This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
1 frTft Etu ffi qtu * qttPT ffi ge' 6ftq sz s$ rlTfu-{ gw qro wde =r-{i 102 orqft d{r {cq-< efrq i}zqffidsr rry rB-w ffi-ffi, va5t (trr) ....... . . eili{fiq-urrrq t
EE
I
Effidq"c F€i{T oqfr frfits,qTa-ft qfuf, @W dis{ d.oilgfr. do, fr.{ t-s ffiEr {rqgi,gNT orexr$w srThts............. sc-rqrft.r"r t
3nA-c-rqe{ d ftq fr ergu Gucrld eftq-m t
vmrqrfr t-n d frq fr e-ft'T d-{ eiBqqflr t
2
's.q. ix -sza/zozs
3TI t ET
(kqro' oo.ot.zozs ol dtfr-a)
z. sr1f,gfi'.. d oeq rie\c dgn non d ot o-+qT fq riErft s'q Rqr fq ffi iqo qqfu rs-{r{ iEt-{ i17/z gqqn-iT +qq tezo,/r dqre rq{ 4qr 7ssq{qfl-e dETqrcl-fr oqd {res tf, o-r-dT-ft cid vrogi*iuo ms vtrrqrfr rrqel t ffiq rlarqfl q]K fu-{r, ffi frrE sffiqrfr €sarrgRr !-{flrfuf, o1.d zw er1fr orffii d ffr ffi q-q-qr or ech'RFI ftqiq' ro.os.zozs e) fu-qTrrqr, ffi eE$ri eurcF T+qfu o1 fc.ffi orffi ftfl-fi so.os.zozs C furtkd o-q arxlso Tw 237oooool- (d m-(Y-s +ft-c. ore) vq-i frqiR( fu-qrrrqr t tw s-qnlqn F-i@r q/1) s-f,-rc t I
3
Vfl.g. +q< -sza/zozs
qiq-q t{ cffirrf, orrfi rrqr qff dqqr rtqfu or ft-q 28.02.2022qqrw dr To-r t Iqffiq-{q ig srTtfi ft{;6 sr.ot.zozsq) Tco ordqro-q 3rffi fufirs qrtsmivr vuy d T{Tq q-rgf, fu-q'r w g,or t r sTrtr-rq-6 frft-{qrfr wn d g-*r t tq< fr frq oi Tfi-fi-oqur Ei uii,Tr Iq-{gd errifi o1 cfr (vi@r q//z) t r
4 's. . iqt -sza/zoze
24.04.2023 (qi@{ /7) d ffqq t fi-q r-fi-fi-or'T or ergtu fu-a 1 6* fi \rtrrarft oqfr ienift-mr a\ Ffr-q rfifi-orq frrn uri atthti g+<t r& ftut , ilq GTrikmT i d-q 61 nftfi6-*ui e)i ,ro ffi Elffi or ftq-q EgH 3FNar t rr€ri orergttt fuqT, fu-gq-a frqio 01.07.2023(q+@i q,/e) d erw rti w srx-qdqfrro ra r-qT, ffi qltqq t erq.ro zF-{FrT rr-qr q,t ts llRTq=Tr re EH w en}kor arqr qqr +t T$ v.RT 5esoooo/-(${rd ore. qqffi Ewt{) v!-i ucil or fr,r$ t t
s. onlkrr aT srftmari t at dfu'f,gq frfuo tl;I fuim 16.08.2023 &-i-@r /rc) A qrqq t sil-nkf,r t o-e-+ d E-+i o-(qqfl ,6qr-q fu-qT t qqB oqfr d gm c-fl frilo z2.ol.2oz3 (si@r /io) dqtaq toilnk{T orergtu qo-q frqr rt'qr I n.alysra gqq qrq o-rqot d q-+-tyT i q6 tr{;-{uT trt1d or sifua rre-r+flr or ergtu fo-qr.rqT t t
5
Vfl.q. iqt -s26/2023
