Disposed

Raghvendra Prasad v. The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Patna HC14 Jul 2014CWJC/6273/2013

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Single judge oral order disposing of four writ petitions filed by Assistant Teachers coordinating with a State agency. The court found the petitions infructuous after counter-affidavits showed new uniform guidelines had been implemented state-wide, defeating the respondents' liability. All applications were disposed of as infructuous.

What did the court decide?

Petitions disposed of as infructuous.

Raghvendra Prasad Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors. — Pension and Retirement Benefits | Patna HC (2014)

¶1

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6273 of 2013

¶3

====================================================== 1. Raghvendra Prasad S/O Ram Balak Singh Resident Of VillageMuradpur, P.O. And P.S.- Mahua, Dist.- Vaishali

¶4

.... .... Petitioner/s

¶5

Versus

¶6

1. The State Of Bihar, Through District Magistrate Vaishali At Hajipur 2. The District Magistrate Vaishali At Hajipur

¶7

The District Superintendent Of Education, Vaishali At Hajipur 4. The District Program Officer-Cum-District Program Coordinator, Vaishali At Hajipur 5. The Block Education Officer, Mahua, Dist.- Vaishali

¶8

.... .... Respondent/s

¶9

====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.9407 of 2013

¶10

====================================================== 1. Arun Kumar S/O Sri Kamal Singh Resident Of Village- BisunpurTraura, P.S. Mahua, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Govt. Basic School, Loma, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶11

Suresh Prasad Singh S/O Late Shivjee Prasad Singh Resident Of VillageKurai Bujurg, P.S.- Gangabridge, (Hajipur), Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Rahimapur, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist- Vaishali, And By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶12

Ramchandra Ram S/O Late Bisheshwar Ram Resident Of VillageGatehabad, P.S.- Hajipur-Sadar, Dist- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher-Primary School, Chack-Sultan, Ps- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, And By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶13

Bijendra Prasad Singh S/O Late Ramkisun Singh Resident Of VillageDilawarpur, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Shitalpur, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶14

Kamlesh Kumar Chaudhary S/O Jagan Chaudhary Resident Of VillageJadhua, P.S.- Town (Hajipur), Dist.- Vaishali Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Khilbat, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶15

Rajeshwar Rai S/O Late Ram Uchit Rai Resident Of Village- Bariyarpur, P.S.- Rajapakar, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher-Midle School- Kakrata, P.S.- Mahua, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶16

Shiv Prasad Rai S/O Late Mahendra Rai Resident Of Village- Bariyarpur, P.S.- Rajapakar, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Middle School Chandpura, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶17

Rajeshwar Rai S/O Ramkeshu Prasad Resident Of Village- Jadhua, P.S.Hajipur (Town), Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher-Midle School Gobindpur-Bajitpur, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶18

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶19

Muneshwar Prasad Rai S/O Jamun Rai Resident Of Village- Shyampur Dayal, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Techer- Amer, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶20

Birendra Ram S/O Late Jamun Ram Resident Of Village- Mohanpur, P.S.- Bidupur Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Utkramit Middle School- Dhabauli-North, P.S.- Bidupur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶21

Janmejai Kumar Singh S/O Sri Jitendra Kumar Singh Resident Of Village- Chachnasir, P.S.- Patepur, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher-Utkramit Middle School, Chacknasir, P.S.- Patepur, Dist.Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶22

Mukund Kumar Singh S/O Late Birendra Prasad Singh Resident Of Village- Sherpur-Bahori, P.S.- Mahua, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Middle School Rampur Kadutand, P.S.- Mahua, Dist.Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶23

Anil Kumar Pankaj S/O Late Bhola Rai Resident Of VillageKishanpura, P.S. And Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Utkramit Midle School- Khajatta, P.S.- Lalganj, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶24

Ramnath Sah S/O Chhthu Sah Resident Of Village- Rahimpur, P.S. And Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher-Utkramit Midle SchoolJalalpur Harijantola, P.S.- Lalganj, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶25

Garibnath Thakur S/O Gurudayal Thakur Resident Of VillageNauwachack, P.S.- Patepur, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant TeacherUtkramit Midle School- Nauwachack, P.S.- Patepur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶26

Mukesh Kumar Paswan S/O Satya Narayan Paswan Resident Of Village- Gobindpur-Bela, P.S.- Baligawn, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Utkramit Midle School, Gobindpur-Bela, P.S.- Baligawn, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶27

