Ramesh Pal v. Idfc First Bank Ltd.

DRT2 Sept 2023SA/299/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

.CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE	DESCRTPTION OFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	qfl.q.299,/2023
02.o9.2023	3Tril{n^q.eTdfuqfrScgw+ftm 3rkq-ffirsqRarot sm-.{rfr^qirqtVq 23rd.e.\rs.fr. d-6d'ft\ fi^qftilortq{siGrfu{ffir sqRerf,t
	1. vrrzrsflC,enil{f,^q&TofGili1) trlgdfrri^.r}fuqerrrTonnfio-qrfi Bs4/2023CaaGrrilfidrflar s"tnf,BTs {arFr 3]ril{r,en{.q.qfl2044/2023k{rf, 11.05.2023^q{SrT^qqrtI!-mroTOI3md}f,{ ioqr^qq'rt
	z. seFkr:^q6 t fu{g eTkf,{ur6Rrgs{noqrrteirieTfr{rfiza.oz. zozzd^qrqqtforqerqrsil-a-{r@\dfrd rodgs,ffi dfldfr_E€^qilnuEftd Grfuq-iqAfrq-qi^qelTfurfrq{rd{€ioT Gil-taTcrR-dfu-qrrqreTr,fu-g sm-{qrfrilfi d av^qr++qs@^qr+ttrsdrrqeru-tgoafr .dfrfrqqrfi-mTVr.fr.asosTzozstqfro 3neyrft-+o1i.08.2023der5rmsrElfi.ro) ft{aT fuqr^rTqTBfue'arrf,'fueerqr 3{rnE{ qrfrqnoftrosrroturqzrirEfrR-q-afrri qr-idq{qkrGrdRq{r6r{flrdfr-gqrgqr qdIE-florEqqarrkl:Gnt(fiqerdaM s-tgdfuf,qa-qrend-cq,en{.q.=i{r.854/2023 flftqo{uT fuqr^qrrsrtt
	3. onlq-o^qelilTr^qdltF{'Twnrz(r) rr-ifift\r{d2002dci-a.fdEflGTkf,{urd trrleTfu{ioog.os.zozsoI,T***

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

PAGE No.

¶7

CASE No

Ramesh Pal versus Idfc First Bank Ltd. — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶8

DATE	OESCRIPTTONOF THE ORDER	REMARK
	29.05.2018 3{q-{fu-fli ^q@e ft-+o30.01.2020 2z.o2.2o2offiq++rWffiflffi ftqfo28.12.2021^{Qaqtrfrtd-cft{;6rt.oz.} 2022d^GTrrr{flfrrS^qdVq^.iel6sqfuor orEq-.qoilA-ffrrurd^qertFefft-o^fun qritgrrgdfuqrrqTBt 4. fiil{6^q&To13iri<sup>u-f,{ulsqd ?FTitErAd"o\erqrfrtd^qfitg^q-qd frrSd3ffiftqGnifi Fr5s^3ilEflqB fuoiBs-reTdTqrfto1^{3r-qtst fu{rfi} 16.03.2020o\srwfu-dT^{qftiltegd-.qel{r} qR-dsneqrfrqioso.ot.zozoIsq-qftqr r+qrqd,fug^{qTTfiss@flqqlqrf,qETtl} Tqi-{qr^qtfdoro,qt+.$/2002^{qrRd3n*{ frqrf,ro.or.zozzd^{norcTt ffi} za.oz.zozz norqlqT^3TBF=qqd^{q]-qEnaRTloffiei,ii</sup> erqByeTofrtn^qHqY'str^r+re-rfr^is fiRu_sofsoff{a^{erqfu.fiy"rofrrnqd} qY'qBIdqqsrd^qIE.mTzzefr{tfrEIkd B,fttE^{rt"klT{o116d ox"r3lt}cmqeTsItR} fu-fl^qmed^rrqerfr^roqurtrqd6-t fro1q6s5a1-6^{oh--oqrqroq$ qqqTstFwl} rgoori^{tnr enierfi{io17.07.2022 qETn} fr;qr^rrqr,fu-g^{ilflEa.rd3Tlil<ooqiqr ot} q-ffiorrnft-mT@cltq2^rrlft{fiHtfttft.BdE<br>Tiffi Bqqlqtor-i<o^TUIq{fl€^tgs qrl{urrr{qcf,qts+Gr+{3rriffi^qelr6-{uT rqdi-froq^qrSt r1q{rtti-ifr08.01.201e {drErEr^qrR-dsniql ftq-fi 6rffiH{rfi o{fuq-.s}

