A petitioners withdrew an interlocutory application. The court granted permission and dismissed the application. The connected PIL was listed for future hearing.
Permission granted to withdraw the interlocutory application; application dismissed as withdrawn.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010092412022
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/1424/2022
SRI RAHMAT ALI AND 40 ORS S/O ABDUL HAMID ALI
10: IJAR ALI S/O MOTLEB ALI
12: ESAF ALI
Page No.# 2/14
S/O TALEB ALI
13: MOINUL HAQUE S/O ABDUL RASHID
14: HANIF ALI S/O KHALIL ALI
15: SMTI JAYEDA KHATUN W/O EASF ALI
16: AFSAR ALI S/O SABED ALI
17: SAHED ALI S/O HAMID
18: IBRAHIM S/O JAYNAL
19: SMT MAHILA BEGUM W/O JUNAB ALI
20: AYUB ALI S/O ASMAT HAJI
21: MOQBUL HUSAIN S/O PURA SHEIKH
22: SIDDIQUE ALI S/O SIYANET HAJI
23: MOTLEB ALI S/O ABDUL HAMID
24: FULURUDDIN S/O SOJU SHEIKH
25: GAJIUR RAHMAN S/O AJGAR ALI
26: KUDDUS ALI S/O SAIDULLA
27: MOSLEMUDIN S/O SAIFUDDIN
28: HAJRAT ALI
Page No.# 3/14
S/O SAITULLA
29: AFSAR ALI S/O MUNTAJ ALI
30: JAHAR ALI S/O NUR HUSSAIN 31: BAJID MUSTAFA S/O ABED ALI
32: IKRAMUL S/O MOTLEB
33: JUNAB ALI S/O AFAJUDDIN
34: SAIBOR HAQUE S/O NAJIRUDDIN
35: SADEK ALI S/O ABDUL HAMID
36: SMT SAHERA KHATUN W/O ABDUL HAMID
37: ASMAT ALI S/O MUNTAJ ALI
38: ABED ALI S/O MUNTAJ ALI
39: MD. SALAM S/O SOFU SHEIKH
40: SAHIDAR S/O MOSLEM ALI
41: ISA HAQUE S/O ABDUL HUSSAIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-78411 VERSUS
Page No.# 4/14
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 RS REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY, JANATA BHAWAN, DISPUR, GUWAHATI, ASSAM, PIN-781006
2:THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM REVENUE AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM F BLOCK 1ST FLOOR ASSAM SECRETARIAT (CIVIL) DISPUR GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN-781006 3:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE ASSAM ASSAM POLICE HEADQUARTERS ULUBARI GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN-781007 4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER DARRANG MANGALDOI ASSAM PIN-784125 5:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE DARRANG MANGALDOI ASSAM PIN-78412
Advocate for the Petitioner : MS H BETALA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM
Linked Case : PIL(Suo Moto)/6/2021 XXX AND 41 ORS.
Page No.# 5/14
XXX
2: RAHMAT ALI SON OF ABDUL HAMID HAJI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.- KHARUPETIA DISTRICT DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 3: JIARUL HAQUE S/O ABDUL HAMID HAJIR/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 4: IMAN ALI S/O SAIDULLA R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 5: SOLEMAN ALI S/O SIANAT ALI HAJI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 6: ABDUL HAMID HAJI S/O HABEJUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 7: RAJIB ALI
Page No.# 6/14
S/O MUNTAZ ALI HAJI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 8: AHAR ALI S/O AFAJUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 9: SABED ALI S/O AFAJUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 10: MOBED S/O AFAJUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 11: IJAR ALI S/O MOTLEB ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
12: JANIF ALI S/O KHALIL R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE
Page No.# 7/14
P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 13: ESAF ALI S/O TALEB ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 14: MOINUL HAQUE S/O ABDUL RASHID R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 15: HANIF ALI S/O KHALIL ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 16: JAYEDA KHATUN W/O ESAF ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 17: AFSAR ALI S/O SABED ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM
Page No.# 8/14
PIN-784115
18: SAHED ALI S/O HAMID R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 19: IBRAHIM S/O JAYNAL R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 20: MAHILA BEGUM W/O JUNAB ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 21: AYUB ALI S/O ASMAT HAJI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 22: MOQBUL HUSSAIN S/O PURA SHEIKH R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
Page No.# 9/14
23: SIDDIQUE ALI
S/O SIYANAT HAJI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
24: MOTLEB ALI S/O ABDUL HAMID R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 25: FULURUDDIN
S/O SOJU SHEIKH R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 26: GAJIUR RAHMAN S/O AJGAR ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
27: KUDDUS ALI S/O SAIDULLA R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
Page No.# 10/14
28: MOSLEMUDIN
S/O SAIFUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
29: HAJRAT ALI S/O SAITULLA R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
30: AFSAR ALI S/O MUNTAJ ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115
31: JAHAR ALI S/O NUR HUSSAIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 32: BAJID MUSTAFA S/O ABED ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 33: IKRAMUL
Page No.# 11/14
S/O MOTLEB R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 34: JUNAB ALI S/O AFAJUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 35: SAIBOR HAQUE S/O NAJIRUDDIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 36: SADEK ALI S/O ABDUL HAMID R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 37: SAHERA KHATUN W/O ABDUL HAMID R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 38: ASMAT ALI S/O MUNTAJ ALI
Page No.# 12/14
R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 39: ABED ALI S/O MUNTAJ ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 40: MD. SALAM S/O SOFU SHEIKH R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115. 41: SAHIDAR S/O MOSLEM ALI R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 42: ISA HAQUE S/O ABDUL HUSSAIN R/O VILL 3 NO. ARIMARI DALGAON REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.-KHARUPETIA DIST-DARRANG ASSAM PIN-784115 VERSUS
IN RE- THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY
Page No.# 13/14
JANATA BHAWAN DISPUR GUWAHATI 781006
2:THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM REVENUE AND DISASTER MANEGEMENT DEPARTMENT JANATA BHAWAN DISPUR GUWAHATI 781006 3:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE ASSAM ASSAM POLICE HEADQUARTERS ULUBARI GUWAHATI 781007 4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER DARRANG MANGALDAI 784125 5:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE DARRANG MANGALDAI 784125 6:THE CIRCLE OFFICER CIRCLE OFFICE SIPAJHAR MARAI 784145 7:XXX AND 40 ORS XXX -----------Advocate for : SC GHC Advocate for : GA ASSAM appearing for IN RE- THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
Page No.# 14/14
BEFORE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
ORDER
Date : 10.08.2022
(R.M. Chhaya, CJ)
Heard Ms. H. Betala, learned counsel for the applicants. Also heard Mr. T.J. Mahanta, learned senior counsel for the Gauhati High Court; Mr. D. Saikia, learned Advocate General, Assam as well as Mr. J. Handique, learned counsel for the Revenue & Disaster Management Department.
Ms. H. Betala, learned counsel for the applicants submits that she may be permitted to withdraw this interlocutory application.
Permission granted.
The interlocutory application is dismissed as withdrawn.
The connected P.I.L. being P.I.L. (Suo Motu) No. 6 of 2021 be listed along with P.I.L. No. 65 of 2021 and other connected cases on 24.08.2022.
JUDGE CHIEF JUSTICE
Comparing Assistant
Rahmat Ali and 40 Ors
The State of Assam and 5 Ors
Soumitra Saikia
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