sqfu ftro. fu-qr, fu{rmTqd-fi +qd rftr$ n (=lwr eTtt/1) d sc fr fu-qi .rqr t, fu ed d--{-( l) 3szsooo / - (t-fiH 6pqsq"ft{i cro) vrt elw o-r srqqqfi ffif, ms d-q \rfr-+-c F{rTo fu-+r.ror, fu5 06.05.2021 (qi-@l sTt/2) ffif, uq o-t 5rrfl-{ c 6}i w dlc V{-r$u-e frqfo os.tt. 2022 (\t@y sTt/ ) ifuo E3rTt m.f,crat-a GnD!-.s Wq-rR"r'rst 2s.01.2023(gi@T GrR,/8)nfua of .r$, fu-g eor+r uq ol g,r_f,r{ T& 6}i d orsq ffi q++ fr=no 02.02.2023 dqrqq t ffi o-rffi ft-qr-{ ro.os.zozs (q+@{ wTtz) d eryxqoTRTf, gen t uufu ft-s d erqrq d oTdqrfr or{rrha- €, oq d-s fi-flfr tlan Hro rc.$.2023 ifud vq e-mTRrd or (vtms eri.rTro) d eiym ffi ?FFffi kflo 30.03.2023 furtRfl @t.d w ffi t5+cl- t rsE $s tqa frq of T$ ot Eqfu"gq sq dqqqq tR{q"' ""-s +{r {q tq-r orr tfu-s" of yrd qi fr_qq & s-{f,ifua at d, ffi oiil.f-d 3trnfumr i frer,ft oTffi frqrq ftr+rr ,rcrgnn orrnk+r o\ nrya ft-sq etB-fl o{ rY-aznq6* der dqrtqq r\ wri {.r.1S {rPr d srfrkfi ts zs sfrqrf, rs fu+fl + sl(i A.S. g{T. Vq-rsu-c zgeoool-(q\ are ersfrs rwn) vr} qqr o-qi tg o.-dr t qqB 3rdko-r d er-5ilq qr ft=ftfr 1s.os.2oz3 ffF r{q-q 1frqr ffifl o1 T$, ffi fleqq t wE o{ ftqIrrqT a1 3lrt at{ wurftm
6
'fl.g. iqt -sza/zozs
ffin =r€fo1 qrhft, fu-i fi 3r-nk6r its rifrr cqr rfr frtq-l
B. Grri-{oqeT t dfufi ild dqqelc t kirff 21.11.2024 a) fufuf, e-d u-rgo fuqrgs uorqrfrq&T t fr ft-fl-fr 2s.11.2024 e\ ftfuf, a-d rqo fu-qr t t e. BlTrr seT d srftq-fi Ts d-d +q-f,rqr q frE yrq 1ffiq t:-
(r),- cqr vf,t-qrfr ffiq $qerr d sl-rt rfl-Rrd et T{ ffi qan (giq"1 3II(/16)qFm ?fr?
(z):- e+r s-cfl{qrfr ffi-q fiten ARr {.Vq.$. qtfrI qw fr,t qrt d we-+r i fuqr rqT fuq vs ifroqa Hrm or.oz.zozs (g+@{ g/B) frD fts-q *o-s oTqRf, frdq.fi zil.q t ?
(s),- 1T6tttf,I Vqqq ?
frc,- vrftyrrl o-) fr-qri t d-m{ M kflqr rf,i' $.o.-
7
vrT. . nq{ -e26 / 2023
' *. q. ;iER -s2o/202s
d ergnx sm{qrfr ffiqr{sadr t ftirmst.ot.zozs qn orSqrcrc arffi vr+gt fuom srBo-{q d sqei zot ca a:r*r ee]-o o1.r$ qqfu sn fr-q3i-qD ffif, frrn ud or enilcq c-{gd frtqren, sil ffi rpr+ u-oftro Eti ft-{r6 rc.w.2023/11.08. zoze d $ a1 fra{ft B Iqfl q7 frgc1 oQz, or..ft sd-s t fu trlgr fuo-rsqrkfi-rrr dgm dq-fi-fi-df qeT o\ s-m v+qfu qqrfi ffi et srgqfr/orflqfu sqTurq-{ d dqqq t fr Ts'sfrt ftq AGr-qD fr=im 28.02.2022 o\ Iffir<. g{?fr, w{fu eq-m' Hfic.{.,1q 6l( srrr-fir 2018 t sEfuf, B, Glprff, fr-q 3mfu vrqrw eli r\ arnrrr 4 s{ Td s-m nqfuq-r HTRI eqm rotqei d aRT \rflwrft ffi-q ricar d E-o t EfddfuqT rr{[ e-rrI
9
Vfl.q. iqq -gza/zoze
GiltRor iqa qrE-i gv ffi erffir+i *nq fuqr e-r et fr.o-q tg lrw-rhd et T$ v+'qfu of q.esr Grqtq rrrrrkT Ei gfrt t, ffi Tft-ftfrwr tg siltfi rlerq qrB-fii"r d vrqer dfuf, B, Tq q6 M q-S f,{-mT-dT qT rrndT of scnsqfr rfler d urffqf, srffi i fr-q dEs Hqfr + LC d frqq t frtqft nssEF) ffi gq GrTtknT o\ ffi EFTffi t qnr +i tg ffif,fu-qrerTt
