This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
\qq.;iq-t -sat /zoz+
guornfrBor qu-s Gr({ TAFDIII
frRqr strsqT d-{d Yo.s qo-s F-flT{ ez-sa frfl ilpq 3fl-aq qrqrs Edl.i (\qft,)
2 ffi i-wn +d rie cfu tFd t& qw frqnr sz-se ftqv nl-q orTiqqrqr {dr twfr.)
snd-coqurrq t
ft-d-q
1
vilc-qrft{-q I
erd-<-o'qm d ft\ fr oni-fiqr--d erBq-m t
2 gs. q. i{t -361 /zozt
smrqrft {{en dfuq fr fr-ilfi YIqdNd fr B-@{ sutrrf, €il0s-fiT 61 31ffinv fr oBqd-{ 31D-q-m I
3IT t YI
(trqlo n-04.2025 dqlR-f,)
z. trwdgfl.q. orrjdq ?rd tfu sriqo.rq t Tilf,: EdgrqStrsqT E)q drf,{ r\ +gtooooo/-(qx o-trs g@T-qi oro) vqi of frffi-qlTdrqfl R=lT-fi 07'03'2018 o\ flw fuq-r 1'qFruR-d w tfttw\ o.r 5rrflrqq'-{d G {izi!-c sfrq \olu-c 1gt@r /1)t, fu-{ sffis-qrft t-fr a-{ frqvfqqT fuil-fi12.08.2023 1q-i-@r /3) iEf, q.,1
3
Vs.q. iqr -sor /2024
.T-{, fu-s-f,r q-ql-q fr{r6 11.10.2023 G'i@r q/4) on}e[-o qa i iBd fuqT, fug gq fts sf,{sTfr vrw i gw qrfuo ffie E-dr A a[irTFrtr tl erm r+ vrffi g+e zooz d ci-fl.fd G'r-ffir \ / s)q oil-ifi ncgo fuer, fur{ w enqr kil-o' 26.02.2024 F-i@{q/6) wRd fuqt rrql tr
4 gs..dq{ -got /zoz+
frBfiq-qqr-di dor5og l.$t t, g tr<3it ol cFIsT q{ fi (Fo t t
5 gfl g.iqs -eot /zozq
wreqq{-37 gs se dq-a frau-a ssss qrihte ftqr ilri {d{ t ReTfrqdqq rr+c d fi+w v+rq 'ierfi' Sfu-dfrilT, fu-{roT ri"ft'fi ffiqrffi to{EII r-rlT, fr-{ fr-{flqeTt fr g$ t*d ox"r ft-{io zo.tt.zozt d q,il-q t dq -orsrc yqfr.q.qrft-qd gen, ffi As-q t lr.r vlalr fu{ro12.0s.2023 1q-i@1sN /2) ffi sp. dqpqq t iBa ofT{, fti-fl-d ift-q sn}Eo qeT i oilqfu o{qrilfi fuql-f,11.10.2023 iRd fuqT, fu-s-fiT frqt@-q"T(+ffi 3TN,/3) d uAwn R=m ta.to.zozs @</sup> t frrqrqros olriro qel o) r1F+o fu'u 'ru
6
vs.q. {fl -361/zoz+
or-d.f-f, 5w urfuoq@e g<k d qTTITFITI fr u-rgo frd.ri3il-nfi q{ srreq fr"Irfi 26'02'2024i-i@l GrR/6)qrRo ger ttq+rsr 6 31ft-ow t fr qri@'T"T q{ *t{ q-d)"n {5frue k{rfis1.03.2024(qt@i aw/t) d wglx66e767533.60 (d o-tt-s s€f,{ drcl fuq-f,{ EqRlrKI {t tw lrq-i fuqIq-d tqr) q't tniltr B rgq q.fi 3il'qTii q{ q-qf, vs.q. 6T qfufl-( ord gq ilB-a tlarqf,Ior ergtu fu-qr qqr B t
(r)'-cqrqt rdq-cT Ffiifi12.08z023(-t@1 oTR/z) dq $ *o-qorqrw m d ql.q t ?
