2023	Neeraj Kumari	The State of Raj. & ors.
92	383	SBCWP No.2660/2023	Shirsti Sharma & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
93	384	SBCWP No.2670/2023	Ramnari Gurjar & anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
94	385	SBCWP No.2671/2023	Hemant Meena	The State of Raj. & ors.
95	386	SBCWP No.2681/2023	Sachin Kasana & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
96	387	SBCWP No.2698/2023	Rakesh Sharma & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
97	388	SBCWP No.2707/2023	Pushpendra Singh Solanki & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
98	389	SBCWP No.2738/2023	Susheel Kasana &	The State of
			Ors.	Raj. & ors.
99	390	SBCWP No.2744/2023	Nikita Choudhary	The State of

(9 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

100	391	SBCWP No.2745/2023	Raj. Ravina Jakhar & ors. The Raj.	& ors. State of & ors.
101	392	SBCWP No.2777/2023	Chanchal Jain & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
102	393	SBCWP No.2792/2023	Ruchika The Raj.	State of & ors.
103	394	SBCWP No.2803/2023	Narendra Singh Shekhawat The Raj.	State of & ors.
104	395	SBCWP No.2829/2023	Ritik Sharma & Ors The Raj.	State of & ors.
105	396	SBCWP No.2841/2023	Hemlata Meghawal The Raj.	State of & ors.
106	397	SBCWP No.2843/2023	Neha Goyal & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
107	398	SBCWP No.2846/2023	Hemant Goyal The Raj.	State of & ors.
108	399	SBCWP No.2851/2023	Neetu Kumawat & Ors The Raj.	State of & ors.
109	400	SBCWP No.2859/2023	Sumit Kumar Bairwa The Raj.	State of & ors.
110	401	SBCWP No.2870/2023	Laxminarayan &anr. The Raj.	State of & ors.
111	402	SBCWP No.2890/2023	Usha Sukhariya & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
112	403	SBCWP No.2895/2023	Sahil Khan & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
113	404	SBCWP No.2913/2023	Manoj Prajapat The Raj.	State of & ors.
114	405	SBCWP No.2918/2023	Vishnu Swami & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
115	406	SBCWP No.2969/2023	Navneet Dwivedi & Ors The Raj.	State of & ors.
116	408	SBCWP No.3025/2023	Meghendra Singh Dhaked & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
117	409	SBCWP No.3034/2023	Ashok Kumar Gurjar The Raj.	State of & ors.
118	410	SBCWP No.3038/2023	Piyush Sharma & The	State of
			ors. Raj.	& ors.
119	411	SBCWP No.3045/2023	Prahalad The	State of

(10 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

			Choudhary Raj.	& ors.
120	412	SBCWP No.3047/2023	Ashok Kumar & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
121	413	SBCWP No.3048/2023	Mohit Kumar Yadav & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
122	414	SBCWP No.3059/2023	Babita Raghav & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
123	415	SBCWP No.3068/2023	Ramesh Kumar Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
124	416	SBCWP No.3073/2023	Mohemmed Sadik Khan The Raj.	State of & ors.
125	417	SBCWP No.3077/2023	Ankur Dadarwal & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
126	418	SBCWP No.3090/2023	Mohit Saini & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
127	419	SBCWP No.3090/2023	Ankit Udaiwal & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
128	420	SBCWP No.3099/2023	Manoj Kumar Saini & anr. The Raj.	State of & ors.
129	421	SBCWP No.3183/2023	Aastha Kapila The Raj.	State of & ors.
130	422	SBCWP No.3349/2023	Pradeep Kumar Bairwa & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
131	423	SBCWP No.3397/2023	Bharti Kanwar The Raj.	State of & ors.
132	424	SBCWP No.3573/2023	Omprakash Gurjar & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
133	425	SBCWP No.3614/2023	Aditya Kulhari The Raj.	State of & ors.
134	426	SBCWP No.3641/2023	Amit Kumar Meena & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
135	427	SBCWP No.3663/2023	Tejaswani Sharma & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
136	428	SBCWP No.3670/2023	Arina Naaz & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
137	429	SBCWP No.3687/2023	Rajan Gautam The Raj.	State of & ors.
138	430	SBCWP No.3709/2023	Sneha Choudhary The	State of
			& Ors. Raj.	& ors.
139	431	SBCWP No.3734/2023	Laxmi Narayan The	State of

