Smt Lata Barkade v. State Bank of India

DRT9 Oct 2023SA/647/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

"^CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

GASE No

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	I
	ffidfuilrrt-o.-gft-s-€sff.fr.eTr$. ys..647/2023
0	10.2023sTrt{Osq{Otfri t frsl-d-f, sElrxtEl3[fus-ffiIl sm-qrftt-ndfuqfrftil+gwr 3Tkq-ffirI	l
	1.srtqsetofsrlifru-*gofrr$.d rffiq-{oTrnqqetrt.g.+q%/2023rilsrfr {Qrrr-q3na-q-{eTr$.q.44ss/2023,erq=T 3ltil{q4soo/,2023ctgm^.r+rBt
	2.^ys-rutoT3rq-frmq fu-qr^rrqr t 3.3rrn@^qeTHRrrrrt17(1)s-r$ffi g€2oo2dqrqtTn+ffEftirorz.oz. zo:s^q\q6q-cr'{qoilBq(qq+rrfurio 07.01.2023,frTu-d{rfu{io05.08.2022, ffi {ilfl^{fuiro03.06.2023oieTc[w} frrn^qdofdfuf,sgrirdrdsrpr erq or-gfliFrf,sdrirf,rfurqa+tT$Brs q-f,{urdkfl €i de}i5ffi qa1 ft-{io31.08.2023\rs^g-wlfudffi olffiftqfqzo.oo.2o23E.\ffi tigv crrrrftrfrri^qr-to1sarqmt-gErThrc or-a-fi frqim'zo.oe.zozso1 u-qofu-w .rqrtt 4.TdGrr-ilfiu-qoorittggft-o< olerqrfttn^qfitgg.roerfferGtr$.*. ztzs/zozttrqdfu-fl^rRrTt,fusor u-q[qvf,{fl-frceT^gTrrrqofuvr^qrg-rr tr	r'i

PAGE No

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

DATE

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REi
5.^yfi-rqE.{ql-$igfuq^qdq-{ vf,t-qrfrceTatsr}rtsTMfuts-dTfrGt ofc-{-rorsr-qfiilEatt^ggo1gurserrkr: froqerqrsr-d-fifuim-rqdr.qtt	ii I
6.{fu+aE{sTrfrdlqBtfu^qqqrq frqror^qqqffi{f,d.aeserrro:GraI ftffisarrrorwf+qno-{tdTdfudq erqrft;S^qrtorernft-{rq-d fu-qr ErlT Gr-qrqo drorBr
7.^qcI:geFkl:ft-dilqeTril3Tl'dfiSI ft-rrf,{qfu-flqrwtt l	i
8.sr-f{6^rre]Errrrqofrri^.r$gs	,
fuoqerqrsrril<qo-rgsenwto1 srd-{6,r+q^qfut,fu-+frfuf,o-rffi
o-rEr=TT€ttt^qreTfrslFoerctfu srrfuq@q++furio07.01.202snfud*t
d^qs-qnoil-iEo^qavowrfido.tHq-d
foqrW mqilfu^qqro-Go-r^qrqfrt qrio-regtufu-wtEHE'nqcrwl u-qoortfusTk{fiTtsq-dc-€foY sd^qse-o-{urtrqf,orifr6s<^gurtt	i l I I l.
gSernmwfuaqerqrftrt^qrtot or-Stqftrqrrqrtt
9.sf,t-qrfrsfld^gmi{f,q^elrlT
sTiff{orfufuow{-qrqdorfr gq
sil-a-fioTfu{hTfo-qrrqr^gI6tht tFI
srBmtfu^q-floru-qooridrzsfu+q orfl+oqt^gsfudq6Iot$Edsq-+1 TSt,fr-dq^qqil-fr,frr€tB1
Hrerfrsrftosl-cBol !h<br>
s-fi-{drfrt-f, et I oTwrfl=I^eII;

Smt Lata Barkade versus State Bank of India — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶14

