Disposed

Sh S Makhu and 22 Ors. v. Sh. Lalnunmawia Chuaungo, Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram and 7 Ors.

Gauhati HC24 Apr 2023I.A.(Civil)/41/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The Gauhati High Court granted an adjournment to the respondents to file a reply to a writ petition after learning that the jurisdiction of the Chief Engineer (BRTF) was altered and the amount payable to petitioners requires recalculation. The matter is to be listed after the ensuing vacation.

What did the court decide?

Adjourning the matter immediately after the ensuing vacation to allow the respondents to file a show-cause reply.

Sh S Makhu and 22 Ors. Vs Sh… — Constitutional and Fundamental Rights | Gauhati HC (2023)

¶1

Page No.# 1/41

¶2

GAHC030004222019

¶3

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

¶4

Case No. : Cont.Cas(C)/16/2019

¶5

S Makhu and 22 Ors. S/o S.Helei, R/o Zawngling, Saiha District, 2: C Beibiahneisa Zawngling Saiha District

¶6

3: L C Luabei Zawngling Saiha District

¶7

4: J Pathaisa Zawngling Saiha Distric

¶8

VERSUS

¶9

Lalnunmawia Chuaungo and 10 Ors. Chief Secretary to Govt of Mizoram, Aizawl 2:Bhupesh Chaudhury Chief Secretary to Govt of Mizoram Aizawl

¶10

3:Brig. Birender SIngh Chief Engineer Project Pushpak C/o 99 APO

¶11

4:MN Ansari Executive Engineer Officer Commanding 71 RCC BRTF C/o 99 APO

¶12

5:P Sama Executive Engineer MADC

¶13

Page No.# 2/41

¶14

SIaha

¶15

6:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Land Revenue and Settlement Department MADC Siaha District 7:Sh.MANV Prasad Chief Engineer Project Pushpak 8:Sh H.Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha 9:Sh.S.P.Kolipey Chief Engineer Project Pushpak 10:Sh.Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha 11:Sh V.L.Hruaizela Khiangte Deputy Commissioner Siaha Disrrict Siaha Mizora

¶16

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr. Lalfakawma

¶17

Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte

¶18

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/34/2022 VT Zecharia and 73 Ors. Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶19

Page No.# 3/41

¶20

VERSUS Subhash Sharma and 8 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board Sena Bhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi

¶21

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R4 & R8

¶22

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/53/2024 C.Viatha and 37 Ors. S/o Haihmo (L) Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶23

VERSUS

¶24

Sh Subhash Sharma and 7 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi-110010

¶25

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte

¶26

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/46/2022

¶27

Sh. C. Viatha and 37 Ors. Tipa 'V' Tuipang Mizoram

¶28

Page No.# 4/41

¶29

VERSUS

¶30

Sh. Subhash Sharma and 4 Ors. Sena Bhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi

¶31

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent :

¶32

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/150/2024

¶33

S.Makhu and 22 Ors. S/o S.Helei R/o Zawngling Saiha District Mizoram

¶34

VERSUS

¶35

Sh Lalnunmawia Chuaungo and 9 Ors. Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram

¶36

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr Lalfakawma Advocate for the Respondent :

¶37

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/145/2024

¶38

L.Sachai and 29 Ors. S/o L.Vetu Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram

¶39

VERSUS

¶40

Sh Subhash Sharma and 13 Ors. lSecretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB)

¶41

Page No.# 5/41

¶42

SenaBhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi-110010

¶43

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mrs. Linda L Fambawl

¶44

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/100/2024

¶45

S.Makhu and 22 Ors. S/o S.Helei R/o Zawngling Saiha District Mizoram

¶46

VERSUS

¶47

Sh Lalnunmawia Chuaungo and 9 Ors. Chief Secretary toe the Govt. of Mizoram Aizawl

¶48

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr Lalfakawma Advocate for the Respondent :

¶49

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/41/2023

¶50

Sh S Makhu and 22 Ors. S/o S Helei R/o Zawngling Saiha District

¶51

2: Sh Beibiahneisa S/o C Laihra R/o Zawngling Siaha District VERSUS

¶52

Sh. Lalnunmawia Chuaungo Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram and 7 Ors. Aizawl

¶53

Page No.# 6/41

¶54

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr Lalfakawma Advocate for the Respondent : Mr B Lalramenga for R6

