Single judge order admitting an appeal where the lower court had allowed a suit and reversed a prior judgment regarding a title dispute. The order stays the lower court decree pending appeal's disposal.
Stayed the lower court decree and reversed judgment pending disposal of the appeal.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010125372021
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : RSA/129/2021
LOKHAR DIGHIR PARER AKHRA AND 13 ORS. REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT/APPELLANT NO. 2 OTHER MEMBERS I.E. THE APPELLANT NO. 2 TO 14
2: HIMANGSHU NATH S/O LATE SHIB NATH VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
3: BIPUL CHANDRA NATH S/O LATE PANDIT NATH VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
4: ASHIT BARAN CHOUDHURY S/O LATE LABANYA CHOUDHURY VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 5: DILIP KUMAR NATH S/O LATE NIPENDRA NATH VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM
Page No.# 2/11
PIN-788709
6: RANJIT KUMAR NATH S/O LATE PEARI CHARAN NATH VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 7: SUDHARSHAN NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 8: SUJON NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 9: SUCHINTO NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 10: BHANU RANI DEVI D/O LATE SUBON NATH SL. NO. 7 TO 10 ARE R/O VILL- BAURBHAG (BATARASHI) P.O.-TILLABAZAR DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 11: PHANI BHUSAN MALAKAR S/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR R/O PANEROGAR P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.S. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 12: REKHA RANI NATH W/O LATE DARIKA NATH R/O VILL-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 13: SANKADEEP NATH @ SHASHANKA NATH S/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH
14: SANKAR NATH @ SHANKU S/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH SL. NO. 13 AND 14 ARE R/O VILL- BAURBHAG
Page No.# 3/11
P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSA
VERSUS
ATIKUR RAHMAN AND 29 ORS. S/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN
2:ABIDUR RAHMAN S/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN
3:RARHANA BEGUM D/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN
4:REHANA BEGUM D/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN
5:MONOWARA BEGUM D/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN
6:JAIGUNA BIBI W/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN R/O VILL-KESHORKAPON P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
7:SUBHAL NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH
8:BABLI NATH D/O LATE SUBON NATH
9:SUBHASH NATH S/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH 10:SUKENDU NATH S/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH
11:SMTI. HARIPRIHA DEVI W/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH SL. 7 TO 11 ARE R/O VILL-BATARASHI P.O.-TILABZAR P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
Page No.# 4/11
12:SMTI SABUJ DEVI D/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH W/O DINESH NATH VILL- SINGLACHERRA P.S.-RATABARI DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709
13:SMTI. MONORAMA NATH W/O LATE HARENDRA NATH R/O VILL AND P.O.-NARTH TAGARNATH MALUA P.O.-BADARPUR DIST-KARIMGNAJ ASSAM-788709 14:SMTI GITA NATH W/O NRIPENDRA NATH VILL-BAGARGOOL P.O.-RAKESHNAGAR P.S.-BADARPUR DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709
15:MITALI NATH D/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH
16:MRIDULA NATH D/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH
17:AMITA NATH W/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH SL. NO. 15 TO 17 ARE R/O VILL- BAURBAHG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST- KARIMGNAJ ASSAM-788709
18:RAM MOHAN DUTTA S/O LATE KANTAI RAM DUTTA R/O VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709
19:RANJIT KUMAR NATH OF LATE PUJATI NATH VILL-BAURBHAG
Page No.# 5/11
P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709
20:PROMOD RANJAN NATH S/O LATE BASANTA NATH VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709
21:SHASHI BHUSAN MALAKAR S/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR
22:ARCHANA MALAKAR S/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR
23:SUNITI MALAKAR W/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR SL. NO. 21 TO 23 ARE R/O VILL- PANEROGAR P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
24:DIPAK NATH S/O LATE DARIKA NATH
25:RUPAK NATH S/O LATE DARIKA NATH
26:BENU NATH
D/O LATE DARIKA NATH
27:ANU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH
28:KANU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH
29:MINU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH
30:MAINA NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH SL. NO. 24 TO 30 ARE R/O VILL- DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM
Page No.# 6/11
PIN-78870
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. S K GHOSH
Advocate for the Respondent :
Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/2123/2021
LOKHAR DIGHIR PAPER AKHRA AND 13 ORS. REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT/APPELLANT NO. 2 OTHER MEMBERS I.E. THE APPELLANT NO. 2 TO 14
