Shailendra Singh Solanki S/o. Shri Manohar Singh Solanki v. Punjab National Bank

DRT20 Aug 2024SA/686/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

PAGE No.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

CASE No

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	V{T.q.686/^zozz
I 20.08.202	Gilt-86 serdfr\frkiqTEMre erflfq-ffirt B-nrqrftt-frdfuq&ft3rffi-n dr€qsrfltrrmrI 1.srrqsq{6}fr-f,qflrII^{Gil-ilqqGil{q} ss2l/2ozs,Hq)tr{Gilffi^eil-$q3337/zozq gqfitrtrterTtEqdfrq-'q{urgdfuoqerqr Gtttfis71o/zoz+^q{UTt^.rqrtt ,2.^{gcFqut.F-rGt-q-dtfi-aftrqTrrqT} I 3.^qrtqTfuilm23.08.202sd^Gr-q-dt-fr-{t lwur^{r{irth1fu-f,Tq-slffitErr{gRIqrkd} I^{et<rTfu{rfi01.08.2022d frq-qfr}"Ifr'r$ I^{v-uuortgrD{uIGmtsolf}nFufRnfuqT} I^vrT+r^{t,fuEerTDqFq{q-qTd frq-qq} {fiFrfiqro-t^qq=IB-f,{qrft^qe{cilqqtl q-txn E)-idq{qrnfrqi{'Tfg dR(ssT .riltt
	4.s-f,rqr*sef^gmfuitq.o3.1o.zo2soi Tf,^{yi1q.@lsiltlq-{gf,fuqTET g-fiTt I}
	5.31arB-f,rqrft^ge{dFrqIualrqd^rrler frqqa(r)vw$ffisd{d^{qrsqq qFfd} GrTiq!-.qrFqTofe-fri{drr=rSof^q-$t, fu..Js-{gf,t{d rtBqfurm22.02.202s^q frrnTS^q"hdergrrr<uni13(+)dG{-fl.17 errfq!-.qtiorkaTo08.10201a^qFlotr 6.B-f,{qrftseTofGil(tfudEeirTr 3il-ifio-l Yerr^q.ilclfuqq-20.10.2023o) q-{gf,fu-qTl-ilt,fuTrdqrqqtGrrqfufr

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

GASE No

¶7

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER .dtof frdIfre qNdvrqeTdBn ffrffifr^{etltE-6qetsqRero}E3TT,^frtgfrx rft rlrrq{fiqTdGiilecn{uT^{eTgf,qfrftrqt} s-s^{3{TETrttl{frEqqrrlT3{r}fi frwflfrtn} qfio-fGrgtqfu-qT^rrrlTtrHTarfr^q-{gf, gsq.G{-qB^qlflfafrqfRdo-{^ftErdfrtnqri oreqtufrtqT^rrqrt^t t. gfufi'qnaqTdtof^qRfrt{ft qrEo-rEqdfrqqii^qrryqfiqTd^3i-flFnsut sigf,oYkqT^{rFITE,Tq qr+ftqq'g'v@} alr{rErq EI{T qrErfiTo,qr.D, 14010/zozq ffi frf6 .fr.ErsRFr ffrtues frulq^ffiro, s1.or.2024at
o.Fsor 12t of^{-r{qrcrlTd crTfl*} erTEq-fl{1ant^vflTqrqo-Ku oTffi^ecFfr{f,{^{qql{iaTt ffi} era.Iffl qrqrf,{trfuoqorffi^qKo-{qe1^frrd-{d-l qrftq[qa-ftt,fuE^g.sscn{ul^q "1 srD!-il^{{1aqTfu{Io08102018t rrqfn}I vq^{Gili-{fiqeTd grurTsqfurfrzs'ot'zozl} o\fu-dTffie qRgrgrqIRn^qTtYTR-"1 o1.og.2oz2t^{gfl-Tqr<elrutd sTTEiI(} '1 u-rgoof^T{,fu-n&^{q$vsrrtYTftrqm}"l or.iond^{sITt+N3i-{tsilts(frqtRnof}9 gfttt^gqfudT^{q@esTNsrtql-kde3} ;frTqd^{frEqerrlTfrtSqH@-ttil} Gi-{S_fiNfttqTw^{gflt,ilqfrttftfirr-dql} tgsd-qo^{seTgrrqETnqrrrrq{fiqr} 1 stEq^q-frt^t I