¶55

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/47/2024 Abednago and 16 Ors. S/o C.Beirahma Tuipang-796911 Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 11 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi-110010

¶56

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte

¶57

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/52/2023 Abednago and 16 Ors. Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram VERSUS

¶58

Sh Subhash Sharma and 11 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan Wing New Delhi - 110010

¶59

Page No.# 7/41

¶60

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R4 R7 - R9

¶61

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/31/2019

¶62

Abednago and 16 Ors. Tuipang Mizoram 2: F Lalhmunsanga Tuipang Mizoram 3: TT Vasti Tuipang Mizoram 4: Hezi Tuipang Mizoram 5: Lawche Tuipang Mizoram VERSUS

¶63

Subhash Sharma and 13 Ors. Sena Bhawan B Wing New Delhi 2:Manv Prasad The Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF c/o 99 APO

¶64

3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary to the Government of Mizora Land Revenue and Settlement Department Aizawl 4:Bhupesh Chaudhury The Deputy Commissioner Siaha District

¶65

Page No.# 8/41

¶66

Siaha-796901

¶67

5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha-796901

¶68

6:Sh P.N. Yadav Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF

¶69

7:Sh R Zarzosanga Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Govt. of Mizoram 8:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner SiahaDistrict

¶70

9:Sh lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District 10:Sh Pheiki Solo Sr. Revenue Officer MADC Siaha 11:Sh S.P. Kolipey Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF

¶71

12:Sh Lalhmunsanga hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District

¶72

13:Smt Nazee Khaila Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous Districct Council Siaha District Miaoram 14:Sh V.L.Hruaizela Khiangte Deputy Commissioner

¶73

Page No.# 9/41

¶74

Siaha District Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Mrs Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte (Addl.AG/G.A. Mizoram) for R4 R7

¶75

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/46/2024

¶76

L.Sachai and 29 Ors. S/o L.Vetu Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram

¶77

VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 12 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi-110010

¶78

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte

¶79

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/21/2019 Sh. L Sachai and 29 Ors Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 2: LC Valaw Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 3: B Beizi Zawngling

¶80

Page No.# 10/41

¶81

Tuipang Mizoram 4: Mala Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram

¶82

5: LC Khaikhei Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram VERSUS

¶83

Sh. Subhash Sharma and 14 Ors Sena Bhavan B-wing New Delhi

¶84

2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF C/o 99APO

¶85

3:R Lalramnghaka

¶86

Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram

¶87

4:Bhupesh Chaudary

¶88

Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram

¶89

5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha

¶90

6:Sh Manv Prasad

¶91

Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶92

7:Sh R.Zarzosanga

¶93

Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Dept. Aizawl

¶94

Page No.# 11/41

¶95

8:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶96

9:Sh P.N.Yadav Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶97

10:Sh Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District. Mizoram

¶98

11:Sh Pheiki Solo Senior Revenue Officer MADC Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶99

12:Sh S.P.Kolipey Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶100

13:Sh Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶101

14:Smt Nazee Khaila Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha District Mizoram

¶102

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mr. P C Lalthangmawia for R14

¶103

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/16/2021

¶104

VT Zecharia

¶105

Page No.# 12/41

¶106

Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram

¶107

2: V Hrachhia Siatlai Tuipang Mizoram

¶108

3: S Pawla Tuipang Mizoram

¶109

4: Lalhruaia Tuipang Mizoram

¶110

5: B Chale Tuipang Mizoram

¶111

6: V Hrachhia Siatlai Siaha District Mizoram

¶112

7: S Pawla Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram

¶113

8: Lalhruaia Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram

¶114

9: B Chale Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram

¶115

10: Ngochhua Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS

¶116

Subash Sharma

¶117

Page No.# 13/41

¶118

Sena Bhawan B Wing New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh The Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force New Delhi 3:H Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Dept Govt. of Mizoram Aizawl Mizoram 4:Bupesh Chaudhary The Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram Aizawl Mizoram 5:Brig Birender Singh Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 6:R Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Dept. Govt of Mizoram Aizawl Mizoram 7:Bupesh Chaudhury The Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha Mizoram 8:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinary T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mr C Zoramchhana

¶119

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/142/2024

¶120

C.Viatha and 37 Ors.