(z):-e+r 3ilftq-iq vgqr fuiffi28.10'2023 (\i-@1 orx,/s) frtsgq e-fu-qT d nq-qn H i\ 3rtlr{fl frt} qfi qt'.q t ?
(s):-a+r 5cqqfuo q@z {<)rErtr qrR-d GrrtqT R=fl-fi 26.02.2024(vi@i 3IR/6) sltlrftl fid qH si-'q t ?
(+):-war+o Vqqq ?
f;q,-q.ft q{qi o<sup>gfi q+rel ft-q-{ g fi-ot frqd ftqT ql sar tt
L q6 gteffi-o frD t fu wq xuX eRoRr+ut€ dBcqgrgr RffiqtS gtrd o fus-€ trru ta (+) sTalqt elrsl I
7
vs.g. iq{ -sot /zozq
l0qffi v{e doto.f( orffiq-{flrfuf, o-{ar t G E ftqk xqqqfi olkf,-tlT dqrteT qm fl (1)w$ffig{d 2002 d ureur+5lrv vlqq{ftqT d31il 3il-ifi tr*gf, o-{ ssr orffi *} gdfi i-dT t,f,q RmYd dBc{q{ {dqilr qrflI tfu of =riorffi ot derar Ewr-oq-q<lH dqrtqq tqqIFIf, fu-qr qrqt ilfr EM,Tr\ osq\ or qfrerq orrtlFdB t
i1. scrrqrft wqen oiqE gqTFIf, cnl=il tot wffigflc 2oo2 d vrqqrq\ vq ffior o-dEor t q-6q o-{t gv m.r rdqqT, 3TIBq-.q rpr of nrffi ms a]lq le4q t frtu-n Uqqrfuo q@e E-d-.s d
6
sfl .dqq -aot /zozq
srr-{aq-fif,rcr\ of $ dqRwq fr snfrft-o slrtel ft=lT-qt 26.02.2024qtw fu-fl trqr tt
9
\g.q. iqq -sot /zozt
'r3. s-orqrft ci*angnr iBarit'T q{ilfl ftito'12. ol.2o23 ofqfuqf, il-ffi 6ir-$f ttqr qrq, il qt-{<-d R{fi-c fuql-6 14.08.2023 dqrcqq t 3lril{6 tkd Q-& vq fi-r +e o<sup>sro ifra g$, qnq fr vs.q.frBqr 3rT{Ee ftfrd strsqT dq-d o<sup>,ft sro nR-fl o1 .rg, d ifiRffiGi-gq.R ft=ilo 18.10.2023 o\ ttrf, d-& Yq }-{qr Q=e o\ }RnoIIdf+E of 1Hr o-qd E{t, fua g< urteoqer t+ii.r gan dfr-d-q 3Tqfu srqli({ ftt{i@ 11.10.2023 G'i@i3ni/3) iBd fuqT, furr-t riilT qfqcl R=im p.ol:o23 fu{if, 16.08.2023 oi elilcoq't rrtra vq.3TN. ftBfi \qftBd gtr€qT ds-d qo-s s lclcr) It'l o<sup>qrq *ia-r orfufie5 o€ gV rr,ft a ot oqw tGil-qfu G1+qTt-fiifr--d fuqr rFII I Sr+ il{6 d sil-iEoqet o\ frq vgn of f,lffi6-l f,aq qqrFrd $1 14. 3r-iffiqa i3rrqfu 3lqrnf,{ or ftqro-{q q-S frrnq.fi fttoilqfr sd-qT tt gs.q at otrg+r- s'to ti frrn T$orft-qz-{ dor5rm sai-qrft rrqen u\ fr-l qan furmp.olzo23 dfr--{-€ q-qd 3ilqn-fi ;il frqrm-iul ;rfi fuqT r-qT, ilq sffiqrft rlcan wqE qR B ofqa ft-rTo ft.10.2023 et3il-iefi qeT q{ qfrflqd flffid nea o<sup>qqrFlf, ot,dIfu Hcnf{fctlzn w tqe g-flFra E\ ird of s-f,rqrfr ffiqvflen idt'i rlan d fr-s-€