DATE
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
.dtof frdIfre
qNdvrqeTdBn
ffrffifr^{etltE-6qetsqRero}E3TT,^frtgfrx
rft rlrrq{fiqTdGiilecn{uT^{eTgf,qfrftrqt}
s-s^{3{TETrttl{frEqqrrlT3{r}fi frwflfrtn}
qfio-fGrgtqfu-qT^rrrlTtrHTarfr^q-{gf,
gsq.G{-qB^qlflfafrqfRdo-{^ftErdfrtnqri
oreqtufrtqT^rrqrt^t
t.
gfufi'qnaqTdtof^qRfrt{ft
qrEo-rEqdfrqqii^qrryqfiqTd^3i-flFnsut
sigf,oYkqT^{rFITE,Tq qr+ftqq'g'v@}
alr{rErq
EI{T
qrErfiTo,qr.D,
14010/zozq
ffi
frf6
.fr.ErsRFr
ffrtues frulq^ffiro,
s1.or.2024at

o.Fsor
12t of^{-r{qrcrlTd crTfl*}
erTEq-fl{1ant^vflTqrqo-Ku
oTffi^ecFfr{f,{^{qql{iaTt ffi}
era.Iffl
qrqrf,{trfuoqorffi^qKo-{qe1^frrd-{d-l
qrftq[qa-ftt,fuE^g.sscn{ul^q
"1
srD!-il^{{1aqTfu{Io08102018t rrqfn}I
vq^{Gili-{fiqeTd grurTsqfurfrzs'ot'zozl}
o\fu-dTffie
qRgrgrqIRn^qTtYTR-"1
o1.og.2oz2t^{gfl-Tqr<elrutd sTTEiI(}
'1
u-rgoof^T{,fu-n&^{q$vsrrtYTftrqm}"l
or.iond^{sITt+N3i-{tsilts(frqtRnof}9
gfttt^gqfudT^{q@esTNsrtql-kde3}
;frTqd^{frEqerrlTfrtSqH@-ttil}
Gi-{S_fiNfttqTw^{gflt,ilqfrttftfirr-dql}
tgsd-qo^{seTgrrqETnqrrrrq{fiqr}
1
stEq^q-frt^t
I

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER .dtof frdIfre qNdvrqeTdBn ffrffifr^{etltE-6qetsqRero}E3TT,^frtgfrx rft rlrrq{fiqTdGiilecn{uT^{eTgf,qfrftrqt} s-s^{3{TETrttl{frEqqrrlT3{r}fi frwflfrtn} qfio-fGrgtqfu-qT^rrrlTtrHTarfr^q-{gf, gsq.G{-qB^qlflfafrqfRdo-{^ftErdfrtnqri oreqtufrtqT^rrqrt^t t. gfufi'qnaqTdtof^qRfrt{ft qrEo-rEqdfrqqii^qrryqfiqTd^3i-flFnsut sigf,oYkqT^{rFITE,Tq qr+ftqq'g'v@} alr{rErq EI{T qrErfiTo,qr.D, 14010/zozq ffi frf6 .fr.ErsRFr ffrtues frulq^ffiro, s1.or.2024at
o.Fsor 12t of^{-r{qrcrlTd crTfl*} erTEq-fl{1ant^vflTqrqo-Ku oTffi^ecFfr{f,{^{qql{iaTt ffi} era.Iffl qrqrf,{trfuoqorffi^qKo-{qe1^frrd-{d-l qrftq[qa-ftt,fuE^g.sscn{ul^q "1 srD!-il^{{1aqTfu{Io08102018t rrqfn}I vq^{Gili-{fiqeTd grurTsqfurfrzs'ot'zozl} o\fu-dTffie qRgrgrqIRn^qTtYTR-"1 o1.og.2oz2t^{gfl-Tqr<elrutd sTTEiI(} '1 u-rgoof^T{,fu-n&^{q$vsrrtYTftrqm}"l or.iond^{sITt+N3i-{tsilts(frqtRnof}9 gfttt^gqfudT^{q@esTNsrtql-kde3} ;frTqd^{frEqerrlTfrtSqH@-ttil} Gi-{S_fiNfttqTw^{gflt,ilqfrttftfirr-dql} tgsd-qo^{seTgrrqETnqrrrrq{fiqr} 1 stEq^q-frt^t I