¶121

Page No.# 14/41

¶122

S/o Haihmo (L) Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶123

VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 8 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) SenaBhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi-110010

¶124

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mrs. Linda L Fambawl

¶125

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/41/2022

¶126

Sh. S. Makhu and 22 Ors. Zawngling Mizoram VERSUS

¶127

Sh. Lalnunmawia Chuaungo and 6 Ors. Aizawl Mizoram

¶128

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr Lalfakawma Advocate for the Respondent :

¶129

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/159/2022

¶130

Sh. Abednago and 16 Ors. Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram

¶131

Page No.# 15/41

¶132

2: Sh. F. Lalhmunsanga Siaha District Mizoram

¶133

3: Sh. T.T. Vasti Siaha District Mizoram 4: Sh. Hezi Siaha District Mizoram

¶134

5: Sh. Lawche Siaha District Mizoram

¶135

6: Sh. T.T. Vakhai Siaha District Mizoram

¶136

7: Sh. Numi Siaha District Mizoram

¶137

8: Sh. C. Beirahnia Siaha District Mizoram

¶138

9: Sh. Betheli Siaha District Mizoram

¶139

10: Sh. Moses Siaha District Mizoram

¶140

11: Sh. Lilipawngia Siaha District Mizoram

¶141

12: Sh. Richard C. Vabeipathai Siaha District Mizoram

¶142

13: Sh. C. Beirapathai Siaha District Mizoram

¶143

Page No.# 16/41

¶144

14: SH. Itle Siaha District Mizoram 15: Sh. V. Beimokha Siaha District Mizoram 16: Sh. T.T. Babeikhaisia Siaha District Mizoram 17: Sh. Dennis K. Vabeikhaisia Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh. Subhash Sharma and 8 Ors. New Delhi

¶145

2:Sh. Manv Prasad Chief Engineer BRTF New Delhi

¶146

3:Sh. R. Lalramnghaka Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Department Aizawl

¶147

4:Sh. Bhupesh Chaudhury DC Siaha District Siaha

¶148

5:Sh. N. Pachhunga Sr. Revenue Officer MADC Siaha 6:Sh. P.N. Yadav. Chief Engineer BRTF New Delhi

¶149

7:Sh. R. Zarzoranga Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Department

¶150

Page No.# 17/41

¶151

Aizawl 8:Sh. Kesavan R DC Siaha District Mizoram Siaha 9:Sh. Lalsangliana DC Siaha District Siaha Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms Zairemsangpuii CGC for R2 & R6

¶152

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/24/2021

¶153

L Sachai and 29 Ors. Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 2: LC Valaw Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 3: B Beizi Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram VERSUS Subhash Sharma and 7 Ors. Sena Bhavan B-wing New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF C/o 99APO 3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary

¶154

Page No.# 18/41

¶155

Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinary T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent :

¶156

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/24/2019 VT Zecharia and 73 Ors Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 2: V Hrachhia Siatlai Tuipang 3: S Pawla Tuipang Mizoram 4: Lalhruaia Tuipang Mizoram 5: B Chale Zawngling Mizoram VERSUS

¶157

Subhash Sharma and 13 Ors Sena Bhavan B wing New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF C/o 99APO

¶158

3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram 4:Bhupesh Chaudary Deputy Commissioner

¶159

Page No.# 19/41

¶160

Siaha District Mizoram

¶161

5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha

¶162

6:MANV Prasad Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶163

7:Sh R.Zarzosanga

¶164

Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land revenue and Settlement Dept. Aizawl

¶165

8:Sh Kesalan R

¶166

Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Siaha 9:Sh P.N.Yadav Chief Engineer BRTF Projecr Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶167

10:Sh Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Siaha

¶168

11:Sh Pheiki Solo Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Dist. Mizoram 12:Sh S.P.Kolipey S.E. (Civil) Chief Enginer Border road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶169

Page No.# 20/41

¶170

13:Sh Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Siaha 14:Smt. Nazee Khaila Sr.Revenue Officer MADC Siaha District. 15:Sh V.L.Hruaizela Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms Zairemsangpuii

¶171

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/19/2023

¶172

VT Zecharia Substituted by Smt VT Lalramengzeliand 73 Ors. S/o V.Hedo Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram 2: V.Hrachhia S/o V.Hedo Siatlai Siaha District Mizoram 3: S.Pawla S/o S.Lailei Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram 4: Lalhruaia S/o Vanhmingthanga Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram 5: B.Chale