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER DATE	REMARK
fr"{^q6qrr-{ncnrsrFIftcrd^ei<r. sTB6-iqdsqeT e-{-rurtrEdr€lfu-qr,rq f+oesqrsTra-fio-rot$ot-{urrStI E€^{GilqlifqrtrEd3Tl'ff{F-iKfrtS} qriorsr-StqmqtI 'ro.3lril(-6qelfl-{t c-qde-s-{uroT 5uq qKiDRq3Trftq-fqq+jIIktio07.01.2023 qrsTrqrR-dtrsTrfuTsWd{ro1qh (q-tffi/2)d$q^qeTrt{f,vertu-qo fu'qrtsrprfrG't@{^q,/3)dwt ftqiozr.oa.2o23e)^{ytrEIIgtr€ro{wIIE} o\ftrd.rt^qaet^qfrt,fus--d^qrtqqd uf< ryngilts-€-delq^gors".de1 +cEdrior^{ergttufu-qrrrqr,fuflor} q-qtqfrir625.03.202so)sil{qrfrt-fit (qi-@rq,/4)dwtkn,ftmd^qrtqq d^qqr1;la-{FII^rt-rlTa1M ft-f,q; i-dftqqo-Iv6l$u-dvc.fr.q.d^.rflt ftffirt^Er+qg{d^gMTSrd^,In-Afr T{^rfr	vrrE6B-m-{srfrt-6d^gMts$ ft-ir6frffuqcdet{\rorsu-co<sup>gq.fr.i qrftef,oqofw€ ffiorffiot ErcEUft^qero)ftqr-6^zs.os.zozsd^cz tdgfl^ert oTlftqiqqafl Rirooz.or. 2023^rNoil-icocatot$fuorqr€tfuqT t,^qfug-(^GIctsTfuffi{froffi q++rdfrv-qfroenfu-qr$I^qffimu qditffitorqrocr€tfo-urrrwrE}g .rtrrqr ?wrflftoTffiT€tof.r$r-qg HftoTrqFildi {*a-qt,wqfusrxil

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
DATE

REMARK

fr"{^q6qrr-{ncnrsrFIftcrd^ei<r.
sTB6-iqdsqeT e-{-rurtrEdr€lfu-qr,rq
f+oesqrsTra-fio-rot$ot-{urrStI
E€^{GilqlifqrtrEd3Tl'ff{F-iKfrtS}
qriorsr-StqmqtI
'ro.3lril(-6qelfl-{t c-qde-s-{uroT 5uq
qKiDRq3Trftq-fqq+jIIktio07.01.2023
qrsTrqrR-dtrsTrfuTsWd{ro1qh
(q-tffi/2)d$q^qeTrt{f,vertu-qo
fu'qrtsrprfrG't@{^q,/3)dwt
ftqiozr.oa.2o23e)^{ytrEIIgtr€ro{wIIE}
o\ftrd.rt^qaet^qfrt,fus--d^qrtqqd
uf< ryngilts-€-delq^gors".de1
+cEdrior^{ergttufu-qrrrqr,fuflor}
q-qtqfrir625.03.202so)sil{qrfrt-fit
(qi-@rq,/4)dwtkn,ftmd^qrtqq
d^qqr1;la-{FII^rt-rlTa1M
ft-f,q;
i-dftqqo-Iv6l$u-dvc.fr.q.d^.rflt
ftffirt^Er+qg{d^gMTSrd^,In-Afr
T{^rfr

vrrE6B-m-{srfrt-6d^gMts$ ft-ir6frffuqcdet{\rorsu-co<sup>gq.fr.i
qrftef,oqofw€ ffiorffiot
ErcEUft^qero)ftqr-6^zs.os.zozsd^cz
tdgfl^ert oTlftqiqqafl Rirooz.or.
2023^rNoil-icocatot$fuorqr€tfuqT
t,^qfug-(^GIctsTfuffi{froffi
q++rdfrv-qfroenfu-qr$I^qffimu
qditffitorqrocr€tfo-urrrwrE}g
.rtrrqr ?wrflftoTffiT€tof.r$r-qg
HftoTrqFildi {*a-qt,wqfusrxil