Shailendra Singh Solanki S/o. Shri Manohar Singh Solanki versus Punjab National Bank — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶13

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER 8. s-f,{q-rftt-o^gMsn-qd^qruqqt fr^.dqrqo-ffidor1irt{etrfi.rlq-fumt Gil-fuq-n{ffi offiF{ffi24.03. 2023dIFIrutt ffi ddTslhf,^qfl=Ie<br>furm06.0r.2023o\TJtqI^qlg-+rt,^slafd qr4-fua1ffi offrfuqm24.03.2023 srFEgitVqffi ddTo\sq-fufuou of^qrg.htt,TqGnilto^qeTdfrq^Gnqr{ff eno1rflDdEiffio-Iffikffi24.0s.
2023dfrYqd{firrrfiqrdGrc{^go-{q I q-{gdcnrdT,fuEgrrqfl.q.frqcrot$ ,ft
'i3s27/zozsTSffT{TErfu-qTqIrrcndlI I aqtStJIt ^q6ftqfRnfu-qT^qrnTt I^{o1srnEo.smvn..wurofu-dTqffie} qRdRIqr-RaqrtyTfu{ro01.08.2022wsq=I t^q,tTd^qrfudGrrtvTkim^23oa2023d GrgrTiGrc-f}erifnfrqiR-dofurg+ttvq
9TRT^{13(+)d Grf,.fdnBdGIrfD!-.q{1arT} F{rro-08012o1Bdfrq-q^q-frGTq-fUilB-at vq^{Grdiqt-fu-ar+Elqrlr,B\Grg{TrFrfr{r6rq-flT} t,i\ecnwrsrGrcrtfu-nfrrd^q-ritg{frl.rr qrqo-r{ulslwrfrEYf,r,GT?dfdgn&-frseT
gTvte-r5dgflqGilterM-q-{ql'.qq-Str
10. w6l ilh-s-{gdfu-qT^rr-qTHYirr<
oil-ic{3337/zozqdlttqqt ffi WqT

¶18

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	fuim^{24.03.2023e\gitftti@-lqqilq-{} e-{flrBd frrqT^rrqTtW^ffi dffio<br>qach-Rq-{dqfioTs{-gq)ETfuqrTqltI{s s-fi-{uT^tism^rlgitr{xur^{dqq(ffqn frtt} q.riqtqEfrtroxq atfrt{ft'ft^{r6rmlT tgrrrtt^{{fiqTd 3iilTtl,g.srgf,Efrfrtql} .rqrtt 11. sffiIft;qrfrd^{r+reT3ril{trqeTgl-{l} qqf, ttq)tr{ uttfi 3337/zo2+,^{€Frq .iltq{ 3712/zoz+,frEq^flrII3il-}qE z71o/zozq^{GrfrFfdd-gqrfrt r q-Rqfuqr} q6*seTffi orffitr{rff^24.03.202? o\g+fttifu^{{qilqecr{ulq-{gnfuqI} Tq{firtt{fiqt^{o-tqmgtTqfqq{fr"n"flt} €ilt 12 sffiftqufrd^{vnq3rd-{frqelgq} e-{gf, t'{i^qaeo/^{20233i-{B q-fkaFrfR!} 6{d EqE€{n{^{q{frwnofqr-ftt t} 13 grrugeT3ttrfl3Ftr;TI^qq ottr 14. qfoTIqqddtrrwl qr3rfHdrslqEI I .r}d) ffi-{ erfffi S.sm.fr^q.q.F^u-ffi-s'l-6

Shailendra Singh Solanki S/o. Shri Manohar Singh Solanki v. Punjab National Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Vijay Kumar Daswani versus Dhfl

State Bank of India versus Ms Dwarkadhish Seeds

State Bank of India versus Lakhan Jat

Mohan Lal Patel versus Assets Care

Shailendra Singh Solanki S/o. Shri Manohar Singh Solanki v. Punjab National Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Vijay Kumar Daswani versus Dhfl

State Bank of India versus Ms Dwarkadhish Seeds

State Bank of India versus Lakhan Jat

Mohan Lal Patel versus Assets Care

Rupesh Saraf versus Aditya birla Huosing Finance Ltd.

Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited versus M/S Narayan Construction Company