¶12

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	5. GniqoseTE-r{Gr-}Ecfr^qFfd qru-{Erdo-i{rCfdordgVftciqerqro-t Tf,^onnfi{ur^{<tst1igiqri3_gqrflfu-}} srioror-jtqfu-qrwrtt
	6 sf,{srft^qeT@1oil{Q,rrgdfu-d .T-iWifuoceffirGnA-fiorq-{rqe-$Udo-r onqfufr^.dtfustrT f{qioao.or.zozo sqq^qeio\gro-{^qrRdfu-qrrqT3nAyrB Vs^qtrfiRqfu6r^oTflgq.qffi zo.oz.zozo @i fuqT^qrg@TB^qs+.Tffioffi o<br>en$ftoftti^qriig^.frvns$ofor-{fud q{qrdgfitrrtr{gdfuqrrrqTtgs{fl Grfuf,{uTd^qnTrz(r)rrqfift'+ezoozd qrrdtteTrrrsqqfilGrfuhqqdqrqqnar'[ @-r{+Er€IqToTfuqerrrlrn-{io1 erffim^qfrttr€strrti^q{qkrf,3nilfi frrwm^qriGr-jtqfu-fl^qqrg '
	7. GrrilfidrilqGil-n{f,^qeTgr{r l-rgd ft-i^.dGrFrMio)tET^qddrunrra+<r (qiwrq,/s) fu{iqt2s.os.2o1lr}c-qBatr GIEqcqg++u\+4q1 y,zaerfuEraqr6q 6{iofrp++rdrlu^g6Et, dergrm orDq.q+io1ordqTfrft-qiqoe.or.zorst {rqfu-dtrGrr}qoserdE-RrftrnTd GrE{q-{s\t€T^qria\Grr}qoeeT^q_o66qr qrrorBfusm-rqfrtoariTeftq.qr{z-{r Rrooe.or.zorsofilqffi3rd-{6s&T^rl-r Tfrof^rT{fi@GrBrcsr6ur6{dio1 Rerfrtffiior+.or.zoredmqqt st 3IEq-.sqilrT6TEr{EGnd^qRen}qo^qa
	alrftcio14.01.201 o)src+it+sFqn

¶16

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
dsiq<Tflq^wgd'Et grtftA^-r{e}-ft^{ascRRerfrft-qdft'tuE} fro*^,oo,.zoret{fl^{f,?a6-lfl;ld qd} d^qrqq<fu^{qsrdrrqfuqI3llqqfl} s-oc-{rfi+fi^{dgnrftqrur-gort eelio} qRTrs(+)rr6q8f,{f,{B(1)sffi^ue zoozof6rffi^{ofsig+1t frrfrtrr{17} (1)r+ffiv{d^{2oo2A a}Tilirwg(s-f,{uT} 6{i 6t^{qr<ol-{uTssq di dqrq-{<} ora-{fi^qeri^{3Tlqq-.qra++ro\dBs-te} qETqrftet^qRRerfrqR,.{idXdzfr-ft r-€tfuqr^{qirflqfiqrftFifit+otzotst} ergqfoto\fr-s-re^{T6TqrftqRt{id} oiq,tlr{q^.$eqrwd3-+t^{st3lertasrBq€q} rpno<sup>snAfuofrtiqfifu^nowrq'to' erqfuerkdt^t 8. qo oo3{q{ 3IWfu-dl^qftflc tdq^{gRTqIRd3rTt$f{qrfioo'ot'2020qI} q{rt,gfl3naPTo1oBrrzd^3r{drc-rt setfuT"t^{qarielqrdgq4Ilftae$} qlcto){{?{r^qacTftE3rTI^{cr-{ril{f,rlrr} qdftdqrzrrf,qfisqRemEq,sqn^iRSd fo-qrt^3rarfdaot^{qHo'lg_{-{r{ oT}T{^3ltNR tfir^sntsTk{t6^{3o.o1.zozoqRo fuqrrrqt} Br^{q-qfrgserlsoqqd r+qmn-dd d{tc} GTri<o^qeTdRI^{GnqfuA ..T{g 6 q5-rw}Xf tGr-q^Grr{@-+q-{{dR^dwat5-or{fu aRd^arT,fuS^{3lTePTk{i-fi15.01.2020d} 3i-5$r{-o ^{-.llql c{U} t"ertt^{qrqrf,qfrq6qu} cadi6oTo-rftqT^{,TqT,frtgqnt -.llqlqlq t} ot$rpn^.ra\rfr E3n^{$1oTqnT3ldffi}

