Allowed

M/S.Prasad Productions (P) Ltd. v. the Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution

Madras HC9 Feb 2024WP/2984/2024

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Writ petitions filed by commercial consumers seeking revision of electricity bills for lockdown periods. Court extended benefit of earlier orders in W.P.No.7678 of 2020, directing TANGEDCO to revise bills applying Supply Code regulations and adjust excess charges. Petitions disposed.

What did the court decide?

Directions issued to TANGEDCO to revise bills for lockdown periods, apply Supply Code regulations, and adjust excess charges.

M/S.Prasad Productions (P) Ltd. Vs the Tamil Nadu… — Service and Employment | Madras HC (2024)

¶1

2024:MHC:6304

¶2

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶3

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

¶4

DATED: 09.02.2024

¶5

CORAM :

¶6

THE HONOURABLE DR.JUSTICE ANITA SUMANTH

¶7

W.P.Nos. 2984, 2985 & 2987 of 2024

¶8

W.P.No.2984 of 2024

¶9

M/s.Prasad Productions (P) Ltd., No.28, Arunachalam Road, Saligramam, Chennai – 600 093. Rep. by its Authorized Signatory, M.S.Bhaskar

¶10

.. Petitioner

¶11

¶12

1.Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited, (TANGEDCO) Rep. by its Chairman / Managing Director, 10^th Floor, No.144, Anna salai, Chennai - 02.

¶13

2.The Chief Financial Controller – Revenue, TANGEDCO, 7^th Floor, 144, Anna Salai, Chennai – 600 002.

¶14

3.The Superintending Engineer, TANGEDCO, Chennai South – 1, Electricity Distribution Circle, Chennai – 78. .. Respondents

¶15

W.P.No.2985 of 2024

¶16

Bossco Steel Industries P Ltd., S.F.No.1415/IA,IB,IC,

¶17

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶18

1/8

¶19

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶20

Arcot to Tindivanam Road, Chakkaramallur Village, Arcot Taluk, Ranipet – 632 511 Rep. by its Authorized Signatory, K.Shanmugam

¶21

.. Petitioner

¶22

¶23

1.Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited, (TANGEDCO) Rep. by its Chairman / Managing Director, 10^th Floor, No.144, Anna salai, Chennai - 02. 2.The Chief Financial Controller – Revenue, TANGEDCO, 7^th Floor, 144, Anna Salai, Chennai – 600 002. 3.The Superintending Engineer, TANGEDCO, Vellore Electricity Distribution Circle / North, Vellore.

¶24

.. Respondents

¶25

W.P.No.2987 of 2024

¶26

M/s.Prasad Film Laboratories, No.58, Arunachalam Road, Saligramam, Chennai – 600 093. Rep. by its Authorized Signatory, M.S.Bhaskar vs

¶27

.. Petitioner

¶28

1.Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited, (TANGEDCO) Rep. by its Chairman / Managing Director, 10^th Floor, No.144, Anna salai, Chennai - 02. 2.The Chief Financial Controller – Revenue,

¶29

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶30

2/8

¶31

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶32

TANGEDCO, 7^th Floor, 144, Anna Salai, Chennai – 600 002.

¶33

3.The Superintending Engineer, TANGEDCO, Chennai South – 1, Electricity Distribution Circle, Chennai – 78. .. Respondents

¶34

Prayer in W.P.Nos.2984, 2985 & 2987 of 2024 : Petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to issue a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to extend the benefit of the order of this Court dated 14.08.2020 in W.P.No.7678 of 2020 in a similar batch matter and to apply the order of this Court as per Article 14 of the Constitution of India, to the petitioner also and consequently direct the 1^st and 2^nd respondents to cause to issue the fresh CC Bills for the month of April, 2020 falling in the lockdown periods as per the above order dated 14.08.2020 and also, to further direct the respondents to refund/ adjust the excessively collected demand charges from the petitioner during the lockdown period.

