The Gauhati High Court allowed 152 applicants to withdraw their interlocutory application with liberty to file afresh after noticing inherent mistakes in the filing. The current application stands closed on withdrawal.
Allowed withdrawal of the application with liberty to file a fresh one.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/18
GAHC010033632018
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : I.A.(Civil) 497/2018
1:RANJIT TERON AND 152 ORS S/O- LT. MASHAL TERON, R/O VILL./ TOWN- BATHAGHULI (PART), BOJARA, N.C. YUSUF NAGAR, UNDER THE SATGAON P.S., DIST.- KAMRUP (M), GUWAHATI, ASSAM.
VERSUS
1:THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 125 ORS
REP. BY THE CHIEF SECY., GOVT. OF ASSAM, ASSAM SACHIVALAYA, DISPUR, GHY- 6.
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. M PRACHA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM
Linked Case : PIL 27/2013
1:X X X
VERSUS
1:IN RE - THE STATE OF ASSAM and125 ORS REP. BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY ASSAM SECRETARIAT DISPUR GHY-6.
2:MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT AND FOREST
Page No.# 2/18
GOVT.OF ASSAM DISPUR GHY-6. 3:COMMISSIONER and SECY. ENVIRONMENT AND FOREST DEPARTMENT DISPUR GHY-6. 4:THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FOREST REHABARI GHY-8. 5:DIVISIONAL FOREST OFFICER KAMRUP EAST DIVISION BASISTHA GHY-29.
6:TREASURED WHEELSTHE NORTH EAST HERITAGE FOUNDATION REP. BY ONE OF ITS TRUSTEES SRI PICKLOO DEKA S/O SRI PRAFULLA CHANDRA DEKA R/O HENGRABARI HOUSING COLONY GUWAHATI - 78106 DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM
7:RANJIT TERON S/O LT. MASAL TERON
8:ABDUL HAKIM S/O SAFER ALI
9:REZIA KHATUN W/O LILU AHMED BARBHUYAN
10:AKRAM AHMED SHAH S/OLT. ABDUL JABBAR
11:LAILA BEGUM W/O JAYNUL HOQUE BARBHUYAN
12:HAMID ALI S/O HAFIZ ALI
13:SWAPNA BEGUM LASKAR W/O ABDUL HANAN MAZUMDAR
Page No.# 3/18
14:BADARUDDIN S/O LT. MONOWAR ALI
15:SYEDA NAZMA BEGUM D/O ABDUL JABBAR
16:HANNUFA KHATUN D/O LIYAKAT ALI
17:KHAIRUL ANAM S/O LT. ABDUL REZZAK
18:KARIMUDDIN CHOUDHURI S/O ABDUL MATLIB CHAUDHARY
19:IMADUL CHAUDHURY S/O REZZAK CHAUDHURY
20:MANIK PODDAR S/O LT. BOLO PODDAR
21:GITANJALI HALOI W/O KANGKAN HALOI
22:MAYA DAS W/O ASHUTOSH BISWAS
23:GOFUR ALI S/O LT. MAFIZ ALI
24:KHEMRAJ SHARMAH S/O LT. BHIMRAM SHARMAH
25:MOINUDDIN AHMED S/O SHARMAN ALI
26:BARIK ALI S/O LT. ABU BAKKAR ALI
27:SHER KADIR SIKDER S/O LT. KADDUS SIKDAR
28:SANTOSH CHAUHAN S/O GANESH CHAUHAN
29:SHAIJUDDIN S/OLT. BASHI SEIKH
Page No.# 4/18