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

REMARK

dsiq<Tflq^wgd'Et
grtftA^-r{e}-ft^{ascRRerfrft-qdft'tuE}
fro*^,oo,.zoret{fl^{f,?a6-lfl;ld qd}
d^qrqq<fu^{qsrdrrqfuqI3llqqfl}
s-oc-{rfi+fi^{dgnrftqrur-gort eelio}
qRTrs(+)rr6q8f,{f,{B(1)sffi^ue
zoozof6rffi^{ofsig+1t frrfrtrr{17}
(1)r+ffiv{d^{2oo2A a}Tilirwg(s-f,{uT}
6{i 6t^{qr<ol-{uTssq di dqrq-{<}
ora-{fi^qeri^{3Tlqq-.qra++ro\dBs-te}
qETqrftet^qRRerfrqR,.{idXdzfr-ft
r-€tfuqr^{qirflqfiqrftFifit+otzotst}
ergqfoto\fr-s-re^{T6TqrftqRt{id}
oiq,tlr{q^.$eqrwd3-+t^{st3lertasrBq€q}
rpno<sup>snAfuofrtiqfifu^nowrq'to'
erqfuerkdt^t
8.
qo oo3{q{ 3IWfu-dl^qftflc
tdq^{gRTqIRd3rTt$f{qrfioo'ot'2020qI}
q{rt,gfl3naPTo1oBrrzd^3r{drc-rt
setfuT"t^{qarielqrdgq4Ilftae$}
qlcto){{?{r^qacTftE3rTI^{cr-{ril{f,rlrr}
qdftdqrzrrf,qfisqRemEq,sqn^iRSd
fo-qrt^3rarfdaot^{qHo'lg_{-{r{ oT}T{^3ltNR
tfir^sntsTk{t6^{3o.o1.zozoqRo fuqrrrqt}
Br^{q-qfrgserlsoqqd r+qmn-dd d{tc}
GTri<o^qeTdRI^{GnqfuA ..T{g 6 q5-rw}Xf
tGr-q^Grr{@-+q-{{dR^dwat5-or{fu
aRd^arT,fuS^{3lTePTk{i-fi15.01.2020d}
3i-5$r{-o ^{-.llql c{U} t"ertt^{qrqrf,qfrq6qu}
cadi6oTo-rftqT^{,TqT,frtgqnt -.llqlqlq t}
ot$rpn^.ra\rfr
E3n^{$1oTqnT3ldffi}

