Disposed

Mather Projects v. Tahsildar,Kanayannur Taluk & Another

Kerala HC8 Mar 2007WP(C)/2325/2007

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court observed that the appellate authority under the Kerala Building Tax Act must not be guided by extraneous government letters and should hear individual flat owners. The court directed that the pendency period be excluded for limitation calculations.

What did the court decide?

Directing the appellate authority to ignore Ext.P8 and Ext.P9, hear individual flat owners, and exclude writ pendency from limitation period.

Mather Projects Vs Tahsildar,Kanayannur Taluk… — Civil Procedure and Limitation | Kerala HC (2007)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶2

PRESENT :

¶3

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.BALAKRISHNAN NAIR

¶4

THURSDAY, THE 8TH MARCH 2007 / 17TH PHALGUNA 1928

¶5

WP(C).No. 2325 of 2007(B)

¶6

-----------------------------------

¶7

PETITIONER:

¶8

------------------

¶9

M/S.MATHER PROJECTS, ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE AT KODIYATT CHAMBERS, RAJAJI ROAD, COCHIN- 682035, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, K.I.MOHAMED RAFFI MATHER.

¶10

BY ADV. SRI.K.I.MAYANKUTTY MATHER

¶11

RESPONDENTS:

¶12

----------------------

¶13

1. TAHSILDAR, KANAYANNUR TALUK, ERNAKULAM.

¶14

2. RAVIKUMAR, SREEPADAM, KARULLIL HOUSE, IRUMPANAM- 682309.

¶15

3. K.C.CHACKO, KANNATH HOUSE, PERUMANNOOR DESOM, THEVERA, KOCHI-13.

¶16

4. BINOY MATHEW, APARTMENT NO.1C, WHITE WATERS, THEVERA, KOCHI.

¶17

5. P.J.CHERIAN, ZUBAIR GENERAL TRADING, P.O.BOX 60808, DUBAI.

¶18

6. ROMAL JAYACHANDRAN, P.O.BOX NO.6472, DOHA,QATAR.

¶19

7. JAYAKUMAR VERMA, P.O.BOX NO.41807, ABUDHABI, U.A.E.

¶20

8. NEENA ANTONY, P.B.NO.O8703, AL-RAJA POLY CLINIC, DUBAI.

¶21

WP(C).No. 2325 of 2007(B)

¶22

9. A.K.MOHAMMAD, PREMIER TOOLS AND HARDWARE MART, P.B.NO.3266, KOCHI.

¶23

10. SEBASTIAN JOSEPH, APARTMENT NO.2C, WHITE WATERS, THEVARA, KOCHI.

¶24

11. K.C.CYRIAC, 114 KHATARI BAGH, NAVAL BASE P.O., KOCHI-4.

¶25

12. E.M.NAJEEB,

¶26

AIR TRAVEL ENTERPRISES INTERNATIONAL LTD., NEW CORPORATION BUILDING, TRIVANDRUM.

¶27

13. PAUL PRAVEEN WILSON, HOFDIJK 493417, XE MONTFORT NETHERLANDS.

¶28

14. RADHAKRILSHNAN, APARTMENT NO.3C, WHITE WATERS, KOCHI.

¶29

15. MR.MATHEWS MATHEW, P.B.NO.2168, 1180 ED, AMSTELVEEN, NETHERLANDS.

¶30

16. JOSEPH EDATTLE, GRUEZEN STR- 56,8600, DUBENDORF, SWITZERLAND.

¶31

17. K.S.VIJAYACHANDRAN, P.B.NO.9381, AHMADI, KUWAIT.

¶32

18. R.J.ROY, APARTMENT NO.4B, WHITE WATERS, KOCHI.

¶33

19. SUNNY THOMAS, APARTMENT NO.4C, WHITE WATERS, KOCHI.

¶34

20. P.X.JOSEPH, APARTMENT NO.4D, WHITE WATERS KOCHI.

¶35

21. THANKACHAN THOMAS, APARTMENT NO.4F WHITE WATERS, KOCHI.

¶36

22. SUNIL JOSEPH, APARTMENT NO.5A, WHITEWATERS KOCHI.

¶37

23. PONNOOSE MATHEW,

¶38

P.B.NO.239, UMM-AL-QUIWAN, U.A.E.

¶39

24. ABBAS ALI MOHAMMAD,

¶40

P.B.NO.31675, ABUDHABI, U.A.E.