10
\s. .iqs -sot /2024
u-rgf, frtn.ri or.q-ilfi 61 ftq-5-qur 6-r f,ut qeT o</sup> s-qfrrd fo-qr Bt
16.qRT 1e(e a) Erffig{e 2002 rroqBf, ftqq (3 a) wrSnfi $d{ 2002 durour+r5rrxni'r qan d fr-s-€ rrgo frd.ri orrqfu srql-ilfi qs frsn o-s qE qri qri w fu srqdEq {ffi qY'q c-sl t, ftd 'd {{{ Ftwd of qanoflqff<-{ elfrtr{rf, trs Eqq d 3l-ei u"fiqel o\ m1fu-d fu-qrqr+. 3TFrqrd tt {fu w q6-{q t w. ftffin nsq t of-ru"ft qeT gxr fr-'r vlan d ft-r-€q-rgd or.viilfi s-f,<-qrft frKftq vrcan o</sup> srw e\ goren, ilqsrql-ifi 6r sf,{ k{w18.10.2023 smncl t f,"fiqeT 6)Hqfrrd o{i d q{srd 3Trt ot oTffi ,klfr-a of =r{, w{daq o\ eqlFrd o-Ei or
11
vfl.q. iq{ -sot /2024
<tfr-d sorqrftseT o-I t,fu-g qqE +sd ftttE ot o{rr[q B r x"ftqeT d rrfrq-i q{ q-{ F{q-,-18.10.2023 ifti-t{dqY.{€ dqrgqq t nfril frt}qfi or ot$ qqTul r-S t I dl+fr of -n ffids-ffisrft qei irrgd r& frrqr,a-qoISqH dernm rN T6 3lBe-iqqE frw{ Tfr fus rloilr of*iiT rp++r dfr$--q q-{gf, 3rqinfi d frqqti fuqr.rqr M oil.iqoqa o]q-qfr-d fuqT Tqr, oTerfdqnt 13(e a)vravBo ftqq s (a) wdffi sd{ 2002 o-T sTcr=r fu-qrqrqr eqFlaq-S C't
17.zrqfr s-f,{qlfrqm iq-a fuqim te.to.zozs d ffqq t m.T q++ d fu-eu-rgo envfu 3rq-ifi fuqlo 11.10.2023 orftqrovq frtn qri o-r qfuqrE frtql B, fo-g fusqa or xfrqa o\ M-€{ e-i ot ot-$ qrrtq q d, ce qa erqdeq d s-<rq d vqti q+req ii c-frq.6r qT qcnil, oTarta q, fullo18.10.2023gtsfr--d vq rqnrerRoo-s qfrqrc qa d wq qrsq o-q tiqn r<sup>qa gTRW T&q-{rg qr {rf,-fto1 sf,{qrfrqqT fr qM r s (s e) rr{ffi Tf,e trdqBf, ftqq3 e cw+(ft sal zooz d oTr5lFrttngr+rmi@-t glctc fuqr t,3lerqr 3ilqfu o{qri{q 6r ftqm-rq fu-q t t
17.A qrf,ftq wrrrl -.{lqldq + ENT en{.4.m frfr|s tuwqote *ff fufu|s(zora) rs vs.fr.S. (3A) E.EqBn ftqq (3 n)qrr oild. €-qffii"e) sel 2002
12
gfl. . iqq -aot /zozt