'r3 oilteoqeT a1 Gri( t uqo ftrd TS ftfu-a Tqdfu-fr a-d dqTurq tsf,Eqrft ffiqrrqe-r w ffiq tn-qt Eq qrrftq qqrq grs ERqrun v@ alIqrcfq d d-6 otrw gtrgqr fr.sq. ft. w. 14633 / zozqq qlR--f, trq tffr.o 04.10.2024,Gqrlqetf, 2024 \ H.fr.Tft Gffiq ErE w &rry rz.o+.zors, E{tr u-ffisrra va;qrqffiq gmr rr*q o:ryr ffsqqqrq orrtE Ffim fi.oa.zoz3gqqFrftqg@TFT qrqroq d vd.ft.(fufrd) iqqr 7470 /zotg fr tilfrn trqft-{m 11 orff, 2o2s m\ irqff-d fuqT TqT t, fu-aq( s.ffin frrqin\ w T(l- sTrfl s-rt-c oili gq S{T fr-d qrT qcT t rht {r+ rnwr ftt qfrRerM ft=q d t {s vffHE-f,rft lcn{ur ftt GiliREl ffi Efu ffi q}'taT ffi fr1qH t,(q ci-gqTq fr-fiI-dT.ilr$,TT
10
Vfl.q. qqq -gza /zozz
zh1 Bq-dqRqN ft1 fr-{il Et"E Hqffqfi q.dsr srqB T{sirkr E}i o-t flq vSqripT tQtr[, fu{ vosil-ft ffiq sseil d sTfuftF sIffi t fi vn-d sm ot ,ri Ws w c*U Reft t eFTTfl cnqrqT \q ffi r1-qqTq fr mt{pd qfr aft o1 ffi ol-ffiq-d--cT GrcB d o+-+orq d oTsqr{ Rtft, GTelfa vorqfr q,1 ffi"q $qeil or mt{.fr enq-sq {w rfr'w, ffi sdft-fiT,rRd Ei E, eIercT sf,rqrft ffiq rr-iatT d gM osC er lEkl srgherrT qx silriBtr fuq-I d t q-i{ o-mut. s-{gd q-r+{ErC t siltkfti m\ drqTfr-f, TSr fuqTqT ITFoT I
11
Vs.q. tx -eza/zoze
s'{ s:{ frqffi ro.oa.zozs ('tffi{q,/6) d or$il{ 15. os.zozs oo of vrrrq erqB ftTfl'fud fu-qr t irtpr frqr qfr-ir fi fu'fl a1 3rTt otg t+qq rtqr ffiaqfr ot qrht, o\ qa Eqi-dr t qfr oiltft-f,r uq qR{erfuf t qRfuf, clt gq ffi oTffi d" 3iftq qt rt iln qi rrqr zrafr,fr, fu-{ ot$ orqeq-oera gtRr rS g-o qri d orqor 3nifu6r sierrqTfr fu d q7 ftqio to sr-fd. zozg d oaqE ts iTfrT rasoooo / -1q-fi 6-ts I 3r6f,{ ercrqzTTfl rwr) vriqqr r€t uoq+t
12
gq. . iqt -sza / zozs
13
Tfl.q. tqr -sza/zozz
sTftq sTrtqr
1e. wt-.fiT$iriqfr ,r$ friq{r d norcl fr crtfumrgmr c-r!f, rH.q. euflFrf,qrqti ftwfl et qffi t vo fierggn siftq Giltsr v-sn fu-qr qror t,(el):- entkor ET-tr tmgf, '{r..9 clrfl'Flf,q-m-r Fflfl ofqrfr B r
(q)'- sf,{srfr ffiq dredr av 3Tr}k6r {qc.O. $R'r or 25 vfrcrf, sgsooo0/-(sfld dr-EIq-qnl rqx) vqiqE frriqfi t wqBderr*er fr{io or 07.2023 (g-i@iq/B) frB rrtqo eti t Reri {sT urnr t r
fiAvr gdqrqrtrq ii eirq ftqio oo.or zozs o) e\Ba fu-qr t
/ o' b' qld) (ffi{qffi) 0.em.0.q. q., G tr.ffis-ra
sqdg{ ffio:-oo.o1.2o2s
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
