The Single Judge allowed a challenge by a prisoner seeking release on parole. The State's reliance on residence and conviction by a foreign court made him ineligible under Thapar Rules. The court varied the earlier rejection of parole.
Parole petition allowed. A direction/direction of parole granted.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
1
एकलप�ठ स�व�ल प�र�ल ररट य�च�क� ��खय� 2673/2014 (त�ज��रस��ह बन�म र�जस��न र�जय) र�जस ��न उच � न य�य�लय, ज�धप%र।
--:: आ द� श ::--
(त�ज��रस��ह)
बन�म
(र�जस��न र�जय)
एकल प�ठ स�व�ल प�र�ल ररट य�च�क� ��खय� -2673/2014
प��;न� पत क� अ�ल�कन ककय� गय�। प��? क7 ओर �� प�म प�र�ल क� रप म: 20 दद�� क7 म��ग क7 गई ह�। प��;न� पत क� र�जय �रक�र क7 ओर �� ज��ब पसत%त ककय� गय� ह�, जज�क� प�र� ��खय�-3 म: अ�ककत ककय� गय� ह� कक �B�कक य��� अनय र�जय क� तन���� ह�, ऐ�� जस�तत म: उ�� प�र�ल क� ल�5 ददय� ज�न� क�नBनन ब�चधत
2
एकलप�ठ स�व�ल प�र�ल ररट य�च�क� ��खय� 2673/2014 (त�ज��रस��ह बन�म र�जस��न र�जय)
ह�। इ� कम म: तनयम 14 ए क� ह��ल� र�जय �रक�र क7
ओर �� ददय� गय� ह�, ज� तनमन पक�र ह� :
14. Ineligibility for release. - The following clauses of prisoners will ordinarily not be eligible for release on parole.
(a) Persons whose ordinary place of residence is outside the State of Rajasthan or who have been convicted by a court Martial or a Court of another State;
र�जय �रक�र क7 ओर �� पसत%त ज��ब म: य��� क� पत� Village Nagla Harji, PS Aantroli, District Aligarh (Uttar Pradesh) अ�ककत ककय� गय� ह�, जज�क� �म�;न म: क�न.0य क�र�गFह, उदयप%र क7 ओर �� ज�र0 क�ददयG क7 दहसH0 दटककट क7 पतत प�श क7 गई ह�, जज�म: 5� य��� क� उक पत� �रK;त ह�। अत: र�जय �रक�र क7 ओर �� पसत%त ज��ब म: अ�ककत तथयG क� �म�;न उक दसत���ज �� ह�त� ह�।
उपर�क क�नBन� जस�तत क� कम म: पसत%त ज��ब म: अ�ककत तथयG ए�� य��� क� अनय र�जय क� तन���� ह�न� क� तथय क� धय�न म: रखत� ह%ए यह प�र�ल प��;न� पत स��क�र य�गय नह0� प�य� ज�त� ह�।
पररK�मत: य��� क7 ओर �� पसत%त यह स�व�ल प�र�ल ररट य�च�क� ख�ररज क7 ज�त� ह�।
पद0प /-
2 issues framed by the court
Whether a prisoner convicted by a court of another state and whose residence is outside Rajasthan is eligible for parole under rule 14(a).
Whether the reasons for non-eligibility in the impugned order are correct.
1 provisions across 1 enactments
तजारीसूह बदरसूह बनम राजसूह राजय
राजसूह राजय
लॉक एसियाजक श द
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