¶24

OATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	q{2o2ot+f,{ftqi6^{0s.0s.2923nfr6I} oogft"ftfiEM"T^{r</sup>Y"ro^frttqduil-'q r$ t^{gs3il-n{fiq&Td a-{r3rq{ fuf,r} s-€TffirsdR^{dqqsTfrfrqffit 1.01.2022} ofRrorqo^{3rrifitriSf,fuqrrtqtfuq-ol} ft{rs{uT^3[t-iPTfrqio^{fi.07.2022d arsrsm} oe{c{tstraRT^{fo-qrrrqrr r+rqr-qBqrg14} qqtfl3IEFqqdcrqqrnd3i-cr'ioYtrcfut fli^zh.qr-St,^{or<qfuqrkd3ntcrd} Ar-qorffiod^{or&{rft-fi6fi r-qiqrd} frr{fi^q@ed^{qrqroqt nAqo u-tgor€l} fu-qT^rrqrenqfr^{3ldctrgxr3TraqrqrRd} o-{isrd^{;qrqrf,qd qqagqmqqqrfuor} ntgoo1'r{^{n,oeftr-tfi11'01'202 tr{ifi} 1s.07.2022il6^{o1rrq-qiqts3lqqffidfrtiqrt} q}'qrStI 'ro.$l({6tgs.fidelsdt^fu3tqi 6e{cq{dranr^{qrRd3il-iqTfr{io30'01'} zozoo\5+t ii &^{fd-{ifi28.05.2022dq} u-tgoorio1^{qrqqr€qI3nilffiqao</sup> sltrer^,ft,fu-g^{gqlcnqBfrq6-quTrqdrS} ft;qr^rrqrI Etr^dr6t^{3rTtPTffi63s.ot.zozo} oleirAft-ofrtn^qfiig^{ttu-rgf,q-f,{ur3i-qB} qrfuott}}
	i1. snieoseTddRIffi 1pil ftq1-6to rz.zozr,^{furrr;+nd qolttiiqero} Hqfuofffi t5rffi^qq,cdG+d $trftrd-cftqro^{tt.oz.zozz(vtmt}x/zz)^fr ntrdr@<sup>.tenAfuofuqTt,^{furqesr3il-n-{r} t3rrn@^qqTdrm^s{Iffi q{rT^gq qzofstEil=tf,I@T fr_6-qolffir.ft-oq

¶42

OATE	DESCRIPTTON OFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	oT{q3rstsilf}aBgs^qF+qtszqd-rr qtqtdq Er{rsrurqTKrfus-€vrq(zoro)r+ vtr.fr.$.llrd^{qfuqlP{d srftq-d}d'^er5wr r[{T5q-qtil3rBF=qqd^ql-qtTrqtr{g(dH srd^qr(q-,dftqGnmfidr& +i^yq qr;rft'q Bz4f,qqrqTcrqdrrrtffi$	s EEt^srg-S-qE$-{^frffiq-dsdd qtilrsqrCtrc(zooo)7sn.fr.fr.16eti qffi orft-EradsE{rTrfufllqqmd 31ffi^qqruru-+goodfumsrrqq^qflqr erqqrF_aB,rrcr^qrqtsrqffl3TBFqqd rrlqrdrsqqq3rqqffif,e<sup>qrddr
	17.^grrdv+rufrsffiqoea^q6',frB fu^qnrrz(r)w$rft^gf,c2oo2d^qrqqrnd ero,tou-rgoi^qrar3nd-fi,Xoor<rad {rruqoT+dTBvsrur^qq-fr3rDIfi{uTtfr rorqo1g_flri aaeftroftorotd ^qTqT.rcI oltfuq-f,to-{drtd-flTfuflq-+qs@ilq' .qlqlc4q danrcrffiqrdft-o.-dffs-dqfr{r qfrgqRqT2Qa4(Z)_sq1[{qil+ogofo.E.6r oztqq{anfr.r{tt
	18.uagreffi-ofrBtfuwnrzo rl{d{frvrd2oo2d3r-d-ldntgodriord qf,qurqrTiE-$qTf,sKq-{or6tortyqts qTq-dltsTRr5qqi<ToTBfr-qqdqt-qqn qrqi-qrSEt-d)tsn3rftqdqrrfiqqEs
	B@^qrqrarratE-sfl-dEt-iTif,tt
	q€Aeftfr	sfrt-q
	qanr{-w-@@qcd'o oi-rqq
	orq^qrfuoro-qfznetzsr zora^ilqrR-dsTrt{r fuflo05.09.2019,^qn-fiq.nffiFGIrBEr

