Ms Krishna Poly Extrusion v. Indian Bank

DRT3 Oct 2023SA/177/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

i. l

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

GASE No..................l.........;...

¶5

DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER DATE	R,EMARIi
Mqenct"tYqffiqvs^srdl f{$-q crEqd^qffirarersrE+o w..177/2023	Ii
10.2023^3Tril{Oqeiof³ⁱ¹dfr^gd.ft.q	-{q erfu{ffirt strrqrfrd-o.dftqfrfrno grf,l ffiq-mt
1.Bqqsflotrqaq^{erql3Tfffi3lr$.1.} s74/2023fuirffi.02.2023\rs^RrrFT qrA-qqer-$.q.+ooo,/zozgft{io22.0s.2023 qrEnr .rqrtt 2.^{gcFWI?D'l3r-q-frm-{}fu-qr^rrqrt 3.B-f,{qrfr^rIeTg	-tlfrdq^errlr3lffc-{ 6'rftfuo^qinrse-q(fo-+r^rurtIern qrnc{oT{ifuoildfuqr.rqrBt 4.sTril{ocelEI{Ift{prz.oz.zozso) qtr17(1)q{fifr\rm-e 2oo2deiilIff,Td s-s-rurREficfG-ee^qc-dgiHRrcrfud eilAcrffiro.26.0e.201e(+@-rq/4) G BRaoc@^qu-sTlERr^qrR-dsr-tcr ftqiooz.oz.zozo('iflr /5)o<sup>sTtIrkT frri^qriofsarirordsrer eilftqcq{fir frfl-o01.07.201sG-i@i^q/6)o1^GIqrftI o<voo-rqrfrd-o.dfuWsqBrnc-trrsd 3i-gFq{rfuclqol^tierowqfu5mftd qriorfttqru-<Hfrilq-iofvor+otig u-qo fuur^.rqrtt
s.^q-{-{qtrqoo-{ingsfuo<olerqr frot^qrttg orrf,fidspr^qr{T5

¶6

GONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶7

I 1i 1li I ti'i,
lri lt, 1,,1i
r l
I ir
lill i
j I ii
I lii l itiii
PAGE No.......,.. .L ""11 i.i "l'l
l l li I
CASE No...... i r'r1' I ..i "'i r!
I

Ms Krishna Poly Extrusion versus Indian Bank — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶15

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	RE
tflq-*ard^.rqrQTrI{S^einmw^fooq HrrIoaEcsr$ e-r^sltl-{Rfrt^qrioi Gr5-tqfu-qr^.rqrtt t. lrqdfu-i^.rttefl-q^3Trilfid^qrtqq terwo.-+qsrurdtg(ilT^qrfud3Tl-tcr foqtfizo.os.2o19vEo-frtrfl^qtrftilal-rt crfudsntqrftqiqoz.oz.2o2o^{qI ftq-fi} TeTFrf,frrt^qrio-r^{oi-5tETfr;qlrrqr}B,^spr fr W^oil-fd[-{d^qrtaqt^{,frgSeilcrqo1} ffiqsarrrf,r^qr$.r{t^t 8.^gerqcr:fuoq^{erqrsTla-fiq ftq-a-tut} fu-qr^qrvsrtt s.si-{q-r^qeTat^sT}itna^erileqA qler€d.rfrttT$ort\ft-dsTrtclto-l Grs-fro--{o-{^qFIIqrortoferwfuot s-srffi^qq-dg{dHRt^cIRdsil€r ftqlo26.0e.201s(gtfl{/4)6^o.trsol sdergnnzoft^qadr5-r-il-$fu^qq-ql qzqrfifrttTi,fu-gr"ftqasqfui-o T€tgeTI,crqvca,qftqorffi^qiqFIx sTrtcrcrfuafuqr^rrqrtId^3il{E-6sH^s-.I o-rffitsqRrdr€t^{gen,eqqEqrdwi} tof^gsfrsYI^{oTqrfrqnoTrilq-ocsol} EFIo-qEsr,dI{s^{frYqn 3fu<-6ceTot} ofttu-qnfrriTifuf,qffiurileq6 o.trsor4fr^{Gil-il{o qm}ifuqrt^at srirq-{6oqioe^qQrfdsftftff^a-E€re-+s a-f,$-a^q-ddldamft{16^04.0s.2022qt iftHnft-f,^q5-qtr6IIa1o.rffitg^fu{i-+. 16.0s.2022+1frfufr{det^T$,dset	I :i