¶20

€fl dsie{ rf,{ure-qf,6{ at^.d
oTffidT+ftfrqrqt
1i.d^qqsrrfuTiqqaqrfrimoz.ot. 2023sil-t(oceTe\crwg{t,^gswoI$ fq-{-<TSt,fu-is-f,EqrfrcadEM u-qofrdT$sTffio1t{il^qrqc<br>sTrBqiqq++furio07.01.202o*uftcel o\ {frrqgsrod^qrtqqtft{;oz+.0r. zozso)ift-aofTs,dt ftqio3r.or.zozo
qs01.02.2023o\Hfl g$tITq.fr..
sTrildl-o^qmdenrGTrqfufr^.rStat
srrfuqiqq+troff,iffi,uorvrl "
wrflrfr ftqq s(r)(z)s-r$frs'ffi2oo2doqs-q c-€tBr
i2.sfl^q-qli.tisf,q-qrfrceTetoi{t
s-FraGTffif oiM^qrsrrr^qrortfu
tw^q-mrerqfrirors.or.zozao)onfrqr
rr-il,wqfuqfuq-f,q+ilfrimz+.0r.
2023^qtnft-dg$tt^gSGilETR^qtsrrnE{
cenddRI^qdfrfuf,GTIqfuB-dfr T$l- *
fuSen24.01.2023tfiTq-{rdd,
aq^!ftoTiffio.^qeTgxtftqprz.oz.zozs^qT
e-qde-.NqeTrfu[iqq++dfrsq^tt
3i-iqko. erqBsrEf,tt i;
13.^quooffi q++ftirooe.oo
zozs^gris-srfzrfldentr-r^qrfurfftdfl
T{ffi o-ffift{1ozs.oz.zozsVI
zozeo\irdd+rrcAr{^qlE-oreri cq{t,B-f,{qrfr eTF{ffiraMk{iozo.o-b;(;
ci-gwr-{ft{1q'zs.oz.zozgo)t+rtRdot
ffi^qTffisq-ar€t Ei,^sTeIIo 1,/ ir'i

¶28

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REII,AR*
Ed{I^{fuiro03.06.2023d 3i-gqrur d} trffi6rf,o1Tiffi olffif+i,T ft{16'zs.oz.2o23o<sup>oTtIrKIfttn^qfiat H6r{drfuu-owrsiqwrfuTfrot^qrs onq rFodgorB^{gssTrBqcqqafl} ftqio'oz.ot.2o23dfrsq^{ttv-o-tulsrqB} qrEirts3r.qdrranrdTqIfrGtgq Tr6rrrf,r^q*f,-r5€qsdr{f,Iot^qrRq-rBo saErflIt, ffi {s^qfilstd^gr-t erMfuofrri^qrifuor<onqtq^c-€f {6^qrf,rI 14.errr^zr-6ildftsn'tqtfu^"TqI f46qe+nor^q-o-tqurtX"rdqwEi qrifr.q t"t 15.seFkr:^zr-6B-d€-fi=qtofurc^tz(t) sr+ffiT€2oo2d^qrqqnid^q-d'f,( trqdsTt-il({/sTfi-f,^qIT+qB-m,q q-qrddfgrrqfrrqtkaGTFqdor-ffig tr ,tl ca-q{flri-{,it{fletrwlofe-qfr 16 gsqxrsrqlErslEfuqqatcTd-q-dTB frTq^tiqmfiqsqilq^qFIIEFIdErirf qtprsrrqwcffi{dcTmorsc.dq
3ffirqq-6d^qrortr^qstiErit^qafiq: rIFFIrqBEkrrIamIF	-iIgl-{I^rIIIgqI dfrodrnierq ldra^{qfu+c sfrE}fu srdl 004 4 .fr. ortot ozd^qrqAtfr^{q-$ aFNejrI}d^ergsn 17H{Sffi\rtrc2oo2dtr(u-qo*.t sr-f,rGTrilfi/3Tfi-d^{qrqBo'GTffidT}iql qt-Aqrqmqdqqsqq-6xvfuqT^qfutt (<br>- :i-