d flsErii {qqq or elcrqffi(fuqr .rqT B I irgR E{flrkl Tm-{q ofqRRarfrrqj dv-or$ t E-(13Trar.{fi sltlETra o-l 3illler{ ffi-q tweiot t I qR qRRarfui tqs s-'rc *ilr E\ fu frrrdr-g dkc{d g-Rr GrareTT srqd<q w frqx ftrqrrrqr trcElxult oil.4{ur vqq{6-ri fuqFTqT t,a\ gc gMq tgs- qm-{q of qRRaTM w fuqx ftrqrqrq ,n\ tqTc-e sTqiqtflI of s-oqqrfr€tqn asl3il-i@ qet S 3ilqfu errqt-fi furf, 11.10.2023 dv-orcl t@t$ twer+qq Gqil6R fr;qr rrqr, ffi sUqH ftfrTdTrnr $-dq't str{qrfi frffiq cr{€n i3il.}efi qa o\ oi$ nqq-o qErq frrqr E\ t
13
\q. . iq{ -eot /2024
sooooooo/-(fi-{ 6ts)$q-} fuil-fi 31.03.2024o</sup> ,JTd'rc 6{i dq-{tq dqreT Tfi 5ffi vrrllEllq o-rtft qkil-q fu'qr, fu-tr fu toooooo/-(6n aro) rui +fi d qruzrq t q--{flIBa frrq t
re. q-qfr trf,{qrfrqeT gxr erqiqqrs dqfla{ qe ft=rI-fi 18.10.2023,+<riq fuqT rl-rlT B, q\ slklq d oil-iqoqel o\ iBo o-s ilft-f,fr-qr rlqT e, g*r f,erl o-t ot$qfl-or r€t B, frtg Ec{qa Riro n.10.2023 t s-f,q-qrfiqel gm oEs-or-eq 3il-}@ qa of 3rt t rrgo ftd.ri v-r<rq o\ sq-5tr c d{r tnrfi{ F.wd frrnqfi or vdofuqT t vqqrdfuf, *o xq {S-q_o aF-Gqrd clrrqr orqff,q t riqtrd o-{iof qEnE qlnefr qero\frT$t
14
gfl. q. iqc -sot /zoz+
srd.i-d 3ldfi u-rgofu-or, frqr qq enfrBo 3rrtqT R=tto 26.02.2024qrRd fuql trqr t I
21.gf,{qrfi sqar gxr fu{i-fi 18'10.2024 dnqo frrn.d @Rd E-c-qriorTilfi d qrqq t3Tdro ceT 6i a;rF-fi frrhrcs{qctrqt rrrrt tgq qt{ qdt-q{ Ttzi!-c fr=l-fi 10.10.2024€ffi{ o-{ 6000000o,z-(d o-tts) sq-} t orfUo of tT<Ttr EPIiff 'dt, fr-{ q\ qfrfl cr{fr zors t tr-d.i2023 a6qlfu6 erBqe{r ien, vrrd HRr ftd,ri zq of 6aaqert t noet-qT {flT Tfu.fi B gq orBffilT d orrtel ft=lo31.07.2024o-l qleiq ovt gr qrnffi qet i esooooo / - 1q-o o+sq-*-fl aru) vui furfkd c].wr firT tqEIT fifuqr t,Tq fuflql{ qRRerddr d e-+rqr fr 3lIiroqet o) @TF-f, frPT€r qfr @-6r on q16or I
15
t
vfl.q. iqs -sot /zozt
qqflrq qRr o-r roqfrcra sIEq + wti qqr r€t fu-qr .rfl B I {q qR{armt dqe eriqn e-{dr tof 3Tril{fi qeT f,q qeli o1q-q.rflflfr o\ Ri6R c-€t o-{ w t,fug ffinqRRerfui doxq s-f,qqrft frffi'q wqan d rrqe{gfi g{flT{qrErrl d qrtqq tuv fuqrE ot rfilrEIFI qrror B t