30:ABDUL AZIZ S/O JAFAR ALI 31:BOBY HIRA S/O LT. JAYRAM HIRA RESPONDENTS NOS. 7 TO 32 ARE RESIDENTS OF VILL/TOWN - BATHAGHULI PART YUSUF NAGAR B AJARA NC P.S. SATGAON P.O. PANJABARI GUWAHATI DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM 32:DONYI POLO NAGAR DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE PANJABARI DONYI POLO NAGAR P.O. PANJABARI WARD NO. 54 P.S. SATGAON GUWAHATI - 781037 DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM REP. BY ITS SECRETARY SRI DHARMENDRA DEORI. 33:SRI DHARMENDAR DEORI S/O MANAMOHAN DEORI CHUKAFA PATH PART P.S. SATGAON SUB-DIVISION GUWAHATI DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM 34:SRI JAGARAN MARAK S/O RANIK MARAK 35:SMTI. MIRA SANGMA @ MIRA MARAK W/O KHANKAR SANGMA 36:SMTI. NIRU SANGMA W/O SULINDAR SANGMA 37:SMTI. RENILA MARAK W/O AKUL CHAN MARAK 38:SRI BHABEN CHANDRA BORO S/O TARUN CH. BORO
Page No.# 5/18
39:SRI RABEN CH. BORO S/O BHABEN CH. BORO
40:SMTI. MANJU BORO W/O AJAY DAS
41:SMTI. CHAPNA MARAK W/O PULIN SANGMA
42:SMTI. PITIKA MARAK W/O SHATIN SANGMA
43:SMTI. GRIPICH SANGMA W/O RAJEN SANGMA
44:SRI RAJEN MARAK S/O RABARTS SANGMA
45:SMTI. BHARATI MARAK S/O KALARAM MARAK
46:SRI NIKIN MARAK S/O BANE SANGMA
47:SRI LENUCH T. SANGMA S/O METHEN MARAK
48:KHELO SANGMA @ KEHLO SANGMA S/O GANESH SANGMA
49:SMTI. BEAUTY SANGMA W/O OWELFINA MARAK
50:SMTI. NIRDAI MARAK W/O RAMATHI SANGMA
51:SMTI. SUSHILA SANGMA W/O JAHINATH MARAK
52:SMTI. SABITA MARAK W/O BALEN SANGMA
53:SRI THICHAN SANGMA S/O KHALADANG SANGMA
54:SRI LALIN MARAK S/O LABAR SANGMA
Page No.# 6/18
55:SRI DABIN MARAK S/OLT. HANDIN MARAK
56:SMTI. KERAN MARAK W/O MICHAN SANGMA 57:SRI HEMEN BORO S/O TERA BORO 58:SRI TULARAM BORO S/O HALADHAR BORO 59:PULIN SANGMA S/O LT. NANDARAM SANGMA 60:POLLITHSON MARAK @ FALITCHAN MARAK S/O GOPAL SANGMA
61:AUGUSTINE SANGMA @ AGESON MARAK S/O MINJENG MARAK 62:SRI THOMAS SANGMA S/O METHIN MARAK 63:SRI MANTU MARAK S/O A J SANGMA RESPONDENTS NOS. 35 TO 64 ARE RESIDENTS OF KHANKAR PANIKHAITI P.O. and P.S. PRAGJYOTISHPUR DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM PIN - 781026. 64:DEVONAGAR DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE KHANAPARA GUWAHATI - 781022 DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM REP. BY ITS SECRETARY SRI DEBANDANDA DOLEY. 65:SRI DEBANDANDA DOLEY S/O SRI TANKESWAR DOLEY R/O DEVONAGAR KHANAPARA GUWAHATI - 781022 DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM
Page No.# 7/18
66:RUWAD NAGAR DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE P.O. KHANAPARA P.S. DISPUR GUWAHATI - 781022 DIST. KAMRUP M ASSAM REP. BY ITS SECRETARY SRI BIREN DOLEY.
