The court reviewed a quashing petition under Section 17(1-A) of the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 2002, concerning its applicability to gram sabhata proceedings involving Scheduled Castes and Balmiki households.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
1 ss.q. ;iTr -276/2023
TUr rqfr 3Tk6,wr sffig(
(q. c. \ts sffisw rrq)
(ffiqffi -qrfiq fr vrq ffqrs rad)
\H.q. =fTt -zta/zozs
@
sn'{<-6qfl d ldq fr sft{r srtnd sTfuq-ffirt B-f,{qrfr a'qtr. 2 d fuq sRE sTk{ffir +ftqgdT=K €ffi{efr d s1e1 fr Htdc ;yc aTfu{ffir t
x
2
w.g. ;i!rt - 276/2023
efftqr
(frci-fi, 11.u.2o23 d Eilfud)
R
gs. q. ;i{t - 276/2023
3
ffior 6 ftqqq qrqETrft-f, Bqfdt or fi vdq fo-qr ,rqr t, ffi qrtsq t orfuoerc fu-qr rFrt t of rqo rotq dqftoq-{ t fr sq B o1qrE o.rwT gq$ t tfl g3TI t I sil-t{6 o.qfr eT aYq \qrsu-erlc. s Efrslg d o-€t.fr riqrkd c-€t t r cfu& oTIfugE-{ tt Rrn t t Ys o'nq ss 3Tk+-Rq otgs c-oror ol g-{i ofrnrrfr ffiorr€f Bt
4 vfl.g. =fTr -276/2O2s
irq egszzzorz srfrst dc ,tfq-q frsaqd.fr.3n{.fr.in$. +o ftTfu& {yffifr fuqiil} dr ffid oG Es eTc-{ sfl T€rT.rfl t t
't1. Err{r 17 (1-A) sr+ff \rE 2oo2 d crfirfl-gux Bffi{srfr t'o srQrqr ffiq €er + Ertr Erm ra (+) fr oprfl €rRr r+ stffi virc 2oo2 d ureETFI d ffT qff qfi srfr o-ffi + fusq fi.Bd qk ffi *ufr qfu fr v66. t o<sup>qm rz (r) wffi VrE 2oo2 d oio.|E srT oTtro-{q A srreT sfl-trqq e-qd o-{i of ffrq erffir cil{ at G t,q-st cfr'rfi sTrfu furd t, srersr <rqr frriqrfr srq wi ca rur Errflr riETrRd fuqr w w t, fuflqq q1DIr11 Tq oTqrqr fu-fl.rfl t ersr-srq6i sK or<q {oto, ePrqr sica: vsq $Tr B I
13.ritr q+tr frqiozo.oz.zozt G'tffiq/12) gs 6'tmr /13)ofl-ilfi d ge @qio 430 t+ea d qEq {-d.{ tr frqq+tr tnl sttrciloq or rlrqT qror to1 B-trrqrfr o-qb rqcr d-6' d am3r-n{o.tnd o.} tilcrd + ct wrt vm fr.rq+tr iiRf, 01 'r$t r q-sfr sTrf{6 wd d erq vFs EId vsag ffirfi frT Uq-crq sFfd t renil<orIeT ErgIor+1 ca tot qs sIIErr q{ {6 ild {€rTrrrrr t of {fudirr gu-n GAE{q,/12) 'q(+@i of drqrd S cfr w666 6-rrfr .r-i / n)qTtf,o wd
k:
qq. g. =fTr - 276/2023
5
t t vsrrnur trrc 6rwT GriRm w tqs uD-o-rur o1 fr*ffi'or d,ft ssq gur t r
14.q6 eTBtr{q snn{o,qffi d {fl ild * saro B o1 En-{I 13 (2) st$ffi gtrc 2oo2 d ffi( nkd of qrt sffi frq qa-qr s-m-{qrfr fu sTQrsr ffdq fiTerr dgnr zfr qa d ftw qxr rs (+) wffi VtE 2oo2 d crqtTrit d ffn o1qd srfr o,rffi or eTfuq si.r t, fug tq-{r ?16 t fu "qqT dq-f, cr6r fr sTrilqo qer o.) frr qmr ilfi-d drt d enqrqqq sTril{oqa o}gg eifu+-<q d vqerqrfuor rqo ori iDItxtcl or{ul sFl-I it{rqtqr uI so-or t" t
1s. T{fr sfl-tq-orT€r Enrqa sTrcfu fr m.r$ t fu oTrt{o,rcr ENr-ii.r gr+ d fus'q u-qo frd .r} eilqril{q or ot{ sf,r vtrqqrfr t-o' d grr iftf, TS fuqr.rur, fu-gqR vcm iftarfr or ffrrrTqt d, re fr tInI 13 (s- A) sy$ffi '€ d T{go d orgun oTrt{o. moft ce{ oi fr-.r qr+r arfi-e *i w ererqT dirr q+rr d frt-q Grlqdqq tnT stn clr Eli rr{ €rNr rz sffi vqe zooz d H-qtrni d trd sTBo-{ur d sqffi urnet u-qa s-{i ofqffin srw c-€t t, sreri-d we t ot frffi ff uotqa of ssqq q?rnn q d frqqg erm rs (z) s$ffi we d trd mrr qrq drfrd frrn qri d ernrn qr elm rz irtffi vE 2oo2 d siil.to srfuo-ruT d sqer GTrilf,{ rgo ovi rrr E-o c-EH q-fr fou rpql g'
x
Ts.g. ;iilt -276/2023
5