¶41

WP(C).No. 2325 of 2007(B)

¶42

25. M.V.SASIDHARAN, P.B.NO.3366, DUBAI.

¶43

26. C.M.SAGEER, P.B.NO.25913, SHARJAH, U.A.E.

¶44

27. ANAS KARUVALLY, P.B.NO.6302, DUBAI.

¶45

28. ZIAUDIN, P.B.NO.5815 ABQAIQ, ARAMCO, SAUDI.

¶46

29. MERCY ALEXANDER, CALSERSTONES, WESTELLA ROAD, WESTELLA, HULL, HU 10, 7SD.

¶47

30. HARIS IBRAHIM, CITY PETROLS, WEST HILL, CALICUT.

¶48

31. M.J.LOUIS, JOSE ELECTRICALS, 8/8A,9/9A, P.T.USHA ROAD, KOCHI-11.

¶49

32. MR.G.HARIKRISHNAN, P.B.NO.412, BEHRAIN.

¶50

33. NOUSHEEN RASHID, C/O.ABDUL AZIZ SAIT, YESRUB, CHERUPARAMBATH ROAD, ERNAKULAM.

¶51

34. SHALEEN AZIZ, C/O.ABDUL AZIZ SAIT, YESRUB, CHERUPARAMBATH ROAD, ERNAKULAM.

¶52

35. STANLY MATHEW, P.B.NO.33098, DUBAI, UAE.

¶53

36. SHEELA PRINCE, APARTMENT NO.51/A RIVIERA RETREAT, THEVERA, KOCHI.

¶54

37. SURESH BABU, P.B.NO.52172, DUBAI.

¶55

38. MOIDEEN PADIYATH, P.B.NO.4411, CENTUARY AUTO, PARTS, DEIRA, DUBAI.

¶56

39. SOYA MEERAN, APARTMENT NO.8 A, WHITE WATERS, KOCHI.

¶57

40. N.V.POULOSE, P.B.NO.591, UMM-AL QUWAIN, UAE.

¶58

41. ABDUL RAHIM ISMAIL, NATIONAL COMMERCIAL BANK, 21ST FLOOR, P.B.NO.20566, JEDDAH.

¶59

42. P.K.GOPAKUMAR, A/404, BIRCHWOOD, POWAI, MUMBAI-400076.

¶60

43. JACOB T.ALEX, PB NO.26936, DUBAI, UAE.

¶61

44. ALATHAF ISMAIL, 14/1570, CHULLICKAL, KOCHI-5.

¶62

45. LAILA JACOB, CA 74, 7TH FLOOR, RIVIERA RETEREAT, THEVERA, KOCHI.

¶63

46. D.K.SUMANGALAN, O.P.Q.L. PB NO.22611, DOHA, QATAR.

¶64

47. CDR.MATHEW, G 255, 2ND FLOOR, PANAMPILLY NAGAR, KOCHI-36.

¶65

48. RAVINDRAN K.KOROTH, 601, LANSDOWNE WAY, T2 NORWOOD, MA 02062, USA.

¶66

49. MOHAN DAS, PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, TRIVANDRUM.

¶67

50. MOHAMMAD FIROZ KHAN, P.B.NO.3367, AJMAN, UAE.

¶68

51. ANTONY JOB, INDIAN EMPORIUM, 2/77 CLAVETTY ROAD, KOCHI-01.

¶69

52. P.K.M.BASHEER, P.B.NO.1721, SAFAT 13018, KUWAIT.

¶70

53. S.G.NAIR, EDEN BUNGLOWS, HIRANANDANI GARDENS, AS ROAD, POWAI, MUMBAI.

¶71

54. ABDUL AZIZ MATHER, 8, MEADOW BANK, WATFORDHERTS, WD 194 NP, UK.

¶72

55. C.M.BASHEER, P.B.NO.601, UMM-AL QUIWAN, UAE.

¶73

56. ANWAR SAIT, ADNAN 14/4 A, CHULLICKAL, KOCHI-05.

¶74

57. P.K.R.MENON, BADRALAYAM, SANSKRIT COLLEGE ROAD, TRIPUNITHURA.

¶75

58. ASHOK PILLAI, P.B.NO.33098, DUBAI, UAE.

¶76

59. AZEEM A.SAIT, J-3, JAWAHAR NAGAR, TRIVANDRUM-695041.

¶77

60. FAHEEM ABOOBACKER SAIT, J-3, JAWAHAR NAGAR, TRIVANDRUM-695041.

¶78

61. K.RAMACHANDRAN, C/O.EVEREADY BATTERIES LTD., P.B.NO.9231, DUBAI, UAE.

¶79

62. DIVYA THOMAS, APARTMENT NO.12A, WHITE WATERS, THEVARA P.O., KOCHI.

¶80

63. REJITH PAUL, APARTMENT NO.12 D, WHITE WATERS, THEVERA KOCHI.

¶81

64. SATHI DEVI KANDOTH, P.B.NO.22669, SHARJAH, DUBAI.

¶82

65. LEKHA VISWANATH, CHITHIRA HOUSE, MAVELIKKARA, ALLEPPEY- 690107.

¶83

66. GEORGE M.GEORGE, PENT HOUSE 13-14 A, WHITE WATERS, THEVERA P.O., KOCHI.

¶84

67. RAZHA KHAN, P.B.NO.7349, DOHA, QATAR.

¶85

68. ANTONY K.DEVASSY, 13405 OAKWOOD, CT, HOMERGLEN, II60491.

¶86

69. MADHAVAN, PENT HOUSE 13-14 D, WHITE WATERS, THEVERA, KOCHI.

¶87

70. PETER POULOSE VALETH, 3RD FLOOR, VACHAMANARE, NO.27, KASTHURBA NAGAR, CHENNAI.

¶88

WP(C).No. 2325 of 2007(B)

