Alkama Bag Centre v. Idfc First Bank Ltd.

DRT10 May 2023SA/280/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER [s.v.^zao,zza	REMARK
10.05.2	lr,^{Gnil{f,ceTd fugff}Tqq\rsf,o^elB{ffirt
	vosrfr^qadftgafr^qfto-orfist eTk{ffirt
	1.Brr-qseTo\oifficarfie{M32/2023 ftqtqr.o+.zoze^qr+ilflcrfrri^qrifumq\ti Xa^{urnerd qrtqqt eifu-dfficsu+ord} fugwgn.r+rtr 2.s-fr-{q o-ror-q-frm-{fu-qr^rrqrt 3.^yerra:fuflqflqr oil-tf,{sT$..1432/2oza ftqifirr.oa.2s2s^q1ft{rwurfoqr^qrrott 4.orrieo^qsdaxr^srm17111wdffivre zoozdcrqtTrildotrorserBo-rqdsqei ftqiora.os.zozs6\u-qf,ftti^.rigsr+-sqd qrtqctfrqq++t,oilErf,qqmuRnBdg$ t,epmra-{$-d-flr^gr-rT+Es iBafu'fl^.rqB, d$-+^rfrsrqHrsI3ilIrKTfrtn^qdofsarqor dsprgqq FqteiwfrETE'slffiEEtq grrqrRf,oTr+{rfrirooz.os.zo22o1eTcrw frrio'rio1warqor^q1-$.r$t.rVseTfr[ffi ftrdr-i^qdorfiorgttufu-qr^.rqrtt 5.GTrterftcio02.0s.2022o\eTcrwfrt}^qd ofsartrorfue*fi.03.2023of^gssTkf,-tuT dc-qatrqd^q6utr{ulsQtqgeuterqtr^qrkd di+^{tanqenilq-ocqT}d^grrlgserkovqd sqerftiro11.04.2023o)rgofrtn^.dqrffi qrrls{qi-flsTEft{qdflt4qfrvqrwrqn o-{ifrgqfumqol^qrcrfrrn^qriotergtu fu-qr^rrqrtt

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

PAGE No

¶7

CASE No

Alkama Bag Centre versus Idfc First Bank Ltd. — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶15

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
8.BIFIseTsilETid^qrqroBqqseloTsrli trgofrrnTncwrffioTsi-q-drm-{fu-qr rl-qlIsf,{srfrceTdgrtlercrfuf,rsu-srffi dsqerg$orffi tHkiE-f,sTr-incFdoBrI of^qM.fru-goo1T$B,fuTf,r si-{ds-{o-r srqr^qrflItetfuim02.12.2021o\er-{-il{o seTorrt{fuor^q-gtffi{dtdHceT^q6ff ensqRrf,Eq,fr-r14.12.2021o<sup>q-qrsc-wa o{itgsrqfrqr^.rqrt entcr^qhorfuirfi03 o1.2o2zdergvxsr-{-n{o^qsT	ffii-in{l.Rr qqrE-Gfuwwfu+rrm.ovruroftqiooo.or. 2022frftlSwfi{ril{f,^qeT}^q-orqrvrRT^qrn 6-{ifgeiftqsrq^qra,fr-<sr.rfrftttw frqioo+.oz.2022dT6Ac^qdet^..T{Bot sr++r6cel vqrswrEtsrRr^qqrcrFirsrecil t,fuos.os.zo2zo1 HT$tdrornitg^qq-qfuqr rrqrId.flc{srf,ftdrooo.o+.zozzdg.rqqerfor eiftcildEqr^qrs-{ftciooz.os.zozzo)eil-tsT clkdfrtfi^.rqrtt e.$IflEdtseBofgsnotqdsil-a-q-6 rreTorerfazrfrqao\ftUi-qdoTiFrerm-t ] tid^rrTqkrgrn{urfrqiooz.os.zozzo}siftq srriyrfuft-q-ogen\dft{aftfuw frontcr cIR-dgcil,ctt[gtt^y-o-rqdoTrieo^qcT?16T& o-6sm-t01oTrt{rcrRddri fuimts-tw entclfl^grcr€tT6rt ro.^qqfrq6viqtofcrRdsntcrRim'oz os.2o22dergvnw^ttar$-e-ExqfrE-did 6KT31.01.2023vs2s.02.2023(gi-ffi^q,/s-q) diPHnfuf,frtnTi t,fu-gwe^q-s-{ord siftqg-fldctnsTril{oseToilRfuf,r e<sup>'/ \lrX