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

tflq-*ard^.rqrQTrI{S^einmw^fooq
HrrIoaEcsr$ e-r^sltl-{Rfrt^qrioi
Gr5-tqfu-qr^.rqrtt
t.
lrqdfu-i^.rttefl-q^3Trilfid^qrtqq
terwo.-+qsrurdtg(ilT^qrfud3Tl-tcr
foqtfizo.os.2o19vEo-frtrfl^qtrftilal-rt
crfudsntqrftqiqoz.oz.2o2o^{qI ftq-fi}
TeTFrf,frrt^qrio-r^{oi-5tETfr;qlrrqr}B,^spr
fr W^oil-fd[-{d^qrtaqt^{,frgSeilcrqo1}
ffiqsarrrf,r^qr$.r{t^t
8.^gerqcr:fuoq^{erqrsTla-fiq ftq-a-tut}
fu-qr^qrvsrtt
s.si-{q-r^qeTat^sT}itna^erileqA
qler€d.rfrttT$ort\ft-dsTrtclto-l
Grs-fro--{o-{^qFIIqrortoferwfuot
s-srffi^qq-dg{dHRt^cIRdsil€r
ftqlo26.0e.201s(gtfl{/4)6^o.trsol
sdergnnzoft^qadr5-r-il-$fu^qq-ql
qzqrfifrttTi,fu-gr"ftqasqfui-o
T€tgeTI,crqvca,qftqorffi^qiqFIx
sTrtcrcrfuafuqr^rrqrtId^3il{E-6sH^s-.I
o-rffitsqRrdr€t^{gen,eqqEqrdwi}
tof^gsfrsYI^{oTqrfrqnoTrilq-ocsol}
EFIo-qEsr,dI{s^{frYqn 3fu<-6ceTot}
ofttu-qnfrriTifuf,qffiurileq6
o.trsor4fr^{Gil-il{o qm}ifuqrt^at
srirq-{6oqioe^qQrfdsftftff^a-E€re-+s
a-f,$-a^q-ddldamft{16^04.0s.2022qt
iftHnft-f,^q5-qtr6IIa1o.rffitg^fu{i-+.
16.0s.2022+1frfufr{det^T$,dset

I
:i

¶21

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
fuHrfii6.o.szo22dTd^{sr-iE-oceTo</sup> erwottre-q^q-{i{g(gRrcrRd^eil-tqroT sr{E\gorw,dfu{^{otrq-q-{ceTd fuq} sfltr{q-fienofsnifti'mt+sftqs +GiqrsiBfi-{urdHqm^oTwo.-+qe{ q{flgidsTrtvrftirozo.og.2o1eo\g+fr titgsTr-ilfiu-gofu-w uror^t 10.sTr-ilfficst^qdv5su1ft{ro^tz.oz. 2023o\E-s^sTBm-{"rdsqeru-qofuu^B, deiqso-d-re(^ql-f,gigrI}crRd^sTttsr
ftfr16zo.os.zorgdfts-q^tift{16^to.os.
zozzdfl-{f{r^qntderq-q5^3i-sD qrBott
11.oi-,{s6id-.Fs-+ffi^qu-trildxr qfudsTrtcrft{16'oz.oz.2o2oqIcrct, oTert-asTrtelo1cft(\tffi /s)ot oF-sf,rod.rq-doqtwetoff,tft qelo)Eqq-$fuqa-+qaqrftftri'ri t ft{prr.rt.zotgo}xfr^{ceTscRerd+fi-t}
q-qrqtrEdo-{ttgsqqfuqrt ildqtqrd ft{aet^.r$frf}drwuoftca^scRra c-€tgcil,ffiw+ro^,fru-qo^{q-€ffu-fl,ilq} 'fi^cetqoTffi^{dlqrfl3ifrqsTrtcl} qrR-dfu-qrrqrI
12.a<sup>qqslrf,q-o^qeTsTariaxot^qa
6f€r^qu-sETI$^qqro+nscRrdd
gtFT arr,f,qsTdEosel^q6o-didfrq
ffifar€tBfuo-effi^{qo-stilgxrcrfud}
srtcrfttro07.02.2020'f,^qq+q3r-ArTt,
onor+t^qqot$ssfrDrt(d{Ism^q-t

