Allowed

sunil jain v. manibhavnam home finance india Pvt. ldt

DRT14 Jul 2023SA/543/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The Special Appeal, filed within the limitation period from the date of knowledge of the challenged order, was allowed despite the order being passed without prior notice. The Special Appeal was finally disposed of imposing conditions on the deposit of outstanding dues with interest.

What did the court decide?

The Special Appeal allowed on conditions: depositing total outstanding dues with interest within six months in five installments; failure to pay two installments consecutively would permit the Bank to

DATE	iJEscRrpnouoFTHEoRDER	REMARK
sA543/23 14t07 t23	ShriRavishankarYadav,Advfbrthe Applicants Noneforthe Respondent
	l.Asperservicealfidavitregistryofthis Tribunalhasdeclaredserviceonallthe Respondentsas perorderdated01101123 whichrevealsthatinspiteol-service RespondentshavechoosesnoItoappcar thereforematteristakenupforhearingex- partewiththisobservationthatifinluture oontestin['']iesporidcntsappcarcclandpray's lbrhcalingt'hclnlttcronnrcritthcnmal.tcr' shallbehdaid again. 2. Onmatterbeing takenApplicanlCounsel byinvitingattcntiononordeldatecll3l)4l23 passedUytiienoM[Jjjansubnritsthatorcleris passed.x.plt1ew,ithout issuingnoticetothe :,,',r :l npplicanls.^" , !.) ,	: 3.,f!plicantCqunsellurtherbyinviting '! 1'!' _.! attefltionod,bossb'ssionnoticeissucdbythe Teh$iidarildtrtbo^rr:I:o/osrz:submitsthaton -i,-^{.^'i-'.-}-^{.v: 1-.} :.:' t8/0]5"/23^fpr:fl!.e^{filsttimctheApplicantscame} toknoweboljt'th.\ordel thelcalicronl7l06i23 this SAhas beenflledwhichiswithintime '+^-.r. ft'om thedateofknowledge howeverbarred by ,- - t" llhritation'fi'trnr thedateofpassingtheorder' rindpLays'iio,tciilrdonation ol-dclaronthc droundctrirdcnrlcr.l above. ,: 4.Onperusalofor:deratPara-3 rhe authdriw^'on:ithcbasis ol' dowh'bv tion'hte HishCourrirr ', ..I .- i:..,. itreveals that principlelaid casco['Adrtva

DATE

iJEscRrpnouoFTHEoRDER

REMARK

sA543/23
14t07 t23

ShriRavishankarYadav,Advfbrthe
Applicants
Noneforthe Respondent

l.Asperservicealfidavitregistryofthis
Tribunalhasdeclaredserviceonallthe
Respondentsas perorderdated01101123
whichrevealsthatinspiteol-service
RespondentshavechoosesnoItoappcar
thereforematteristakenupforhearingex-
partewiththisobservationthatifinluture
oontestin['']iesporidcntsappcarcclandpray's
lbrhcalingt'hclnlttcronnrcritthcnmal.tcr'
shallbehdaid again.
2. Onmatterbeing takenApplicanlCounsel
byinvitingattcntiononordeldatecll3l)4l23
passedUytiienoM[Jjjansubnritsthatorcleris
passed.x.plt1ew,ithout issuingnoticetothe
:,,',r :l
npplicanls.^"
,
!.)
,

:
3.,f!plicantCqunsellurtherbyinviting
'! 1'!'
_.!
attefltionod,bossb'ssionnoticeissucdbythe
Teh$iidarildtrtbo^rr:I:o/osrz:submitsthaton
-i,-^{.^'i-'.-}-^{.v: 1-.}
:.:'
t8/0]5"/23^fpr:fl!.e^{filsttimctheApplicantscame}
toknoweboljt'th.\ordel thelcalicronl7l06i23
this SAhas beenflledwhichiswithintime
'+^-.r.
ft'om thedateofknowledge howeverbarred by
,- - t"
llhritation'fi'trnr thedateofpassingtheorder'
rindpLays'iio,tciilrdonation ol-dclaronthc
droundctrirdcnrlcr.l above.
,:
4.Onperusalofor:deratPara-3
rhe authdriw^'on:ithcbasis ol'
dowh'bv tion'hte HishCourrirr
', ..I .-
i:..,.
itreveals that
principlelaid
casco['Adrtva

OATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
Birlav/s^lCarnetElias^{[rertrarlclcsarrclltrtoth} proceeded'inthepl'ocecclins^{r'</sup>ithtlLtt^issuirr noticetottreApplicarlts^{andhaspassecl th} orderunder challenged^{rvithor-rtservingl.totic} totheApplicants. 5.ItisundispLrtedthatoldcl^{iscr-prtrtcatl} lookingtonotice dated^{1(r/05123Ann.P-liti} apparentthatnotice^{hasbeenclelivcteclonth} Applicantson Applicantsgot IIt/05r23 knolrleclsc onu,hichlritsi lu[routtltcortl therefbre fiorngettingthe^{ktrou'ledgcabo} the orderu der challenge^{this petition isllle} n 1 I t' S S on17 li'om t06i2 ^jlrvhichlisuithin^{.1,iclavs.I Ior"'cv} pusslrlgtlrc orclcritis balrcclbrtirrcⁱ opinionofthisBench^{Applicants ate cntitlc} togetberiefitofexclr,rsion^{o1'tlictimeu'hic} passesawa4,b;1o13gettingl<nou^lcdge. (r.Orithis.$rtltrrtrl'lppliclrtiorllilt'cotrtltltlaLitl ofdefayisailowc{: ' I :i ^'' r.' 7.Maitcri'sdikcn'upforhcating^orrtncrit pplic4nt' C0 dpplicant.i:h ^{r:estill read,vto dcpositallthedr} 'l outstandin[,!rs re1'lectedunder^theordet 8.A r.rnselsubrnitsthat^tl . :... .1 9.-Applicitnt thercrnait.ting.allloLtllt C'ottrrscllirrthcr^{str[rntitstll rI} tVittroirt giriiri,eofportLrnity^{trr thcAppliclrr} qider;passedby'theResponclentauthoritl ,iot eiecutablelagainst^{thc Applicarttssincet} Applicant.s'alillr{'ll1^{sharitlgilrtt'llsi()ll to}lr}

OATE
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER

REMARK

Birlav/s^lCarnetElias^{[rertrarlclcsarrclltrtoth}
proceeded'inthepl'ocecclins^{r'</sup>ithtlLtt^issuirr
noticetottreApplicarlts^{andhaspassecl th}
orderunder challenged^{rvithor-rtservingl.totic}
totheApplicants.
5.ItisundispLrtedthatoldcl^{iscr-prtrtcatl}
lookingtonotice dated^{1(r/05123Ann.P-liti}
apparentthatnotice^{hasbeenclelivcteclonth}
Applicantson
Applicantsgot
IIt/05r23
knolrleclsc
onu,hichlritsi
lu[routtltcortl
therefbre fiorngettingthe^{ktrou'ledgcabo}
the orderu der challenge^{this petition isllle}
n
1
I
t'
S
S
on17
li'om
t06i2 ^jlrvhichlisuithin^{.1,iclavs.I Ior"'cv}
pusslrlgtlrc
orclcritis balrcclbrtirrcⁱ
opinionofthisBench^{Applicants ate cntitlc}
togetberiefitofexclr,rsion^{o1'tlictimeu'hic}
passesawa4,b;1o13gettingl<nou^lcdge.
(r.Orithis.$rtltrrtrl'lppliclrtiorllilt'cotrtltltlaLitl
ofdefayisailowc{:
' I
:i ^''
r.'
7.Maitcri'sdikcn'upforhcating^orrtncrit
pplic4nt'
C0
dpplicant.i:h ^{r:estill read,vto dcpositallthedr}
'l
outstandin[,!rs re1'lectedunder^theordet
8.A
r.rnselsubrnitsthat^tl
.
:...
.1
9.-Applicitnt
thercrnait.ting.allloLtllt
C'ottrrscllirrthcr^{str[rntitstll rI}
tVittroirt giriiri,eofportLrnity^{trr thcAppliclrr}
qider;passedby'theResponclentauthoritl
,iot eiecutablelagainst^{thc Applicarttssincet}
Applicant.s'alillr{'ll1^{sharitlgilrtt'llsi()ll to}lr}

