Mr Sushil Kumar and Ors. v. Muthoot Housing Finacne Company Ltd.

DRT18 Apr 2024SA/1095/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

CONTD, ORDER^.SHEET

PAGE No

GASE No

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER fg{ $fdEqR\ti^ci-q frsa gEeErsRirrwrfiqo.qftffifr& gfl.q.rces/2023	REMARK
18.04.2024	sl-ilEos&TdfrqfroilfrtT'l-qffi erBrmrt B-f,.{rfrffiqrrqendftN^,tlBfu ffrrf,reftr66I
	1.Brrtt^qETo\fr-dq^erqroil-ilfrd^r+rq ffiq^rrgr{rf,TdfrEwSqT^q-il I 2. Tmwro-rGi-{dtfiqfuqT^q-qT I
	3.^qd-{f,se{^gMfu{ltn^2s.11.2023C qltrn(1)H{Sffiv{ezoo2dHq'qriid Gi-il..fd^qEe?FwIm.r q++rorfufusd^qrel fuRtrffr grqgrFr{lqrRdorTarTfffrfr 13.02.2022^31q1-qdfrrt^qrt,r1Terfr^GtTDqrq qfrgrieflqqTofrrar+ottgq-qdfoqr^.rqr tr
	4.rrwl^q-rgerF{i^ttgqfr-f,qo<sup>emr frrS^qfitggm^oil-nqq{s^eTIEINq{Itqd fuql^q-qrtatfudT^qRtevlq5vdHRI sil-+qTfu{i-fi13.02.2021^grqetqwt^qrRf, fuq-r^rr-qrtrBil-alros&To\craqftd-qnHRr iRilfrfuft-{r6zs.os.zozrd^qtqqt qrTHTEr=T EoTI,f,E[qenftqoTDq-ffirt TrETrofuqr,ft^.r$ffiTr6^rNorriffiseTi serrfl:odTerrTqgqdrrqafr^qdfiy-{gd fuqr,CAq-o13.01.2021oi fr{wm-qftqt rr{r-tIm.flqsqroetTtffiqeTqrftqEffiqr_c saT^qrrilErrrfudmg{dsqailEo-rEqi-qt

¶5

PAGE No....................

¶6

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶7

Mr Sushil Kumar and Ors. versus Muthoot Housing Finacne Company Ltd. — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶8

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	284/2022ftlqi-fi^{12.01.2022o\s-qd frql'} fuqoTft-{rfi{uT^{ftlqto18.10'2023th\frtqT} rTrrT,ffiffqqtfi^{q-$wraord *FIsr} t^{gseTBfi{uTd qqe{qEwr{uts-{gf,frtqT} rrqrt'IsqGilqrilw ftaq^{erqrfrti qrior} or5tnrfrtqrrqrt^t s.B-f,wrft^{qeTat3Nt qlgd frtn}'rn qelqwfr6qefiT3nilfid^{q-{rqd ffaq} t^qftor(o{t^{gq3il-qkcdft-{Tfrq-$B ot} snncfise{Hrrrl^{ftq-rd 3iq{ qmfrqs?E} qr{nEFIdflrle{^qrFrrr+fiq^sqRemqfr ECnr^{wqmftqwqqrrilEFId arsfiqrq} .ftr,dfrqqt^ot$qdTSfr'd^IssSTTEII-{ qrq-{gflfrffiflrTT3llnfio<sup>frwflftt} wio-rsgtnr^{frtqr.rqrt t} 6. qr+ftq q.g.wl qrqrlq a l.D.F.c. SE ^do'frt,,q Ytqr ITIETW.ft 4309/zozgt^{qrRn oTrtqrftlqto} rt.os.zoze^ti ft^{.dqNsTTd 3T1w11flrrrl{ftq'ro-t GE} ser,Kr:ftqT-o.f,^{fuqTqrflqIRqI {flEMrI} toil-nEo^{qflgrrtrqerfr1eHqToil-ifro-r} F-{rfiwT^{sQtrrKI:fu-qTqrwrt t} T.sf,.drfi^{seTa13{t{t sTFrMit} {qEtfr1^{frqqqqTftlqtfi31'01'201st} rrq+Bf,tW^{snBq@{dqqTfrFtrf,24'04'201e} t^gqDrdtr^{gsqFPeqrrTt gsqqrE} o'Rur+^{ftNfiqrErf,r gmB erfuat t} B.^{qaoofu-f,rffe} rtq'gt^gMqrkd ontqT 6-Rur oT^{qqqt,dro\Rc1e} t silq^qrE qaqTfrof^qqn

