Mohan Lal Patel v. Assets Care

DRT20 Aug 2024SA/648/2024

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No.

CASE No......

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	11.q648/ZOZq
20.08.2024	Gra-q6^qeTdfr\frTtlq dq^3{k{firTt sf,{qrftverrSqRerfl^I B-f,q-qrft^qeTo\nftqr^fuqrrrqll 1.slII[^qeTcfrtrq^{erqT3nilfi42s1}/^ZOZq dv+rercilf,Rq^{vrgr{rf,Td iq-gq{}Eql^{rrqrt I} 2.^{ql"Iftq rT.q.wtqFlrarq srffid{<YqQ} gSTETNTf, qrEror@qtEF 16e33/ 2024d6;rmrd qed StdI ErsRi.r fufuas^{qqrRn oTrtqrk{ro 01qnr{ zozqfr} sfr^q-{gdq,t.r$t,^{ftffi-d3i-{f,to-qt qril} qraTtfuflTftqBzq^qTzlTaFId^grqr3n}ffi seTof^q-rtr-fiTo{s^{srlurxq{ft-Eqf,fu-qlt} +ten-iqo^qsT{tT^{GIBfr-wTd vrqel}Tfl.g^trKlrI fuqTt,fuE^{ntrfr"q Bzq;qEilEr{id gKI} Gilt-ffisefo\Grato'r$dIq^.rSkqTTqT, sTQrfd^qo{uiq-{gf,o_{it^{gsfrtrq o\RTlqd} q-fifuqTrrqTt,eTerfd{serfuorqrTo){q gcnqqof ffiqaTqtl^qg{{'qflqvqr<br>ftqiRd^znrqlB^r 3.sorqr-ft^qeTd^{sqReTdrfrEliq{wFTUI} yfiqeftqwtryr^.rwtr 4.fr-dq^{&rtiTsil-nq{3rr$g.4137}/^zozqd r+rer^qifu-f,3ffi^{T{.arrrf,T51ftqrfiq-ftrqqr} wtt s.Gilt-{f,^qeTgMfu{b^{2s.06.2024o\gTRI} 17(1)rrffi^gre2oozd^{sTq'effi\d ff-nqa} 1'flqfr.r^{qriTR=no21.os.zo1ld qTsIfu-f,T} qNetqrsgrgrq-kastTarTfuilo-20.03.201s o\erqrE+frti^qdofe-auortg^q-{gofuqT .rqrtgqrogqq-qd a-{ifr gvfu-d-qo\erqr frTastrgqr WI srfilc

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

Mohan Lal Patel versus Assets Care — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶8

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	frt$urt tgyQrfiGidftqsltfi err$q 413t/zou^q-{gdfuql^.rq[tt 6.fr--f,qer+rTsr-nw^qrTT€qGTTETT(te1 srrfefi^qeTddqq-firsreo\ trvWierffit vqfrq^qrtr-qo6rdrrdqrTnBdof^.dvq rlr{r1+rrqdifrwd20ozdorilrfds{Tifis-*gd fu-qTTqT,f,+Esil-nefisefs)Gilt(mdquy tqRTdvrqad-k-aU-{-{dmrolgrYtrn qrq q-SEil,cre-fueiltEEseTxurrtdrqTqrrortI sfiBqtrqt^gfiT{flvrqTqr-q^q-Fnqt smrqrftorqfrdrrrrefsqgdfuqTTqT,fuE ot$E6ntr=TfrfrdTIrk.f,TrqrflGil-ieos&Tol- Fil-{vmrsu-dvorqrfr@-qtzn2isorqr-ft @q-rfrro)FTHrhro-{ftil.,dqsTrA-q-qrrq-6Rr 16,10,000,/-Fnf,6drGIer+rwv)Fq-idcFlFI frqto-s FtH;cdutrqrtt qflfuqTTzrT,^p)q grRTfrq-qo-q=rrqrrortt 7.3iltefrseT^qrGrfto.emtoffu{io-03.06. 2024@)G6l31ilq-mrluTe111q-fu^q-qqlpfl R-{m31.0s.2024^q$ltfu,il- Tqt,mIGil-ilnfi-q-ul o)3rTteTffi-q;zo.o3.2o1so-rflqEGn, Tq fuimrc.06.2024or^{qqrFroq-ftftfuqlwqr-{i} igGn+fie-{gf,fu-qr,fuT^qqRiro14.06.2024 o)v-RfrBurwg{,m.dqr-ura^qcn{ursrgf,fu-qT rrql IilT3TttTT(wfuoqefi-tqr{gcFTUIg"Tqiq wgiwrioiGrSirrfu-qT^.rqrtr B.nft.B-f,rqrftse{{f,d{rilffi d^qrq qWftq-orfl.tsHo-r{ursr}E-frseTdsrTtEq gqYFraTqadsu-srtot{f,sggtffi{qw q-Str
	e.^qrRdGIrtrTR=im20.03.201soTemdtfiq m-{^qrq[qrflIt^qft.a"ft^qero] o-{sngd