DATE

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

REMARK

10.ApplicantCor-rnselpra)/slbr linaldisposal
ofthisSAu,ithlibeltytopa)'allthe
outstandingwithinsixmonths.
ll.Sincenool.rcappealcclon bchall'ol'thc
llespondentnothinqis ourccor.cltorcbLltor
disbelievethecontentionancibonalldeol'thc
Applicants.

12.Asper demand rroticeasonIlrl2'12tlrcre
isou(standinglbrI1s.14,44,360.88/- andas per
order dated13104123the authorityhastaken
total^'out5JqndingRs. i4,44,361/-rvhichis
loundfigui'6':
I
13.lookingtothcamountrrerrtit'lnedundcr'
thedcnaidrtirgtiigan<jundertheorderdatecl
l3/0+l31'rassedlr) tlrc \l)l\ltll.ilin
t.
Applicant.s^{i'''arc'liablc}todcposittotal
outstandingasor-r2lll2t22lts.I^-1,{4,36l/-
plusinteresttilldepositing lastinstallrrenlas
percontlacltialratc..
i^.
:i
tinrithowdvef;sixl.nonthspcriodis1oolongto
14,^{,QirrceApplicautsalcvoluntarily,aglccto}
depo5ittottioutstandinguithintelestrrithin
s'ix^{rliionths:then}thisSAmalbeclisposeclol
Iltralll:sqh.iccttocorrclilionlrrlclcposittotal
qLrtstrlrctiiiglri[thlirtercsruithinlllrccirinrc
epolr
t,
tthe,'diioirntinopirrionol'thisIlcnch
tota
cnodIr,enrr.r thsuoLrlci bcsrrllicicnt
I
d
I
I

DATE DESCRTPTION OFTHE ORDER	REMARK
inlirrr t5.^{TheretbrethisSAisbeingclis;rosecl} finallyonconditionsn'tcntionuillrs[rclori:- l' (ir)TheApplicants shalldepositintheirlo account Rs.14,44,361/- (Rupecs Fourtecn La Forfy FourThousand,l'hrec[]unclrcdan SixtyOne:only)withtlrcRcspondcntIlanki f-our installmentswithinfive ntonthslio todayoutofitRs.3,00,000/-(Rupees Thre Laconly)shallbedepositeclr,rithin^()nclront i.e., till 14108123,secondinstallnrcr Rs.3,00,000/- (RupeesI'hreeLac onll)sha bsdepositeii'titt^:t+logl23,thirdinsrallme Rs.3,00,0007ilttupeesThree I-aconly)shatlb depositedtiUl411023andlirurthinsrallnc Rs.3,00,0007. lRupeesThrecLaconly)shallb depositedfitl'tatt7/23,fifth&tastinstallme Rs.Rs.2,443,671,!(RupeesTwo[-ac,Fort FourThousfrd,^-fhreeIlundlcciandSixtyOn only)withl0fiainjhqanrountlllusintcrest beinginformedbythe I{espondent-llanksha bedeposite t4l:t2t23. il d'ti t t (ii)'n.rpilni.ntltlantiisdilccteclto last dueto flrcApp'lici.lr)ts \itlrirrl5tlrr depositingl.iisl:installnrer)ti.c.l-lI2Ii '; . ..r-. -.r, r sllor the ,irdir':iAsscd Ujjaih,:is^{lhb'fe6y lUy itrcAdclitionalCollcct} rad.ay. '-,!',)-- l$irv.,fwiththe^cl'l'cctfror I ( (lii) afo tak ptr A'd t