¶46

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	.qlqlclq o1q-sftd darsr^eletf, qr$c fufr-s wisru o-drqr "-6-q-ff 3l-d[ fr.iqsrst,/2oos^ilclftd eniqrfu{ioso 04.2010, ^{qr{Esrd 2010 \rg.} S.fr.ofi--{dr$q ^rD?t6<II1361 ql-{ftq drorva^{qrqra-qd El-{t} ^{d.fr.qqco-}crfid} ET$TI 3II fr{-q EFI?F'III qs qqr$ thnrorfrt{rc frfrys ^2015gfl.fr. m.^ofi--{dr$-{ drot^{zszzzfiqfrMfudfuql} .rqrBt 1e. e<sup>qcqlRr5^{Tqt(r3fiF-qcteosd} HclrrFT^qrsrrz(1)1]ffi^{g+d2oo2d ffc} u-qodiura^{u-oqutrt qr+''or€lB,aq} ol'il{6^qeTdrt+sfrc^{o1ftqtR(rlqqrqB} d^{qqsl(g'q.eTlfm-r"Td rrqerftqfooo.os.} zozs6Iulaofr,t'ri^{gnroq"Tt +sfu+r} 613mfud^{qrqrdc.frfr_mqgurt)q6flqI} frrn^qd.qr&^Bt \tf
	20 sqt-firgrxo1^{-,[email protected]} orfil{fi^qeTa1^3nrt^s-qerfttn.rd w{qreneqordEs^{gsfto oi} roBfu^{qNI17(1)rl.{ffig{d2oo2d {fl} yrowrteTRis^qqi"Jqfqfrqcofs]q}-qf,r^q +it^{srdeoqflq,13ir{t rqoerile< trnt} 5TqlEr^GftF={q{ffi q}.qrfrtt 21.s-<^{qRRPTMd fi-oor}"ro^Bfu wqGflilelo^qeTgmqtgdxa^3n]c{tr{T17 (1){flffiv{e2oo2^{q-{EqrErflt,flq} enneo.rq^gRTtr{g(^{{€rJTcarff{q,eil{.q'} 2044/2023ft-flfi^{11.05.2023{ffi} fr'q n$i6warl A

¶50

DATE	DESCR]PTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	22 3rE-(fi^qeTEl{rry ona-fiil{r5^q{rf{r3rfuhqq, \rs.q.8s4l2023 gs{aFI=i3rTil({6qrfi2044/2023G-{K fr,isrddt
	23. qfu3ndqfi^qeT6RIe-tnd{f, GrdEca,rqB^qEIdBrfuqerqT3rrilfi {ffi zil.qr&qrqt^rtqTtt^q"n<fsq 3trlcfi^qeT6Rrtr{gf,^z16w..2ss/²⁰²² ei-q-B^qrE)_d+{rftqtRdordgv^gcfr{fl{w frrffo1^qrfrtt 24. glrqgel3N-qI3rtF[qqqrqol'tt qRvnq^_s.,iE\t ro,rerFfci-snmtwqrfuqr^qri t slD ...,/ ,/ 6ll^n-on'ula) ffiqBrfY+ift fi.el-{.fl.q.q.,?i^E-ffiR1-G

Ramesh Pal v. Idfc First Bank Ltd.

A compact analysis

Statutes considered

Case details

Similar cases

SBI Staff Housing Cooperative Society versus Housing Urban Development Corporation Ltd.

Punjab National Bank versus Vinayak Motors

Central Bank of India versus Sukhdeen Prasad Kol

Anirudh Singh versus Icici Bank Limited

Ramesh Pal v. Idfc First Bank Ltd.

A compact analysis

Statutes considered

Case details

Similar cases

SBI Staff Housing Cooperative Society versus Housing Urban Development Corporation Ltd.

Punjab National Bank versus Vinayak Motors

Central Bank of India versus Sukhdeen Prasad Kol

Anirudh Singh versus Icici Bank Limited

Gopal Krishna Joshi versus Muthoot Homefin (India) Ltd.

Ms Odtin Food Solution versus Bank of Maharashtra