¶26

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMAF	i I
sqRTfrcdo-qrwsr5cRrf,d^qrort,d q6s{rorErfudtofs-m-{ortqlkdi qrdsifrq ertcrorsrc Tddqsqqftqr dsiqqsTrtcrdfut-qsq-q-r^qrw6tI 13.E-{r^gfiyurn3nilet-6^ge{o-rd^qa oefitfut6+ffi^qwcrd^qrqroqt scfurdc-€tgq,s{+tsqRrdr-md^(dsfr GB,^qaqtQrqfrtSfiEM"r^ffio.ri TSIfu-fl^uiTErDdI,orsqoferlieoceTi olffiofGTrt{r^qkrrcrtatsqrFrf,^qft rqor€tfuqrt^gscfr6-d-ffico-sdrd rrqeTBqfurd d-+at-Sol-$GtTqfu^q-d o-iffiB,n-qcrR-dGTrt{rtd^rfrmasFfa t, vdcP4\d^ergwwfr^(d+nffin-{l "1tr-fl,^{eTqtdqri(6.seT6-ro-&ffiqu€ErT} ar{^{crR-dentclo-r}Erqfuilo^07.02.2020t frE)-n^Gr-Sqrfr-dfuqr^qdn '^96foirod gseiltcro+sfrqn+oi<g+frtitg qqsTfuo-rrrdwqfl^q-{-{urtrq(fu-qrrrrql erT,fu-dft{1orz.oz.zozao\zr-6e-6-{ur u-qofu-+r^.rqrt,^EilsI-qEerfuatr i4.GTril{o^qadaxrftarqmqrfrtt^qfi fu^{rqofrdTnsil-A-cqt u\zraeTIETr{} fuqr^.rfltof*+eoqqsffisrfrff,t Hq-flY-dT^tnrnqrcreI €^eltg{TK TrrrrEflqtrwlqtrEf,^tFqTd^Q]vsvm-{srfr d-f,dEr{T THIEIFIrwrqffionfifuqr rrqTQ1TI{ssq,{ttu-gosTffitqa v.redrnto1sTril<ocerd^gMfuirf, so.os.2o22a(\i-@i/8) dsr+f,r	ii l l i I I l i I	I I I I 1 t I i

¶31

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER			.
trqafuqr,dB-f,{qrfr^d-fiiffi6x^frtqr, dsFff,vt-dld^{GIEfl-{GrriEo-.Mo-r{rRT} qqrorfr,ft,fu-g3{ril{6tlqt^qtRrq'n Tfrfu'qr,^qfrofrdro^2s.l'1:022iq^zt.tz- zozzdtstrPr^qqrovi fu^wwfrrt ffiflorior^3Ti{f,{rqo^fuur,ffi r.redrortfufogwffiq-f,^TTTIIEII"I cwrsfuiro3o.os.2o2zat^q-do-lqTFFI Tfrdridonq^{qqrErq q-Krqstrsd}d gor w,fuqHqril-qtrK[qtrqf,e]i^slQrsr -rWE\qriqnt3Tlil{oqsolstrq ffqrffifl o-qrto-roEAmoE-.n^IITqT r-€td^qrflI,qrgtfrs-ffiq^oPaqafr Bd^{q.-iqeqrru-wrT}E-gI^{crfuf,3l)-{crfuiro} ol.o2.2ozoo<sup>sTretfudfrrn^qdfu^ww ffqrvoEKwllqra^trftIrotrq(^o-{td qqiqsqqTdfrqTdzozoitsflwdg+t ,fi,fu-g affusrg^qarqrfroferq{enfr q-{fi-qsz.Kl-qqFr-f,qEnTTqffl3rfrfuqq dsffiitofRrfffl^{o-{II-EFIfrtnTSfu} frRgsifitrfi-{urrqd^{r€tfo-qrrrqt,aq} ft{16so.os.zozzd^{qrlIEIl=Ts-w[sd sTltrl-{} qqenteocaelsrqffqrdft-wxor ot$ror€tft-d-f,rcfr^{gqemmw fl+oq} erqrfu-qr^ons6-ctt 15.^qOoo^eT{r6-+€t^q-s-dgigr{r crR-dsr-tcrft{1o^{zo.os.2o1ooTcrc}t,{s frqqloT^gnenil<oceno\ftiro^to.og. zozzdc-ddd^gptail,a-q{fl^eilscro1 ..fisrdfuf,o.-{itg+sfrq-fldgiqqtrfi-{ul e-qf,o-t-fl^anI^.rdfr^{gsfiqflq-*il-{-at}	lr . ll i	ll i i ili rii L I I	I il iri