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

REII,AR*

Ed{I^{fuiro03.06.2023d 3i-gqrur d}
trffi6rf,o1Tiffi
olffif+i,T
ft{16'zs.oz.2o23o<sup>oTtIrKIfttn^qfiat
H6r{drfuu-owrsiqwrfuTfrot^qrs
onq rFodgorB^{gssTrBqcqqafl}
ftqio'oz.ot.2o23dfrsq^{ttv-o-tulsrqB}
qrEirts3r.qdrranrdTqIfrGtgq
Tr6rrrf,r^q*f,-r5€qsdr{f,Iot^qrRq-rBo
saErflIt, ffi
{s^qfilstd^gr-t
erMfuofrri^qrifuor<onqtq^c-€f
{6^qrf,rI
14.errr^zr-6ildftsn'tqtfu^"TqI
f46qe+nor^q-o-tqurtX"rdqwEi
qrifr.q t"t
15.seFkr:^zr-6B-d€-fi=qtofurc^tz(t)
sr+ffiT€2oo2d^qrqqnid^q-d'f,(
trqdsTt-il({/sTfi-f,^qIT+qB-m,q
q-qrddfgrrqfrrqtkaGTFqdor-ffig
tr
,tl
ca-q{flri-{,it{fletrwlofe-qfr
16
gsqxrsrqlErslEfuqqatcTd-q-dTB
frTq^tiqmfiqsqilq^qFIIEFIdErirf
qtprsrrqwcffi{dcTmorsc.dq

3ffirqq-6d^qrortr^qstiErit^qafiq:
rIFFIrqBEkrrIamIF

-iIgl-{I^rIIIgqI
dfrodrnierq ldra^{qfu+c sfrE}fu
srdl
004
4
.fr. ortot
ozd^qrqAtfr^{q-$ aFNejrI}d^ergsn
17H{Sffi\rtrc2oo2dtr(u-qo*.t
sr-f,rGTrilfi/3Tfi-d^{qrqBo'GTffidT}iql
qt-Aqrqmqdqqsqq-6xvfuqT^qfutt
(<br>-
:i-

¶35

dsrqtrrr'id^ergrrntrqd+i^qrdqrsq{
dsw^znrdmtr^ervloq-65-{QTrft-d
frEtfu^qm17(1)sr$-S^gtrc2oo2d
tratrqd*DwI{a^qrsc,t^t
17.^ql=rfiqBailq^alr{flEfqEI{T^ef,qq
rrcTrft-sq vrq(zoi6)14\ry.fr.fr.314^tt
frEg{arTfr-da1^.T{tfu^{qM5 qqt{r}
sTfut{qqosFItItq^qr<qaqrdF[^;rdtatlr qfr+.GTftdvssTInfirqdo-{iig
e-trrn{f,sq-qfrtr+frw^+tqfisqB^qd qmftqwrFIar-qrilqdanr
gdtffi'.r5cr crf+qfrsqERird
sd'fr Etirn scrC+e^(zooa)zt's^.fi.fr.
rcg-d^{rorqfiqd fqEg{arlfunofG t}
fulqclsoIEFqqdtr(^qrqEnF-dmls
srqfiqrdu-{,fi^qm5Tqffl^sIEF-qq rgoed^qFxrffi{IFIrq^gqdqilid^orq
srq-qfrfdd^qr-d$^{qti q-qmq}orfttq sTBftqqdffn^qrqqlF-dqqqfrcrai
ffif,^q-{ieterffior^{c-€t B}r^qF-fiq
$@d-q^AIrII]EFTEI{t to,^sfrs{+Er
q-al GTIET
cr$te fufr&fuf{d^oTqrd
5240 2022 ftdq futrr11.08
2022 .fr.fr. 10
o1eiBfi'rrrsirztof^{.r$ dql-gfl} I]T
3rgfl-i fur^qdd^errqrrzstffiv+e # 'I
, q-6-r"rtEim5qqkTsTEfrqqd ^qr-qqlf, .,t
ai'1r€tdrdt frft# 18. gsd^qrplfrsrqHrrqw
1?{1} qFrfiqs-aq-qrf,dtdanr^qM <br>)