23.gre q6r f,-o sd.{rft vrcafl grqr 3ilt{flIlT a ftFqqm r g (4) qi+ffi v{e2oo2 d 3trd o1 T$ 6rffiq1 ltroro-t sc=I t, gs s<d n s-m-{-qTfr qer d wqrq d3T$Tri (\tffisns,/s)o- 3qs-q 3ilfiq-rq qq--fl fu{if, 2l.1o2oz3itrd fuqI qrqr q{flrffo tvq qm t+ wffi vf,c 2002 d3rd'fd 5weiBo q@e {d.{ dqrqraru q ffiq{zozz d f,rFrq srr}Eq u-rgf, frt} qri w otTerl ftFll-fi 26.02.2024qrRo gen t'dqq oiliffiqeT gM mrqan 6 ft-u< qiqfu 3T?qril({qr{r vpn R=noQ.08.2023R=iT6 16.08.2023 oi ilK 6-t 60 trqr] dGl({ R-{rfi11.10.2023 o\ }Rd o-q ft-q erT' ilq sfiI 3rqrilfi dqrqq tsETff ..T{ 3rT'qfu3lamr frt} .rd 3r-gs)q w q<sup>rX gq{ strs-drfr ffiqqr{arl t fr.qr, sn ftii Tn M o1 vpn zotqqT o\ 3ilq;ffi vrw *ig 15 ftersA sTEr olfrf, -rq-r 3n$6qfi er gq orBfi-{tT d v+qm rlcnRfaqflq+teq r\ qE gqrFra o-{cl el of olqti(q 61 faq@-{ur otwqtr'o fu-qi .rqr B,
16
Tfl: .iqq -sot /zoza
fu-g Err frq-q fi u-+lor d3ril-s tt 3lfuo-iuT Errftw-s w vizr B o1 s-f,i_qrfr riserT i3T.q-rnfi otfrqroqq o-q oil-if,oqeT o<sup>q-qfu-d o61 foat,erqto ensr. o Hsilr\ mlq-flq ftt$ frqT uoftqel dfr-s-€ umr s (+) q{Sffi vf,c 2002 d trn GrrDq-c,q qafl ftqrfi za.to. 2023 (qi-ffi 3rR,/5) iBo fr-fiqrqr, oTelcl-l qxt M rl$;ifr v+e d 3r-f,.i-d gw <rfuoqfree {d--{ d T+reT 3il-nF !-{gd o-{srTtqr Rql?D 26.02.2024qlw Cr\ frD' ft-s-€ fuqrqFrr +,lqql6l t, d Relq rdqri si.qr&Bl
2s. sqtffiqFtd qRRaTfuf d s-{TYr tsrko-qq ot qo t of qq oil-iffi qet ftri .ri m"r qn q-qrqilt {S-mi-i o{ T6t t, {d fr fi \rfi3-if, HEIIEIIq v-rorq ftqt ft-fl@ 18.03.202s o<sup>-tt 35oooo00/-(fto-tr-s v-am eru) sq$ o-t wFIIEIFIq-wro frqr, eE aoftqeI o-r vfigwvTTTEIFIqkil-s fr qpaq tm"r fuqrq o-r vtrlEtFl oG orGrcrcN fr-f,rTqTR, iT sf,c-qrfr ffiqsT{an qR q-iffi qet d r{rnEtl;t trkttq dqFfd qrfu ofqrx
77
vfl. . iqt -gor /zozq
r\ irge r-tr t, d\ ftfu--f,qe drlltrl-tt t mrftqsT .h</sup> sqRYffi vrRr aar rkrcr ti ig vrare frqr c-fifr t Ts ,3il-i@rTeT q{ q6 qrfud EiTI of n-fl-XtlRtrwrBdRIRT t gkcDq {{rtTETl=I Il-kllci dgrq qrd-S \rqq{q{ d orjsq roqfrcrf, 31ft1qqryov qkil-q u-tgn ot, e+uto oil-i<oqel o\ qq--dq 6q[6 o-t GI.NN xq fuil-E oT ilrllEl l-l Tfi 5-WT{qrtTI-q q-Kilcr dqrurq R\ o-{i tg kqrqqr sBf, E)=n I fu-dqR qs Gmft q mufuqrq q,-T qqrEr-q rfr d srflI, aq s-orqrfr rlqedt ol sTIn{f,TsT d fa-{-€ Sql ftqTw +Es iBo o-q orlt o1 orffi o-{i of so.xor #ft t