¶35

In all W.P.'s For Petitioner : Mr.S.P.Parthasarathy For Respondents : Mr.D.R.Arun Kumar Standing Counsel

¶36

COMMON ORDER

¶37

Mr.S.P.Parthasarathy, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner

¶38

produces copy of order passed in W.P.No.31379 of 2023 dated 02.11.2023, which he states is applicable on all fours to the present matters. Mr.D.R.Arun Kumar, learned standing counsel, on instructions, would accede to the aforesaid submission.

¶39

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶40

3/8

¶41

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶42

In the interests of the clarity, the entirety of order dated

¶43

02.11.2023, which in turn, makes references to earlier orders, is extracted

¶44

below:-

¶45

Ms.Keerthana Shenoi, learned counsel on behalf of Mr.L.Jai Venkatesh, learned Standing Counsel accepts notice for the respondents and concurs with the submission of the petitioner to the effect that the issue that arises for resolution in this Writ petition stands covered by an order passed by this Court on 28.04.2022 in W.P.Nos.10774, 10777 and 10779 of 2022.

¶46

2. The prayer of the petitioner is for a mandamus directing the respondents to extend the benefit of order dated 19.04.2022 and 28.04.2022 and direct the 2^nd respondent i.e., Deputy Financial Controller, TANGEDCO to issue fresh current consumption details (CC details) for the months of April 2020 to July 2020 and May 2021 to July 2021 which stands covered by the period of lock down imposed with regard to HT Service connection No. 099094000552 provided at premises Nos. 85 & 86, Arcot Road, Karambakkam, Porur, Chennai – 600 116 and the petitioner has also sought a direction to the respondents to re-work the bills of HT Service No. 099094000552 and adjust any excess amount that had been collected as against the future demands.

¶47

3. A similar prayer has been raised by the petitioner in W.P.Nos.10774, 10777 and 10779 of 2022 and that Writ petitions had come to be disposed in light of the order passed in W.P.No.2384 of 2023 on 09.02.2022, in the following terms:

¶48

?......

¶49

2. The petitioner seeks a mandamus directing the respondents to extend the benefit of order dated 14.08.2020 passed by this Court in W.P.No.7678 of 2020 to the petitioner and consequently direct the third respondent to revise and issue fresh consumption bills in respect of the petitioner-s service connection for the periods when the establishment was under lockdown consequential to Government Orders.

¶50

3. The petitioner has approached this Court earlier in W.P.No.19906 of 2020 seeking an identical prayer. That Writ Petition has come to be allowed on 04.01.2021 following the ratio laid down in W.P.No.7678 of 2020 and

¶51

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶52

4/8

¶53

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶54

applying the same to this petitioner as well. The relevant portion of the order reads as follows:

¶55

-The Hon-ble High Court of Madras has passed an order on 14.08.2020 in W.P.No.7678 of 2020 and others batch and the operative portion of the order is reproduced below:

¶56

?45.....

¶57

a)TANGEDCO shall issue a revised bill to the petitioners by applying Regulation 6(b) of the Supply Code for the entire period when the establishment was under shut down;

¶58

b)If TANGEDCO has already recovered the entire dues from any of the petitioners, the bill shall be reworked in accordance with the direction given in Clause (a) and the excess amount shall be adjusted towards the future bills; c)If the demand made by TANGEDCO has been adjusted from the security deposit and any of the petitioner has been asked to pay any amount towards additional security deposit on that count, the said claim shall be withdrawn forthwith and the calculation of the additional security deposit shall be independently done under Regulation 5 of the Supply Code and demand/adjustment shall be done in accordance with the said Regulation;

¶59

d)The TANGEDCO shall not levy compensation charges towards low PF from the petitioners during the period of lockdown. Even if such levy is made in future, show cause notice shall be issued to the consumer and an opportunity shall be given to the consumer before levying any compensation under Clause 6.1.1.6 of the Tariff Regulation;

¶60

e)If any amount has already been recovered towards levy of compensation charges for low PF from any of the petitioners, the said amount shall be adjusted towards future bills.