't7. dr srg n-ra tq-6 sTE B at sTrtq-o ca dt sfl slfufilT of effior d ffa cr+a o-rrft .r$ +rr qa-+ fuiro zo trar$ zozr ('tffit /12) eg-er ('+ffit /B)qerfl eriq-o qa o1 sir t ref, H rt €flq-nfi ftiro zo.os.zozr (qi@-t /14) ueror ('ifli /16) de-ol{r tqr.o rz stt$ VtE2oo2 d crqErrit A tr(r ro-qur/qrfufiT rEo ovi?DT qrE onq vsq r€l gsTr Ts fufl sil-tvr ftqio o+.0+.zozz (Sm< y/zz) d crftf, +i w sTriffi cH olqxr 17 Hgsffi gre zooz d crqETri} d siilrtd rorur e-qo o-ri orqrq o-xur vsq EgTr,q6 sTrtcr ffm, t-frc)fuiq ffi wug EIil$ d ErtIgR-{ fr crfrd fu-qrrrqT t', eterlf, er-t{r fuirs' oa.o+. zozz d sTle\ft-f, frrtqfi fu or< onq Ers orFo-rq ot ffior d trd Efo' er*rfl sicrf,: fr^frrt sw fr ssq c-S geil t, oTr'f{6 ca al crRd sTrirt fr{t6 04.04. 2022 6t EH ficrd t iqra tqq-sr sil-t{o. d m qRds t crR"f, entvr or qqrq frqrd tq-qr dri cH t crRd BTricr -i gdfr ti tS ftrsqn orqq ofqq{eTl EIRI 17 (1-A) Hidffi $E 2oo2 d sErso-s (q) (fr) (fr) t ot T$ t, srQrsrE[rr 1e (r) ein.O.fr. vtrc 1ee3 scqo-s(a) (aa) (b) (c) oiruto, slerqT Ers zo S.ft.fr. d tr( o1 Ti t, ffi gIIEIT{ q{ frBd qfu o\ s-f,wr rE( ori or E-o fuf,f,r B, tflr ot$qrs onq sfleTE6{ur a ffior d fff, sfl viin'wI dsTfuqtrif vs(trrNt d eo'Rr t vsq drcry.re q-fr elott 18. erqgs$ qrer fr ffiq frfu6 cRfuTfr Td fi t o1qnr r+ st.ffi Vrrs2002 d trf,cfu,fn snk ot q)fu6 oTrfuq-iq sr< o-{i tg oTrilfi rqd 6{i \ri 3il-tYr crRd 6-{t of slffiflr vs ffwi-dmftriq q@e ol c-fl-{ o1 T{ t, fus-+1rQrftq ueror Effi @ ffior d ffi Bffi sfrTfr sTrk furf, t,slari-d Rr+frd dfuil toslersr frffiq €{alT o\ {6 E6 Tfr ftqr .rqr o1 t 3Tq-ft gargsn frtS ft 3TD-o.{ur dsqeT sTlilfi rga or vd t
Vs.g. ;ir( -276/2023
7
1e.qe elffi{d fuft t at frF tg}fima ffie sTQrsr frBo. cftr*cq) fr furfr d, d am Erm 14 qYSffi g€ 2oo2 d srqErrit + cirrIr crRd sTrtcr d nErfl d sTrfrfrf, ori ererfl fqH tf tnr FD ft.kdqfu o'f erm tz (t) rrtffi \r@ 2oo2 dqrqq1-q} d ffn rErc fuqrrrqr tqii qR .Ff$ qfril so: o) Bqqfurtrh sTrk ol fu-qf-<x eIQIsIqc,|fft iffl o-{dr t, aeqM rz (+-q) d ffT sTfuo.-{q o} tt RDrR fr-qn fi nqf, srw or trfreror or frfrrrq o-{i of erffiflr c-Er-{ 01 .r$ t t
E \g.q. =igT -276/2023
trn sffi sTrtcl dt oTre\fud ftrnqd & eTrf,frZsTftd .ft sS uvr ffi sTfu{q d sqs rEf, 6Hr dfl, fus zur ffi oTBo--rq of reTrfiq ffior d eftft{ vffi frq Bmft-cq cfq*c GIerqT BF6qftil-ee o-t ailqtdq furotr
23.rDEFFrs'q qE ftqtR'il fuqrqt-f,r g 6eTl-4q-oceT at frr teTrgt n O sYs-S vtrc 2oo2 d vrqETrfi A trd {s erBo,qq +g,ft{ rEd rE rorq enfiq effior d erns n g"T As w gtqrt fr.q c-fr B, fu-g s-f,{qrfr ca d sfl ild tsTfi-6-{q stlrd rS tsff rqd ;FDTUI ei-sEfi cR'qq dqrpr F-{K frtnqfi q}.q t t onq dqe dr$ nowr eletffiot derrnq tgt qfi d.q TS +dr t, e-c c-6{or ffif,r Tqi srd Hrrq;qrqrfrq d scH rga ori tg 3il-tffiqs ofqrcs fuqr rnn fqB sqo *or t t
I Vfl. Y. "iTt -zta/zoza
2s. il{gqri ffi 6p{Rro fu-qrqror t fu sTrt{l o1 sflFr-f, ch dqpT Til oTrtqq \d(Kriq eTril(fi ca ol ilffirdqrqs fu-qrqrq t eTril{q o1qE cfr oTffiq w rdqrq t
27.qRqrq <d e\ t
sTretr g-d Rlrqler-{r d errq lffi6 rr.oa.zoze o1
dfuo fu-qrt
s{f,g{
fut6:-11.04.2023
o>? o,lr.' (iTqfrsr-flq-id) ffi{ orffi, 0.em.O
q. c., w u-ffis.ro
1 issue framed by the court
Whether gram sabhata is within the exclusionary Directive under Section 17(1-A) of the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 2002 regarding information of Scheduled Caste forearm.
4 provisions across 1 enactments
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