¶12

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
fuqT wIT^erTI^{zLTftqeTd Ergrfr=Iro15'01 '201e} o\u-+rq^q-{gdfuqTI^{\n-{rqd qtqqt}Td^o1 ft{fl3^qrdd^{3tqqqeHmloarqm{tgq} qBqzhtfrxflrrrrq^q{qdriof^erf,ofr'T-{ t ere-o:slI{t^qeTo'rs-flr{^{o-l3ltNNtfl3{rtqT} k{rfi20.03.2019^{qTKfuqTtrqrt r} 'r0.^qETecD3ili-ffsq{C^{ailteTo-tSl=l} q-6-ftqR Fq-re{^q}Bflfu{i-tr^21o5:024d qrqrTtEtto-tsrqt,^gsfrEqfr^qsftoor qotofslslTiqo sHsTtNe-ef,c{t{rs^d vlrrsTdFq-floTffi^{tsqRerf,E\g-+leIIgq} wfltl^{q-{gdfrtq-ITqT,ilq3iliffis&Te-tq6} qlfuf,enatsiRq3rTtql^qrRf,i^a-oFF{,I a1frfDru\of^{ETTmT-fr{sdTYq3IRqsrtaT} qftdi t+skqrrdsiqr^sTBo-wTd^rrqeT e-*-(qs-{Ef,^srdTI^{qRetr}eos&{C g-{qr$} ot+EsTS^{fr-mTEYf,l,3Tltffis&Tsrtn} q,-iflcqt-qrsd tsqRerf,EfrEGl. -q lqlflq E'ril.,f,q^{qRRaftft-qEYfi,fuE}Eq-{r$^o-l Grc-{Nto{u,t^{qeTfttB-TR€TfrcdorqIRf,} sTerTdfr-s-€fuirfi^{20.03.201et 3il-ilnfi-rl-urd} frq!rE"TEt{r^{qrflql+qT,3Tef-a3ilt-ffissTo-l} q6ild{ffi qt.-q q-Stfu3rlil{oTuTm<br>q-6-frer(GnAeTo-lgrartBflkilo21.05.2024 d^qruqqt^gent^t it.s-u<rost-iffi^{seTznlo\qaa-dt fu} ll.rrlanfutl-fi^{21.05.2014i corfr}'Ti^iTRTd or-f,.fde-f,22,oo,oo07-(er{T{^aro)sq-n fr-.q-ft-qdrfuit^frqn-sFls--c^{dff{q t} wrrTorkqTt,n<sup>gsfrEqi^gsfrsorqot at^qRfrqT^rrqTmq^qd-{filr"li5rTf,l-{^zF( Ril.,frt{^.ftfrr-flY-ddBea/ffi'q^lT{er