Ranjeet Kumar S/O Sathu Rai Resident Of Village- Sukki, P.S.Patepur, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Techaer-Primary School Chhapra, P.S.- Patepur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator 18. Shiv Shankar Kumar S/O Late Dhanu Sah Resident Of VillageJhamman-Ganj, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Middle School Chhapra, P.S.- Patepur, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶28

Md. Maqbool Aalam Ansari S/O Late Abdul Hai Resident Of VillageJandaha, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Primary School Shekhpura (Urdu), P.S.- Mahnar, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶29

Ajay Kumar S/O Late Janardan Rai Resident Of Village- LawapurNarayan, P.S.- Mahnar, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Utkramit Midle School, Bathnaha, P.S.- Mahnar, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶30

Laxman Ram S/O Shiv Narayan Ram Resident Of Village- Rampur, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Middle School Nari-Khurd, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶31

Rajesh Kumar S/O Late Sakaldeo Rai Resident Of Village- Rohua, P.S.Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Midle School

¶32

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶33

Rasalpur, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶34

Ramrup Prasad S/O Jagdeo Mahto Resident Of Village- Mahjidpur, P.S.- Manpur, Dist.- Nalanda, Posted As A Assistant Teacher Primary School (Sanskrit), Jandaha, P.S.- Jandaha, Dist.- Vaishali, By Now Working As A Coordinator

¶35

.... .... Petitioner/s

¶36

Versus

¶37

The State Of Bihar, Through The District Magistrate Vaishali At Hajipur

¶38

The District Magistrate Vaishali At Hajipur

¶39

The Selection Committee, Block Calestral Resources Center, Vaishali At Hajipur Through Its Chairman

¶40

The District Education Officer, Vaishali At Hajipur

¶41

The District Program Officer-Cum-District Program Coordinator, Vaishali At Hajipur

¶42

.... .... Respondent/s

¶43

======================================================

¶44

with

¶45

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.11231 of 2013

¶46

======================================================

¶47

Sanjeev Kumar Mishra S/O Late Ram Sundar Mishra Posted As A Assistant Teacher Govt Middle School, Sugaon, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran, By Now Workin As A Block Resources Person (Brc), Sogauli, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran

¶48

Manoj Kumar S/O - Amar Nath Singh Posted As Assistant Teacher, Govt Primary School, Kanchhedawa, P.S. Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A -Block Resources Person (Brc) Harsidhi, P.S. - Harsidhi, Dist East Champaran

¶49

Kumari Onam Singh W/O Nawal Kishore Singh Posted As A Assistant Teacher Govt Middle School, Sugauli (Girls), P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brc), Sugauli, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran

¶50

Satyadeo Prasad S/O Sri Lakshaman Prasad Ray Posted As A Assistant Teacher Govt Primary School, Kanunia, P.S. - Adapur, Dist - East Champaran , And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brc), Adapur, P.S. - Adapur, Dist - East Champaran

¶51

Pramod Mishra S/O Late Chandrama Mishra Posted As A Assistant Teacher Utkramit Middle School, Bagaha, P.S - Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Coordinator, Govt Basic School , Kritpur - Mathia, P.S. - Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran

¶52

Pramod Prasad S/O Rosan Prasad Posted As A Assistant Teacher,, Utkramit Middle School, Jogirahan, P.S. - Turkaulia, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brc), Turkaulia, P.S. - Turkaulia, Dist - East Champaran

¶53

Ashoka Kumar Mishra S/O Shivnath Mishra Posted As A Assistant Teacher Govt Middle School , Ramgarhwa (Girls), P.S - Ramgarhwa , Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Coordinator Govt. Middle School, Ramgarhwa (Boys), P.S. - Ramgarhwa, Dist - East Champaran

¶54

Sitaram Prasad S/O Babulal Prasad Posted As A Assistant Teacher

¶55

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶56

Utkramit Middle School, Sisawania (Urdu), P.S. - Banjaria, Dist - East Champaran , And By Now Working As A Coordinator , Govt Middle School, Jatwa (Urdu), P.S. - Banjaria, Dist - East Champaran

¶57

Niraj Kumar Sharma S/O Late Chandrashekhar Prasd Singh Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Kapoor- Pakari, P.S. - Chairaiya, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Coordinator Govt. Middle School, Sirawan, P.S. - Chiraiya, Dist - East Champaran

¶58

Dharmanath Das S/O Bhola Das Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Dhakoha Bala Tola, P.S. - Motihari , Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Coordinator Govt Middle School, Dhakoha, P.S. - Motihari, Dist - East Champaran

¶59

Madan Chaudhary S/O Late Raghunath Chaudhary Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Nakardei, Urdu, P.S. - Suhauli, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Workin As A Coordinator, Govt Middle School, Karamawa - Raghunathpur, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran

¶60

Shashi Bhushan Gaurn S/O Panna Lal Prasad Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Bangra - Sarahri, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Coordinator , Govt.Middle School, Supawar, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran

¶61

Bir Baitha S/O Late Channa Baitha Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Middle School, Kauwaha, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Coordinator, Govt Middle School, Chhagaraham P.S - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran

¶62

Shiva Sharma S/O Gaya Sharma Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Shiswa (Hindi), P.S. - Banjaria, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Coordinator, Govt Middle School, Siswa (Urdu), P.S. - Banjaria, Dist - East Champaran

¶63

Prabhu Nath Prasad S/O Ganga Prasad Yadav Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Middle School, Mali, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Coordinator, Govt Middle School, Mali, P.S. - Sugauli, Dist - East Champaran

¶64

Rajendra Thakur S/O Late Baidhnath Thakur Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Middle School, Mehta Tola, P.S. - Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Coordinator, Govt Middle School, Lakshamarwa - Pipra, P.S. - Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran

¶65

Sunil Kumar Srivastawa S/O Late Raghaw Prasad Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Middle School, Paithanpatti (Urdu), P.S. - Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Coordinator , Govt Middle School, Bhada (Boys), P.S. - Harsidhi, Dist - East Champaran 18. Birendra Kumar Singh S/O Late Nagnarayan Singh Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Middle School, Pipra (Girls), P.S. - Chakiya, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brc) Chakiya, P.S. - Chakiya, Dist - East Champaran

¶66

Sunil Kumar Srivastava S/O Late Lalan Prasad Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Bhartuiya, P.S - Chakiya, Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brc) Chakiya, P.S - Chakiya, Dist - East Champaran

¶67

Umesh Kumar Sharma S/O Madan Lal Thakur Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Sirasia - Maharani, P.S. - Chakiya, Dist - East Champaran , And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brp) Chakiya, P.S. - Chakiya, Dist - East Champaran

¶68

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶69

Kailash Prasad Gupta S/O Late Shivadani Sah Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Fatehpur - Parsaunia, P.S. - Mehasi, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brp) Mehasi, P.S. - Mehasi, Dist - East Champaran

¶70

Sunita Kumari W/O Laxman Paswan Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Primary School, Mathia, P.S. - Mehasi, Dist - East Champaran, And By Now Working As A Block Resources Person (Brc), Mehasi, P.S. - Mehasi, Dist - East Champaran

¶71

Sujit Kumar Singh S/O Vindhyachal Singh Posted As A Assistant Teacher, Govt Middle School, Fulawar, P.S. - Babjariya, Dist - East Champaran And By Now Working As A Coordinator, Govt Middle School , Fulawar, P.S. - Banjariya, Dist - East Champaran

¶72

.... .... Petitioner/s

¶73

Versus

¶74

The State Of Bihar , Through The District Magistrate East Champaran At Motihari

¶75

The Bihar Education Project Council, Shiksha Bhawan, Rastrabhasha Parisad Parisar, Saidpur, Rajendra Nagar, Patna - 800004

¶76

The District Magistrate, East Champaran At Motihari

¶77

The Principal District Teachers Training College, East Champaran At Motihari Cum Chairman, Selection Committee, Block Calestral Resources Center / Block Resources Person , East Champaran At Motihari (Deat)

¶78

The District Education Officer, East Champaran At Motihari

¶79

The District Program Officer-Cum-District Program Coordinator, East Champaran At Motihari

¶80

.... .... Respondent/s

¶81

======================================================

¶82

with

¶83

Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.3964 of 2013

¶84

======================================================

¶85

Arun Kumar S/o Sri Kamal Singh resident of village- Bisunpur- Traura, P.S- Mahua, Distt- Vaishali, Posted as a assistant teacher Govt. Basic School Loma, P .S- Jandaha, Distt- Vaishali, By now working as a coordinator.

¶86

Ramchandra Ram s/o Late Bisheshwar Ram resident of villageFatehabad, P.S- Hajipur- Sadar, Distt- Vaishali, posted as a assistant teacher- Primary School, Chack, Sultan, P.S- Bidupur, Distt- Vaishali, and by now working as a coordinator.

¶87

Bijendra Prasad Singh S/o Late Ramkisun Singh resident of villageDilawarpur, P.S- Bidupur, Distt- Vaishali, Posted as Assistant teacher, Utkramit Middle school, Shitalpur, P.S- Bidupur, Distt- Vaishali By now working as a coordinator.