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

REMARK

8.BIFIseTsilETid^qrqroBqqseloTsrli
trgofrrnTncwrffioTsi-q-drm-{fu-qr
rl-qlIsf,{srfrceTdgrtlercrfuf,rsu-srffi
dsqerg$orffi tHkiE-f,sTr-incFdoBrI
of^qM.fru-goo1T$B,fuTf,r si-{ds-{o-r
srqr^qrflItetfuim02.12.2021o\er-{-il{o
seTorrt{fuor^q-gtffi{dtdHceT^q6ff
ensqRrf,Eq,fr-r14.12.2021o<sup>q-qrsc-wa
o{itgsrqfrqr^.rqrt entcr^qhorfuirfi03
o1.2o2zdergvxsr-{-n{o^qsT

ffii-in{l.Rr
qqrE-Gfuwwfu+rrm.ovruroftqiooo.or.
2022frftlSwfi{ril{f,^qeT}^q-orqrvrRT^qrn
6-{ifgeiftqsrq^qra,fr-<sr.rfrftttw
frqioo+.oz.2022dT6Ac^qdet^..T{Bot
sr++r6cel vqrswrEtsrRr^qqrcrFirsrecil
t,fuos.os.zo2zo1 HT$tdrornitg^qq-qfuqr
rrqrId.flc{srf,ftdrooo.o+.zozzdg.rqqerfor
eiftcildEqr^qrs-{ftciooz.os.zozzo)eil-tsT
clkdfrtfi^.rqrtt
e.$IflEdtseBofgsnotqdsil-a-q-6
rreTorerfazrfrqao\ftUi-qdoTiFrerm-t
]
tid^rrTqkrgrn{urfrqiooz.os.zozzo}siftq
srriyrfuft-q-ogen\dft{aftfuw frontcr
cIR-dgcil,ctt[gtt^y-o-rqdoTrieo^qcT?16T&
o-6sm-t01oTrt{rcrRddri fuimts-tw
entclfl^grcr€tT6rt
ro.^qqfrq6viqtofcrRdsntcrRim'oz
os.2o22dergvnw^ttar$-e-ExqfrE-did
6KT31.01.2023vs2s.02.2023(gi-ffi^q,/s-q)
diPHnfuf,frtnTi t,fu-gwe^q-s-{ord
siftqg-fldctnsTril{oseToilRfuf,r
e<sup>'/
\lrX

¶19

DATE	DESCRIPT]ON OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	d^gsor-tclfum*oz.os.2o22etftfufi sTra-q-oceTofs..cRift^qfr{f,S$t,ecl G'i@1^{q,/s-q)d frtrfliRf,6Iid erE} GTd-qoceTo\oil-t{rkirfi02.0s.2022oTEr=r ilior^q)sTkf,ar{fo-qr^rrqrt,csfrrsl-fl +.qr€ttr^qsf,t:6t^qEfrqlR-dfu-q^qrorB fusrwftrerorsffi^gdramcrfudfrri TtsTriyrftciooz.os.2o22^qrgneniro^qeT ofoTrtcrsrRd+ifu{i-o.tfr^errr
	11.Gt-tr^qatqcrtof^qqsrra-{6ceno)omr ft_or*-"1ffiE+r^gMcrRf, 3il_tilftim 02.0s.2022o-rEFroil-tclcIRoEYiftqFFtfr er gsgsertil olsilr\fuf,frrnqfifuor< o-nqenicrcrRddifuimtfrssqd gor w,nqaqrRil-m'fi.o3.zoz3o\eTqtf, oTril{qfrsFfdsqqorqfu crrFrrlzzzfu+sd fuf,qtu-gofuut^rt-qlqEc-mrurXurdsw g{qdtgilqqfu-qr^qrs-oortt rz.entqm^qerofofttfq-dqerqrsl-ilfiA frErqfr^qae-d{rqr^rrrflBfum-rurorTiyrfu ftq-f,dril-id^qs_qra3il-iffi.ceT^gmUK rlrrrEn=Td^q-qmfrow^engsdqTor-$u-cd $trrdwo-rGt-SitTo-{dl{6I,{flo.nul ffi qno-eifuo+iAqrsfuirfi04.03.2023 o\sTffsisr$ft-aorifroo-{ttgrqofu-+t .rqr,d07.03.2023etiftdgoTlEse-rot fudq^q-{il-fr+itefiTfrti^qridr.qtI
	rs.GTrileo^qeTd^gsa-dor fuiqs-m-q-qrfr ceTof3]lrt^q6e-E-cDrfu-qr.rqrt+trrq^qm

