State Vs Bishan Singh — Himachal Pradesh HC (2024) — LawSathi Research

State Vs Bishan Singh — Himachal Pradesh HC (2024) — LawSathi Research

What the court decided

AI extract

Outcome

Release of the enhanced amount of compensation, along with proportionate interest, in favour of each applicant-claimant as per her/his share recorded at pages 209/219/336 of the paper book, to be remitted to the bank account detailed in Paragraph-2 of each application, subject to proper verification of identity; all eight applications stand disposed of.

Issue for consideration

Whether the miscellaneous applications (CMP Nos.10206 and 10208-10214 of 2024) filed by the claimants should be allowed so that the enhanced amount of compensation, along with proportionate interest, is released to each applicant as per her/his recorded share.

Ratio / Principle

With no further appeal pending before the Hon'ble Apex Court against the decided RFA No.8 of 2012, CMP No.10206/2024 was allowed: the enhanced compensation with proportionate interest is to be released to the applicant as per her share (pages 209/219/336 of the paper book), remitted to the bank account given in Paragraph-2 of the application subject to proper verification of her identity; application disposed of.

Key takeaways

With no further appeal pending before the Hon'ble Apex Court against the decided RFA No.8 of 2012, CMP No.10208/2024 was allowed: the enhanced compensation with proportionate interest is to be released to the applicant as per his share (pages 209/219/336 of the paper book), remitted to the bank account given in Paragraph-2 of the application subject to verification of identity; application disposed of.ratio¶¶12
With no further appeal pending before the Hon'ble Apex Court against the decided RFA No.8 of 2012, CMP No.10209/2024 was allowed: the enhanced compensation with proportionate interest is to be released to the applicant as per his share (pages 209/219/336 of the paper book), remitted to the bank account given in Paragraph-2 of the application subject to proper verification of his identity; application disposed of.ratio¶¶18

Detailed headnote1 paragraphs

State of HP and others v. Bishan Singh and others, RFA No.8 of 2012 (order dated 04.07.2024, Bipin C. Negi, J.). Eight miscellaneous applications by the claimants - CMP Nos.10206 and 10208 to 10214 of 2024 - were allowed on the strength of the recital that the RFA judgment (recited as decided on 03.12.2013 at ¶7 and as 03.12.2023 in the CMP sections) had drawn no further appeal before the Hon'ble Apex Court. In each case the enhanced amount of compensation, along with proportionate interest, was ordered released to the applicant as per her/his share recorded at pages 209/219/336 of the paper book, to be remitted to the bank account given in Paragraph-2 of the application, subject to proper verification of identity; each application stands disposed of. No reply was intended from the non-applicants/appellants (State). No statute or precedent is cited and no monetary figure appears in the text.