Ms Shrawan Kumar Agrawal v. Punjab National Bank

DRT4 Mar 2024SA/1130/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

¶1

. CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶2

CASE No.

¶3

DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER DATE	REMARK
8{tl-qEqT{sTqrItEI fr-sq qqrqtgr.rf,il6 T{.9.1130/zs
eniffiseTdfrqfreT&rrrwtn srB{ffi1 04.
sncqrfrt6dfu+ft+{sg} uB+51I
1.s+Fr^qeTo\fr--f,qerqrGil-ifisn-$q 6186/zozttfirfr$.12.2023dHIpjI{eF[q srrilfierr$.qsoo/2024^q{Eqr^.rqrtt 2.IrrDwIorerqdtfi-{fuqr^rrqt I
3.Gil-nqrs&TFrgrfu{r6fi.12.2023ot elttrfi(1)sffigdd2ooz+sr+rT-nd
ci-f,.i(^q6rFwIerTfucqqffTT,*FRFT furimoz.ot.2o2a(td{fi/)dr^cilTrkT frrn^qrio1sarcrordvlpreruquiFto
trarrrdTig rqf,fuqr^.rqrtIrDwIs-{gf, o{t^tigvfunqCennfrti^qfi&^g*r-n en{q6186/zozzRqi-fi18.12.2023C{fl
orrErr-{^qrrqf,fu-qT^.rqrtofsT-il{frto A^gM*ii-r{qnifta frtt^fr--rT{ftt} erTfuqgr{firortwII.F'RI=Ifu{i-6^02.07. zozse\T$^gfrqTsrl=IR^{q.{n ovrfrqr} rrfl	dqwqrasrTAEo^q&Tsf,{qrftt-frfr dfrtqrww{ffirr^{11.01.2023}fuf,} fu-qr,fus^q{sil-{fl-s{RqT^trqro1-orsrd
ffid^?F{ftqT^qItTI,fuEt-oHRI^frd
fuffi qq-qTsorQrooqfr.r$tE-€

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No.

CASE No

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER INfuf,q&TfltFTTfi{UIYT q( Ei^{qrio-rsi-gtqfuurrr+rt r} 4.{{{rfi{q^{frsrf,rcrfts8rgMq}d
Tf,^{oiltfio-r\ilnqs-{gdfuqT.rqrt TS}
fuia..qemreil-ifio-rfufud^q{rqs-{gd
fuqT^rrcr-tt,fuE dfufrildd^qturrrt oil-qfufrT$tetTn.q.Gi-qB^qrftilt, U,T^{dqw giqfifr.qq-St r}
s.Gn-ilEoseTHRrr6wr+dk-arri ddmq er.Frsilte{sao/2024rtg-f,or sn^qTfrt-6HRrnRd{+n:ftrdqqT
fumor.o1.2oz4d^qrtqqqmiftoft1^.r$
{ ffi qrffi frffi01.02.2024o} rerFrofrrtufiorqr\ufuql^.rqrtr
6.s-orqrfttoargrdfu-fiwt^qlirq
o-rfutqo{tEqild{sT^rr-rl-t'tftt\ncr Tf,^{Grla-fiGrqfuqrBf,t,Grp;q-qern<E}
g"r <Nwgtud^q-).qrfrtr
7.eQrrkr:3il-i@srTft1 3il(t^q-{gd frrS^.rifre,qerrroiltfielr-$q
6186/zozeflftgrfiwrfu-qTwwtI
8.^qTiffiqeTdgMr$gd1ou-owrd
cr+drmqtwEtfusf,rqrft t-6Hrqr
GiltnosrqqEqNorqtntTdfr-sqqglfi
gqfuq{rgr+{r23s4/zouGsflqr *
frHc^qqrrqdsq+rfrffifi qror EqilSffi^qri&s6rprda1^.rgGil-Bqrq
{q-qT^{ftqlm02.07.2023}TiSfuTfranrrgq
Hwwd^qpTRrR36rqrqo-Rurtg
Ts.q.fu68.12.2023Cwgdet.r$t,
q)qemEq-qrGmBilp-atr

Ms Shrawan Kumar Agrawal versus Punjab National Bank — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶12

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
9. geT Td 4 ttA-6qoTo-xursdfudfuqT.rqrtftt qr{r^q-6TRrd*i dswtcroil-nrnsqT ffiFIET B-f,{q-TfrTfi-dTfiIETTfiI]ETFIfu'TE lfiro11.07.2023wgdfuqt,fuT{^rN sf,aqrfttf, d^grgrTrrTEIrq^zn-t3TIEINT=I kqT^rrrrTIEfio-t{uTrrwrrrgd^znrit fuf,q $nI^qfrs-r{qfrffierflGrCfifr qqfqrrrqrtt
10.ffi-602.07.2023o\trfiTRrd^otTfuq. rdqqTo-r^grq3il-t(6^qqTo\frRqdw t fttqio11.01.2023d^q-6-AEf^qFTIrTI;IT
qri-r,or{urqfiGt@(Itz)olq.{ gf,.qrft to.dTfit&Tfurm11.07.2023ot s-rgdfu-qTuFII^qrqTq[ilt,ffi qnqq teil-iqq-^qe{i^qm-fqrRIRTCso^{qftpl-f, q} t-eao{io-tGrjtqfu-qt,ai^qRfuilo. 11.07.2023t^qKE-r{utrqqTot,^q},rq^,fr erTt{o.^qmo\gseTkfrwTdsqeTfu{r6 26.08.2023ffiFrFwI^qqdoqtqr^qT,fuE lffio13.12.2023CFDwItrqdfu-qt^rrql, ilqsnino.^qe{o\lfrm2o.os.zo23t^r2.12.
zoz3d^qtqEqfrEEo-rr{etqw+o^or{ut fiII=TT^QtrI,fuE^gtrdfr'iT}frEq^HTII sil-nEqtcorqr^rrrro-f{qfrt{ftfrEM"I t^qqiwoletqt Tfrt,^znxul'ot Gniqq sefHRI^{q</sup>E{Rqm^11.07.2023 Bffi{qrfrt-fidsrtef^{s-{gilfuqlq-il,s$d} qtrlqt sdsfuqT'rqrofelTilqsst{^q{}
ffiqrE-flvtRTQ<sup>qEA85qfrqaq{ ffircfrrn^qfiatsflfr^{fr.rieft,E</sup>}
sil-nqq^qe{e\TW^T&t,^qTsIfrvds