(11 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

			Raj.	& ors.
140	432	SBCWP No.3764/2023	Tosif Raza & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
141	433	SBCWP No.3765/2023	Ashish Kumar Singhoya & ors The Raj.	State of & ors.
142	434	SBCWP No.3806/2023	Pradeep Kumar The Raj.	State of & ors.
143	435	SBCWP No.3815/2023	Meena Sameria & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
144	436	SBCWP No.3836/2023	Jale Singh The Raj.	State of & ors.
145	437	SBCWP No.3846/2023	Suman Kanwar The Raj.	State of & ors.
146	438	SBCWP No.3855/2023	Nitesh Kumar Kumawat & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
147	439	SBCWP No.3856/2023	Mohammad Uzer Ansari The Raj.	State of & ors.
148	440	SBCWP No.3880/2023	Mahendra Singh The Raj.	State of & ors.
149	441	SBCWP No.3887/2023	Surendra Kumar Bhati The Raj.	State of & ors.
150	442	SBCWP No.3891/2023	Indu Gurjar The Raj.	State of & ors.
151	443	SBCWP No.3897/2023	Annu Tank & Ors The Raj.	State of & ors.
152	444	SBCWP No.3990/2023	Bhupendra Tak The Raj.	State of & ors.
153	445	SBCWP No.4001/2023	Soniya Keelka & Ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
154	446	SBCWP No.4003/2023	Shaili Vyas & ors. The Raj.	State of & ors.
155	447	SBCWP No.4004/2023	Nidhi Sharma The Raj.	State of & ors.
156	448	SBCWP No.4023/2023	Ankit Yadav The Raj.	State of & ors.
157	449	SBCWP No.4026/2023	Jyoti Lunia The Raj.	State of & ors.
158	450	SBCWP No.4086/2023	Priyanka The	State of
			Chaudhary Raj.	& ors.
159	451	SBCWP No.4093/2023	Devendra Soni The	State of

(12 of 12)

[2023:RJ-JP:19998]

[CW-1008/2023]

				Raj. & ors.
160	452	SBCWP No.4098/2023	Pinki Bajiya & Anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
161	453	SBCWP No.4099/2023	Suman Choudhary & Ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
162	454	SBCWP No.4324/2023	Neelam Kuri	The State of Raj. & ors.
163	455	SBCWP No.4387/2023	Gaurav Sharma & ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
164	456	SBCWP No.4465/2023	Rahul Kumar & Anr.	The State of Raj. & ors.
165	458	SBCWP No.4883/2023	Pawan Kumar Buddh & ors.	The State of Raj. & ors.
166	459	SBCWP No.6054/2023	Amrat Lal	The State of Raj. & ors.
167	460	SBCWP No.7086/2023	Narendra Singh	The State of Raj. & ors.
168	461	SBCWP No.9191/2023	Dinesh Kanwariya	The State of Raj. & ors.

Manoj Kumar Saini S/O Ramdhan Saini v. State of Rajasthan

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Manoj Kumar Saini S/O Ramdhan Saini v. State of Rajasthan

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Geet Prakash Gulpadiya S/O Ratan Chand Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan

Deepak Singh Rathore S/O Gopal Singh Vs State of Rajasthan

Hemant Kumar S/O Shravan Kumar Vs State of Rajasthan

Prahalad Choudhary S/O Shri Shivcharan Choudhary Vs the State of Rajasthan

Ashok Kumar Gurjar S/O Hanuman Sahai Gurjar Vs State of Rajasthan

Ramesh Kumar Sharma S/O Shri Moti Ram Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan