Ms Odtin Food Solution v. Bank of Maharashtra

DRT2 Sept 2023SA/922/2022

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	\q..e22/2022
02.09.20 3	onn{sceTdfugfrTrfuicrf,TE 3TfuilffiII
	BdrqrfrceTdfuqfryrcnogi orfu+mt
	1.^g{rqqeT e77/2023YS 2231/2022kqior+.rr.zo22dTdGTfffi dsrqrid.{Brq€cilq-{enilerotT{.* s8o/2023,Tarrr13llifis74/2O23qrgfi HTPIEil^TTqTBI 6) f{dqerqr ef,alf{dqeFIr onilfi oTrilfi
	2. g-.F\rulo-t€i-fcT}6-{fu-qtrrqlt
	3.onnq-6^rrsEr{IftqteFso.og.zo22d €InI17(1)s-irffiVtrd2oo3dsrqETrqfA er-a.fa^qeg-q-rur$workfi-ruTdqqeT{-.r q+rrfoiro04.0s.20211gi@rq,/1)o-i esrwffiqriofs6rrrdTfu rqdfuqr vlrh-r 3f,q 3r5'srFrfisErrrdrerfrGBt
	4. e-6rure-Ed rh-{itgqffdqol eFIIftti qri tgyarfion'fi{err$.q. 22s7/2022{donnfidsrqc-gdfu-qr TrqITI
	s. qfue-m{"rHer,rEqqlfiqfusrBd ttero'erqenffit^qrXurdvwgr+( dTdfodqffirTona-fi 6-rftrr6-r"r qmftqq.c.BEIalrqrtrq Ernfrfrsqrfuor Ecio43os/202s .gw.fr.^rDEfu
	f{s-dr+qrcrf,ltierqSc-6-r"rfrcrfu sTrtsrRir+,11srrFFTzozszdc-6Mfr qsrrf,:ftrrfrTqfu-qrqrqrerqrqoBt

¶5

CONTD. ORDER-SHEET

¶6

PAGE No

¶7

CASE No....

Ms Odtin Food Solution versus Bank of Maharashtra — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

DATE	DESCRTPTION OFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	6.{f,3rrifid^qrPrc-qdfrtn^rr} fuoqerqrorrffio-IoIIqRBol^oTifq-o @qtq-2^q3sr+ffiv{ed3trd*isrfr o.rffitGtcft-g^e)tq++r^qnetriq-6. e-qi61^rNdIftf,gi,ffi fft-q onqi{fi^q-gdfuqr^rrqr\rsenieoceTd x"r^qrio)w.fr.q.qftE-dftri^qrior onqtur^rrqlt{SffdrEdftlrdwrot s-{qratrft{S^qss-m-i-qrftfo dem qqd-drffio-rifrilqri oloilYqrs{fi icqr^.rqrtgSsd-q frs-o{oru-qoc-€t fu-qr^rrql{S+soTrfuT6qqq-{rft-{ro. 24.12.2021ifuooqfr^.r$t
	7. GTra-{6s&roloprcBoff€ 6r"iitfudr^qWgMcrRdoTrtYr ftiroro.or.zoradfur-e^gfurfuv-eq+rr dffs-€e-6-{ure-Edo-{i^it1+o< gurtt
	8. B-trrqrftt-fidamfuaqeffir sTra-fioTyaro.t^qqrsftiroso.og.zozs rqoo-GEqoTlile{otf+tETfu-qr.rqrt fttETo.remmto1oTrftqsq++furio 24.12.2021o)ET(tTilffi-fro1^.r{Bt ffi sFDETqTftnkd+t^.rgB,fu-g GTI'{q-+.ceTtsrqftqrdsiqqn6-{ur u-qor€tfu-qrBI{rr^qrntfito.R fuqr fu-qr^rrqrtofoilfuc-flq+off,rffid rrrsrfl,froTff{6serBffic_qrfttfi t sc-to-t^q-qNIo-r^y6rerTIsttoIIErr{^q{ rqaurferft{trfrrt^qrtorsrj+T fu-qr^.rqrBt
	e. Bdi-qrftceTof ofttrgofut .rierfu&dfor er-q-fro.l o1crqrqrort

¶12

DATE OESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
sfffu{io.24.12.2021 3rrfuq€eErro-Go1 Td{q-fl(yiffi{ sfft/1)ffi srok{f6 27.12.2021 d^qrtqqtsfro[rilef,rr"Idcrc^qr,HTsr frerqtrdq-q^qeTdtiqrTstsYv(o'd qlrrqrfrnR-d5faq-q1qrf,rtIvtrrqrfr ceranTift-f,cfrtarcwsrworio-r^rfi EftrTeNfrEqrqt ffi ergvxoTrn{6. e-qrfi2HRrET(krclEs crqo-G ot erd6-S^rr$d'r
10.gEoTr+<-o.^qeTioTciurn6q6 srerolrfuqflq++ft-tioz+.tz.zoztfr cfr{d.{fuqrB,dergryqftordr^qr}.r ofori{q-6ceTo'}onfuqtqqaqrftqrfiz+. 12.2021o1sfturwg{tr 11.AfuB-m-rqrftceTofeirqt^qo onqfud^.r$Bo1^qrwsttfrtrflffiro. 24.12.2021,3Trfucg{firr-€ft,^qfu ftirorr.or.2o2zdifud^{q,t .r$qq-+} 6+er^{trr./4)ftqqa (1)s($-Ss{e} zoozdffnifrdollfuq-€qflt,ftilt orrn<-o.^qateneifuoagfum,fu-g^zra snqfuffi qtsc-€lB, o-tqot 1q-ie1/3){d{r^{ft-{i624.12.202'td} qrqqtvtr{qrftt'ogm3fl-ilq-6cmol sFif,^qqfuot^GTrfuqscriftTfi6 str-qrfrt-6d^qTctiot^erStufour .rqr B\tiqEB-mrqrfr ceIgMu-gofun rrtqqrqffiqeo.oe.zo23ofotrs-orzi {sEd{r^{o}3Trfuq€q+trwdE-ooG} ES^{cfuqnfu-qrrrqrB,aq fi-ao.ITd ot} oTril<ocelo)e-o{qc-\1f,oritg^sK ortq ot.r,rmtq!fro^{qaqr frir6'z+.t2.}

DATE
OESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

REMARK

sfffu{io.24.12.2021
3rrfuq€eErro-Go1 Td{q-fl(yiffi{
sfft/1)ffi
srok{f6
27.12.2021
d^qrtqqtsfro[rilef,rr"Idcrc^qr,HTsr
frerqtrdq-q^qeTdtiqrTstsYv(o'd
qlrrqrfrnR-d5faq-q1qrf,rtIvtrrqrfr
ceranTift-f,cfrtarcwsrworio-r^rfi
EftrTeNfrEqrqt ffi
ergvxoTrn{6.
e-qrfi2HRrET(krclEs crqo-G ot
erd6-S^rr$d'r

10.gEoTr+<-o.^qeTioTciurn6q6
srerolrfuqflq++ft-tioz+.tz.zoztfr
cfr{d.{fuqrB,dergryqftordr^qr}.r
ofori{q-6ceTo'}onfuqtqqaqrftqrfiz+.
12.2021o1sfturwg{tr
11.AfuB-m-rqrftceTofeirqt^qo
onqfud^.r$Bo1^qrwsttfrtrflffiro.
24.12.2021,3Trfucg{firr-€ft,^qfu
ftirorr.or.2o2zdifud^{q,t .r$qq-+}
6+er^{trr./4)ftqqa (1)s($-Ss{e}
zoozdffnifrdollfuq-€qflt,ftilt
orrn<-o.^qateneifuoagfum,fu-g^zra
snqfuffi
qtsc-€lB, o-tqot
1q-ie1/3){d{r^{ft-{i624.12.202'td}
qrqqtvtr{qrftt'ogm3fl-ilq-6cmol
sFif,^qqfuot^GTrfuqscriftTfi6
str*-qrfrt-6d^qTctiot^erStufour
.rqr B\tiqEB-mrqrfr ceIgMu-gofun
rrtqqrqffiqeo.oe.zo23ofotrs-orzi
{sEd{r^{o}3Trfuq€q+trwdE-ooG}
ES^{cfuqnfu-qrrrqrB,aq fi-ao.ITd* ot}
oTril<ocelo)e-o{qc-\1f,oritg^sK
ortq ot.r,rmtq!fro^{qaqr frir6'z+.t2.}

¶16

OATE OESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
2021u\ifrilEd^sFEgRTffi zt.tz.zozt o\nfudo1^.r$.r'rtrqftd^{qrtdrqB I}
12.frt-S^{q-6-dT'tf,erlq-5B ofeqt} sTril{ficeTt^{gs3Trfuqsqa-tro\w<} o-{iA^q{qrdsrrrlftff^detEtc-fi{ur e-trdfu-fi,dca^oesftffi{d^Bd oritrq-o^qeTo)sTIEqfl^q++rft-+ro^24. 12.2021^qfti-qdsrod^{qrtqqt ftRqi} zoztI^er-q{qfr^crqdI^.r$ "ff^rercaTriffi sHs-rd^qeoqrqtfo^vfrwcr^crt orrnq-o.^q-qioro<sup>qr<g$,d^B-d-{+rft +o,of^gsorffi^q1frorXur^{dvw ae} ftsn"tq€ftt,^{qcaTri{6'qai lrrq}
ftfl dotqssd{-qrfrt-6'^gnTnfud sTrfuriqq++rolg-+frtifurow e-qf, s-rfrqr+dr,fu-gs^{qTE+ ftdq}t fuiro 3o.os.o2o22o)c-6{ur^g-qd frlqrtsre^qRo\fusrer6rqrfrof^sqq 6q1frzar$2022@^gerofut wt m-qt,o)y.rooqfur^{qFI,d-q,fttzo} ft-{flterfuoorfuoq ro-tq^u-qdo{t tcrqr^qrorB,orerfd^oTril<oqeTETtre-Ed {f,^{c-6-rurersD qrfudt t}
13.srqffiq qc;IqEtfueqr smTs^qqlErsTEft{qd^qrqErmfdernm qtfuoqer{IoIIilfiffiffiosq-sruTguT
dqwEr-qr$igftqr^qrsoorBt^gs
orD-6{"r^?D'rqdBo1cr+ftqcrrq
qrqrilqdamflHqrd'fuo.-dfufr&
ftt=€sfff{d,s'Etrsqr rqer.qzouQ) cq.fi.'d.d.+osofo.Fs6loztfui^.ri
orftqf,dergsxEIm17^qr$ffivire2oo2 d<tio-.f-ou-*go disrft eiftso-rww

¶20

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	Td^{&{rD-o-rrqrd qrqroqd weru-ge} iEre^?IrEqaorf,rt,+$^q.c.€.d eiffi^qrse-Edfuqrqrf,rB,erqfugq orfuo.{'rd^qqerq-Edgse-o-rq o-rE$s srEc-{o'rBI
	14.E-€-dHTgIfr^qmftqGrilq qrqrtrqEI{ra-{rft}cs gmffiq {er
	c6+n frt-€filtuc-nffi Sfr,tqq
	M+ret,tf si-q^(zoos)z^{qs.fr.rft.tog}d
	q-6rort cffiftGrftTddergonfur qffif6frsqttftqlErnrqfrqrsrsqrF-d o1^.r$B,v{dfrsqtqmsrqf{r orEftqqrsoedlilturqcr+wc-€l E)frd \st-Ss-fivord^amqrrqo'r^grrqfrqr ffif,o-riorfrilo.TfrdnTI
	15. q6fiqBEkrrI:til-ql6rildgm cffi{dB?kTEErddctDRrt^q6 stffiqBof^qmrz(1)vffigae zoozderqETHft+Esqdtr BGgqffis sr+Td trilfi.Bdqfuofs-s-r"r u-goodtE+sfu{sofqrqfrqr crqtrfud o1^rr$t,.rqwfi-ddc-drjsr Es^erfuo-rqoirss.rqfrqr o)fuknRf, tE{iofetffiorqTTfiqBakrrrqFnem dsqtfr^qTs-{Erdticffi{d.,gq-6$ q-sr$tfi-sdq-oeisric-€tBr
	16.ss s<rfiiftfuq^qmfiqs@ qrqrmdfExtcftrqrF{dorftqdfi
	offiaY+rftqSt^qr+ftqrttrrsBErRrrrnrrr d^qreftddffn+dn dfrffircd crf+eftft	sfrras sIQRrg-wsTro,t*-t
	Etrsrrc+6,otfrs-rc Gerq^qrfuqrro.qifi

¶30

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
TtT{4I{-q wftrq icr$+eftfr	s
fuftaerfidsz+o/zozz tdtudtrq
Rirorr.oo.zooz^qot.rgqrqrdGr$sn sfl^u-ovurt^erms^qqisrqfiftqqd cEErHdr[Ts6fu^qrqrqrortts$il{6 tolEo'{'rEHMqrqtdilrtot oTrnffirrerFMrwofuoeercroTrifi od.q.2207/2022H-or+.rr.zozzffion frrn^qri*.qc-fre'r
18.d^qsGnn{fi^qeTFMrqdTd q-fi{urcrqEsrEdB,aq enieoqergItT gs€ffiBerfude-s-rqttu-gocr-qrd-o-ff sidRqGTrffien$.q.saolzozssrdTryiw{ gqed.q.s74/2.023srdfudqerqrfrr$ qdtgdw.froiltrc{vdcsM crfu ontcrfitro'fi.12z022t^'sq{fuf,Srw q-6{qtgqdsqrft-qm'r+.ql-€lB, HsrF{Ffdu}sr^qrdrtr
1e.^q6wE ft-qqrortofqR G{rtqrft-{ro$.12:022oisTre}ft-dfrr}qri fu^{wwfiqygq6e1B,n-caili{ficer}sfl oTrtcTdfrs-qttyQnD'gtD-rqrEoortfu Fkr-rB,dqcTrtffi-rrqolgcffiq enn{ridqnsqtB-drn.r}apqfol Grfuf,fi6-{i ofs6q61sffi1
20.BctffiTgfirtsnA-{fi^qeTErntrEd fuoqerqronnq-{vtl.u.zzzt72s22F.iw 14.11.2022ftffifuqr^qrf,rtt
21.d-{f,srrrsgdTdsTra-fiqNT17 (1)s$ffiV+d2oo2\r{Lg.ee2l2022orqfu qlfudfufR-dorigvqSwrqrftrw fu-qr^qrortt

DATE		DESCRIPTTON OFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	22. ottI	g+rqqeTsrrl-;IT3ilrqTqr(qqir6{
	23. oTfu+	^qRunqqdfuqrqFD'{Tm{ul sFrntfEtftf,{qIqrilI p fisFfi-ftrffi S.em.0c.c.Gwfiwrra

Ms Odtin Food Solution v. Bank of Maharashtra

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

SBI Staff Housing Cooperative Society versus Housing Urban Development Corporation Ltd.

Punjab National Bank versus Vinayak Motors

Central Bank of India versus Sukhdeen Prasad Kol

Anirudh Singh versus Icici Bank Limited

Ms Odtin Food Solution v. Bank of Maharashtra

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

SBI Staff Housing Cooperative Society versus Housing Urban Development Corporation Ltd.

Punjab National Bank versus Vinayak Motors

Central Bank of India versus Sukhdeen Prasad Kol

Anirudh Singh versus Icici Bank Limited

Gopal Krishna Joshi versus Muthoot Homefin (India) Ltd.

Ms Bricem Builders and Ors. versus Punjab National Bank