¶12

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER d^qprzo^qrdzo2ot^{zeqi2022e1srqB} qTTftqszzKFIqFIIEFId ftqlff-iaTd wD-RI^{qqqfqToTEft'qq}d^{qTqerT-r\o\RTfUd} T€[r^lTrlT,dq3il-]@^qsl{s^sITarT"<sup>g+fi tttg^.inftRq-sd^{Gi-nff,GTefd28T$2022}
ilFo.ftfi^q-qf,ors+trT^an,fuE2s.11- zozzo'r^qexF{uItrqd$n,^{dt3iltqTRqifr} 01w{qfizo216'twr/^{6)d frqqfrtft} ei-qB^qrBott
e. GittsItqo^qstf{f,qerqrfrt}^qd wC^{GTIEIT{qil-qt}t,vtrd^{GTSqR3ililqoi} Tarrft-qGfiqKrftt^{qEIrEq{eeFkI:fu-f,T}
qusTffitrTqg(dHrTqTGiltEq^q-{gf,or frqr,ftffiatsfr(\tffi/7)dwt^u-qd ftt^.r$t,fusf,rfuqtorqRqio^8.10.2021 rh\fu-qT^q-qr,M qfrt\i@{/B){rnr{ t w^erril<oqsTt^{qmftqEdlnres@}
Rllqlc{q dsrrqT^qrErfi-Iqqiozaq/2022 fu{ifi12.01.2022e('tffi /B)dw t
trqdfrtqt,fu{rorfr-{rfiwrfuim^fi.10.2023 o\ftrqT'TtrF{fr^.dffit'raTA^GTXv+t{ srkfi{qd^{qqm qE}ltthwts-qdfoqtt
10.B-f,{qrftsqlHNIsnt[d^qtzl-rTt
frdqer.ilfrd^qfio-rfr-ttqfu-qTr-qrt, fuE trqf,sTffiit^qsn<sup>qrqr \flrf,Itat s1-ilffi^qatftffir^qrs1ffi{rqg{dsqer vfi'^qetqGrrArTd^erqrqofrdqfitg^uerro: tfii-o12.10.202ro\sn-i-{qrqdfttqt,ffi sdsfuqTofB+qil{rfttfrqT*q+t
s.rdffh'Fr^qsoETTdttg^qlBsqftorrcrr Bw^qrRnoneYrfttofrsor-sfrat^.d

¶27

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER sc+iltmtTfi6^qqft-qE-ffi il@ -..llqlc{q d^qqaurErsT+fi(^svRl-oE3n^gqqTErfiT ddtgr{sSffio fr.krswINo-r5l=I E3II,^rlc[ qtftrorqlq-qrfr.r$tflTfi-q Edw @T^{qlqrrlgxtqrRf,3rl-iqT} fuimfi.10:023^{tisdrqrft t.oarqrm .r{} Gilqfud^gtFRIfr {s^{3TBfiwTd {{rlsT} ffitrBwrr{skrerE}t^ddQqorsds frrqr^q-ilt,fuEvt{^{dQqo-lgneniroqm} o\o+f,sqg{d^Gil-eqrk{rfi^8.102021t dTotnt 14.^{qRqmftqEffisrtrwTqrqrrld} grrqrRf,^qTerTfr^q'rqftqTdfqqqt^qd kn^qriofot{^{ftErrtet.TiEtft, TqqE} GTBowr dqlx$lt frdqe+,il^ertt-ficr-l frqtarq^cFKlT,fuE^{oililqos&Td gEd} ergtuw{seTkowTd^{srl&TTfiwttrqd} o-{tatffiiTdrt?t^{g{qTfrroro-tfrrro-wr} oqfl+qr^qqtt,dq{rrq^ftqTo-tss'TXu^<}v wss^GTfuo{uro\soqorTd^{frrtowT orHI} tr 15. qqRqr+ftq q.s.wr ^qr{nc't-qdERT sffif,^{qr?rqgtil oTFffq}Bi6^{fru< eTr$.fr} en$.fr.err$.to.dfr&zo24 ⁽¹⁾w.ft'fl.d.
s16frfrr$^qqrend^srTflt{{fl^stfto-wr o\trNI17(1)^q{+ffi\rdd2oo2d^en-il'i( rqf,*t^qrdFDwIt^qrrsTqf{r^olfuBqq drom^tifrdqerfl-oviof sTffiaT^qTK i',fu5fu{fi^Gil-tffiqerdrftffi^erqr$Ti or^qqiq\q{rqil-ftot-{ur^qcil=Tlfreiottt