2: HIMANGSHU NATH S/O LATE SHIB NATH VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
3: BIPUL CHANDRA NATH S/O LATE PANDIT NATH VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
4: ASHIT BARAN CHOUDHURY S/O LATE LABANYA CHOUDHURY VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
5: DILIP KUMAR NATH S/O LATE NIPENDRA NATH VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709
Page No.# 7/11
6: RANJIT KUMAR NATH S/O LATE PEARI CHARAN NATH VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 7: SUDHARSHAN NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 8: SUJON NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 9: SUCHINTO NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 10: BHANU RANI DEVI D/O LATE SUBON NATH SL. NO. 7 TO 10 ARE R/O VILL- BAURBHAG (BATARASHI) P.O.-TILLABAZAR DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 11: PHANI BHUSAN MALAKAR S/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR R/O PANEROGAR P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.S. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 12: REKHA RANI NATH W/O LATE DARIKA NATH R/O VILL-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 13: SANKADEEP NATH @ SHASHANKA NATH S/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH
14: SANKAR NATH @ SHANKU S/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH SL. NO. 13 AND 14 ARE R/O VILL- BAURBHAG P.O.-TILLABAZAR
Page No.# 8/11
P.O. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM VERSUS ATIKUR RAHMAN AND 29 ORS. C S/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN 2:ABIDUR RAHMAN S/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN 3:RARHANA BEGUM D/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN 4:REHANA BEGUM D/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN 5:MONOWARA BEGUM D/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN 6:JAIGUNA BIBI W/O LATE SIRAJ UDDIN R/O VILL-KESHORKAPON P.O.-DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 7:SUBHAL NATH S/O LATE SUBON NATH 8:BABLI NATH D/O LATE SUBON NATH 9:SUBHASH NATH S/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH 10:SUKENDU NATH S/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH 11:SMTI. HARIPRIHA DEVI W/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH SL. 7 TO 11 ARE R/O VILL-BATARASHI P.O.-TILABZAR P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 12:SMTI SABUJ DEVI D/O LATE SUKUMAR NATH W/O DINESH NATH VILL- SINGLACHERRA P.S.-RATABARI DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709 13:SMTI. MONORAMA NATH W/O LATE HARENDRA NATH R/O VILL AND P.O.-NARTH TAGARNATH MALUA
Page No.# 9/11
P.O.-BADARPUR DIST-KARIMGNAJ ASSAM-788709 14:SMTI GITA NATH W/O NRIPENDRA NATH VILL-BAGARGOOL P.O.-RAKESHNAGAR P.S.-BADARPUR DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709 15:MITALI NATH D/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH 16:MRIDULA NATH D/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH 17:AMITA NATH W/O LATE SHASHADHAR NATH SL. NO. 15 TO 17 ARE R/O VILL- BAURBAHG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST- KARIMGNAJ ASSAM-788709 18:RAM MOHAN DUTTA S/O LATE KANTAI RAM DUTTA R/O VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709 19:RANJIT KUMAR NATH OF LATE PUJATI NATH VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709 20:PROMOD RANJAN NATH S/O LATE BASANTA NATH VILL-BAURBHAG P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.O. AND DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788709 21:SHASHI BHUSAN MALAKAR S/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR 22:ARCHANA MALAKAR S/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR 23:SUNITI MALAKAR W/O LATE LALIT MALAKAR SL. NO. 21 TO 23 ARE R/O VILL- PANEROGAR P.O.-TILLABAZAR P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM
Page No.# 10/11
PIN-788709 24:DIPAK NATH S/O LATE DARIKA NATH 25:RUPAK NATH S/O LATE DARIKA NATH 26:BENU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH 27:ANU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH 28:KANU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH 29:MINU NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH 30:MAINA NATH D/O LATE DARIKA NATH SL. NO. 24 TO 30 ARE R/O VILL- DHARAKUNA P.S. AND DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN-788709 -----------Advocate for : MR. S K GHOSH Advocate for : appearing for ATIKUR RAHMAN AND 29 ORS. C
BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHIVJYOTI SAIKIA
ORDER
Date : --08.12.2021
Heard Mr. S.K. Ghosh, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant. .
Since the appeal is admitted for hearing, the judgment and decree dated 20.03.21, passed by the learned Civil Judge, Karimganj in Title Appeal No. 6/2018, allowing the appeal by decreeing the suit of plaintiffs and reverse the judgment and decree dated 12.01.2018, passed by the learned Munsiff No. 1, Karimganj in Title Sit No. 199/1986 shall remain stayed till disposal of the appeal.
I.A Stands disposed of.
Page No.# 11/11
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Lokhar Dighir Parer Akhra and 13 Ors.
Atikur Rahman and 29 Ors.
Partbijyoti Saikia
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