¶173

Page No.# 21/41

¶174

S/o B.Beizi Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 6: Ngochhua S/o Huchho Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 7: Liani S/o Bili Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶175

8: C.Vabeizi S/o C.Ako Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶176

9: C.Rahlu S/o Tlaso Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶177

10: B.Chasia S/o B.Hedo Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶178

11: V.Laihlao S/o V.Hlado Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶179

12: K.Malsawmdawngkima S/o K.Ngailua Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶180

13: C.Nohei

¶181

Page No.# 22/41

¶182

S/o C.Chhohu Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶183

14: AZ Zawngia S/o Khuapho Siaha Dist. Mizoram 15: S.Vathlie S/o S.Thasi Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶184

16: S.Thacho S/o S.Laikhei Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 17: L.Beirangia S/o Dako Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶185

18: S.Rahlu S/o S.Ngiakhaw Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 19: S.Viatlo S/o S.Chhahlei Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 20: V.Chabi S/o Taido Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 21: C.Pachi S/o C.Pathaw

¶186

Page No.# 23/41

¶187

Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 22: V.Lalhlao S/o V.Hlado Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶188

23: N.Lalthanmawia S/o N.Lalhrao Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 24: Melody D/o HT.Beichi Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶189

25: HT Laltlanzauva S/o HT Beichi Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶190

26: B.Beizi S/o Leiphyu Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 27: P.Sawthly S/o S.Chholei Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 28: LC Valaw S/o Atu Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 29: LD Beinaisa S/o Kheko

¶191

Page No.# 24/41

¶192

Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶193

30: ST Maipha S/o ST Philip Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶194

31: L.Khutha S/o Liahmo Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶195

32: HC.Chhuasa S/o Seitu Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶196

33: K.Nothlei S/o GC Bithei Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶197

34: S.Vanlalhruaia S/o S.Zaluaia Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 35: Adi S/o Sibala Siatlai Siaha District Mizoram

¶198

36: Bitlai S/o C.Chhihno Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶199

37: Nunemi

¶200

Page No.# 25/41

¶201

D/o A.Khuapho Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 38: Beimopathai S/o Molei Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 39: L.Varo S/o Hrehrua Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram 40: Andreas Bohla S/o B.Tlabu Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram 41: S.Ahaza S/o ST Selua Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 42: B.Madili D/o C.Bitlai Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram 43: S.Beirapha S/o V.Palua Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶202

44: ST Nixon S/o S.Chhobi Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶203

45: B.Tlabu

¶204

Page No.# 26/41

¶205

S/o Valai Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram 46: Hesa S/o Beitlo Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 47: TT.Khusa S/o T.Laizel Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 48: S.Pailei S/o Chhochai (L) Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶206

49: TT.Zahmo S/o T.Abela Siaha Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶207

50: KT Beikhokhei S/o KT Mako Siaha Siaha Dist. Mizoram 51: Tlochha S/o Laichho Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 52: L.Meka S/o Lawkhe Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 53: LD. Beiphasa S/o Kheko

¶208

Page No.# 27/41

¶209

Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶210

54: HT Lawmkima S/o HT Sibala Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 55: M.Sama S/o Hrehlaw Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶211

56: M.Assiara S/o M.Maldai Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶212

57: S.Phosia S/o S.Pasa Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶213

58: C.Lawchhi S/o C.Hruatu Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶214

59: S.Sawma S/o S.Chhochai Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶215

60: C.Khochhua S/o C.Ako Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 61: Hredo S/o Hei-ei

¶216

Page No.# 28/41

¶217

Zawngling Siaha Dist. Mizoram 62: Vabeihrakhai S/o L.Laina Siatlai Siaha Dist. Mizoram 63: B.Tevo S/o Kolai Siaha Siaha Dist Mizoram 64: S.Ngiado S/o S.Machi Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 65: B.Pheihra S/o B.Taima Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 66: L.Tlahlo S/o Ito Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 67: Lalchhuakmawia S/o C.Thangkhuma Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶218

68: K.Vanlalmghaki D/o K.Nahlei Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶219

69: J.Sipa

¶220

Page No.# 29/41

¶221

S/o J.Chhiakhei Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 70: T.Van-upa S/o T.Chhia-ena(L) Siaha Siaha Dist. Mizoram

¶222

71: S.Lalramzawna S/o S.Pawla Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 72: ST.Rosa S/o C.Hloma (L) Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 73: N.Jelly D/o N.Thahla Tuipang Siaha Dist. Mizoram 74: ML.Rammawia S/o JFM. Sanga Siaha Siaha Dist. Mizoram VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 9 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan B Wing New Delhi-110010

¶223

2:Brig. Birender Singh The Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶224

Page No.# 30/41

¶225

3:Sh R.Lalramnghaka

¶226

Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Dept. Aizawl

¶227

4:Sh Bhupesh Chaudhury The Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha

¶228

5:Sh N.Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram

¶229

6:MANV Prasad Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶230

7:Sh R.Zarzosanga Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Deprt.