¶40

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	I REi
qf,{frefr,fuqEgTri{oqHtsrd-dr dergw^qrRrqqro-riofsqqftqrd siqt{rRr^qqrc-€tfu-qr,fuso.rur^y6gw rrrrElr=rvwrq^.frGrfltrdd^.rqr,fu-gErs fisor^qoto1flT{et^{otETr+f,l sIsr.ITg.D'} gKHqrqmrwrqofoTrisrfif+oqerqr o-doieTIEr-rr€tdsofrt '16.ercq6iil6tlr{5^qqfflslBft-qqat sr+sf,r^qIqq=IB,{fl s<ffr^qd s-d-e-+qt uX^qpafiu$qnq^qrqro-qd gM qrffiqrdfuo,afrfr	sfrs-dqfocc sfi'q,^gtrgqlvs Grar2oo4^(z)9c.fr.'d.d.+oa o1oPgarozfrftt^.riugq(6 ^3i-5HR Ernr17^q-i6$v€2oo2d<fffiu-qo Eltsrfr^eTftaoTswTaffiox^qrd qtqtdq dwqeirqodtsrdq-Eq-rtnl +dTtG^q.c.d.dffr^qrstrqdfrtqr qrort,enrfdwsTBo,-{qdwrmu-Eo gTlrrr{qo-rwdqsK^qeoTBt g-sdsleIfrqlq-fiq@krq qtqrdq iimffirr {ctcdffl fftqftturd+d-eft sfitqqMtrc \q erq^(zooe)zgs.fr.fr.rogd^q-{-rort cffi{f,sTftq(dergsnfu{^{qrrd</sup>d frsq^ttfrtq^qrqfrqrfrqfftdof.T{t, sf,dfrTqt^qmsrqfsrsTfufrqqrgosd ylrrEn=Tcrfql-S}frdgst$q-orqt .qlqLl{I olsrqrfrqrffiao-Ei or 't7. EI(I fri-on6^g6r,

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

I
REi

qf,{frefr,fuqEgTri{oqHtsrd-dr
dergw^qrRrqqro-riofsqqftqrd
siqt{rRr^qqrc-€tfu-qr,fuso.rur^y6gw
rrrrElr=rvwrq^.frGrfltrdd^.rqr,fu-gErs
fisor^qoto1flT{et^{otETr+f,l sIsr.ITg.D'}
gKHqrqmrwrqofoTrisrfif+oqerqr
o-doieTIEr-rr€tdsofrt
'16.ercq6iil6tlr{5^qqfflslBft-qqat
sr+sf,r^qIqq=IB,{fl s<ffr^qd
s-d-e-+qt uX^qpafiu$qnq^qrqro-qd
gM qrffiqrdfuo,afrfr

sfrs-dqfocc
sfi'q,^gtrgqlvs Grar2oo4^(z)9c.fr.'d.d.+oa
o1oPgarozfrftt^.riugq(6 ^3i-5HR
Ernr17^q-i6$v€2oo2d<fffiu-qo
Eltsrfr^eTftaoTswTaffiox^qrd
qtqtdq dwqeirqodtsrdq-Eq-rtnl
+dTtG^q.c.d.dffr^qrstrqdfrtqr
qrort,enrfdwsTBo,-{qdwrmu-Eo
gTlrrr{qo-rwdqsK^qeoTBt
g-sdsleIfrqlq-fiq@krq qtqrdq
iimffirr {ctcdffl
fftqftturd+d-eft sfitqqMtrc \q
erq^(zooe)zgs.fr.fr.rogd^q-{-rort
cffi{f,sTftq(dergsnfu{^{qrrd</sup>d
frsq^ttfrtq^qrqfrqrfrqfftdof.T{t,
sf,dfrTqt^qmsrqfsrsTfufrqqrgosd
ylrrEn=Tcrfql-S}frdgst$q-orqt
.qlqLl{I olsrqrfrqrffiao-Ei or
't7.
EI(I
fri-on6^g6r,