DATE
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER

REMARK

fuqT wIT^erTI^{zLTftqeTd Ergrfr=Iro15'01 '201e}
o\u-+rq^q-{gdfuqTI^{\n-{rqd qtqqt}Td^o1
ft{fl3^qrdd^{3tqqqeHmloarqm{tgq}
qBqzhtfrxflrrrrq^q{qdriof^erf,ofr'T-{
t
ere-o:slI{t^qeTo'rs-flr{^{o-l3ltNNtfl3{rtqT}
k{rfi20.03.2019^{qTKfuqTtrqrt r}
'r0.^qETecD3ili-ffsq{C^{ailteTo-tSl=l}
q-6-ftqR Fq-re{^q}Bflfu{i-tr^21o5:024d
qrqrTtEtto-tsrqt,^gsfrEqfr^qsftoor
qotofslslTiqo sHsTtNe-ef,c{t{rs^d
vlrrsTdFq-floTffi^{tsqRerf,E\g-+leIIgq}
wfltl^{q-{gdfrtq-ITqT,ilq3iliffis&Te-tq6}
qlfuf,enatsiRq3rTtql^qrRf,i^a-oFF{,I
a1frfDru\of^{ETTmT-fr{sdTYq3IRqsrtaT}
qftdi t+skqrrdsiqr^sTBo-wTd^rrqeT
e-*-(qs-{Ef,^srdTI^{qRetr}eos&{C g-{qr$}
ot+EsTS^{fr-mTEYf,l,3Tltffis&Tsrtn}
q,-iflcqt-qrsd
tsqRerf,EfrEGl.
-q lqlflq
E'ril.,f,q^{qRRaftft-qEYfi,fuE}Eq-{r$^o-l
Grc-{Nto{u,t^{qeTfttB-TR€TfrcdorqIRf,}
sTerTdfr-s-€fuirfi^{20.03.201et 3il-ilnfi-rl-urd}
frq!rE"TEt{r^{qrflql+qT,3Tef-a3ilt-ffissTo-l}
q6ild{ffi
qt.-q q-Stfu3rlil{oTuTm<br>q-6-frer(GnAeTo-lgrartBflkilo21.05.2024
d^qruqqt^gent^t
it.s-u<rost-iffi^{seTznlo\qaa-dt fu}
ll.rrlanfutl-fi^{21.05.2014i corfr}'Ti^iTRTd
or-f,.fde-f,22,oo,oo07-(er{T{^aro)sq-n
fr-.q-ft-qdrfuit^frqn-sFls--c^{dff{q t}
wrrTorkqTt,n<sup>gsfrEqi^gsfrsorqot
at^qRfrqT^rrqTmq^qd-{filr"li5rTf,l-{^zF(
Ril.,frt{^.ftfrr-flY-ddBea/ffi'q^lT{er

¶18

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	sril{fiT.Tdfrs-€ ei-jhf,^qq-{qrt{r^qofi or {frt,aY\rBdrq^q{slqvq^tiRrf,rqc ed6rrfr^qIrrfiftt,fuE{s^GTkf,{uTe) qr{fi(r)r{ffiv{dzoo2+offior{Tq qfiqTfrsiws-{gnfrr}qtrhwlqfrErq'd o-{Tr6rrrilTEr=ro{io1Efrtt{flEMrt tmr eiltqo^qeTgmru-{gf,frriTns-fi-{ur-ⁱ qrfu-d rr6r{raTmrqfterqfuqTqril,a}fu-dr q@etqrflgrrqr-Rdstqrfu{ro.2o.os.2o1s t vil<^qrqm-Rqtgfum2s.06.2024o) q-{gf,fuqTq-qTrnwrG{-fl-Bor{rrq{ft'qTt qTtsntSqffi-q cn-qg^qTp-nrnRIfiqro] mfloriorot$ sfuf,\qECss{fron'r$ t,ecrsil-iqos&Tofstmt^q-{gdfuf,ql errnc{^,r-dfrs"rrql-fr^qeTsqRerf,TtiEGr,ill fr{fio.xTSfuqT^qTqchnrIo-xqot^qTTfil r?zrilq^qrcrrrqd^ggtsffi{o}-erqte{ grcfuqeMftrfu&fus-€rft'rSffi (zors)ovs.fr.fr.+tzdscn{ulti^qrqrs^qqld srtsB-'qqfrt^qrsrTmrigq^qnerlfr^.r$q fu-f,wt^q-{gdqTE,srftd,Grnfifrrwfu! qT{TqIEg,,r-dfrmfis&Tivl'RIfiqTq srrqfu^qsorfrdt{sERtssfr -o! B^q,ts-qD erfua^qrEtnrwrd^GnqRw^u-rgi qdg{i.q.g'T CEwgtufiq}'qq.f[t\f fu-dq&IEIToiliwrfifl{ m^qdero)! GTTrrr{c-frtt tz.srftrrsrls-{gdGIf,Rq^str}qq4137/^zozt oIIqTr&-{^qtEyfr-wflfuqT\ilrflIt'rrJIetr€ oiltffi^qeiHM^q-t1decn{utGt-qD^qrDnfrufk 6-{igq$ftr+{^q{fr.{wfu-qT^qrort^t

Mohan Lal Patel v. Assets Care

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Vijay Kumar Daswani versus Dhfl

State Bank of India versus Ms Dwarkadhish Seeds

State Bank of India versus Lakhan Jat

Shailendra Singh Solanki S/o. Shri Manohar Singh Solanki versus Punjab National Bank

Mohan Lal Patel v. Assets Care

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Vijay Kumar Daswani versus Dhfl

State Bank of India versus Ms Dwarkadhish Seeds

State Bank of India versus Lakhan Jat

Shailendra Singh Solanki S/o. Shri Manohar Singh Solanki versus Punjab National Bank

Rupesh Saraf versus Aditya birla Huosing Finance Ltd.

Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited versus M/S Narayan Construction Company