M/S Noble Chlorochem Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise & Anr.

Punjab & Haryana HC4 Sept 2014CEA/64/2014

Download

Case brief

from the order text

What is this about?

of 2014 -1- IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND…

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

M/S Noble Chlorochem Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Anr. — Punjab & Haryana HC (2014) — LawSathi Research

¶21

�� !? ��" $ �,!!.�% ��, � +! �0!"#$#�% �� +! �"�% ,�.!,$9 #%.�.!0��$�%�,,� !0�#%� +!��11!��-�9�)!�%� #"!0��+!��11!**�% �#$ !%8�8!0�#%�-�%3��" 3,!��%0�"!�,�%"!�� $$#3-��# �%� !��%� +! 9!�,��'E�5��($��/�13,"+�$!0��" �,9��%0��%0�$ �, !0�1,�03" #�%�� $$#3-�7##"� !��E:''��?�!��'EF��+!��11!�% �+#,!0�� 1�, #�%�#%� +!�.�"�% �1,!-#$!$��($��)!��"+!-��. ��/ 0��,-!,9 6%�?%��$��($��)!��#% ��%0��+!-#"�5��+#?�%#��%�,!% ��:��(> 1!,�-�% +�.#0!�!�$!�0!!0�0� !0��:��'':��%0�$3)$!@3!% �!�$!�0!!0 0� !0��'��'��+!��11!**�% �$! �31�# $�3%# �#%� +!�$�#0�1,!-#$!$�#% +!�9!�,��'':��%0�$ �, !0�1,�03" #�%��3-#%3-��+�,#0!�)9��) �#%#%8 ,!8#$ ,� #�%�"!, #�#"� !��%%!43,!��>��,�-��!% ,��4"#$!��!1�, -!% � ��?!.!,5 �03! � ��)B!" #�% �,�#$!0 �)9 � +! ��,9�%��3 #�% ��% ,� ��,05� +!��11!�% �$ �11!0�# $�1,�03" #�%�#%� +!�9!�,��'''�� !,� ?� 9!�,$5�# ��8�#%�$ �, !0�1,�03" #�%�� $$#3- ��# �%� !�#%� +!�$�#0 1,!-#$!$��7#%"!� +!��88,!8� !�.�3!��"!�,�%"!$�� +!��11!**�% 03,#%8� +!��#%�%"#��9!�,$��,�-��>�F� ��>��?�$�)!�?��",�,! �, ��;�",�,!$5�# �?�$�%� �,!@3#,!0� ��1�9�!4"#$!�03 9�#%� !,-$�� %� #�#"� #�% ��E(��:>��0� !0 ��:��: ��%%!43,! ��>:��%�, ,!8#$ ,� #�%�"!, #�#"� !�#%� !,-$��3!�'�� +!��!% ,���4"#$!��3!$5 ��,!�0 �?# + �%� #�#"� #�% �0� !0 ��%%!43,! ��>��% 13,$3�%"! � �� +! �%� #�#"� #�% �0� !0 ��%%!43,! ��>��5 � +! �11!�% �,!83�,9 ��#!0 �0!"�,� #�%$ ��$ ��%0 �?+!% � +!#, �$�! �.�3! !4"!!0!0 ��'���"$��% �,!$1�%$! � �� +! �! !, �0� !0 ��;�� ,!"!#.!0��,�-� +!��%8!�731!,#% !%0!% 5� +!��11!**�% �.#0!�! !,�0� !0 �'�� %%!43,! �>�� $3)-# !0 +! ,!@3#,!0 0�"3-!% $(#%��,-� #�%�#%"30#%8� +!�"�1#!$��8,�3%0�1�%��?!.!,5 03,#%8 � +! ��#%�%"#� �9!�, ��>��31 ��.!-)!,5 ��?+!% � +!

¶24

�88,!8� !�.�3!��"!�,�%"!�� $$#3-��# �%� !�!4"!!0!0 ��; ",�,!$5 � +! ��11!�% ��11*#!0 ��, �,!8#$ ,� #�% �!*!" ,�%#"�*9 ��%0 ,!8#$ ,� #�% �"!, #�#"� ! ��;;�G��?�$ �#$$3!0 �)9 � +! �!13 9��--#$$#�%!,5��#$�,��%� +!�)�$#$��"�19��11#"� #�%�#% ��,-��%0�� +!,�0�"3-!% $�$3)-# !0�)9� +!��11!�% 5� +!��%8! 731!,#% !%0!% ��%8�?# +��%��%$1!" �,�.#$# !0� +!��" �,9�1,!-#$!$�� +!��11!**�% ��%�E��3, +!,5�#%��,0!,� ��!4�-#%!� +!��0-#$$#)## 9 ��%� #�#"� #�%�0� !0��:��:��%%!43,!��>:�5� +!�"!% ,��!4"#$!�$ �� ,�- � +! ��#"! ��!13 9 ��--#$$#�%!,5 ��#$�, �.#$# !0 � +! ��" �,9 1,!-#$!$�� +!��11!�% ��%��%0��3%0� +� �)� +� +!�3%# $�� +! ��11!�% �?!,! ��3%" #�%#%8 �#% �$!1�,� ! �1,!-#$!$��""�,0#%895 ,!$1�%0!% ��#$$3!0��$+�?�"�3$!�%� #"!�0� !0�'��+! �11!�% �$3)-# !0 �,!19 � �� +! �$�#0 �$+�? �"�3$! �%� #"!��+! �0B30#"� #%8 ��3 +�,# 9 �.#0! ��,0!, �0� !0 ��E��: ��%%!43,! ��>F� "�%�#,-!0� +!�0!-�%0��E��"$��%0��$��#-1�$!0�1!%� 9��% !@3���-�3% ��%0�#% !,!$ ��!!#%8��88,#!.!05� +!��11!�% ��#!0��% �11!����%8�?# +�$ �9��11#"� #�%�)!��,!� +!��,#)3%���+!��,#)3%� .#0!��,0!,�0� !0�:��%%!43,!��>��0#,!" !0� +!��11!**�% � � 0!1�$# ��;C�� +!�03 9���%8�?# +�1,�1�, #�%� !�#% !,!$ ��!%"!5� +! 1,!$!% ��11!��

M/S Noble Chlorochem Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise & Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

M/S Noble Chlorochem Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise & Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Gurcharan Kaur Vs Commissioner of Income Taxk

Pawan Aggarwal Vs State of Haryana & Ors.

Commissioner of Income Tax Patiala Vs M/S State Bank of Patiala the Mall Patiala

M/S Jitco Overseas Projects Now Jop Power Infra Engg Ltd. Vs State of Haryana & Ors.

M/S Vanick Oils & Fats P Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs & Anr.

Babu Lal and Anr. Vs Union of India & Ors.