¶43

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER 18.^ql-{+qs@ilq^qFrrerird yffi{dB?mEq-dde6rcrfr gl-{ q6 B-ds-fistof^qMrz(1)E-{i-STrc 2oo2dsFrqnfrtEsqdqtgsEsfrcls BqdiEd3id.fufr.Bd^qfuiloino{qs-Ef, a-{itg45fu{fl ofsqqftflcrqtrrF-f, o1 .r$te-qwoTfus-rqo.rwqrq fiqro) fufiTrRds{to1erffif,r^qm+qBEkl-rr -qlqlclq dsc-trffiqq-{Erd+tcffi{d sTftqdds-{TqTrffi-ddTil-gvt-irStr
1e.{fls-<rffrfrft-qqrT+qBz.r qrqrf,dtfmsffi{dsTftqHq-s-cffi dt
20.^q-aftqrT;lrsEI -qtqtctq *^qo-s
0-d+Hrgrtmn $mftqfrqr+S cr$+c
ftft&f{d-qsolPTrrf,wsltsts{ SFg{rq
t-n \q^Grqqrfufiro.qio,
ttzs't/zo'ra^qdBf,ffq m6os.og. zorg^ilcffi orfuq(derSsxerRT17 wffi^g€2oo2dffE^q-o{ur+sfu{s df{iu-qf,+{rsTffi}\rq{flsq.iE frsqq*q ffioo-Gorot{srqEr-{ T€fd{Sfr"lqofo.Fsor12^qqmfiq
BaT^qrqrFFrd^gmqq{QjrraT$t^qfr rrnr17(r)orsTidfiS.em.d.dwaXa o'rffiorFl-srrrsort,ffift-f,q^erql frtS^qrttg^eTnrs {qtfl^3TEftqqd stqqFr^qToff-drfr etit^{qffiqirdiD<IT}
GI^q;qrf,qENI ^{sTtrdorcRtq-derf'€}
frft&Gsrq f{sq rDFt-qTTo-{ffSt

¶49

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	@il[ I
	3[ar2o1ogs.fi.fr.srqErHq?mrDcrr1361 ds-fi-r"rfrfi^qmfi-qso-sfl-sd^gm q!-{€TIfr.r{to1qrr17q{$ffi'{dsft o-rffi^qt(q-{dergw Tf,strcoTffi d-tt^qr{srqfiloTEftqqdsrryn^qrt rSddr^qs ^q<ft^qrrfiqdrorva -.llqlclq ffirEtrg{{ t-o.ffd-d^qrdd.orn (o.eTn6.)E'qwrc/zorsifdft-dtrq fuiooz.rr.zozzfro.trsflrzterftro frqr^rrqrtotrrtrdffi^y€d^Gr-ir.f-dtET ot$^qrqqrqr€tt,s\Lsil-r.O.6a5ft+s dcrarf,u-qodriffie-4-turfrfuoqA Gr-qEotemrfrri^qriorerfuoxs-il-{ o-rord,tio-Fsrrzr^tiqq{QTrfrTgt o1A-oeflqrffi^qrids'qtiqd3Il]Tq fr' oHq -.1lqlc{q ^qataoofva R[{Ifc,l{I fi^qrq6q1i4<irfuo^-rSIors-{-flTI
	21.v-sdsreTfr^qrfiqEdq^aIFIrEr-q Enr +o,dq,r$(rsfsrqffs-{
	q-rc-{ftH ({Sfnqfrdq-6udi-efuq}s
	frffdoTfi-diz4o/2022t+frilfr"{q
	ftdrorr.oe.zoozdnorcrd^!ftgsno<urt errrts^qqfErorDfrqqdsrqtr-qdrrlTS *+^qrqrqrcntt
	22.$IT{6oTBfi-{qEHMw^qEq-f,l Bofeiraroqq^gMGI.NE-+€t^qq-dg{ Er{crkd3rtq{fuim26.0e.201evq tffiE{quwilglncrfud3il-qwfriros7.s2.
	2o2o^qIsileift-f,frrt^qrifuu-qo^q-6

Ms Krishna Poly Extrusion v. Indian Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Hdfc Bank versus M/S Bonnie Foi Society

Afford Motors I Pvt. Ltd. versus Ms Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd.

Ms Agrawal Tractors And Spares versus Axis Bank

Ms Keshav Roadline versus Punjab National Bank

Ms Krishna Poly Extrusion v. Indian Bank

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Hdfc Bank versus M/S Bonnie Foi Society

Afford Motors I Pvt. Ltd. versus Ms Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd.

Ms Agrawal Tractors And Spares versus Axis Bank

Ms Keshav Roadline versus Punjab National Bank

Shri Mukesh Malviya versus Piramal Capital and Housing Finance limited

Dharmendra Kumar Jain versus Ncml Finance Pvt. Ltd.