67:SRI BIREN DOLEY S/O SHANGKADHAR DOLEY RUWAD NAGAR P.O. KHANAPARA P.S. DISPUR GUWAHATI - 781022 DIST.KAMRUP M ASSAM
68:SRI BHASKAR JYOTI PEGU S/O SRI KULABAR PEGU
69:SRI BENI DOLEY S/O SRI TANUJ DOLEY
70:SRI ANIL DOLEY S/O SRI DECEMBER DOLEY
71:SRI TARA NATH DOLEY S/OS RI PHULESWAR DOLEY
72:SRI HEMA KT. PEGU S/OLT. ANANDA PEGU
73:SRI BISWAJIT DOLEY S/O BIDHESWAR DOLEY
74:SRI MINO KT. PAIT S/OLT. BHABO KT. PEGU
75:SRI JITEN PEGU S/O SRI KHUKEN PEGU
76:SRI UMESH PATIR S/O SRI TUNI RAM PATIR
77:SRI NABA BORO S/O SRI HANTU BORO
Page No.# 8/18
78:SRI PRADIP PEGU S/O SRI BOMBESWAR
79:SADANANDA PEGU S/O KULASON PEGU
80:SRI RANJIT DARIK S/O SUNA RAM DARIK
81:SRI KIRAN KUTUM S/O BROJENDRANATH KUTUM
82:SRI PRANJIT DOLEY S/O SRI PATIR DOLEY
83:SMTI. PROVAWATI PEGU D/O LT. KULANATH PEGU
84:SMTI. SWARNALATA DOLEY D/O LT. BAPUNG DOLEY
85:SRI RAJIV PEGU S/O BOMBESWAR PEGU
86:SRI BINOD DOLEY S/O SRI TANUJ DOLEY
87:SRI SAURAV SAIKIA S/O PUNA SAIKIA
88:SRI NABAJIT PATIR S/O SRI JIBAN PATIR
89:SRI BHUPEN DOLEY S/O DHANU RAM DOLEY
90:SRI KUSHAL MILI S/O UBHAY RAM MIRI
91:SRI SANJIB DOLEY S/O SRI BOLEN DOLEY
92:SRI MANUJ PEGU S/O SRI LOKHESWAR PEGU
93:SRI AJOY RAM DOLEY S/O SRI DEBEN DOLEY
Page No.# 9/18
94:SRI DILIP TAID S/O SRI TANKESWAR TAID
95:SRI PUNA RAM DOLEY S/OLT. GANDHI RAM DOLEY
96:SRI RANJAN DOLEY S/O SRI KULAMON DOLEY
97:SRI TARJAN PATIR S/O SRI BILUWAR PATIR
98:SRI RAJU PEGU S/O SRI SHAPIDHAR PEGU
99:SRI CHANDAN PEGU S/O SRI HIRA PEGU
100:SRI NABIN DEORI S/O DHIREN DEORI
101:SRI ROBIN PEGU S/O SRI HOLIRAM PEGU
102:SRI BIJOY BASUMATARY S/O SRI CHATARAM BASUMATARY
103:SRI SATYA PEGU S/OS RI HALIRAM PEGU
104:SRI NARENDRA KUTUM S/O SRI BIRASON KUTUM RESPONDENTS OS. 69 TO 105 ARE RESIDENTS OF KANGKAN NAGAR 2 NO. KHANAPARA MOUZA- BELTOLA P.O. BAGHABARI P.S. DISPUR GUWAHATI DIST. KAMRUP ASSAM
105:SRI RATAN ROY S/O SRI DEBARU ROY
106:SRI BANKIM SARMA S/OLT. UTSAB CHANDRA SARMA
107:SRI NAYANJYOTI DAS S/OLT. NITUL DAS
Page No.# 10/18
108:SRI DHANMONI KALITA S/O KAMINI KANTA KALITA
109:SRI BHUBAN DAS S/OLT. DHARANI DAS
110:SRI KANAK PATOWARY S/OLT. BHABIN PATOWARY
111:SRI BIREN DAS S/O SRI RAM DHAN DAS
112:SRI RAM KRISHNA DAS S/O SRI KAMAKHYA DAS
113:SRI AJIT CHANDRA DAS S/O SRI BHABEN CHANDRA DAS
114:SMTI. JONALI KALITA W/O HAREN KALITA
115:HARPATI SARMA S/OLT. JADAB SARMA
116:SRI PINU KALITA S/O SRI HEMANTA KALITAA
117:SRI KUMUD CHANDRA DEKA S/O PRAHLAD DEKA
118:SRI PABAN BAISHYA S/O LT. SARAT BAISHYA
119:HEMANTA CHOUDHURY S/OLT. UTTAM CHOUDHURY
120:SRI GIRIN DEKA S/O SRI RAMESH DEKA
121:SRI KANDARPA DAS S/O SRI ADITYA DAS
122:SRI MRINAL TALUKDAR S/O GAJEN TALUKDAR
123:SMTI. KAMINI BORO W/O SRI BIMAL BORO
Page No.# 11/18
124:SRI SUKUMAR BORO S/O SRI PRAFULLA BORO 125:SRI NARAYAN DAS S/OS RI GAURI DAS 126:SRI KAMALA MILI W/O SRI ACHYUT HAZARIKA ALL ARE APPLICANTS ARE RESIDENT OF VILL/TOWN- SIVASAGAR MOUZA- BELGOLA P.O. BAGHARBARI P.S. SATGAON GUWAHATI DIST. KAMRUP METRO ASSAM 127:MAJULIPUR DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE MAJULIPUR PO KHANAPARA GUWAHATI ASSAM REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT SRI RAJIB KUMBANG 128:SRI RAJIB KUMBANG R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI 129:SMTI JUNU SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
130:MONESH SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
131:RAJU SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
132:PINTU SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI 133:SMTI. DAMAYANTI BARMAN DEKA R/O GAROBASTI
Page No.# 12/18
PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
134:SUBHADRA MARAK R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
135:RABITA MARAK R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
136:MINTU MARAK R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
137:PRUTUL DAIMARI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
138:SHANTA SHIL CHAKMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
139:KARUNA BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
140:KALYAN CHAKMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
141:HAILU RAMSIARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
142:SMTI SUMITRA SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
Page No.# 13/18
143:ANIL SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
144:DIPALI BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
145:DAMAYANTI BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
146:KHAGEN SWARGIARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
147:KANAK BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
148:DURGA MONI DAIMARI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
149:RAMESWAR BASUMATARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
150:PULAK TALUKDAR R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
151:ANIMA SHARMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
152:KAMITA BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON
Page No.# 14/18
PO PANJABARI
153:RAGESWAR DAIMARI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
154:NIRMALA BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
155:ANGAJAI MOG R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
156:BABUL BARMAN R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
157:NILJEN BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
158:BIPIN DAIMARI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
159:AJALI BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
160:HARI CH. RAVA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
161:PRADIP CH. NATH R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
162:PARAMESWAR DAIMARI
Page No.# 15/18
R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
163:ANANDA GOGOI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
164:PADUMIBALA BARMAN R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
165:DIPALI SANGMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
166:GOBIN BASUMATARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
167:PRANAB BORAH R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
168:KANAK DAIMARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
169:BINOD BASUMATARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
170:SAMBAR BORO R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
171:PRADIP KUMAR RAVA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
Page No.# 16/18
172:MADHU MADHAB DAS R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
173:CHANDAN NARZARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
174:ABDUL LATIF R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
175:SUREN BORAH R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
176:MRINAL DUTTA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
177:DECOROUS MOCHAHARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
178:MALABITA CHANGMAI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
179:MINA BARMAN R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
180:SABIDAR DAIMARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI 181:SURESH NANDA CHAKMA R/O GAROBASTI
Page No.# 17/18
PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
182:ANJALI BASUMATARY R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
183:AJIT DEKA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
184:SANTI KUMAR CHAKMA R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
185:MAHINDRA DAS R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
186:NILIMA DAIMARI R/O GAROBASTI PS SATGAON PO PANJABARI
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR.S S DEY Advocate for the Respondent : GA ASSAM
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ACHINTYA MALLA BUJOR BARUA HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NELSON SAILO
ORDER
Date : 07-11-2019
AM Bujor Barua, J
Mr. MK Das, learned counsel for the applicants submits that there are some inherent mistakes in the interlocutory application and the applicants seek to withdraw this application with liberty to file afresh.
Page No.# 18/18
Accordingly, the applicants are allowed to refile a fresh application in the correct manner.
Interlocutory application stands closed on withdrawal.
JUDGE JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
RANJIT TERON AND 152 ORS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 125 ORS
ACHINTYA MALLA BUJOR BARUA
NELSON SAILO
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