¶23

DATE	OESCRIPTTONOF THE ORDER	REMARK
	5Brkrsrfufi{qdcrqqrqe_fr_rqEffiH Tfrdrd,ffisn-il<-o.ceT+tsn{tfuoqerqr frri^qrifue-or+r^qTT6Io.Rrffiq n.S {6!iltfltI r+.vmt-qrfrd-6oifriti+oqerqrsTrd-fi o.r^.rotwrXfiocFffiTEovfrgvwmgem\ S ff{qtsTrqfufrT$tatfumqffirfrt} qriq}.qrSftt rs.entffF^qsgrqrerciilddsqeJqi qr+ftqsqf,qqrqroqd 1998 7 olCd+qPo+. q.srltrtqnrs rqkrsrBftqq+frq-q d st-ffrrTf-6fr-4-rfrrturiAfu€Tf,^qn ffi(fuqr^rrfltvs^qqtErorBft{qd crqqFla)crqqrF-f,frrd^qfidBEfwt rffi(fu-qrrqrttVrd^qpTfrTrrFrrerHrrr 6oqfrfusrsdv-o-sqfrfrfudsr{rd 't7w/2o22tHTftqBEkrrI ..{lql(,lq EI(I dB-dfrufuftqia'zz.oz.zoozot€<fif,fuqr .rqtIsrriE-6rreTF[rrfff,qrqgeidfor er<<Xd-oerqfifu-qr^rrqr I i6.soqqdsiil{qrfrce{offr{tfuoqmqr sTrilfiorfutEToGgv16ildrqrrrqrt'ot tIt{I17(1)Hffigtrc2oo2doio.f-oy-qo +isrfror-ffiro-rsrqna-o:ffioxrui srd -qtqleFl ^ttrgot^ql-fryriFrf,orffi srqff,^q-Eu-edergwEtdrtIsflo-t-{urrTnr5 qqkrorBftqqdsrqEr-{sil-rtr-dc-€l*irs{ fftfrfuo. frSor)dETriqilflr{qsqilq 04 4 .tll{.llcRI ^{-</sup> <l', A"^/' o,tCd+q}

¶32

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER q-al TDBFIT
Sr;[I ^qraftqrils o1^qosfis
[email protected](Etg.)Earqog fr. 3785 2012 fr.
s12s1/2o'tl+ffi {frffir Tdcr$ie
ftfr&QTeiE^qefir$-woTrststo.i-fiwlif 3pqfrcrRf,oTrtsrRiroos.os.2o1ssiH-qffif, ft;-flTqrBr
18.tsciffirgw[ro1T$^qrs[tolBovurilT Frw.{^qqqEsg+lt^qfreTWfuot^q.srffi sd{arrrclkdkci-6^{oz.os.2o22s.rqqeTo</sup> groxwRo3TrtvrtfuflsTrt{r o-rEFrsTrd-q-o qao)frirooz.os.zozztfrrut,orertd sTti<oceTo\wsrft-m-{urdsqers-qaentcr "<br>gff-frtitg^qrEonqRirooz.os.zozzt fivs.l+flsTi{<-ocsdfl-cirat,aq snl17(1)E-t$ffivtre2oo2d^qlqqm-gst-{ sTril{ocas)+sfrqfldoi(ioreri-d3i-str6 18qI2022d6^qrfuortrqdflt-+^ent^qR o)fuersr-arcrfr^tn1q-qfutg^qn-fiqB@ilq}
qtqtdq gr-*rEfrwfiqqiErorEfu{qd
crqqri)EtfuR-f,^qstdfrqqitrsrfud ft{Yiloi^rrurildftrqr^qrq,dtrfl fiftgszg qlzozzo1qqrqdIqfidcrsroelrieocm o1frEdtrn^qff-osrqfiqr3rarfdsr-tcr fuimtasfrs-sdsis{frs-fi{"rs-qde-Ecr sTMQTr,fu-g18qq2022dqgtD{ure-qd o-{iofssqfiqrdsicixnrurc-q(qE}6-r ftq;6'ra.oa.zozs01^q-6ernwrc-fEf, fu-qrrrqr tulfrErfRf,srqsrqBtsi-sBfiqtt,

¶37

DATE	DESC PTI FTHEO D R ilddsrpr^qr+fiqtsErrrr^qrrrlerqdfuqE'I eTq$rETd^qtldEfifdfu-qr^rrflt,vc^qrTn srr({trIrcorfrgVSflfi6@-rrf,tofs-m eru-{q(tt^qm+qvafl-q^qr+l?rqdAmtt Tf,-tuil+frsqtermsrqfilffiftqq^q{ ft-qrio-{t\TTssfl-{flr Tfi6fr-qnftdrrrior Tflvrrcfr-qr^rrqrt,fu{^{qqii}q qnr}s@t yrdm-fl sfrld l-Str	REMARK
	20.trssTfufr-{urdwqerGrril{oceTofettit trEdfu-qi^rri[q-6tro-rq^qRrrz(r)s-ffi vtrc^2oo2dcrqtri\dtrf,u-go^gurt,oo sTril{oceTol^q6ckIFIT^qro1^qqrguu-o-r"rfr qrrt5qqfErsrftfrqqdsr+nqflgqB, fusorfuerrnqt,u-qfuvf,q-qrfrceno1sTt{ trgafrtn^.rtwt-fr^{qFfdqrq-gETdt}t^qr{ rz(r)vsifrv€2oo2dstrErqoffi qdsrdu-s-{rrdwwfiXoffior d ttu-goisrdqrsq-rdergw51a qtqtdq frEItfril fu-qr^rrirt, ffi qRI5Tqtil GIBft{qd^qrqqnart=rfr drit 21.a"res-q-tlff^qFIdeTs-{ETdd^qrsqqt T6frEsed:vffi{d tof^ermfi⁽¹⁾ sr+ffi\rtrc2oo2dcrqqritd3rf,.i6rqodi qrdq-o-{"rierxrsrqtflGIEfuqqdsrqEit-{ dFtr€t*d,ne{fletn{ul^{itq-qfuqrEtnl{ul} o-rEFIsrril{fi^qao)sntqlcltrdE}ifuirfi 02.0s.2022trort,aqftErffudsqqfrql^a5 ttrflderEqeiw fuor^q'clffi{drffT crkd snt{rft{rooz.os.zozzdT+frtitg furfRo^qqqfiqr+sfrqfld^{3i<<u-qdr€t}

¶41

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER lifg^qHOo-Rur$srrarrrf,rBgoil-{{ficeT drtle-Ed^zr-6trm{q^q-qBsrBdtvq^err+ro cmo1sTlrte-qf,^qrq-{Ela)t^gsq-d-r"rfr sTlil{o'ceTo'}ot$^rrEET€tffiIEsd frq0-avflt-qrfr^qeTEr{trq-dfrt}Tn qq-gerdqcRrvrkf,fu€T-d'ide-o'RIn sil-a-c-6^rreTgmrgooioRtsTffe{^qr{s qqlErsTftfrqqffi dr.qr$tBr	REMARK
	22.STrFr-r-q3Tffq-{seilET{re-{gf,^sidRq oTrilfiard.y.ttsz/2s23ft{io11.04.2023^Frr{T srqtflsTBft{qft{Kfufl^qrortt
	zs.oil-i(o^qe+d^gxru-goftd^.riu-fi{'rfi €6.q^(KriqfqdoTft-q-q-{tc-rre+dT*fu nirrq++ffiqzo.ot.zozt(qtffi^q/3)'s effio-+€r^gd<amcrRf,3Ir+crft{16oz.os. zozzficFdd(vi@r^q,/3)'q(vtqq^q/s) dwti u-gooGgvgqsct{€ffi o-rffio)erqrwfrti^qrio-reTftfl{o-t {r6r{raT^qlfr.lT{tfu-{^qIrT13⁽⁺⁾s-tffivre zoozsaqBoftqqe⁽¹⁾u-ffitezoozd traifra6)t^q-frGrrBrnq++ofot$^qfr rorqtTSt,^q6frffifiq++ro\iBn frrn^qriorfotro^+ftsFfdrSt,e-o^qsfrqq fr^q-fr.r{rrarqor3lft-qq{ft-fr-qE)itfr-flur fr.qr€ftr
	24.{flEffir ttqr^qrqdI^qsrowrd ffaqt3Tr'{q-o.cad^{gM q-fr}T$T€q saririleTT{fudts-srffi^gRrclRd^sntcl ft{16oz.os.zozzd^erqrwfrd^qrtd^qpl riirrg+tt dterqrwftriqdtridkdt, tuE

¶45

DATE	DESCR]PTIONOFTHE ORDER \d^GntflRirooz.os.2ozzd^GTrem-f,frrirrri fu^{rqoq-s-rur3nqBortrat I}E^flol-{urGrq Gl-il{f,celatGT}tte-qd16s-fi-{"rGTrtg"T dswsTMfuafrri^qdtgtsc-S{E UIIf,II 2s.^qRrarqiqlsTEfu{q^qasrqErF-do-{flrt fuor-qBerfufle-s{urftrwo-qfrqrqr}fl,Td frfrtEftceTtsrqfiqror^qfuqrqcfu-fldrr qqfr{flc-f,{"rfrffitfrcflgmyfuqrqfi fo-qr^rrqrtIqsoRuIGl-q3il-i@rreTaRr Irqo16s-o{"r efl-tS-{-qdtgdk-dis-i drqr€l *r 26.BqttmrEslrfqfugsoeqtor^qfte{oro-{i dcrqrd16crigqo1sil-ieogrtre-qf, ro-sqerqfusrftf,tGu-Enfuoeerqr3il-isc rffi fr.ql-Stt'lerltrocergxrrq( sTrnfi^qxr1z(i)E-i$ffigEe2oo2gfrwqw or-qE^qrBf,frqffud o-{d EvF-tsfu-qrqror tt	REMARK
	27.^qRqrqed dr za.erffiqerffiorm^rfUrflkdr€rrcirqI qld) ffi{qffi S.em.d^qs1'su-d-srra

Alkama Bag Centre v. Idfc First Bank Ltd.

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Dheerendra Singh Kirar versus Bank of Baroda

Bank of Baroda versus Mahendra Kumar Rathi

Ramshankar Shivhare versus Dewan Housing Finance Corporation Ltd.

Ms Blue Line Water Solutions versus Punjab National Bank

Alkama Bag Centre v. Idfc First Bank Ltd.

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Dheerendra Singh Kirar versus Bank of Baroda

Bank of Baroda versus Mahendra Kumar Rathi

Ramshankar Shivhare versus Dewan Housing Finance Corporation Ltd.

Ms Blue Line Water Solutions versus Punjab National Bank

Indian Bank versus Smt. Sarita Hiranandani

Kabir Sharma versus Shri Ram Housing Finance Ltd.