¶44

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER		REMAI
	ffiSffi\r{e2oo2de-Wuitt^qm5Tqffl orBfuqq+crqqmlo:r^qrirqf,to-frq.q^q qffi orftqd^q-q-ffiqtftrfld ffd^qrrfiqqar-flsa^q[qrdq01 so-strdERTtmR iifrffiq Tdvrf,tei frft&ft-s-{ sreNrf,w oTrfrrw^gfuT{ +6o,ifrwq,esrdl^qrfuorEqi6, 31251/ zorat^qfusTrtcrfuto^os.os. zorg,^ql;rfiqodof,rsq^qrqffiqot qu-strd+Ertt ortrflo..cRt{f,cr$+c fufr&ltierqfutq ^iD-6T;ITT€-{ff\ti sIdI^gq.fr.=f+t1s1/2ool tcrfu eTrtsrfu{io' 30.04.2010,^qT{Eer<T 2010 gfl.fr.fr.ffidr{c IDEITDEIT1361 E cr{fiq&-dr BA^an-{il-dqdem^d.fr. q+Cot{ffidHB:ggerf,IsrqolT 3[{;IlaarrT frr<Eirr-oirr ltiff tffiI o.rftqq fufr&zots .fr.fr.d-{ drdr 25727Grq-dtofiqBftrc-dff{q t^qE frEE-{Qrtrd E{Sffiv{e2 q-f,rurtErM oqr€ldt 19.Sflil{6 qilddTt01strn@cHgl{r trqfl e-a-w{o^{qK qz}dswott,ftrs rrnr17(1)stffiv{e2oo2dffE or{ursor-Idriftciot+sfuqsd ffi-{ultrqf,o-{tet srqftqr t,ffiffin^frrnqrifu^TRrs oTEFqqdsrqETHsr-qYfqc-€ltt IL T i srBFqqd	I	il ;

¶55

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	RE
q.frurEfll-6qqfrTffirqsil-a-fiffi frrqrStl 23.^{ql-{fi-q q.s.s@a[rlrEfrr}dB!-rt-fr H-<ffif,^qTq-{Er(q(TrrGnflTrrco-tgq Ssffd^.FTTflt^o1qRffiqq^3ll-ilfi trqf,+i tftli-{20.0s.2023o-}sil-tilo ceT^gme-qf,{f,fu-SfrrrEr{f,rtgGTfi 1ur^{dsq{frfuf,drfr,treqaq-{-{ulEs} srfu+-tqd^qqeig{qdtg dkdE)-{r
qFITqlflI,fuEffi oTffifuiro 2s.07.202adfrq..dE)^qrtdwrsTfr
roqqftq-adg-o-rt^yqetrfuc€{qql ft{tq'o7.o1.2ondfrqqfr^q-o{olvrglrrS fr^q-qEsrB(t,aq^eTd{f,cH^o1{s g?DWrqql=lfi-q q.c.sa 'qlqIc{q d sc-t-ffi^qrq-{ETdfr^q6rSffi t 24.^gccRfuTfutfr^gsfi-oor{fltot qrilq-rcHaRTe-qo{iyilEr{uriletGlr$*. 44ss/202sgs{Qrq-q3trilfierr$.q.
4soo/2023{fle4wl^qgrTdq^q{ ft-{ro-iqfr'qr€ltt^q-oswGTffid qrttr dt I
2s.^z16FrEfo-qr^qrorto1 enileo^qS ffi q+<rft-ri-o31.08.2023gsm orffiftqiszs.os.2o;ndftsq ns-qii
ffqret^qqfEritrutgqgerono-ttl
u-qoori &ffirdt,re{fl{tiltlfl ord-fid^qrtqqtsd-fr^.r$enqMior GTft-fl{s-{tofretirorrifrt
26.B?mTequTIOHTgT^rl-6t=lEIII{f,O-EI
ofoTrEqflqa-nfi+tio07o1.2023dfrs&

Smt Lata Barkade v. State Bank of India

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Ms Krishna Poly Extrusion versus Indian Bank

Hdfc Bank versus M/S Bonnie Foi Society

Afford Motors I Pvt. Ltd. versus Ms Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd.

Ms Keshav Roadline versus Punjab National Bank

Smt Lata Barkade v. State Bank of India

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Ms Krishna Poly Extrusion versus Indian Bank

Hdfc Bank versus M/S Bonnie Foi Society

Afford Motors I Pvt. Ltd. versus Ms Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd.

Ms Keshav Roadline versus Punjab National Bank

Shri Mukesh Malviya versus Piramal Capital and Housing Finance limited

Dharmendra Kumar Jain versus Ncml Finance Pvt. Ltd.