¶231

8:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner Siaha District 9:Sh P.N.Yadav Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶232

10:Sh Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R4 R8 & R10

¶233

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/43/2022

¶234

L.Sachai and 29 Ors.

¶235

Page No.# 31/41

¶236

Zawngling Mizoram VERSUS Subhash Sharma and 8 Ors. Sona Bhavan 'B' Wing N.Delhi

¶237

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms Zairemsangpuii (CGC) for R2 R6 & R9

¶238

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/25/2023 Sh. L. Sachai and 29 Ors. Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh. Subash Sharma and 9 Ors. New Delhi Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mrs. Linda L Fambawl for R7

¶239

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/34/2023 C.Viatha and 37 Ors. S/o Haihmo (L) Tipa V Siaha Dist. Mizoram VERSUS

¶240

Page No.# 32/41

¶241

Sh Subhash Sharma and 6 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan B Wing New Delhi - 110010

¶242

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R4 & R6

¶243

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/134/2022 Sh. VT Zecharia and 73 Ors. Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram 2: Sh. V. Hrachhia Siatlai Siaha 3: Sh. S. Pawla Tuipang Siaha District Aizawl 4: Sh. Lalhruaia Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram 5: Sh. B. Chale Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh. Subhash Sharma and 9 Ors. New Delhi 2:Brig. Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak Aizawl

¶244

Page No.# 33/41

¶245

3:Sh. R. Lalramnghaka Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Deptt. Aizawl 4:Sh. Bhupesh Chaudhury Deputy Commissioner Siaha Siaha 5:Sh. N. Pachhunga Sr. Revenue Officer MADC Siaha Mizoram

¶246

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent :

¶247

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/56/2022

¶248

Sh. Abednago and 16 Ors. Tuipang Siaha District Mizoram

¶249

VERSUS

¶250

Subhash Sharma and 7 Ors. Sena Bhavan 'B' Wing New Delhi

¶251

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R4 & R8

¶252

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/23/2021

¶253

C. Viatha and 37 Ors. Tipa V Siaha District

¶254

Page No.# 34/41

¶255

Mizoram

¶256

2: Atu Chozah Tipa D Siaha District Mizoram 3: Beihu Nohro Tipa D Siaha District Mizoram 4: S. Rahlu Tipa V Siaha District Mizoram 5: C Vepaw Zyhno Siaha District Mizoram

¶257

6: S. Ngodei Tipa V Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS

¶258

Subhash Sharma Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) and 9 Ors. SenaBhavan B Wing New Delhi

¶259

2:Sh. P. N. Yadav The Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶260

3:Sh. R. Zarzosanga Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Department Aizawl

¶261

4:Sh. Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner

¶262

Page No.# 35/41

¶263

Siaha District Siaha

¶264

5:Sh. Pheki Solo Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha

¶265

6:Sh. Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha 7:Sh S.P.Kolipey SE (Civ) The Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO

¶266

8:Sh Lalhmunsanga Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Siaha Mizoram

¶267

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mr. P C Lalthangmawia for R9

¶268

Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/166/2022

¶269

Viatha and 37 Ors. Tipa 'V' Siaha Siaha District Mizoram 2: Atu Chozah Tipa 'D' Siaha Mizoram 3: Beihu Nohro S/o N.Lai-ih Tipa 'D' Siaha District Mizoram

¶270

Page No.# 36/41

¶271

4: S.Rahlu S/o S.Nhiakhaw Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶272

