file of the learned Sub Court, Tiruchirappalli, to set aside the above orders of the Commissioner as well as the Deputy Commissioner of HR & CE Department. The learned trial Judge, after considering the evidence and documents, declared that distribution of Panagam and Vadaparuppu during Pagal and Rapathu festival at Four Pillars Mandapam, Naalukettan Entrance in the plaintiff temple during the Vaigunda Egadasi Festival day and also perform the 'Ashtothra Archana' daily to the plaintiff idol are religious charities and also declared some of the other endowments as religious charities and some of them as private charities. Aggrieved over the same, appeal suit in A.S.No.216 of 1959 was filed before this Court. This Court, upon re-appreciation of evidence both oral and documents, held that the performance of Rapathu and Pagal Pathu Ubayams during the Vaigunda Egadasi is religious charity and the same was enforceable one. After that, one of the descendant, Madhusoodhanan filed a suit in O.S.No.319 of 2007 on the file of the learned District Munsif, Kulithalai for declaration that the resolution has passed by the descendants of the grandson of the executant as illegal and void and allow him to perform the Ubayamas as private charities of Ramasamy Rao in the temples situated at K.Patti village situated far away place of plantiff’s temple without impleading the plaintiff temple. In the said suit, they entered into compromise and the first