¶16

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	fuqT^rt-ql gfl50 tee@TIT^qrfiTIt,^{qEgfiqe+q3i-5tqt,} fu{t{rcrjftTE{s-tgdortt^sE{t ftrSfiftRn^qfuC^rnFI{ftntW ffi O-tEfiTSRqT^{uilTl-.Fdt,O1gqO1} qrEEr{utsrqdqfidqwrdeniro^qer srrq{ftqT+^GiqqGTfuo{rTd^{{rTHq-{gd 6Ttdftqsttqt,ftx^no-rurq-r1f,6{i d^qrE,fioil-iqo^qeTt{a^{orjtttvf,{fl-ft} tiq.ererqrffiqlT{arTtt orITFoIt,GTeffl qTiqqqeTthtGirrtAeqeffirfrti^qfi tnroioTIEil-{fuqT^rrqlt,^qdrffi qt'q rStt
	11.{q^qRRarMqrdfr^B-rowrftt-6 d^grsrXoud-ctE-rwqrq^q-{gfl=rg^fo-ut rt-qrt,GrQrtttfrffiflrrlorTtfio-tfrfuo qqrqs-sgdqS[fuqr.rqr,oe.fr{fuTrrEI {ftqTdGietrFwItr{gdo{i^ch-t<rfuG Gil-ilqsss{oltrqfrdqtu-rgflfrt}TS rDwI^qsfuwr-ror{qwrcftrt^qriot ErfuG^,ft3il-fEo^q{t,ftNl-d^oTItItqfr qtrftq\rqtrq qf{[fd.I d^qr{rqgiil
	qHR o'r-enqtR!-q^q..r#fgM
	frfrasftsq trftuTdt.MOors)6^g{T.
	fr.fr.t'tzdrromfr {flfi-dolffiTtet qTtqo-qq{HKtq-{gds-qBqrts-as-ogqW qlEq{E-isdqtqrfrt,o-xurqtfueq erqrftri^qri.nroN sAoGTTEr{rStt
	12.sc-FrsqsiltEo^qsTgt-rrwgdfrffi trrTIGnilfierr{.g6186/zozs3rTqrr&-{
	e)_{rsED'{fr$ffifuqr^qroltt

¶20

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	13.il{5$rT3il-ilr6s&r^gr-{re-Kkr^gs.g. 1130/zozsd^qrEo-x{fdqrff02.07.2023 q{GnErRf,EtmrcilqEelfuattgSK{w frrffiof^qrfttt
	14.{fusrTtffis&IFRI^q-{gdTf,^qs.q. ci-qBelftdE)aay fuwgi\ilfi^q),q q-€fqgrrrrrTIEso.RurGilteoqeTHRI{fl trfi{ut^qffi T{qq[,ItcF.l-?t=Tfu{i-ff og^q+qft2oz4dernrn^q{srfl-fuf,at^q-$ ffi orffiF{rTo01.02.2024ol^qarFrd ftrS^qdt^q-qBf,{errr?rsiltfix"IdE wgt^qriqi.qr€ttt
	1s.sa-trrsrTrpfl-qGiltfiilTftpnftd sTer GtF{FfdutsrurdTt^qfiqRffi {q-qT^{Rq-tmoesi{ft2024d rnRTt} frqiRaffi otffi 01.02.2024dr6l'sl HrFdg$,atsfiTffi qil{To\g+ft tttg3il-n{fr sefYQrfr^{IlcF{uIq-{gdoa} w6drt,^(q{tr{e-FI=T^slrnfid^qTulqt frrtTtor-jt\tTo\sdT-to1vqqor^vf'ftt
	16. orraqoseTHRIrqd yfl..1130/zozsGn-qDorfuil^qtgqF.rK o1srfttt
	17.BTq^{qeT3ill=Il-3ill=Ilqqq6;T} ottr
	18.^q-RrTrqd frtqrutcrT oTffiqFr{frE{Bdrsr^qri t trq q@ ffi-{oIffi S.enq.fr^(qqvq@ 9cF{uI

Ms Shrawan Kumar Agrawal v. Punjab National Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

The Daddy Agro Food Industries Prop of Mrs Deepti Grover versus Central Bank of India

Ms Extol Education Society versus Punjab National Bank

Dheerendra Singh Kushwaha versus Cholamandalam Investment and Finance Company Ltd.

Extol Education Society versus Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited

Ms Shrawan Kumar Agrawal v. Punjab National Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

The Daddy Agro Food Industries Prop of Mrs Deepti Grover versus Central Bank of India

Ms Extol Education Society versus Punjab National Bank

Dheerendra Singh Kushwaha versus Cholamandalam Investment and Finance Company Ltd.

Extol Education Society versus Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited

Malkhan Singh versus Aspire Home Finance Corporation Ltd.

Pankaj Sharma Son of Late Nk Sharma Aged About Years versus Chief Manager and Authorized Officer Edel Weiss Assets Reconstruction Company Branch Mumbai