¶61

f)These directions will apply only for the period during which the establishment was under total lockdown due to the orders issued by the Government and it is made clear that it pertains only to the Minimum Charges payable under Regulation 6(b) of the Supply Code and there is no

¶62

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶63

5/8

¶64

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶65

exemption or concession insofar as the charges payable for the actual consumption of electricity (Energy Charges); and

¶66

g)If any of the establishments continue to be under lockdown due to the Government Orders passed in this regard, the minimum charges alone shall be collected till the lifting of the lockdown.

¶67

46.All the writ petitions are accordingly allowed...? 3.0 However, TANGEDCO has filed appeals against the above order vide W.A.No.836 of 2020 and etc. before the Hon-ble Divison Bench of Madras High Court and the appeals are yet to be heard. Hence, the Superintending Engineer/EDCs are instructed to implement the above order scrupulously without prejudice to the outcome of appeal filed as stated above. The above order may be implemented only to the petitioners and also to those who have obtained similar order in this matter.

¶68

(By order of the JMD/TANGEDCO)

¶69

Sd/~dated 16.10.2020

¶70

Chief Financial Controller/Revenue?

¶71

4. In addition, I have in an order dated 28.04.2020 passed in W.P.Nos.9642, 9644 and 9646 of 2022 also stated as follows:-

¶72

'4. Though the aforesaid order passed on 04.01.2021 would, in my view, suffice to protect the interests of the petitioner for the subsequent periods as well, since the prayer therein was for protection in respect of all periods falling under lockdown consequential to Government Orders, learned counsel for the petitioner would seek a specific direction in respect of the periods of lockdown from 2021 onwards.

¶73

5. Thus the benefit of the aforesaid order stands extended for the periods commencing from 01.04.2020 as well when the establishment was under lockdown pursuant to Government Orders passed in this regard.

¶74

6. In light of the admitted facts and legal position as between the aforesaid Writ Petition and the present Writ Petitions, the same order is taken to be passed in these Writ Petitions as well. '

¶75

5. In light of the admitted identity in facts and circumstances

¶76

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶77

6/8

¶78

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶79

between those matters and the present matter, the benefit of that order is available to the present petitioner as well.

¶80

6. This Writ petition is disposed accepting the request as set out in

¶81

the Writ Petition. No costs.

¶82

These Writ petitions are disposed in the terms of the above

¶83

orders. No costs.

¶84

09.02.2024

¶85

Index:Yes/No Neutral Citation:Yes mpl

¶86

¶87

1.The Chairman / Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited, (TANGEDCO) 10^th Floor, No.144, Anna salai, Chennai - 02.

¶88

2.The Chief Financial Controller – Revenue, TANGEDCO,

¶89

7^th Floor, 144, Anna Salai, Chennai – 600 002.

¶90

3.The Superintending Engineer, TANGEDCO, Chennai South – 1, Electricity Distribution Circle, Chennai – 78.

¶91

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶92

7/8

¶93

W.P.No.2984 of 2024 etc

¶94

DR. ANITA SUMANTH,J. mpl

¶95

4.The Superintending Engineer, TANGEDCO, Vellore Electricity Distribution Circle / North, Vellore.

¶96

W.P.Nos.2984, 2985 & 2987 of 2024

¶97

09.02.2024

¶98

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶99

8/8

M/S.Prasad Productions (P) Ltd. v. the Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

M/S.Prasad Productions (P) Ltd. v. the Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Volleyball Federation of India Vs Secretary to Government

Dr.B.Aashika Vs the State of Tamil Nadu

S.Sumanth Ram Vs the Commissioner of Geology and Mining

Clara Vs the Chairman

R.Indirakumari Vs the Principal Secretary to Government

M/S.S.K.L.Exports Vs the Chairman