5: C.Vepaw S/o C.Houtu Zyhno Siaha District Mizoram

¶273

6: Sh. Ngodei Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶274

7: Sh. Lallungmuana Hrahu Sh. B. Rinawma Tipa Siaha District Mizoram

¶275

8: Sh. B. Rinmawia Tipa Siaha District Mizoram

¶276

9: Sh. S. Paima Tisih Siaha District Mizoram

¶277

10: Sh. Vanlalngheta Tipa Siaha District Mizoram

¶278

11: Sh. K. Ra-u Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶279

12: Sh. L.C. Valaw Zyhno Siaha District Mizoram

¶280

13: Sh. Felix Byhnarona Solo

¶281

Page No.# 37/41

¶282

Siaha Siaha District Mizoram

¶283

14: Sh. V. Ringmuana College Vaih Siaha District Siaha Mizoram

¶284

15: Sh. N. Phohlo Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶285

16: Smt. Ch. Remsiami Tipa Siaha District Mizoram

¶286

17: Sh. N. Seizah Tisi Siaha 18: Smt. Engkimi Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶287

19: Smt. B. Lalramliani Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶288

20: Sh. K. Jarome Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶289

21: Sh. Z. Vangia Theiri Siaha District Mizoram

¶290

22: Sh. K. Ria-uh Tipa Siaha District Mizoram

¶291

Page No.# 38/41

¶292

23: Smt. Zadami Tipa Siaha District Mizoram

¶293

24: Sh. C. Zebadi Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶294

25: Sh. N. Sakha Tipa 'D' Siaha District Mizoram

¶295

26: Sh. N. Molua Tipa 'D' Siaha District Mizoram

¶296

27: Sh. S. Khulai Tisi Siaha District Mizoram

¶297

28: Sh. Z. Beihroly Saikoa Siaha District Mizoram

¶298

29: Sh. Ngophia Siaha Siaha District Mizoram

¶299

30: Sh. NG Hema Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶300

31: Sh. N.C. Makho Siaha Siaha District Mizoram 32: Smt. Zingmawii Tipa

¶301

Page No.# 39/41

¶302

Siaha District Mizoram

¶303

33: Sh. Lalengliana Tipa Siaha District Mizoram 34: Sh.MC Sahmo Vahia Siaha District Mizoram 35: Sh. K. Hichhau Chapi Siaha District Mizoram

¶304

36: Smt. Vanlallianzuali Tipa 'D' Siaha District Mizoram

¶305

37: Sh. C. Zesi Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram

¶306

38: Sh. C. Lawsi Chhaihlo Tipa 'V' Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 5 Ors. Secretary Border roads Development Board (BRDB) SenaBhavan 'B' Wing N.Delhi-110010 2:Sh P N Yadav Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF c/o 99 APO

¶307

Page No.# 40/41

¶308

3:Sh R.Zarzosanga

¶309

Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Dept. Aizawl Mizoram

¶310

4:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha Mizoram

¶311

5:Sh Pheiki Solo Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram

¶312

6:Sh Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha Mizoram

¶313

Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte (Addl.AG/G.A. Mizoram) for R1-R3

¶314

B E F O R E

¶315

HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MARLI VANKUNG ORDER

¶316

Date : 01.04.2025

¶317

Mr. Lalfakawma, learned counsel for the petitioner is present along with

¶318

Mrs. Mary L. Khiangte, learned Govt. Advocate appearing for the newly

¶319

impleaded D.C, Siaha along with Mrs. Zairemsangpuii, learned counsel for respondent Nos. 3, 7 & 9/BRTF.

¶320

Page No.# 41/41

¶321

The learned counsel for the respondent/D.C, Saiha submits that she may

¶322

be given further time to file their show cause reply since there is new development, wherein, the respondents are yet to ascertain the amount still to be paid to the petitioners by adjusting the amount already received by the petitioners.

¶323

In view of the above submission, list the matter immediately after the

¶324

ensuing Vacation .

¶325

JUDGE

¶326

Comparing Assistant

Sh S Makhu and 22 Ors. v. Sh. Lalnunmawia Chuaungo, Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram and 7 Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Sh S Makhu and 22 Ors. v. Sh. Lalnunmawia Chuaungo, Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram and 7 Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

M/S Sree Maa Multi Kitchen and Restaurant Vs Assam Power Distribution Company Limited and 4 Ors.

Chandra Dhar Teron Vs the State of Assam and 6 Ors.

Md. Abdul Kader Vs the State of Assam and 6 Ors.

Rochhunga and 20 Ors. Vs State of Mizoram and 4 Ors.

S.T.Beichhuasia and 42 Ors. Vs Sh Bhupesh Chaudhury and 2 Ors.

C. Lalramchhana @G. Lalramchhana Vs The State of Mizoram