¶89

71. SUSEELA NAMBIAR, 202, KRISHNA KUNJ, GOKULAM, FILM CITY ROAD, MUMBAI.

¶90

BY ADV. SRI.BEPIN VIJAYAN SMT.S.LAKSHMY GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI. MUHAMMED RAFFI

¶91

THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 08/03/2007, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶92

WP(C) NO: 2325/2007 B

¶93

APPENDIX

¶94

PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS

¶95

EXT.P1. COPY OF ONE AGREEMENT FOR SALE OF UNDIVIDED INTEREST IN THE LAND AND FOR CONSTRUCTION OF APARTMENTS DT. 8/9/04.

¶96

EXT.P2. COPY OF THE ABLE CONTAINING THE PARTICULARS OF NAMES OF THE ALLOTEES, AREASOF THE FLATS AND THE PARTICULARS OF THE PAYMENTS.

¶97

EXT.P3. COPY OF THE SALE DEED EVIDENCING THE ASSIGNMENT OF PROPORTIONATE UNDIVIDED INTEREST IN THE LAND 29/11/2005.

¶98

EXT.P4. COPY OF THE PROPERTY TAX RECEIPT IN RESPECT OF THE APRTMENT DT. 19/6/06.

¶99

EXT.P5. COPY OF THE MEMO ISSUED BY THE CORPORATION REGARDING CHANGE OF REGISTRY DT. 21/6/2006.

¶100

EXT.P6. COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE R1 DT. 30/10/2006.

¶101

EXT.P6A. COPY OF THE ASSESSMENT ORDER IN FROM NO. 5 DT. 30/10/2006.

¶102

EXT.P6B. COPY OF THE DEMAND NOTICE IN FORM NO. 6 DT. 30/10/2006.

¶103

EXT.P7. COPY OF THE CHEQUE EVIDENCING THE REMITTANCE OF RS. 3,55,882/- DT. 30/11/2006.

¶104

EXT.P7A. COPY OF THE CHEQUE EVIDENCING THE REMITTANCE OF RS. 1,49,768/- DT. 30/11/2006.

¶105

EXT.P8. COPY OF THE GOVERNMENT LETTER DT. 28/4/92.

¶106

EXT.P9. COPY OF THE GOVT. LETTER DT. 28/4/92.

¶107

EXT.P10. COPY OF THE RETURN SUBMITTED BY AN ALLOTTEE.

¶108

True copy

¶109

tga

¶110

K.BALAKRISHNAN NAIR, J.

¶111

W.P.(C).No.2325 of 2007-B

¶112

Dated this the 8^th day of March, 2007

¶113

JUDGMENT

¶114

The petitioner challenges Exts.P6 (a) assessment order under the Kerala Building Tax Act and Ext.P6 (b) demand notice issued pursuant to it. Against those orders, the petitioner has got a right of appeal before the appellate authority. It may invoke the same. The period this writ petition was pending before this Court shall be excluded while computing the period of limitation in filing the appeal. It is ordered that the appellate authority while deciding the appeal will not be guided or influenced by Ext.P8 or Ext.P9. The Government have no power to issue any direction to the appellate authority which is discharging a quasi-judicial function. The appellate authority shall go only by the materials placed and the submissions made before it.

¶115

The building tax will ultimately be a charge on the building constructed. So, the ultimate owner will be liable to pay the same if others neglect to pay it. But, in the case of buildings of this nature, the liability to pay tax depend upon the terms of the contract entered into between the parties. The individual flat owners are definitely interested persons. So,they shall also be heard by the appellate authority before final orders are passed. The interim order granted by

¶116

WPC 2325/2007

¶117

¶118

this Court will remain in force for a further period of one month from today.

¶119

The Writ Petition is disposed of as above.

¶120

K.BALAKRISHNAN NAIR, JUDGE.

¶121

Mather Projects v. Tahsildar,Kanayannur Taluk & Another

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Mather Projects v. Tahsildar,Kanayannur Taluk & Another

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Ksrtc Vs Rta,Kottayam

Ksrtc Vs Rta.,Kottayam

Sri.Abdul Azeez Vs the R.T.a., Wayanad

Ksrtc Rep. by Its Md. Vs the Rta

Parackal Distributors Vs the State of Kerala

M/S. Venus Sales Corporation Vs the State of Kerala