st.oz. 27. 3rriqoqet iGTBEF-Iq +3rTtqr ffi zozq dq-qffi ii tzsooooo / - 19f, o-trs u.ffu aru) uqi rnqr fuqT t I $lqfl vrRr w s-f,.qrft t-o or of$qr"nflfox rfr t, fu=g srq or-iffigeT uqqdFII
18
'fl.q. i{t -361/zoz+
qrf,flt t, oq sffi-{qrfi riqpn o\ f{tRriftrqr qror B ot orBowT d urtwrSs-nqfl qrRr qqr Riro r\ Xau-< d qqrqtffi-a o-i, E-{rgqRqro ofrrq=Il 6-t qffiqc {tzt!-c dqrwq t3s @-rd ft-qq d otil {6-rqr f,ur {ft ofqmmr€l snrrel o-sr trnt
sIRq 3il-ePT
2s. srri-fil-5qrxfr-il{rT t3il-}@ qeT gRI tr{gf, gs.q. eqt-Fraqro-q ffiorsof qrft tvq ftqrgili 3iRq oTrtcTY-Erq fttqr qrot t '-
(r):- vorofi sj{ergRT iEf, fr-'T r1++ tr+ro 12.08.2023olrrr{d of qrfr B t
(z):- vor+rftqiqar awrnfr-o 3rTftq'q {fl--fl ft=lo 28.i0.2023ftB gq qfraff d ffi-a eqftd d-fi{ Rfr-dd-i tsrqrw of qrft t t
(s),- 5@q-fuo, qmz E-disxr qrRf, flteT furl@26.02.2024frls gq qfu-qr d frqfi-o qtq 3rrtrl Eti c]3lqrfl fuqr qror t t
(+),-qrieo s&T 6'1 6 qra A 3iE1 -oXlfl rrqptt=Iq{fltl d qrtqq tmq ft=qrq 6l ft-irfr-i"T o{i ot gEqTq-flq o1 srft t t
(s):- enil<oqeT gm 3TEflur d srTtPT Rllo 3j07.2024 frq-6q ii rnqr 01 .r{ sl.RI tzsoo0o0/-(vfi
19
Tfl.q. iqq -sot /zozq
orisq-d-fl aru) uwirrqr frqioo\ e-an-qr tflT{fr q{qfrftra 6t t
(o):- a-<rgrmqro ofrl-ur{l 6-{ sorqrftrrcaTr 3il-i@qer o\ Et{q-dtq-i {tztn-cailTffi so o-rd frqsr d or-fl sqra o-t{n Ic1.f,q{qrd 3Ir}@ qet ts e-cn-rqlglRr d frw frq-+1rf, qrlEllq rftilcl s-qf, o'{ s-drrlI
(z):- uR Gil-rtrft oqrd @tor-qB g 7qfoor< o-T vrrnEIFIg+Irf,qlrlElt=T trcdl-q sTqta 3ilqrfr gam t q-fi E\ qrflT, att vf,{qrfr rrqen o\ sIEo-r"T d 3rirulixqqi srRr o\ Tf,er<q rlqlqtf,-{ d qrqro tq --'frT d frq-q t ds Rq-sq}trfl }Bo o-sls-qffi $-dT 2oo2 A Hsflr\ Tq s-{ffis-tr 2oo2 6 Pwi ot Fa-rcr *qraq ord E\ @lffio-{t hl{qd-rcll frftt
d^ ( ? (vm ft-qrqq--d) {9T;I:_ w6tst3( ffiqoTlffi ftqi-fi:-17.04.202s(E-d-tfl-d vsqq) E-qds{
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
