The High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur dismissed a second appeal as infructuous due to a subsequent order by the Mining Engineer regarding the quarry licence priority, decided on 29.07.2011.
The second appeal is dismissed as infructuous. The appellant is free to challenge the order dated 29.07.2011.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
S.B. CIVIL SECOND APPEAL No.69/2011. Ravindra Singh Vs. Abhinandan Prasad & Anr.
Judgment dated 06/02/2015
1/4
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JODHPUR.
:: J U D G M E N T ::
S.B. CIVIL SECOND APPEAL No.69/2011.
Ravindra Singh Vs. Abhinandan Prasad & Anr.
Date of Judgment
th :::: 06 February 2015.
P R E S E N T
HON'BLE Dr. JUSTICE VINEET KOTHARI
Appearance:
Mr. Rajesh Shah, for the appellant/defendant. Mr. Manish Shishodia, for the respondent No.1/plaintiff. Ms. Suman Porwal, Addl. Govt. Counsel for Mining Deptt.
BY THE COURT :
S.B. CIVIL SECOND APPEAL No.69/2011. Ravindra Singh Vs. Abhinandan Prasad & Anr.
Judgment dated 06/02/2015
2/4
Makrana, whereby the suit filed by the respondent No.1/plaintiff being Civil Original Suit No.176/93 (39/89)- Abhinandan Prasad Vs. Ravindra Singh & Ors., for permanent and mandatory injunction was dismissed.
“आद�श
अप�ल�र�/व�द� अभ�न�दन पस�द जर�य� आम म�ख�य�� श� द�पक क�म�� ब�सल क ओ� स� प�यर�/पत#व�द� �ववन& भस�ह व अनय क� ववरद पस#�# द�व�न� म+ल अप�ल अन#र-# ध��� 96 सपठ0# आद�श 41 तनयम 1 वय. प. स�. ववरद तनर-य एव� ड5क ठदन��क 30.3.2010 द�व�न� म+ल व�द स�खय�- 176/1993 (39/1989) अभ�न�दन पस�द जर�य� आम म�ख�य�� द�पक क�म�� ब�सल ववरद �ववन& भस�ह व अनय व�द ब�ब# घ8षर� व सर�य� तनष�ध�ज� द��� य8गय भसववल नय�य�ध�श (क. ख�.) मक��न� आ�भशक रप स� सव�क�� क ज�#� ह> औ� तनर-य एव� ड5क ठदन��क 30.03.2010 क8 अप�स# ककय�ज�#� ह>। अप�ल�र�/व�द� क� व�द ववरद प�यर�/पत#व�द� इस स�म� #क ड5क ककय� ज�#� ह>, कक व�द� क� व�दगस# ख�न स� य8गय श�सन सचEव ख�न (ग�प) वव��र सचEव�लय जयप � क� आद�श ठदन��क 8.5.1991 क� तनदFशG क� अन�स�� सकम प�चधक��� द��� आद�श प�र�# क�न� #क ब�दखल नह�� ककय� ज�व� औ� सकम प�चधक��� आद�श ठदन��क
S.B. CIVIL SECOND APPEAL No.69/2011. Ravindra Singh Vs. Abhinandan Prasad & Anr.
Judgment dated 06/02/2015
3/4
8.5.1991 क8 #�न म�ह क अवचध मI प�लन� स�तनशK# क��। अप�ल�र�/व�द� आद�श ठदन��क 8.5.1991 क प�लन� मI सकम प�चधक��� द��� आद�श प�र�# क�न� प� यठद अपन� द�व�न� अचधक�� प��वव# म�न#� ह>, #8 #�पK�# L सकम नय�य�लय मI व�द क��र प�प ह8न� प� सकम नय�य�लय मI क�य-व�ह� क�न� क� भलए सव#�त �ह�र�। अप�ल वयय पकक���न अपन�-अपन� वहन क�Iर�, #दन�स�� ड5क पE�- बन�य� ज�ए।
तनर-य क पत# य8गय भसववल नय�य�ध�श (क.ख�.) मक��न� क म+ल अभ�ल�ख क� स�र अववलमब ��ज� ज�व�।
Sd/अत# शजल� नय�य�ध�श (फ�सQ ट�क) प�ब#स� भशवव� मक��न�"
S.B. CIVIL SECOND APPEAL No.69/2011. Ravindra Singh Vs. Abhinandan Prasad & Anr.
Judgment dated 06/02/2015
4/4
the said order dated 29.07.2011 produced by the counsel for the respondent No.1/plaintiff, is taken on record and copy of the same has also been supplied to the learned counsel for the appellant/defendant.
(Dr. VINEET KOTHARI), J.
DJ/9
Ravindra Singh
Abhinandan Prasad
Dr. Vineet Kothari
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