DATE
DESCRTPTION OFTHE ORDER

REMARK

inlirrr
t5.^{TheretbrethisSAisbeingclis;rosecl}
finallyonconditionsn'tcntionuillrs[rclori:-
l'
(ir)TheApplicants shalldepositintheirlo
account Rs.14,44,361/- (Rupecs Fourtecn La
Forfy FourThousand,l'hrec[]unclrcdan
SixtyOne:only)withtlrcRcspondcntIlanki
f-our installmentswithinfive ntonthslio
todayoutofitRs.3,00,000/-(Rupees Thre
Laconly)shallbedepositeclr,rithin^()nclront
i.e., till
14108123,secondinstallnrcr
Rs.3,00,000/- (RupeesI'hreeLac onll)sha
bsdepositeii'titt^:t+logl23,thirdinsrallme
Rs.3,00,0007ilttupeesThree I-aconly)shatlb
depositedtiUl411023andlirurthinsrallnc
Rs.3,00,0007. lRupeesThrecLaconly)shallb
depositedfitl'tatt7/23,fifth&tastinstallme
Rs.Rs.2,443,671,!(RupeesTwo[-ac,Fort
FourThousfrd,^-fhreeIlundlcciandSixtyOn
only)withl0fiainjhqanrountlllusintcrest
beinginformedbythe I{espondent-llanksha
bedeposite
t4l:t2t23.
il
d'ti
t
t
(ii)'n.rpilni.ntltlantiisdilccteclto
last dueto flrcApp'lici.lr)ts \itlrirrl5tlrr
depositingl.iisl:installnrer)ti.c.l-lI2Ii
'; .
..r-.
-.r,
r sllor
the ,irdir':iAsscd
Ujjaih,:is^{lhb'fe6y lUy itrcAdclitionalCollcct}
rad.ay.
'-,!',)--
l$irv.,fwiththe^cl'l'cctfror
I
(
(lii)
afo
tak
ptr
A'd
t

DATE		DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
	(iv)If consecu theRe agains 1310412 Ujjain.	theapplicantsfailtodeposittwo tiveinstallments as mentionedabove, sponder,t-Bankisfreetotakeaction ttheapplicantasperorderdaled 3passedbytheAdditionalCollector
	16.Sub SAisb	jecl1o cor-rditior-rsmentioncdabove this eingdisposedof linally.
	17.Rec	ordbeconsignedto the record roo!n.. 'r' sb
		'.<br>:':(RaHfii*fr^Rrt.t; PresidingOfficer 'l:SiC D.R.T,Jabalpur (M.P&C.G)
	,t.:i;il	1:r. r"1, 'l

DATE

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

(iv)If
consecu
theRe
agains
1310412
Ujjain.

theapplicantsfailtodeposittwo
tiveinstallments as mentionedabove,
sponder,t-Bankisfreetotakeaction
ttheapplicantasperorderdaled
3passedbytheAdditionalCollector

16.Sub
SAisb

jecl1o cor-rditior-rsmentioncdabove this
eingdisposedof linally.

17.Rec

ordbeconsignedto the record roo!n..
'r'
sb

'.<br>:':(RaHfii*fr^Rrt.t;
PresidingOfficer
'l:SiC
D.R.T,Jabalpur
(M.P&C.G)

,t.:i;il

1:r.
r"1,
'l

sunil jain v. manibhavnam home finance india Pvt. ldt

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

sunil jain v. manibhavnam home finance india Pvt. ldt

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

M.P. Power Management Company Ltd. versus Bank of Maharashtra

Waliya and Company versus Bank of Baroda

Rahul Jain versus Au Small Finance Bank Limited

Smt Reeta Agarwal versus Union Bank of India

Shri Dadarao Tale versus Vastu Housing Finance Corportion

State Bank of India versus Prateek Kamesh