DATE
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
sc+iltmtTfi6^qqft-qE-ffi
il@ -..llqlc{q
d^qqaurErsT+fi(^svRl-oE3n^gqqTErfiT
ddtgr{sSffio
fr.krswINo-r5l=I
E3II,^rlc[
qtftrorqlq-qrfr.r$tflTfi-q
Edw
@T^{qlqrrlgxtqrRf,3rl-iqT}
fuimfi.10:023^{tisdrqrft t.oarqrm .r{}
Gilqfud^gtFRIfr {s^{3TBfiwTd {{rlsT}
ffitrBwrr{skrerE}t^ddQqorsds
frrqr^q-ilt,fuEvt{^{dQqo-lgneniroqm}
o\o+f,sqg{d^Gil-eqrk{rfi^8.102021t
dTotnt
14.^{qRqmftqEffisrtrwTqrqrrld}
grrqrRf,^qTerTfr^q'rqftqTdfqqqt^qd
kn^qriofot{^{ftErrtet.TiEtft, TqqE}
GTBowr
dqlx$lt frdqe+,il^ertt-ficr-l
frqtarq^cFKlT,fuE^{oililqos&Td gEd}
ergtuw{seTkowTd^{srl&TTfiwttrqd}
o-{tatffiiTdrt?t^{g{qTfrroro-tfrrro-wr}
oqfl+qr^qqtt,dq{rrq^ftqTo-tss'TXu^<}v
wss^GTfuo{uro\soqorTd^{frrtowT orHI}
tr
15.
qqRqr+ftq q.s.wr ^qr{nc't-qdERT
sffif,^{qr?rqgtil oTFffq}Bi6^{fru< eTr$.fr}
en$.fr.err$.to.dfr&zo24 ⁽¹⁾w.ft'fl.d.

s16frfrr$^qqrend^srTflt{{fl^stfto-wr
o\trNI17(1)^q{+ffi\rdd2oo2d^en-il'i(
rqf,*t^qrdFDwIt^qrrsTqf{r^olfuBqq
drom^tifrdqerfl-oviof sTffiaT^qTK
i',fu5fu{fi^Gil-tffiqerdrftffi^erqr$Ti
or^qqiq\q{rqil-ftot-{ur^qcil=Tlfreiottt

¶38

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	qIflIIEEIFI-S'TTTflFFWIdHIgIq-{gd Gn-ilfi srxr5wfErGTBfr'frstT'tl{S-{^qFF{ ft(KfuqT^qrortt 18.^qRqTqssq3il-iEm^qelHMrr!f,Y{{ q.loes/zozecrqBerfuntt t^qrtycN wgtrnrt ut.q^qelqrfurfRn^tn{tgs,stfr rf,{^qrfuffio1wftt't
	1e.slrrstTGlqfl-eilrqT^qqqFIottt 20. qftqqcde)t
	e-6wrGrffisrqr(tEg[FirrtqT^qrqI 21. ffi S.enq.E(qsvqEd-s,Td)

Mr Sushil Kumar and Ors. v. Muthoot Housing Finacne Company Ltd.

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Smt Pooja Khare versus Punjab National Bank

Harish Kumar Rai Son O Fshri Amritlal Rai versus Madhya Pradesh Gramin Bank

Nafees Ur Rehman versus Punjab National Bank

Rumita Jain versus Punjab National Bank

Mr Sushil Kumar and Ors. v. Muthoot Housing Finacne Company Ltd.

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Smt Pooja Khare versus Punjab National Bank

Harish Kumar Rai Son O Fshri Amritlal Rai versus Madhya Pradesh Gramin Bank

Nafees Ur Rehman versus Punjab National Bank

Rumita Jain versus Punjab National Bank

Bank of India versus M/S Continental Furniture

Icici Bank Limited versus Komala Singh Patel S/O Bhikama Singh Patel