¶88

Kamlesh Kumar Chaudhary S/o Jagan Chaudhary resident of villageJadhua, P.S- Town ( Hajipur), Distt- Vaishali posted as an assistant teacher, Utkramit Middle School, Khilbat, P.S- Bidupur, Distt- Vaishali by now working as a coordinator.

¶89

Rajeshwar Rai S/o Late Ram Uchit Rai resident of village- Bariyarpur, P.S- Rajapakar, Distt- Vaishali, posted as an assistant teacher Middle School Kakrata, P.S- Mahua, Distt- Vaishali by now working as a coordinator

¶90

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶91

Birendra Ram S/o Late Jamun Ram resident of village- Mohanur, P.SBidupur, Distt- Vaishali, posted a an assistant teacher Utkramit Middle School Dhabauli- north, P.S- Bidupur, Distt- Vaishai, by now working as a coordinator

¶92

Janmejai Kumar Singh S/o Sri Jitendra Kumar Singh resident of villageChacknasir, P.S- Patepur, Distt- Vaishali, posted as an assistant teacher Utkramit Middle School, Chacknasir, P.S- Patepur, Distt- Vaishali, by now working as a coordinator.

¶93

Mukund Kumar Singh s/o Late Birendra Prasad Singh resident of villageSherpur Bahori, P.S- Mahua, Distt- Vaishali, posted as an assistant teacher Middle School Rampur Kadutand, P.S- Mahua, Distt- Vaishali by now working as a coordinator.

¶94

Garibnath Thakur S/o Gurudayal Thakur resident of village Nauwachack, P.S- Patepur, Distt- Vaishali, posted as an assistant teacher Utkramit Middle School Nauwachack, P.S- Patepur, Distt- Vaishali, by now working as a coordinator.

¶95

Laxman Ram S/o Shiv Narayan Ram resident of village Rampur, P.SJandaha, Distt- Vaishali, posted as an assistant teacher, Middle School, Nari Khurd, P.S- Jandaha, Distt- Vaishali, by now working as a coordinator.

¶96

Ramrup Prasad s/o Jagdeo Mahto resident of village Mahjidpur, P.SManpur, Distt- Nalanda, posted as an assistant teacher Primary School (Sanskrit), Jandaha, P.S- Jandaha, Distt- Vaishali by now working as coordinator

¶97

.... .... Petitioner/s

¶98

Versus

¶99

The State of Bihar, through the District Magistrate Vaishali at Hajipur namely Sri Jitendra Srivastava

¶100

Kanchan Mala Shankar D/o Late Indira Shankar, The Chairman, Selection Committee, Block Calestral resources Centre, Vaishali at Hajipur ( D.I.E.T) 3. Sri Shashi Bhushan Rai S/o not known The District Education Officer, Vaishali at Hajipur.

¶101

Sri Premchand S/o not known the District Program Officer cum District Program coordinator, Vaishali at Hajipur.

¶102

.... .... Respondent/s

¶103

====================================================== Appearance : (In CWJC No.6273 of 2013) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Mahendra Thakur, Adv. For the State : Mr.Utsav Kumar, AC to GA-11 For BEPC : Mr. Girijesh Kumar, Adv. (In CWJC No.9407 of 2013) For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Mahendra Thakur, Adv. For the Intervener : Mr. P.N.Pathak, Adv. For BEPC : Mr. Girijesh Kumar, Adv. (In CWJC No.11231 of 2013) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Mahendra Thakur, Adv. For the State : Mr.Sunil Kumar Mandal, SC-24 Mr.Arjun Prasad, AC to SC-24 For BEPC : Mr. Girijesh Kumar, Adv.

¶104

Patna High Court CWJC No.6273 of 2013 (5) dt.14-07-2014

¶105

(In MJC No.3964 of 2013) For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Mahendra Thakur For the Respondent/s : Mr. S.D. Sanjay

¶106

====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JAYANANDAN SINGH ORAL ORDER

¶107

5 14-07-2014

¶108

In view of the statements made in the counter affidavit by the respondents that the engagement of Coordinators is being done in all the districts of the State uniformally on the basis of the new government guidelines, the petitioners have no case.

¶109

In the circumstances, these writ applications have

¶110

become infructuous. The same are disposed of as such.

¶111

(Jayanandan Singh, J)

¶112

Arvind/-

¶113

Raghvendra Prasad v. The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Raghvendra Prasad v. The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Deepa Kumari Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Arbind Sharma Vs The Bihar Agriculture University and Ors.

Sansar Devi Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Sunaina Yadav @ Sunayana Yadav Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Arun Kumar and Ors. Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors.

Md. Seraj Ahmad and Anr. Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors.